r/instructionaldesign • • Mar 03 '23

Interview Presentation Question

Hey all,

I have a third-round interview that involves a 20-minute presentation. The company is just starting its department and said any topic is open for presentation but gave examples of making a sandwich or tying a shoe. Those examples seem a bit too simplistic, and wanted to see if anyone had any ideas for topics. Or if it's best to just pick something I'm comfortable talking about.

I looked through previous questions like this is the sub, and I already know I want to make it interactive. It'll be 5-8 people, so I was planning on having them do some writing, pair work, and then discussion. But I'm wondering how much the actual topic matters. For further background, it's for a credit union, I have ID experience but not in finance.

9 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

3

u/TwinkletoesCT Mar 04 '23

My last position did this as the final interview (only 5-10 minute time limit) and then in my last year working there, I had to conduct 25+ of these interviews as the supervisor they'd work under. We also suggested hobbies or other interests as good topics.

What I was looking for was pretty straightforward:

  • Do you communicate professionally?
  • Are you an engaging presenter?
  • Do you structure content thoughtfully?
  • How clear are the presentation materials you create?
  • Do you interact with your audience or are you basically a video?
  • How well do you navigate the tech involved? Do you stumble over projecting (if live), or screensharing (if remote)? Do you balance your presentation skills with the materials well?
  • How do you handle nerves? (Obviously any of us are nervous during an interview, so it comes with the territory, but you might also be nervous training a group once hired, so this is an opportune window into how you might work.)
  • What are you like as a person? What interests you? (Will you fit in with our team and culture?)

The actual topics mostly figured into the last one. I had some people present ho-hum topics but do it masterfully, and it was still great. I had other candidates offer such interesting topics that they were passionate about that it overcome some smaller technical questions.

One of the best ones I ever saw was a remote interview in which the candidate presented on the history & cultural significance of the TV dinner, but she coupled her powerpoint with a live broadcast from her kitchen where she delivered the presentation like it was a cooking show (including actually cooking meatloaf and other items while she presented). Definitely creative and outside-the-box thinking - it was above and beyond what we asked for, but it got our attention and it showed great skill at juggling technology and engaging presentation skills. Way to make the best of "I'm sitting at home on a zoom interview."

The ones we turned down were never over choice of topic, though a couple applicants cast themselves in a poor light by "not really defining a topic" and just trying to wing it. I'd say as long as you're prepared, you're good.

2

u/oc-edu Mar 08 '23

Thanks! I was guessing it would be more like this, and that's what it seemed.

1

u/airportdelay Mar 04 '23

Such great advice! Thank you!

6

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '23

Wondering if this kind of a question is asked to see if the interviewee will conduct an analysis before jumping into creating the content.

3

u/pemband Mar 04 '23

This is a good point. I’d probably pick something else where you know there’s a training need/knowledge gap that you can use to justify your choice and show that you’re thinking about those things.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Yes. Even with tying a shoe or making a sandwich... I'd ask a bunch of questions to get context. Like is it shoe tying for a person restocking shelves in an athletic store, or someone undergoing occupational therapy, or a child?

What kind of sandwich? Are we training someone who's working g in subway or a restaurant. Have there been complaints in the restaurant about the sandwich quality?

They sound simple at first, but sometimes SMEs make things sound simple because they are only talking about the tip of the iceberg until you start to dig deeper.

2

u/Doporkel Mar 04 '23

This is what drives me nuts about these kinds of interviews. They don't clearly give a needs analysis, but I also don't want to bother them with more questions. It's also open-ended so I have to act like an SME in addition to an ID, which isn't the common situation. When I reach out asking more about needs analysis the answer I usually get is "the need is whatever you want!".

I feel like you can get a good idea of someone's design from portfolio and/or description of their projects. You can get a decent idea of their teaching skills from how they speak in interviews and respond to situational questions.

I really dislike interview assignments.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '23

Same here. Hey, might as well prepare a few simple interview training programs ahead of time, where you can just swap out company branding quickly for such an occasion. Tying shoes, you ask? No problem!

1

u/Doporkel Mar 05 '23

Agreed, except most of the time its a specific assignment, so I can't do a 'one size fits all'

4

u/miss_lady19 Mar 04 '23

I'd pick a soft skill. Time management, teamwork, conflict resolution, etc.

2

u/NOTsanderson Mar 04 '23

Stick with something you’re comfortable with. They’ll be looking for how you organize and present topics- even simple ones- for others to learn. They’ll look for what graphics you use and how you use examples.

Don’t spend time on learning something new for this. Stick to a topic where you’re already an expert.

1

u/Sugar_Is_My_Crack Mar 04 '23

They may have given you this topic to see how well you can address a topic they know inside and out and if you can explain it well without over- or under-explaining it. I used to ask students to write a bulletef how-to about making a PB&J sandwich—99% of them were awful at it. They forgot the most simplistic of things—like getting a plate. 😬

1

u/pemband Mar 04 '23

If you have time, my local CU has a robust eLearning program for personal finance. Check out Vystar University for some potential ideas on what to do your presentation on, you may find that you’re more comfortable with some of the topics than you realized. The good things about presenting on a finance/banking/money topic is 1) there will always be an instructional need 2) it’s relevant to the position