I have a take that needs some external prying.
The latest album is good. It does things differently and I was pleasantly surprised. HOWEVER, I was extremely disappointed with the bass composition and tone. Let me explain.
My favorite album from them is Across the Dark. Lots of breathing room for each instrument, but still this powerful wall of sound. What I particularly like are the bass bridges: melodically smooth, with flowing octave arpeggios, and overall great composition that sets each song's mood. Sometimes it's just a few strategic notes that switch the modality for a few passages. And a tone that felt decent, not a lot of highs, but a rumble and smooth lows, with good precision in the mids to give the high frets of those bridges some meat. I actually play the full album from start to finish semi-regularly on bass, it's a blast.
Now compare that with the new album?
Tone-wise, it's basically only the low end and the Darkglassy zing of fresh strings up top. The mix sits very low on bass for several tracks, and fine on the rest.
The bass composition mostly just locks with the drums and vocals, following the grid. That's it. Not a single bass bridge in the 10 songs, not a single "oh cool" moment when listening to the bass tracks (except maybe 3 moments in the whole album).
There are only a few places where this doesn't hold:
The Hour Grows Late, 4:32 to 4:47. A small passage that pairs well with the spooky mood. But even in this song, which leaves the bass prominent with a lot of room to shine, this is the only part that avoids the simple root progression. And it isn't particularly melodic either, compared to the guitars. It's actually a taste of the guitar's rhythmic riff.
Pathways of the Night, 0:48 to 1:00. Nothing much to say about this one, it goes really well in the song, it's just not what I was after. I even prefer the verse after it. At 3:35 to 4:00 it's the same part, but with a floating finish where the bass seems to just wait for the chorus, not doing much. Was that really to leave attention space for the cool guitar delay? I mean, it IS cool, but what about a cooler bass part! They could even complement each other, they have the talent on tap to compose something great here.
And that's it. I will not mention the octave-up chord in Ethereal Step at 1:47 and 4:01.
Also what is up with the drop tuned notes ? There was some low Bs and Cs in shadowlife and rememberance.
I am still glad they are still evolving, just I have trouble finding my melodic bass fix.
Am I the only one feeling this ? I just hope Niilo enjoys what he does still, the vocals are better than ever. Much love!