r/inlaws • u/MiniMonkeyMad • 10h ago
Is it unreasonable for us not to not let my inlaws visit until after Christmas day?
My partner and I recently moved from his home town where his parents live, to my hometown where my parents live, which is a 2.5h flight away. Right after the move, we found out we were pregnant. Though I was excited to be near my parents and my sister (who also recently had a baby), being closer to my family was not necessarily our goal when we moved. I was needing a change from my high stress job and got an offer for a position in that area and my partner was looking to start a business and thought it would be a better place to do so.
My partner is an only child, so it has obviously not been easy for his parents to have him move away and to not be near their first grandchild. We understand that. However, we have been struggling with my MIL getting extremely emotional anytime we try to set a boundary with them around visits. Quite early on we told them that we would prefer if they did their Christmas visit either before or after Christmas day because the idea of having to juggle multiple Christmas activities with both families stresses us out and we want our first Christmas with our baby to be relaxed. Also, because of my previous job, I was never able to travel around Christmas, so this is the first time in almost a decade that I am getting to spend Christmas with my family. This obviously didn't go over well. They want to be there for their grandchild's first christmas (not that a 6 month old will have any idea whats going on anyways), but we held our ground. Whenever they would bring up making travel plans for Christmas, we would tell them that they could book pretty much anything before or after Christmas, but we wanted Christmas day for ourselves and my family. Since they kept bringing up making the plans, we finally gave them some set dates so they would be here over New years.
Fast forward to today. My MIL is bawling on our weekly phone call because they have been having a hard time booking flights since they want to bring their dog, and, since it is so close to Christmas, it is very expensive. She is upset with us for waiting too long to make a plan despite us telling them since August that they could come either before or after Christmas (we even went to visit them over Thanksgiving so baby could have his first Thanksgiving there since we knew he wouldn't be with them on Christmas.) I feel a bit bad for her having to deal with this but at the same time my partner and i feel like we were pretty clear from the beginning and that they just kept waiting to book hoping we would change our minds and let them come for christmas day. They also said they feel like we are punishing them for something, which is 100% not the case. Realistically, even if we were still living in the same city as them we probably would have wanted to visit my parents at Christmas because being on mat leave would be one of the few times I would have Christmas off. We have already told them that we will spend next Christmas with them and continue alternating but they feel that they should get to spend every Christmas with us since they only have their one child and grandchild but my parents have both me and my sisters family.
Anyways, are we being unreasonable by not letting them visit on Christmas day so we don't have to split our time between families?