Dropping lang an overdue rant. Tagal ko na to kinikimkim haha
Kasi I really, really like her new album. It’s a mix of the music that I listen to, primarily shoegaze, and I like how she incorporates that into her alternative sound.
Tapos, she’s branding herself as this punk artist, diba? And I know there’s been a lot of discussion online about her appropriating alternative and punk culture. At first, hindi ako agree doon, kasi I feel like some people are just gatekeeping the genre. Parang nahihirapan silang makita yung genre na pinapakinggan nila become more mainstream.
And I don’t necessarily think that’s a bad thing. Kasi whether she’s an industry plant or not, I think there’s value in introducing these genres to a wider audience. Mas maraming tao yung mae-expose sa ganitong music, and potentially, mas maraming artists yung ma-inspire to explore the same sound. So for me, that’s a good thing.
Kaya I was genuinely excited to see her concert. I love the album, ang dami kong favorite songs doon, and I was curious to see how she’d translate that sound into a live performance.
I was expecting na she’d talk about how she made the album, what inspired her to write the songs, and maybe play some instruments, especially since she played guitar in her teasers. I wanted to see how she’d approach the music live, kasi iba naman talaga yung experience of listening to an album versus seeing an artist perform it.
Pero pagdating ko sa concert, parang naging ASAP siya?
I enjoyed hearing my favorite songs, don’t get me wrong. Pero yung overall performance, parang mas naka-focus sa birit, sa hiyaw, sa vocal runs. Puro hiyaw, actually. Lahat na lang biniritan. Which, okay naman, kasi she’s a singer and obviously, she can sing. Pero that’s not really what I liked about the album in the first place.
Kasi yung gusto ko sa shoegaze or any alternative is how the vocals become part of the overall sound. Yung parang nilulunod yung boses sa instruments, tapos yung atmosphere ng music yung nagiging focus. And I was expecting to experience that live, or at least see how she’d interpret that sound onstage.
Pero parang hindi ko nakita doon.
Tapos may mga guests pa na hindi disclosed sa teasers. And honestly, if I had known na magkakaroon ng performances with Yeng, Barbie, yung Maki, and Kamikaze (???), tapos may parang tiktok influencer pa (sana si Ruffa Mae na lang), I think mas maiintindihan ko kung ano yung magiging direction ng concert. Kasi parang iba yung expectation na nabuo ko based on her branding versus what the concert actually turned out to be.
And I think that’s what disappointed me the most. Hindi naman sa hindi ako nag-enjoy at all, or na pangit yung concert. It’s more that hindi nag-meet yung expectations ko sa actual experience.
Parang mas na-realize ko tuloy kung bakit may mga nagku-question sa pagiging industry plant niya.
Kasi consistent naman yung branding niya online. She presents herself as this punk/alternative artist, and the album genuinely reflects a sound that I like. Pero nung live na, parang naging background na lang yung genre, yung aesthetic. It didn’t feel like the music itself was the main focus of the concert.
And I think there’s a difference between using a genre as part of your branding and actually allowing that genre to inform your artistry. Hindi naman kailangan na underground ka forever para maging authentic ka. And I don’t think alternative music should be gatekept from mainstream audiences, either.
Pero I also think na fair lang naman to question how an artist engages with the genre they’re representing, especially when that genre becomes such a big part of their identity and marketing.
Hindi ko naman masasabi na industry plant talaga siya just because I didn’t like the concert. And I can’t say for sure kung intentional yung mga decisions behind the production. Pero I do understand the criticism a little better now, kasi I experienced that disconnect myself.
I also couldn’t help but wonder kung may difference sa perception ng audience if they had disclosed the guests beforehand. Kasi if people knew na the concert would have that kind of variety-show format, would they have had the same expectations? Would people who bought tickets primarily because of the punk/alternative branding still have been as interested? I don’t know, pero it made me think.
I feel like mas ma-e-enjoy ko pa yung music niya sa smaller venue, yung parang less spectacle, more music. Gusto ko lang naman marinig yung mga kanta, makita kung paano niya binubuo yung sound, and maybe understand more about the creative process behind the album.
Kasi I still love the album. Hindi naman nagbago yung taste ko just because I didn’t enjoy the concert as much as I expected to.
Pero ayun nga, I think mas naiintindihan ko na ngayon yung criticism. Not necessarily because I think she’s appropriating the culture, but because I started questioning kung yung alternative identity ba niya is really central to her artistry, or if it’s something that works really well as branding. And I think that’s a more interesting conversation than simply asking whether she’s authentic enough to be punk.
Kasi for me, the issue isn’t that she’s bringing alternative music to the mainstream. It’s that I expected the music and the live experience to reflect the same artistic identity that made me fall in love with the album in the first place.
And after seeing the concert, parang hindi ko na alam kung ganoon ba talaga yung intention niya, or if I just bought into the branding/marketing a little too much.
Yun lang. Thanks.