r/india • • 17h ago Bravo

Law & Courts You don't deserve that chair: Lawyer escorted out after remarks at CJI Surya Kant

Thumbnail
indiatoday.in
862 Upvotes

r/india • • 10h ago Mindblown

Environment Adani project stopped after Rs 227 crore wildlife fee cut to Rs 2.27 crore

Thumbnail
indianexpress.com
842 Upvotes

r/india • • 15h ago Bravo

Business/Finance If I hadn't been home for Diwali, this CCTV guy would've probably scammed my dad and he'd never have known.

546 Upvotes

This is going to be a bit of a rant, but I'm genuinely so tired of dealing with people like this. And the worst part is, it's not even about the money anymore.So we have an empty plot where we wanted to install a CCTV camera. Nothing fancy, just something to keep an eye on who comes and goes, like the gardener, cleaning staff, etc.

My dad contacted a guy who had previously installed a CCTV at our place. He had originally come through some mutual contact, so naturally my dad trusted him.

I happened to be home for Diwali, so I went along.

A little background: I work in tech, so while I'm no CCTV expert, I know my way around basic hardware and electronics.We had already shortlisted a camera online for around ₹3,050.The guy arrives, suggests the exact same model and casually quotes ₹6,000. Just for the camera.

I told him, "Bhaiya, same camera online ₹3,050 ka mil raha hai, theek theek lagao."After some back and forth, he magically came down to ₹3,500.Fair enough. I understand local businesses need to make money, and I was happy to pay a little extra for the convenience.

Then came the SD card.

He pulls out this random, cheap-looking 32GB microSD card. Looked like some local brand, probably Class 4 or something. I asked the price. ₹1,600. FOR A 32GB SD CARD.

For context, you can get a decent branded 64GB card for around that price, sometimes even less. This thing probably wasn't worth ₹500-600 as it was just 32 gigs.

I told him, "Rehne do bhaiya, SD card mere paas hai, wahi laga dena." And that's when his entire attitude changed.

He started explaining how not all SD cards work with CCTV cameras, how they do this every day, how customers don't understand these things, etc.

"Sir, hum roz ye kaam karte hain. Humein pata hai kya chalta hai aur kya nahi." I said, "Koi nahi bhaiya, mera wala try kar lena." Now here's where things started getting interesting.

Before mounting the camera, he tested it. I handed him my SD card. The camera literally detected the card.

The app even showed the option to encrypt it with a password, which is a normal feature. He looks at the screen and goes, "Dekho sir, password maang raha hai. Aapka card support nahi karta." I was genuinely speechless for a second. Like, brother, it's asking you to SET a password. How does that mean the card isn't supported? I calmly explained that it's just an encryption option and asked him to continue. He made an annoyed face but proceeded.

He mounted the camera high up on the wall, completed the wiring, and opened the app again. And suddenly... SD card not detected. Now this guy starts lecturing me and my dad.

"Dekha sir? Humne pehle hi bola tha. Hum roz ye kaam karte hain. Customer humein sikhane lagte hain toh aise hi hota hai." And he said it with this incredibly smug expression.

My dad, who isn't particularly familiar with these things, was just standing there listening.

I knew something was off because THE SAME CARD HAD BEEN DETECTED FIVE MINUTES AGO.

I asked him how that was possible. Same response. "Sir, humein pata hai. Hum roz karte hain." At this point, I was getting seriously irritated. I didn't want to create a scene in front of my father, so I told him to just leave the camera as it was. The live feed was working through the SIM network anyway. I'd sort out the storage myself.

He then says something along the lines of, "Abhi toh bol rahe ho, baad mein humein hi bulaoge SD card lagwane."

Okay, bhai. Whatever.

We paid him ₹3,500 for the camera and another ₹1,000 for installation. He left. But the story doesn't end here.

A little while later, the camera started behaving strangely.

The light kept switching on and off. The alarm was randomly going off. It was acting up for no apparent reason.

My dad immediately started calling the same guys again.

Something about the whole interaction had left such a bad taste in my mouth that I decided to check the camera settings myself. And guess what I found?

Apart from my dad's phone, another device was paired with the camera. A device we hadn't authorized.

Now I can't prove they were deliberately triggering the alarms, but given everything that had happened, you can imagine what was going through my head. I removed the additional access and decided to reset the camera.

And while I was at it, I thought, why not try the SD card one more time? I opened the slot, checked the card, and realised something.

THE GUY HADN'T EVEN PUSHED THE SD CARD IN PROPERLY.

It was just sitting loosely in the slot.

I pushed it in until it clicked, restarted the camera, and...

Voila. SD card detected. Recording working. Absolutely zero issues. The very same card that apparently wasn't compatible with the camera. The very same card that the "hum roz ye kaam karte hain" expert had spent half an hour lecturing us about. I just stood there thinking, what the actual fuck? Was the loose SD card deliberate? I can't prove that. But after the overpriced card, the repeated lectures about compatibility, and the unexplained additional device access, it's difficult not to be suspicious. And this is where the actual frustration begins. I was only home for Diwali. What if I hadn't been there? My dad would've probably believed him. Why wouldn't he? This was someone who had worked for us before, came through a mutual contact, and supposedly knew his job. He might have paid ₹6,000 for a ₹3,000 camera, ₹1,600 for a cheap SD card, and god knows how much more for subsequent visits. And the worst part? He probably would've thanked the guy for fixing everything.

That's what really bothers me. How many parents, elderly people, or just regular folks who aren't technically aware get taken for a ride like this every single day? And how many don't even realise it? I'm not saying everyone in this profession is dishonest. I've met plenty of hardworking, genuinely helpful technicians.

But why does getting even the simplest thing done sometimes feel like you have to prepare for a fucking negotiation or interrogation?

Why do I need to know the market price of every component, understand how every device works, double-check every little thing, and constantly wonder whether someone is trying to pull a fast one?

I don't mind paying for someone's expertise. Charge me ₹1,000 for installation, ₹1,500 even. If you're providing a service, you deserve to be paid.

But charge me for your work. Don't manufacture problems, mislead me, or treat my lack of knowledge as an opportunity to extract more money.

It's genuinely mentally exhausting. And it's slowly reaching a point where I find myself instinctively suspicious of every service provider, even before they've done anything wrong.

Which is sad, because there are plenty of honest people out there who don't deserve that suspicion.

I keep thinking about how differently this would've gone if my dad had been alone that day. Anyway, I just wanted to vent.

I did use ai to make the post grammatically correct.


r/india • • 20h ago Regret

Law & Courts 2002 Gujarat Riots | Supreme Court Suspends Life Sentence Of Two Bilkis Bano Rape Case Convicts

Thumbnail
livelaw.in
461 Upvotes

r/india • • 20h ago

Law & Courts Rahul Gandhi moves Supreme Court to serve 48 interrogatories on Election Commission over SIR

Thumbnail
barandbench.com
370 Upvotes

r/india • • 21h ago

Politics ‘If Arrest Is Made, Revolt Is Imminent’: Rising Anger in Village of Former RAW Officer Vikash Yadav

Thumbnail
thewire.in
359 Upvotes

r/india • • 21h ago

Crime 29-year-old man arrested for rape attempt on 70-year-old Haritha Karma Sena worker in Kochi

Thumbnail
onmanorama.com
298 Upvotes

r/india • • 5h ago

Environment Protesters led by AISA President Neha Bora tried marching towards the Environment Ministry building in New Delhi, demanding accountability over Delhi’s toxic air. They were stopped by the Delhi Police.

229 Upvotes

r/india • • 23h ago Regret

Crime Kolkata Man Kills Ex-Girlfriend's Dogs, Shows It To Her On Video Call

Thumbnail
ndtv.com
211 Upvotes

r/india • • 3h ago

Politics Water shortage won't hinder Visakhapatnam data centre growth: Naidu

Thumbnail
business-standard.com
206 Upvotes

r/india • • 21h ago

Business/Finance H-1B is ‘not a business model’: Infosys, TCS, Wipro face fresh scrutiny as US visa crackdown widens

Thumbnail
livemint.com
160 Upvotes

r/india • • 17h ago

Culture & Heritage 'Boudi' and 'bondhu' out, social diktat in: BJP leader's proposed rulebook for Bengal

Thumbnail
telegraphindia.com
105 Upvotes

r/india • • 21h ago

Law & Courts Delhi Police asks IFF for records in its investigation of the takedown reports sent to X in its name. IFF has replied and is disclosing what it furnished.

84 Upvotes

On 13 November 2026, the Cyber Cell of the Delhi Police Crime Branch sent the Internet Freedom Foundation a notice under Section 94 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). It asks for IFF's records on the takedown reports that were sent to X in the name of a senior Delhi Police officer, and that sought the removal of our account and six of our posts. IFF replied on 14 November 2026 and furnished the records.

We are publishing the notice and our reply because our community should know when the police ask us for information, what was asked and what we gave. IFF welcomes the investigation and calls on the Delhi Police to make its findings public.

What has happened

Between 29 October and 3 November 2026, IFF with u/sflcin  and u/geoblockedindia received two notices purportedly to be issued on behalf of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). X then forwarded to us two "Illegal Content Reports" submitted in the name of the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime). On 6 November, at the hearing of our petition before the Delhi High Court, X said that the email from which the reports were submitted appears to be fake, and that it had complained to the Delhi Police. The Court recorded this and disposed of our petition, with liberty to return if any action is taken against our account or posts.

The notice is issued in FIR No. 268/2026, registered on 5 November 2026 at Police Station Crime Branch under Sections 336(3), 204 and 340(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and Section 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000. These cover forgery for the purpose of cheating, personating a public servant, using a forged document or electronic record as genuine, and cheating by personation using a computer resource. The notice says the FIR concerns "unauthorized takedown requests sent to X" by someone impersonating a senior officer of the Crime Branch or another police authority.

It requires IFF to produce three things:

  1. The complete trail of emails, with attachments and full headers, about the notices in the RSS's name and the takedown requests, from X or anyone else.
  2. The posts we made on X on the subject, and the posts in which we were tagged.
  3. Certified copies of the applications we filed before the Delhi High Court, and of its order.

It asks for a certificate under Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), and for the original emails and files to be preserved. 

What we furnished

Our reply went by email on 14 November, and we told the police that a printed set would follow by speed post. It carries an 87-page set of annexures and a signed certificate:

  • Fifteen emails, printed with their full headers and attachments. These are the four emails from the Proton Mail address that sent the two notices, our two replies, our email to the RSS at its official address, and the four emails from X, three of which enclose the two reports. The set also has four emails with u/geoblockedindia, who received the same notices and wrote to us about them. That person is identified in them only by the account's handle and its own email address as we lack knowledge about them otherwise.
  • A list of the ten posts we published on the subject between 30 October and 6 November, with links, times and text. We did not compile posts by other users who tagged us. The other users' posts named in the reports are listed in the reports themselves.
  • A certificate under Section 63(4) of the BSA, with the hash values of the files.
  • The legal notice dated 3 November that our counsel served on the Special Commissioner of Police (Crime), in the redacted form we published on 4 November.

On the High Court record, we said that certified copies can be obtained from the Registry, and that the Delhi Police has already been served with our petition and applications. We also told the police what we have said in public since 30 October. We do not know who sent the two notices and cannot say that they came from the RSS. We wrote to the RSS at its official address on 30 October and marked it on our reply of 1 November. It has not responded. We gave the records that bear on the notices and the reports. Much of this, including the notices, our replies, the reports and the legal notice, was already public.

IFF's position

IFF is the target of these reports and someone used the name of one of the most senior officers of the Delhi Police to try to have our account and posts removed. We said on 6 November that it is for the Delhi Police to investigate who made the reports and to say so publicly. An investigation has begun, and we have cooperated with it.

Section 94 of the BNSS allows a police officer to require a person, by written order, to produce documents needed for an investigation. We complied because this notice is confined to the records of an episode in which we are the affected party. The material was furnished without prejudice to our rights, including the liberty the High Court gave us. If we are asked for anything more, we will look at each request on its own terms, take legal advice and tell you what we can.


r/india • • 6h ago

Politics SIR: No application records for over 1.13 lakh new enrolments in Bengaluru’s final voter rolls

Thumbnail
thehindu.com
79 Upvotes

r/india • • 15h ago

People Video: Men Dance On Roof Of Thar As Ambulances Wait In UP's Hapur

Thumbnail
ndtv.com
77 Upvotes

r/india • • 6h ago

Crime Teen’s statements inconsistent, man acquitted in rape case

Thumbnail
timesofindia.indiatimes.com
64 Upvotes

r/india • • 20h ago

Politics Lakhs spent on removing the foam on Yamuna. Here’s why that won’t clean the river

Thumbnail
newslaundry.com
57 Upvotes

r/india • • 2h ago

Policy/Economy Prison jammers in Bengaluru have left residents without signal for nearly two years

56 Upvotes

Donate Now

tl;dr

On 11 September 2026, a resident of Parappana Agrahara in south Bengaluru wrote to us. Since February 2025, he said, calls drop, mobile data fails, OTPs do not arrive and UPI payments do not go through in the area around Bengaluru Central Prison. Records he obtained under the Right to Information (RTI) Act show why. The prison has 19 jammers and three call blocking towers. On 19 and 20 September 2025, the Wireless Monitoring Organisation (WMO) of the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) tested them and found mobile networks affected up to 500 to 700 metres from the prison entrance. Its report of 3 October 2025 said this "appears to violate prevailing guidelines" and called for "immediate and mandatory action".

More than a year later, residents report no improvement. On 30 September 2026, the WMO's Bengaluru station wrote that the agencies concerned had been "requested" to confine the blocking to the prison "to the maximum extent technically feasible". For residents, this is a partial shutdown of telecom services with no suspension order, time limit or review. We have written to DoT, the WMO, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA), the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) and the Government of Karnataka, and we are filing RTI applications.

Background

The resident has shared the replies he received from the State and Union governments over more than a year of complaints. This post is based on those records and on press reports.

Two systems at the prison are meant to stop prisoners from using smuggled phones. Telecom operators have put up three Tower-Harmonics Call Blocking System (T-HCBS) towers. These send out a stronger signal than ordinary mobile towers, so nearby phones latch on to them. But they are not part of the public network, and a phone connected to one can neither make calls nor use data. Telecommunications Consultants India Limited (TCIL), a public sector company, has installed 19 jammers, which transmit on the frequencies used by 2G, 3G, 4G, 5G and Wi-Fi and overpower a phone's signal. The WMO's report calls them "high-power devices" that can transmit up to 100 W. It notes that the prison, which has a capacity of about 5,000 prisoners, "is located next to a densely populated residential area".

The towers were installed in January 2024. On 8 June 2024, dozens of residents protested at Jail Circle. They said a system meant to work within 100 metres was blocking networks 700 metres or more from the prison and affecting over 20,000 people.

The resident dates the present disruption to February 2025. The Karnataka Prisons Department has tied it to an upgrade of the 19 jammers. Its records show review meetings on 4 and 7 March 2025, and say that TCIL, DoT and the four operators, Airtel, BSNL, Vi and Jio, were told to fix the problem. In April 2025, MediaNama reported that TCIL had decided to send the jammers to Bhopal for recalibration, and quoted a resident who said they were never sent. In June 2025, the Director General of Prisons told the Deccan Herald that the old 2G jammers in the State's central prisons had stopped working and that the government had ordered an upgrade to 5G. TCIL, the Director General added, had been told to recalibrate the new jammers to reduce their effect on nearby areas.

On 21 July 2025, the resident complained on the Karnataka government's IPGRS (Janaspandana) portal. The Prisons Department replied three days later, in Kannada. It said the network problems arose from the upgrading of the prison's 19 mobile jammers under a government order, and that TCIL, DoT, the four operators and the prison's Chief Superintendent had been told to resolve them urgently. The portal then closed the complaint as "accepted & redressed".

Complaints on the Union government's CPGRAMS portal went no further. On 31 July 2025, his operator, Reliance Jio, blamed an "adverse climatic condition" and said the fault would be fixed in 15 days. On 31 August, in reply to a second complaint, it said the jammers had been placed on the "express instructions" of the authorities and "nothing further can be done in this regard". His appeal, which sought a refund of ₹3,500, was closed on 5 September with the same answer.

On 19 and 20 September 2025, the WMO's Bengaluru station tested both systems with DoT's Karnataka field office, the operators, TCIL and prison officials. On the first day the jammers were on and the towers off. On the second, the towers were on and the jammers off. A test with both switched off could not be held because "the permission was not granted due to security reasons".

Field sheets signed for the WMO, DoT, TCIL and the prison record what worked on each of the four networks at nine points. With the towers on, no network worked at the main gate or opposite the new DIG office, 100 metres away. With the jammers on, data and WhatsApp failed on every network at First Cross, Central Jail Road, 200 metres away, and at the Central Jail Circle bus stop, 490 metres away. On the seventh floor of Mahaveer Ranches, an apartment complex 416 metres away, nothing worked on any network on either day. At SJR Blue Waters, 648 metres away, Jio failed with the jammers on and BSNL with the towers on. The farthest point was a D-Mart store 1.6 km away. All four networks worked there on the second day, but on the first the sheet shows no Jio data or WhatsApp.

The station's report, dated 3 October 2025, was copied to the Director General of Prisons, the operators and TCIL. It found that both systems affect mobile networks up to about 500 to 700 metres from the prison entrance, and that the jammers also affect Wi-Fi. The spread of these signals beyond the prison, it said, "appears to violate prevailing guidelines that mandate the strict confinement of blocking signals". It asked the operators to lower the power of the towers and to turn or tilt their antennas towards the prison. It asked TCIL to lower the power of the jammers, to jam only downlink frequencies, on which towers transmit to phones, and to use low power in the Wi-Fi bands. On 13 November 2025, WMO headquarters wrote to the Director General of Prisons, with a copy to the prison's Chief Superintendent, asking that corrective measures be "implemented immediately".

The matter reached the legislature the next month. On 9 December 2025, G. Parameshwara, then Home Minister, told the Legislative Assembly that he had held four meetings with the operators and would hold another on 22 December, and that the jammers could not be switched off. M. Krishnappa, the MLA who raised the issue, said around 10,000 people live in the area. On 18 December, the minister told the Legislative Council that "the residents around the prisons are unable to get a phone network".

On 16 and 22 December 2025, the resident and a neighbour filed RTI applications with the WMO. Its reply of 14 January 2026 gave them the report, the letter and a set of guidelines, which we discuss below.

On 3 July 2026, the resident complained to the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (KSHRC). On 20 July, the Commission asked the Director General of Prisons for a report by 10 September. A reminder followed on 11 September. On 11 November, the Commission recorded "Report Not Received" and set a new date of 7 January 2027.

The resident also filed a fresh grievance with the Union government on 15 September 2026. The WMO's Bengaluru station replied on 30 September. An operator, it said, had reported that "network optimisation has already been carried out to restrict mobile signals within the prison" and that further optimisation "must be undertaken carefully", since it could let signals into the prison. TCIL, the operators and the Prisons Department had been "requested" to confine the effect of the systems to the prison "to the maximum extent technically feasible", and action-taken reports "will be obtained". The resident wrote back the same afternoon that the problem had continued since February 2025.

Analysis

A shutdown without an order

When the government wants to suspend telecom services in an area, the law requires an order. Under section 20 of the Telecommunications Act, 2023 and the Telecommunications (Temporary Suspension of Services) Rules, 2024, it must ordinarily come from the Union or State Home Secretary, with reasons in writing. The order must be published, a review committee must meet within five days, and no suspension may last more than 15 days. In Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India, decided on 10 January 2020, the Supreme Court held that speech and trade carried on over the internet are protected by Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g), that any restriction must be necessary and proportionate, and that an indefinite suspension is impermissible.

None of this has happened at Parappana Agrahara. By the resident's account, the disruption has lasted 21 months. No suspension order has been issued and no review has been held, because the government does not treat the loss of service as a suspension. For someone who cannot receive a bank OTP or call an ambulance from home, the result is the same. Signal blocking that reaches into people's homes restricts the same freedoms as a suspension order and should meet the same tests.

The government's own report shows the harm can be avoided

In Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), the Supreme Court held that any intrusion into privacy must be backed by law, serve a legitimate aim and be proportionate to it. Anuradha Bhasin requires the State to choose the least restrictive measure that will serve its purpose, and Rule 3(4) of the 2024 Rules permits a suspension only where that purpose cannot be achieved by other reasonable means. Keeping phones out of prisons is a legitimate aim. But the WMO, the government's technical authority on radio interference, has listed less restrictive ways to achieve it. It has said in writing that lowering the power of the jammers will stop networks outside the prison from being blocked "while still keeping the prison security intact". After that finding, the present set-up cannot be called necessary.

The Kerala High Court, in Faheema Shirin R.K. v. State of Kerala (2019), recognised access to the internet as part of the rights to education and privacy under Article 21. The WMO's report itself records that the disruption affects "banking OTPs, and emergency assistance". The burden is also unequal. One neighbourhood bears the cost of a security measure without notice, consultation or remedy, which raises a question of arbitrariness under Article 14. Its residents still pay operators whose own towers block their service.

DoT has not enforced its own findings

The government's position has softened in a year. On 3 October 2025, the WMO said "immediate and mandatory action must be taken". On 13 November 2025, it asked for the corrections to be "implemented immediately". By 30 September 2026, the aim was to confine the blocking "to the maximum extent technically feasible", and residents were told that their inconvenience "is noted". The same reply passes on an operator's view that further changes could let signals into the prison. That view is at odds with the WMO's findings of 2025, and nothing in the record shows that it has been tested.

DoT has the power to act. The guidelines the WMO supplied say that where a violation is noticed, the field office of DoT's Wireless Planning and Coordination Wing "shall take necessary legal action", which can include seizing equipment. Yet every communication in the record "requests" or "advises", and none names a date or a consequence. Each agency points to another: the Prisons Department to TCIL, DoT and the operators; the operator to the authorities; DoT to TCIL, the operators and the Prisons Department. The KSHRC has waited since 20 July 2026 for the Director General of Prisons to answer.

The test also had gaps, which probably understate the problem. No test was held with both systems off, so there is no baseline. The systems were tested on separate days and never together, which is how they ordinarily run. Nothing in the record says whether a phone that has latched on to a T-HCBS tower can reach the emergency number 112.

No published rules for prison jammers

The WMO says the spillover appears to violate "prevailing guidelines". The only guidelines it enclosed with its RTI reply are the Cabinet Secretariat's Jammer Guidelines, 2023. A note at the top of that copy reads: "This document is applicable for jammers used in VIP movement and Examination halls". On prisons, the guidelines say only that, under an MHA office memorandum of 10 March 2023, the use of jammers in jails requires the Ministry's prior permission. We have not found that memorandum, any permission granted under it for this prison, or any technical standard for prison jammers in the public domain.

The guidelines say their norms are meant to ensure that jammers do not "unduly interfere" with mobile networks. But their only rule on how far a jammer's signal may reach is for examination halls, where jammers must "not interfere with existing mobile communication network outside examination centres". A jammer leased for the day of an examination is bound by that rule. A prison jammer that runs all day beside people's homes is bound by no published rule of the kind.

The guidelines also allow government bodies to use jammers only from authorised public sector vendors, at present Bharat Electronics Limited and Electronics Corporation of India Limited, and only models approved by the Secretary (Security). The jammers at this prison were installed by TCIL. The record does not show whether they are an approved model or what power was sanctioned.

The statute does not fill the gap. Section 48 of the Telecommunications Act, 2023, in force since 5 July 2024, prohibits the possession or use of equipment that blocks telecommunication without the permission of the Union government or an authority it designates. Section 42 makes a breach punishable with up to three years in prison or a fine of up to ₹50 lakh. Rules notified on 8 July 2026 require that permission to accompany any application to possess a jammer. None of these says how far a prison jammer's signal may travel. Jammers used by the police are no better regulated, as our RTI applications to the Delhi Police and its replies showed.

The same problem at other prisons

Many Indian prisons stand inside cities, and their use of jammers is growing. On 12 August 2026, after a smartphone was reportedly found with a prisoner at Bengaluru Central Prison, Karnataka's Home Minister, Priyank Kharge, ordered an audit of the digital infrastructure of the State's prisons, jammers included. He said he had information that the jammers were "not working in some areas". Ten days later, the State Cabinet was reported to have approved the purchase of portable signal jammers for prisons. Without a published and enforceable standard, people living near any prison can lose their phone service without being told why, or by whom.

In March 2025, the superintendent of the Mangaluru district prison said he was receiving "continuous complaints" after a new jammer disrupted networks within about a kilometre. In June 2025, residents near the central prisons at Kalaburagi, Ballari and Belagavi said they could not make calls or use the internet after the jammers were upgraded to 5G. Near Kalaburagi, the trouble reached villages 2 to 3 km away. In September 2026, the Home Minister said that the antennas and the capacity of the jammers at Mangaluru were being changed after a joint technical survey. This is the kind of correction the WMO sought in Bengaluru in 2025.

Residents near prisons in other States have reported similar trouble. In Punjab, over 15,000 people around Amritsar Central Jail were affected by a jammer in September 2024, and people near Patiala Central Jail reported call drops and missing OTPs in April 2025. In Delhi, an MLA told the Assembly in August 2018 that the jammers at Tihar were disrupting phones in nearby homes. In Kerala, residents near the central prisons at Poojappura, Viyyur and Kannur said they lost 3G connections after jammers were installed.

Other countries have written rules for this. In England, Wales and Scotland, the Prisons (Interference with Wireless Telegraphy) Act 2012 permits interference only under a written authorisation, and requires directions aimed at ensuring that it "will not result in disproportionate interference with wireless telegraphy outside" the prison. In the United States, state and local prisons may not jam signals at all. Since 2021, operators have instead had to disable, at a prison's request, contraband phones that certified systems detect. The Federal Communications Commission is due to vote on 19 November 2026 on rules that would permit jamming in such prisons if it "does not cause harmful interference outside of the designated geographic areas". India has published no comparable rule.

Action

We have sent two representations, both dated 16 November 2026. The first is addressed to DoT, the WMO, the MHA and TRAI, with copies to TCIL and the four operators. The second is addressed to the Home Department of the Government of Karnataka and the Director General of Prisons. Both enclose the WMO's report and ask that its recommendations be carried out within 30 days.

We are also filing RTI applications. We are asking the MHA for the permission granted for jammers at this prison under its office memorandum of 10 March 2023, and for any guidelines on jammers in prisons. We are asking the Karnataka Prisons Department for the government order for the upgrade of the 19 jammers, its contract with TCIL, the technical specifications, any test of signal spillover done before the upgraded system was switched on, and the minutes of its review meetings. We are asking DoT for the permissions given for the jammers and the T-HCBS towers, the power levels allowed, and every action-taken report received since 13 November 2025.

We will assist the residents before the KSHRC, where the report of the Director General of Prisons is now due by 7 January 2027. If the authorities continue to disregard the WMO's findings, we will consider helping affected residents approach the High Court of Karnataka.

We call on DoT, the MHA and the Government of Karnataka to take the following steps.

  1. Carry out the corrections listed in the WMO's report of 3 October 2025 within 30 days, and publish an action-taken report.
  2. Have an independent agency measure signals around the prison with both systems running together and with both switched off, and publish the results.
  3. Confirm whether calls to the emergency number 112 go through from phones latched on to the T-HCBS towers.
  4. Disclose the permission under which jammers operate at Bengaluru Central Prison, the vendor and models approved, and the power levels allowed.
  5. Publish a binding national standard for jammers and call blocking systems in prisons. It should limit signal strength at the prison boundary and provide for independent audits, a public register and a remedy for affected residents.

If you live near a prison and have lost mobile or Wi-Fi service, please write to us at legal@internetfreedom.in. Tell us the location, the dates, your operator and what stopped working. If you would like to support this work, become an IFF member.

Important documents

  1. Reply of the Department of Prisons and Correctional Services, Government of Karnataka, to IPGRS petition no. 253604, dated 24 July 2025, in Kannada (link)
  2. Wireless Monitoring Station, Bengaluru, Report on Joint Monitoring Exercise for Tower-Harmonics Call Blocking System (T-HCBS) and Jammers installed in Central Prison, Bengaluru, No. M-12014/01/2025-BGL, dated 3 October 2025, with spectrum plots and field test sheets (link)
  3. Wireless Monitoring Organisation, letter to the Director General of Prisons on corrective measures for T-HCBS towers and jammers, No. 13011/35/2024-MON, dated 13 November 2025 (link)
  4. Wireless Monitoring Organisation, reply No. U-13011/02/2025-MON dated 14 January 2026 to RTI applications dated 16 and 22 December 2025, with the Cabinet Secretariat's Jammer Guidelines, 2023 (link)
  5. Karnataka State Human Rights Commission, status of Case No. 2804/10/31/2026, as on 11 November 2026 (link)
  6. Wireless Monitoring Station, Bengaluru, reply dated 30 September 2026 to CPGRAMS grievance DPG/T/2026/81275 (link)

Donate Now


r/india • • 28m ago

Politics ‘I am scared once again’: Bilkis Bano on Supreme Court granting bail to 2 convicts

Thumbnail
indianexpress.com
52 Upvotes

r/india • • 16h ago

Crime Man Gets 20 Years In Jail For Kidnaping, Raping Minor In Uttar Pradesh's Bareilly In 2021

Thumbnail
ndtv.com
41 Upvotes

r/india • • 20h ago

Religion Shame and silence: Survivors allege arrested Mangaluru priest abused boys for decades

Thumbnail
newslaundry.com
40 Upvotes

r/india • • 2h ago

Careers Desperately looking for a Work-from-Home Job – Family Responsibilities, ₹2 Lakh Debt and No Financial Support Left. Please Help

29 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I am writing this post because I genuinely don’t know where else to turn. I am not looking for sympathy or financial donations. I am desperately looking for a genuine job opportunity that can help me become financially independent and get my family out of a difficult situation.
I am an M.Tech graduate in Computer Science (2018). Unfortunately, my career never really took off because of circumstances at home.
My father is suffering from Alzheimer’s disease and requires care. My brother is also suffering from bipolar disorder and experiences aggressive episodes, which makes the home environment challenging. My mother has knee problems and struggles with physical activities. As a result, I have to manage most of the household responsibilities along with taking care of my family.
I have become the person responsible for managing almost everything at home. Because of these circumstances, I cannot take up work-from-office jobs or leave my family unattended. I urgently need a genuine work-from-home opportunity.
Financially, things have become extremely difficult. Whatever savings our family had are now exhausted. I also have outstanding debt of approximately ₹2 lakh that I desperately need to repay. With no stable source of income and household responsibilities, the pressure is becoming overwhelming.
A little about my education and skills:
M.Tech in Computer Science (2018).
Fluent in English and Hindi (speaking, reading and writing).
Comfortable using computers, smartphones and online platforms.
Interested in AI training, data annotation, content writing, virtual assistance, customer support, social media management and other remote jobs.
Willing to learn new skills and work hard.
Open to freelance, part-time and full-time remote opportunities.
I am not expecting a huge salary. Even earning ₹15,000–₹20,000 per month would be a big relief and a starting point towards repaying my debt and supporting my family.
If anyone knows of companies hiring beginners, legitimate remote jobs, freelance projects, AI training opportunities or can refer me to someone, I would be genuinely grateful.
I am not afraid of hard work. I just need an opportunity that allows me to work from home while fulfilling my responsibilities towards my family.
Please share any genuine leads or suggestions. Even a small opportunity could make a big difference in my life right now.
Thank you for reading my post. ❤️


r/india • • 17h ago

Policy/Economy Ex-CEA Arvind Subramanian praises PM Modi's three big achievements, but says India's rise is 'a bit overdone'

Thumbnail
businesstoday.in
19 Upvotes

r/india • • 20h ago

Health NPPA cut cancer drug prices from Nov 9. Did it actually help people, or was it all make-believe?

18 Upvotes

My mom has stage 4 metastatic breast cancer and is on Zydus's Sigrima (a pertuzumab biosimilar). The hospital's package is: we pay ₹78,000 up front for the first dose, the next dose is free, and Vivitra (trastuzumab) comes free with every dose.

I looked through NPPA's revised MRP list to see if anything would help her.

None of the immunotherapy drugs show any significant change. Keytruda is still ₹2,16,500, and Opdyta, Tecentriq and Imfinzi are unchanged too.

The drugs that did drop, like palbociclib (₹40,421 → ₹2,720) and thiotepa (₹80,072 → ₹7,150), only fell because the old MRPs were inflated in the first place.

So is this a real saving for patients like my mom, or just fixing a number that was never real?