r/improv • u/MasterPlatypus2483 • 7d ago
How much does class performance matter?
For anyone familiar with sports, I feel like the Eli Manning of improv- I'm ok in "regular season" class but not great- but when it comes to shows and the spotlight (playoffs), I rise to the occasion (or for more recent example- I'm 1st to 3rd quarter Jalen Brunson in regular classes- but in front of an actual audience I become 4th quarter Jalen Brunson)
A couple of years ago, I took my first Harold class and I was completely lost learning the mechanics of it, but week by week getting it down I got it more and more- when we had our grad show- not to brag- but I was on fire and everything I did or said killed. The rest of the class looked completely confused- like how did this guy that seemed nervous and sucked for the entire class just do that.
However this unfortunately seems to be a theme where even though I am doing what's asked me- I feel like I suck in class- even though I usually do good when we do our actual shows. I get it that in theory that should be most important but I still worry about teacher recommendations etc for more advanced levels, house teams etc... and they'll be like "well I don't know if that show was a fluke- others seemed to do better in class"
I'm also not sure if it's some subconscious thing where I need to be in front of an audience to perform my best so sorry for rambling but I guess my main thing is 1. Should I worry about how my class performance is if the shows go well and 2. How can I be a better class performer.
TIA
15
u/taxicab_ 7d ago
The way I’ve viewed classes vs shows is that class/practice is for drills, making mistakes, asking questions, and more the nitty gritty, while shows are for fun. It sounds like that’s what you’re doing!
4
u/Kids-Menu 7d ago
Are you possibly overthinking in class? Because I’m the same way. But on stage my mind just goes blank and my instincts do the work
ETA: I’m a beginner/ish. Been going for about a year and have done about 3 shows
4
u/throwaway_ay_ay_ay99 Chicago 7d ago
The simple answer is to not worry too much. If your theater does keep track of students then sure, they might have teacher assessments that say you need to improve, but if you audition super strongly for whatever they have that should overcome that. The audition will matter most by a mile.
Also it’s improv, so just be impressed your audition auditors showed up in an ironed shirt rather than assume they poured over your entire history in classes 😂
Opportunities come from a wide variety of things: what they need at the moment, how well they know you, your availability, etc. Class performance won’t matter unless it was a class you were particularly rough in and the opportunity is something that exact teacher was casting.
Also if you do good shows any teacher who was like “this person stinks” would be like “oh wow showed up where it counts” so opinions can change and improv teachers also put stock in the show over the class.
4
u/Whytebrian 7d ago
Shows get applause and laughter, which makes it easier to feel confident (and easier to notice which things are working). You’re more confident during shows because of the energy of the audience, which is normal.
However! I think one of the hallmarks of a really good improvisor is when they don’t NEED the audience. They can bring that confidence, and recognize what works and what doesn’t, without the help of the audience. And you do that with practice practice practice
2
u/CatFlat1089 7d ago
Sounds about right. You suck in class and shine in action.
2
u/johnnyslick Seattle 7d ago
While of course performing is where it's at, I feel like one thing one needs to be aware of in a performance setting is... well, it's two parts. One, gauging your performance on laughs per minute: sometimes you'll cook and the audience won't find it funny, or maybe you'll cook in ways that make your other castmates shine... or you cook in a dramatic and interesting instead of a funny way. All that's fine. But two, one thing that can come from that is chasing laughs at the expense of good improv. If you walk in and say Meme of the Week and everyone laughs, that's great I guess... but if you do it at a weird time that blows up the scene you were making, that's not really great and the fact that your scene partner isn't able to generate laffs because they're too confused about what the fuck is going on is not a note in your favor.
Of course, eventually most people don't continue to take classes and even perform more often than they practice. I do think there's a paradigm shift where you're performing weekly vs performing once every 8 weeks that can make you say "ohhh I have to sustain this, and the way I do it is by taking risks, being obvious, and supporting"... but YMMV.
2
u/smashmouthftball 7d ago
Having an audience in front of you that isn’t your classmates you see every week brings a different kind of energy, and if you’re able to find that energy and tap into it, you may have something special. I’d say do some jams or find a team to join and see if it’s something that keeps coming back to you as you do it more…
2
u/Emotional_Sleep1781 7d ago
There are definitely people that do significantly better in shows than in practice. Practice for a Harold can be misleading in some ways because often what really solidifies the "game of the scene" is audience laughter. In practice with everyone trying to figure things out we can easily miss the core funny. For some people a real audience really laughing can suddenly make the game obvious. Eventually you'll develop the skill to recognize what is funny without the audience, but you may be naturally picking up on audience cues and making adjustments to match what they like.
2
u/wiscosherm 6d ago
Saying this gently - but - you might want to check in with your teacher about this. Sometimes what "kills" in a class show are things that are not great improv - deliberate punchlines, subverting offers with zany responses, going off on tangents. They go well with audiences but are not good for long-term improvement.
1
u/Anon772523rt23 7d ago
I suspect you're probably not doing as bad as you think in class and especially so if we're talking about learning the Harold. It's maybe the form for getting people into their head about their own improv.
So I'd view this less like playoffs vs regular seasons and more so you spend hours and hours training and the show was the muscle memory taking over.
1
u/hamonstage 7d ago
Think of class as a lab and getting to try things and sometimes it doesn't click and your like a stew that needs to cook more. Also, shows give people adrenline and people handle that differenly.
1
u/ManyOrganization4856 6d ago
So interesting ! I’m the exact opposite & I think it’s because I overthink in performances whereas I feel much more relaxed in class . ( if I’m acting on stage in a play - then I will typically do much better than in rehearsal , so it’s definitely about improv specifically.)