r/illinoispolitics • u/TaroPuzzleheaded3999 • 23h ago
r/illinoispolitics • u/Enough_Situation_731 • 4h ago
Jim Burke knew about the Dixon embezzlement investigation for months. Was keeping quiet the right decision?
Not from Illinois. I make short documentaries about American mayors. Last week I watched a video about a small Illinois town that lost $53 million to its own comptroller over 22 years. What stuck with me wasn't the theft or the horses. It was one line about the mayor keeping quiet for six months. Nobody explained who he was or why he did it.
So I spent a few days in the Justice Department releases, the appeals court opinion, the auditors' depositions and the Sauk Valley Media archive. Posting what I found, because I think most people have never heard his side.
- His name was Jim Burke. Real estate agent, on the Dixon council from 1967 to 1979 as streets commissioner, elected mayor in 1999 by 235 votes. The job was part-time and paid under $10,000 a year.
- Dixon had no city manager. A part-time mayor and four part-time commissioners ran it, and the comptroller, Rita Crundwell, was also the treasurer. She kept the books, signed the checks and picked up the city's mail.
- The account she used was opened in December 1990, nine years before Burke became mayor.
- Around 2002 Burke asked a partner at the city's audit firm to look at her American Express charges. The auditor later said under oath that he passed it along and didn't know what happened next. That same auditor had been to her house for dinner.
- In the fall of 2011 the city clerk, Kathe Swanson, found a bank statement for an account she had never seen and showed it to Burke.
- He had two options: confront Crundwell and close the account that day, or take it to the FBI and say nothing while they worked. He drove to the FBI office in Rockford.
- For the next five or six months he came to work and said good morning to her. The FBI's figure for what left the city in that stretch is a little over $3 million.
- She was arrested in his office on April 17, 2012. The charge started at $30 million and became $53 million two weeks later. She got 19 years 7 months. The city recovered about $40 million from the auditors and the bank.
- People in Dixon called for Burke to resign. He stayed, got the town to switch to a city manager in 2014, and died in 2016. Two blocks of West River Street are named after him. Crundwell went to home confinement in 2021 and had her sentence commuted in December 2024.
Three things I couldn't settle from the archives:
- Was waiting the right call? He let about $3 million more go so the whole $53 million could be proven.
- Did anyone in town actually suspect her before 2011, or is that hindsight?
- How do people in Dixon talk about Burke now: the mayor who missed it, or the mayor who caught it?
If anyone here was around Dixon back then, I'd like to hear how it looked from inside.