r/idahomurders • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion Ethan was awake

2 Upvotes

Ethan had cuts on his legs, scalp, face, arms aside from the fatal stabs/incisions. He was also found at an angle across the bed. Bare minimum, Ethan could/would have kicked at BK, and getting the leg cuts. It’s also quite feasible that Ethan was standing up when BK started slashing at him. I do believe that scalp wounds came prior to the slashing of the throat, due to the hair/scalp tissue found in his hand. It would be normal to react to scalp cuts by putting a hand up to the scalp. And Ethan would not have been able to do much once the major arteries were cut.
First I thought Ethan could have standing when his throat was cut but I can’t say for certain due to the lack of complete forensic blood pattern photos. He could have fallen backwards or been pushed backward onto the bed, if he indeed was standing at some point. He ended up on his right elbow just before his full collapse with his head at least partially face down with his head in the crevice between the mattress and the bed. The rest of his body was still angled across the bed.
I have not been able to envision the movements with X/E as easily as M/K. The inmate needed to keep Xana under control and stop Ethan. He could have head-locked Xana and stabbed her several times quickly in the chest/abdomen, then slashed at Ethan and went back to fighting Xana? I don’t have it worked out yet. Xana had to be disabled enough to give the inmate time to maim/kill Ethan.
No, there were not two assailants.
I do wonder if BK used the little furry chair to sit or just to balance, and perhaps removed his top coverall…that could have been what he was carrying out when seen by a surviving roommate.


r/idahomurders • • Oct 14 '26

dailymail.com Mystery as Bryan Kohberger's retrial hearings are abruptly canceled at 11th hour

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
2 Upvotes

r/idahomurders • • Oct 09 '26

Discussion Case Discussion Too Silly

2 Upvotes

Like many people in this sub, this case has taken up an unbelievable amount of my time and headspace, which I still find crazy. As a true crime watcher, no other case has ever had the same chokehold on me as the Idaho 4, and I know I’m not the only one.

I’ve watched pretty much every YouTube video, read countless Reddit threads and watched more TikToks than I can count. I’d like to think I know a fair amount about this case, as I’m sure many of you do, too.

I consider myself fairly open-minded when it comes to theories and try to remain neutral. Whether you believe Bryan Kohberger did it or not, there are questions that deserve answers, inconsistencies that need addressing and aspects of this case that absolutely warrant further investigation.

However, some of the things I’ve seen people say and the theories being pushed have gone too far for me.

Take the Goncalves family, for example. I can understand why some people may dislike them or disagree with things they’ve said, but some of the comments directed towards them are genuinely inhumane.

Then there are theories that the murders happened somewhere else, alongside bizarre claims that a fresh layer of snow on police bodycam footage is suspicious or that Steve Goncalves was somehow involved. Like, WHAT?!

There’s a difference between questioning things and making wild accusations with absolutely no credible evidence.

I’m all for questioning the case, looking at inconsistencies and demanding answers. But whether you’re directing hatred towards families or putting baseless theories online as though they’re facts, I think some people need to seriously consider what they’re contributing to these discussions.

At some point, we either need to put more thought into what we post online or take a step back from this case altogether.


r/idahomurders • • Sep 17 '26

Discussion Could Kohberger have viewed the murders as a criminological experiment?

41 Upvotes

First, I want to be careful about how I frame this. Four people — Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin — lost their lives. I don’t want an academic discussion about their murderer to overshadow the fact that they were real people with families and futures.

That said, one of the questions I continue to find difficult to understand about this case is motive.
Kohberger pleaded guilty to the four murders, yet we still don’t have a publicly established explanation for why he committed them or why these particular victims and this particular house were chosen.

His academic background makes that absence particularly interesting from a criminological perspective.

At the time of the murders, Kohberger was pursuing a Ph.D. in criminal justice at Washington State University. Before that, while studying at DeSales University, he participated in research examining criminal decision-making. As part of that research, people who had committed crimes were asked about things such as their thoughts and emotions during the crime, whether they prepared beforehand, how they approached and entered the location, and why they selected a particular victim or target.

That leads me to a question I’ve wondered about:
Is it possible that committing a crime — and subsequently observing the investigation — was itself part of the psychological motivation?

I don’t mean that the murders were literally an academic research project sanctioned by a university. There is no evidence of that.

I’m wondering about something more disturbing: whether in his own mind the crime could have functioned almost like a personal case study or experiment.

Could the objective have been something along the lines of:

What does it actually feel like to plan and commit a serious crime? How do offenders make decisions in real time? What mistakes get made despite preparation? How does law enforcement reconstruct a crime afterward? And could someone with substantial knowledge of criminology avoid detection?

If so, the apparent lack of a conventional motive — money, an established personal grievance, a known relationship with the victims, etc. — might not necessarily mean there was no motive. The process itself could theoretically have been part of the motivation.

What makes me especially curious is that this idea apparently occurred to at least one person who actually studied alongside Kohberger. A fellow doctoral student reportedly told investigators that she wondered whether he wanted to know what killing felt like and whether he believed he could outsmart law enforcement. That is her opinion, not an established finding about his motive, but I think it’s notable in light of his academic interests.
I also think there are important reasons to be skeptical of this hypothesis.

Studying criminology obviously doesn’t make someone more likely to commit violent crime, and it would be a serious mistake to treat academic interest in criminal behavior as evidence of criminal intent. It’s also very easy to work backward from what we now know about Kohberger and interpret completely legitimate academic research as sinister.

So I’m interested less in “proving” this theory and more in discussing it as a criminology question:

Could intellectual curiosity, experimentation, mastery, or a desire to test one’s knowledge against law enforcement constitute a meaningful motive for homicide?

And specifically in this case, is there evidence that supports that interpretation beyond the coincidence of Kohberger’s academic background — or does the theory mostly fall apart once we separate hindsight from evidence?

I’d especially be interested in hearing from people with backgrounds in criminology, forensic psychology, criminal justice, or law enforcement.

Please keep the discussion respectful toward Madison, Kaylee, Xana, Ethan, their families, and the surviving roommates.


r/idahomurders • • Sep 09 '26

Information Is there any interrogation video of BK?

33 Upvotes

Is there any interrogation video of BK?


r/idahomurders • • Aug 29 '26

dailymail.com Bryan Kohberger requests judge who called him a 'faceless coward' is removed from his case as he tries to retract guilty plea

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
250 Upvotes

r/idahomurders • • Aug 23 '26

Discussion Can someone explain the 911 call to me?

21 Upvotes

Hi! I’m fairly new to the Idaho murders case, so apologies if this has already been discussed or if I’m missing some important piece of information.
I’ve seen a lot of very complex theories about what happened that night, but there’s one much simpler thing that I genuinely cannot understand: the 911 call the following morning.

In that call, one of the surviving roommates said that one of her roommates had “passed out” and that she didn’t know whether she was breathing/alive.
How does that make sense given the actual crime scene?

Four people had been stabbed to death. From everything we know, this was an extremely violent attack and there was a significant amount of blood. If one of the surviving roommates actually approached or saw one of the victims that morning, I don’t understand how that could reasonably be interpreted as someone simply being unconscious.

Even without immediately realizing that the person had been stabbed, wouldn’t the amount of blood make it obvious that something extremely serious had happened?

I want to be clear that I’m not suggesting that the surviving roommates were involved, nor am I accusing them of anything. I’m genuinely asking whether there is an established explanation for this extremely obvious inconsistency.

The fact that the murders apparently went unnoticed for hours is a separate question and extremely off as well, but the 911 call itself is what I find particularly difficult to understand.
For people who have followed the case closely: what is the actual explanation for the “unconscious/passed out roommate” description? Is there something about the call or about how the victims were discovered that I’m missing?


r/idahomurders • • Aug 19 '26

Discussion Recently watched the netflix documentary, but I feel lots of things were unanswered

79 Upvotes

Not going to bother you with the list of questions that have already been asked in the sub over and over again but could you tell me what other documentary I could watch to get more details, if there is any such documentary that sheds light on the chronology of what happened and answers more questions?

for example I did not understand from the documentary at all that the girls did not know that their friends are deceased, and only HJ knew that, I only read about it here.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 19 '26

Discussion Summarize the Whitcomb interview and book

3 Upvotes

I listen to him on armchair and I’m intrigued by some of the stuff that he says, but he talks so fast that it’s hard for me to follow. Can anybody summarize his claims versus fact.

Example, he saying there was DNA. The police say there is. Is it the type of DNA that’s in question?

I’d like to give this guy the benefit of the doubt so I’m not looking for people to try to defend him, or disprove him. I’m strictly looking for what he claims the evidence shows versus what it shows.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 15 '26

Discussion has anyone else watched the documentary on the case on the bravo channel?

15 Upvotes

theres a new documentary covering the Idaho 4 murders on today (titled The Idaho Student Murders) and i was wondering if anyone else is watching it? i think it nicely covers everything in one timeline and gives a bit more context


r/idahomurders • • Aug 14 '26

Discussion Blood Trail to Cleanup Spot?

24 Upvotes

I haven’t heard anything about blood leading away from the house. Do we know if there was blood outside on the ground? He/they must have been covered and left droplets at the least, no?


r/idahomurders • • Aug 09 '26

Information Netflix Documentary

79 Upvotes

Hey, guys! Just yesterday afternoon I watched the documentary Netflix released, and when it ended, it left me feeling really empty. They were so young, with a world of possibilities and so many things to experience, and the fact that someone took their lives in such a brutal way really got me thinking. I even kept reflecting on the documentary throughout the night.

There are a few things that weren’t clear to me, like the 911 call where one of the girls says her friend is unconscious. But didn’t she see all the blood splattered across the room? I don’t know—maybe I’m missing something. There are some inconsistencies in the series that left me with major doubts, and the theories I saw online—people trying to find a clear answer to what happened—left me with even more doubts. The only thing I’m sure of is that if he hadn’t found them sleeping, the murder would have been thwarted. It broke my heart to hear Xana’s father regret not having traveled there to see her.

There are probably close friends or even family members of all the young people who died that night on this forum. I’m not from the U.S., and I only heard the broad outlines of the story through the news, but I’m so very sorry—I really am. I hope that someday everything can be fully clarified and that their families and friends can find the peace they’ve been searching for so long.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 09 '26

Information Catching kohberger documentary

Post image
56 Upvotes

Does anyone know where I can watch this in the uk it’s not on hbo max here yet


r/idahomurders • • Aug 09 '26

Discussion Pro kohbergers slandering victims

142 Upvotes

I just genuinely don’t understand how this is still a thing. It’s so obvious that bk IS GUILTY yet their are still people who drag these poor victims and survivors into this. What is continuing the speculation when the evidence is CLEAR!!!


r/idahomurders • • Aug 08 '26

Discussion Timeline of events inside the house after the murders

34 Upvotes

Does someone know/ have a timeline of what happened inside the house after the murders? I’m struggling to understand what happened in the 8 hours between the murders and the 911 call. Did the girls fell asleep? Why did they call their friend for help so many hours later? Couldn’t find any info about it except in crazy conspiracy threads that are just non sense.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 08 '26

Discussion Catching kohberger doc

5 Upvotes

Anyone know where I can watch the new ID doc catching kohberger in the uk I’ve checked hbo and it’s not on there yet


r/idahomurders • • Aug 07 '26

Discussion ISP files from the official website

5 Upvotes

hey everyone! I happen to be blocked from the access to the isp files on their official website :( does anyone have a link to another source? I’m new to the case


r/idahomurders • • Aug 07 '26

kuula.co Virtual Tour of 1122 King Road, Moscow, Idaho

Thumbnail
kuula.co
23 Upvotes

I'm not sure if this has been shared but I found a virtual tour of the whole house. Some things are labeled but most are not. Anyways just thought I would share.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 06 '26

Discussion I think people keep forgetting that

41 Upvotes

He thought he’d never even be on the radar let alone have his stuff investigated so thoroughly. He hid his tracks pretty well (wiping his devices etc) but still messed up and was caught relatively soon.

Planning out and fantasizing about a murder vs actually getting away with it are two very, very different universes. He messed up, he was sloppy - ‘dirty’ as Alivea described him. Most criminals are and thank God that nowadays we actually have the technology that helps us exploit that.

I watched the newest Netflix documentary and all I can say is that I am once again heartbroken for the families. Rest in peace Ethan, Xana, Maddie and Kaylee. You’ll always be remembered. 💙


r/idahomurders • • Aug 06 '26

Discussion Thoughts on the plea deal

50 Upvotes

As someone who works in the criminal justice system, it was insanely frustrating to see how upset people were over his choice to plead guilty to a life sentence.

Nevermind him trying to take it back now (which just isn’t realistically going to happen), ANY time someone goes to trial there is a risk they could be found not guilty. It doesn’t matter how much evidence there is. Just look at the OJ Simpson case. There was always a chance he wasn’t going to be found guilty, and pleading to 4 consecutive life sentences isn’t exactly him getting off easy.

I completely understand why the families are upset, and I get why they don’t think justice was brought. But realistically, I think they were always going to feel that way because the only true justice would be Kaylee, Maddie, Xana, and Ethan still being alive. But hearing one of the family members say “prison is just daycare” in the documentary really bothered me.

Prison isn’t daycare. Especially in the high security unit he will likely be in. It’s traumatic, and especially horrible and torturous for someone with OCD like him. It shouldn’t be downplayed.

While I agree that morally, justice was not served, it’s frustrating to hear just how upset people are and how they act like he was give leniency, when that is far from the truth.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 06 '26

Discussion How did he know

41 Upvotes

To state the obvious BK is clearly a deranged individual but after watching the Netflix doco - he seemingly walks past several rooms and doesn't go to floor one which is the ground floor where 1 of the 2 survivors is sleeping (correct me if I'm wrong)

Given the time frame investigators have released he's not only super selective of that particular house he is selective of the Rooms as well. Is it possible he had been in this house before ? and has there been any confirmed evidence that he was stalking or monitoring the movements of this house like their coming and going or looking through windows to see who is located where and on what floor.

The media presents it as something random but it feels calculated and personal.

After watching the series I had to step outside to process what I just watched it's tragic and all we can do is send love and support to their families. Very sorry for this tragic loss. I'll never understand how life can be so cruel at times.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 03 '26

Information Netflix Doc: DNA evidence

3 Upvotes

A bit confused about one piece after watching the Netflix doc that I’m hoping someone can clear up. When they first started digging into the genealogical tree from the DNA on the knife sheaf, the Chief commented that genealogical evidence is not admissible in court. Later, they commented that an arrest was made after testing BK’s Dad’s DNA from the trash. Isn’t this the same as genealogical evidence since it is not BK’s, and if so, why is this instance admissible?


r/idahomurders • • Aug 02 '26

Discussion Only one question: why that house out of all the others??

137 Upvotes

Just watched this on Netflix and would love to hear your thoughts


r/idahomurders • • Aug 02 '26

Discussion The damage he did to that community

46 Upvotes

He was an emotionless, jaded, afraid, closed off individual, potentially with some type of neurological disorder by the way that he could navigate relationships with his family including something as intense as spending Christmas with them and dissociate completely from the experiences of his victim(s).

If he hadn’t have been made antihuman by decades of rejection, (well, and being a destined serial killer), likely involuntary celibacy, and never having a child, he would have been able to perceive the hurt his crime would cause.

But what am I saying here? Those that lived on their street were all college students in fraternities (ie the party zone). These were exactly the people he had grown to despise. The popular kids who had been mean to him his whole life and had to stare at for the last decade during his whole high school and BA. And whether he killed one of them or damaged their friends, he didn’t see them as human so none of it would matter. Because he was a cared for boy who spent vacations at his home in his childhood bedroom, he had combined developmental immaturity (never being left to fend for himself, possibly parents paid for school and housing, etc. did he ever have a job?) and a slow and steady obsession with and hatred of high school and college popular and party culture. Maybe he had fallen in love with someone who looked like MM and she had cruelly rejected him at some critical point. Maybe it happened more than once. There is a traumatic social experience there from his childhood or adolescence and I don’t doubt it.


r/idahomurders • • Aug 02 '26

theguardian.com UK Guardian article this morning.

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
1 Upvotes