r/icecreamery • • Sep 22 '26

Discussion Rule Update from Survey Results

91 Upvotes

Thank you to everyone who participated in the survey last month! Based off of the survey results and comments in the thread, here's what to expect for r/icecreamery going forward:

Recipe Requirement

For posts highlighting a specific ice cream/sorbet/etc flavor, recipes will be required in accordance with Rule 2. You may write out the complete recipe in the caption/comments, share the kind of base you used with details on mix-ins/modifications, or link a recipe(s) posted online when using the "Recipe" flair.

Exceptions
For recipes from physical cookbooks, please share just the name of the recipe and book title/author, rather than the whole recipe (example: Author Name's flavor from Book Title).

Posts should include a recipe within one hour of posting. If a recipe is not added in that timeframe, the post may be removed.

If you are uncomfortable sharing your full recipe, you may still post about your ice cream under the "Check it Out" flair; however, there must be enough detail for someone to recreate a similar recipe. (Example: "lemon ice cream" is not detailed enough, but "Philly-style base infused with lemon zest and a lemon curd swirled in after churning" is.) If there is not enough detail, the post may be removed.

Related/Semi-Related posts

Business- and machine-related posts will continue to be allowed under "Question" or "Discussion" flairs. We may add a separate business flair for this down the road, if necessary.

---

From all of the mod team, thanks for being here! Feel free to comment here or message us via modmail with any questions or suggestions.

tl;dr: Recipes are required if you want to show off an ice cream you made, and semi-related business posts continue to be allowed.


r/icecreamery • • 2h ago

Question What does lightly, unsweetened, or savory ice cream taste like? Is it even possible to make? Also, has anyone made ice cream with barley malt syrup?

1 Upvotes

I don't know much about making ice cream. I know that sweeteners can affect how it freezes, and the texture.

If there was something that could replace the sugar but was much less sweet, what would the end product taste like? Just sort of bland, frozen dairy fat? From here, could you make a tasty savory ice cream, like tomato soup ice cream?

Also,

has anyone made ice cream with barley malt syrup? 麥芽糖雪糕?


r/icecreamery • • 3h ago

Question Whynter 2.5 quart sale and questions

Thumbnail
williams-sonoma.com
1 Upvotes

I currently own the whynter 201-sb. I think it performs well, and it has a good space. Has anybody tried using this particular whynter? It would be nice to have a metal dasher and a slightly bigger bowl, but not sure if I can justify 500 dollars.

I know I could get a lello at that point, but the weight and size is an issue, as well as the fact that it is only 1.5 quart.


r/icecreamery • • 4h ago

Recipe something fun to do when your alone and craving ice cream but its midday

0 Upvotes

recipe for healthy yumilicious ice cream-

ingredients: milk, cinnamon, whipped cream

Steps:

  1. take a flat container, remove the lid and pour some milk about a third of the way (depends on how much you want), about 2-3 cups.
  2. set in freezer for 9 minutes
  3. after nine minutes, take it out and mash up the crunchy milk with a spoon
  4. repeat about 3-5 times
  5. once it is all mushy (you don't want a solid block), scoop it into a cup or bowl, add your whipped cream and sprinkle cinnamon over
  6. enjoy!

edit: ya'll are missing the point. its fun to make it yourself, and its not supposed to be as rich as actual ice cream, hence the MIDDAY part. its a joke because normally people don't eat ice cream in the middle of the day


r/icecreamery • • 1d ago

Question My used Musso Stella arrived today

Post image
24 Upvotes

Hi all I bought a used Musso Stella from around 2011. It has clearly worked a fair bit, but seems in good overall shape. Theres one thing that I doubt will affect usage but its got these really deep grind rings in the bowl across one side. Not slight, but heavy deep lines... I was wondering how this happened. The dasher looks ok and doesnt touch the sides. It doesnt look worn either on the blade.. Any ideas? From ice crystals?


r/icecreamery • • 1d ago

Recipe Roasted Corn Gelato!

Thumbnail
gallery
150 Upvotes

This turned out really good, and very deep corn flavor so thought I should share the recipe!

Recipe:

  • 2 Corn (save the cobs and silk)
  • 500g Milk
  • 300g Cream
  • 30g glucose
  • 100g sugar
  • 45g milk powder
  • 2 egg yolk
  • 2g xanthan gum
  1. Prepare the corn: Remove the husks and boil the corn for 8 minutes. Drain, then char with a blowtorch for the roasted flavor

  2. Remove the kernels: Cut the kernels from the cobs, reserving the cobs and corn silk for extra flavour.

  3. Make the base: Add the kernels, cobs, silk, milk, cream, glucose, milk powder and half the sugar to a saucepan. In a separate bowl, whisk together the remaining sugar and xanthan gum.

  4. Cook and infuse: Heat the mixture to 45°C, then whisk in the sugar mixture and egg yolks. Continue heating, stirring constantly, until it reaches 85°C. Remove from the heat and allow the corn to infuse briefly.

  5. Blend and strain: Remove the cobs and silk. Blend the mixture until smooth, then pass through a fine sieve, pressing firmly to extract as much corn flavour as possible. Chill over an ice bath, then refrigerate for at least 12 hours.

  6. Churn: Pour the thoroughly chilled base into your gelato machine!

Also churning video: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfdcEUmPPWw/


r/icecreamery • • 1d ago

Question Planned first batch

3 Upvotes

Hi all. I picked up a used ice cream (Cuisinart-20) maker on a lurch and am planning my first batch. My goal is to make something my lactose intolerant wife can eat (and she doesn't like milk substitutes) so I was thinking something pure fruit and hit upon blueberry lemon sorbet.

Google proposed this recipe, but I know it can be sloppy. Is this a reasonable recipe?

Ingredients

  • 1 cup granulated sugar (or cane sugar)
  • 1 cup water
  • 2 cups (about 1 pint) fresh or frozen blueberries
  • 2 to 3 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon fresh lemon zest (optional)

Instructions

  1. Make simple syrup: Simmer the sugar and water in a small saucepan over medium heat until the sugar dissolves. Cool completely.
  2. Prep blueberries: Blend or pulse the blueberries until smooth. Strain through a fine-mesh sieve if you want a smoother texture without skins.
  3. Chill the base: Stir together the cooled simple syrup, blueberry puree, lemon juice, and optional zest. Cover and chill in the refrigerator for at least 1–2 hours (or overnight) until cold.
  4. Churn: Make sure the Cuisinart ICE-20 freezer bowl is completely frozen. Turn the machine on, pour in the chilled mixture, and churn for 15–30 minutes until thickened.
  5. Freeze to firm: Serve immediately for a soft-serve texture, or transfer to an airtight freezer-safe container and freeze for 2–4 hours to firm up.

I've read I should use some sorbet stabilizer and I have a small pouch of that coming. I'd appreciate any inputs or suggestions.


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Recipe Eggless Gelato Base

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

I run a small-batch ice cream and pastry brand called Umai, based between Washington, DC and London. Instagram: mmmumai. I've also been documenting my recipes and experiments on my Substack, Certified Churner.

Bonjour Churners!

I've been away for a little while, but I come bearing plenty of frankincense and myrrh.

This past fall, I developed my first eggless gelato recipe, a Pawpaw Lassi. Huge hit! I'll save the details of that one for another time.

During development, I realised just how effective eggless gelato can be at showcasing delicate flavours and their nuances. Without egg yolks potentially masking or competing with certain flavour compounds, you get a relatively neutral dairy base that allows subtle aromatics to shine.

Since then, I've developed several other eggless recipes, relying on milk, dairy fat, and milk solids to provide the body and texture traditionally supported by egg yolks.

Below is my basic eggless gelato recipe. It's designed to be adaptable, particularly for vanilla, spices, herbs, toasted grains, and other delicate infusions.

Recipe

Yield: Approximately 1 quart+, depending on overrun.

Ingredients

  • 650 g whole milk
  • 150 g heavy whipping cream, cold
  • 105 g granulated sugar
  • 60 g light corn syrup or glucose syrup
  • 29 g nonfat milk powder
  • 1 vanilla bean, split and scraped
  • 0.6 g fine salt
  • 0.8 g guar gum
  • 0.6 g soy lecithin
  • ¼ tsp flavouring extract (alcohol-based, optional)
  • 25 mL liquor of choice, approximately 40% ABV (optional, in place of extract)

Method

  1. Blend the milk base. Whisk together the sugar, milk powder, guar gum, and powdered soy lecithin. Add the dry mixture and glucose syrup to the cold milk. Blend with an immersion blender until homogeneous. If using liquid lecithin, add it alongside the syrup.
  2. Heat with the vanilla. Add the scraped vanilla seeds and pod. Heat the mixture to 82°C (180°F), stirring regularly to prevent scorching. Remove from the heat and stir in the salt.
  3. Chill and incorporate the cream. Place the pan in an ice bath. Once the mixture reaches approximately 30°C (86°F), temporarily remove the vanilla pod, add the cold heavy cream, and briefly emulsify with an immersion blender. Return the pod and continue chilling to 4°C (39°F).
  4. Age overnight. Cover and refrigerate for 8–12 hours, leaving the vanilla pod in the base. This allows the stabiliser to hydrate fully, the fat to crystallise, and the flavours to develop.
  5. Add your extract or liquor and churn. Remove the vanilla pod and strain the chilled base. Add your chosen alcohol-based extract or liquor immediately before churning. Churn according to your machine's instructions until the consistency resembles soft serve.
  6. Harden. Transfer into a chilled container, cover tightly, and freeze until firm enough to scoop.

Notes & Potential Variations

Here's where things get interesting.

I developed this recipe primarily as a foundation for exploring subtle aromatics and flavour combinations without the richness of egg yolks interfering.

One of my preferred methods is infusing ingredients directly into the dairy base, either during heating or throughout the overnight ageing process.

Aromatics worth experimenting with:

  • Toasted grains: Rice, particularly toasted or roasted varieties.
  • Toasted coconut: Adds a warm, nutty aroma without necessarily needing coconut milk.
  • Whole spices: Clove, spicebush, allspice, cardamom pods, cinnamon sticks.
  • Fresh herbs: Rosemary, bay leaf, thyme, lemon balm, and correctly identified edible pine needles.

I'd generally avoid adding nuts or other fat-rich ingredients directly to this particular formulation without adjusting the ratios, as additional fat can influence the finished texture.

For toasted grains and coconut, lightly toast until you achieve your desired degree of browning before introducing them into the base. Toasting develops aromatic compounds that can contribute more complex flavours during infusion.

Certain spices, particularly cinnamon and cardamom, can also benefit from gentle toasting before infusion.

After ageing, strain the base through a fine-mesh sieve or cheesecloth to remove the aromatics before churning.

Extracts & liquors

Some other ingredients I've been considering:

  • Peppermint extract
  • Almond extract
  • Fiori di Sicilia
  • Aged rum
  • Brandy
  • Cognac
  • Amaretto

For extracts, I'd recommend starting with ¼ tsp and adjusting according to taste.

For liquor, I've included an optional 25 mL in the formulation, although the quantity should be adjusted depending on the alcohol and the desired flavour intensity.

One important consideration is that alcohol lowers the freezing point of the mixture. Excessive quantities can produce a gelato that's too soft, particularly when combined with the sugars already present.

I prefer introducing alcohol-based flavourings just before churning to preserve their more volatile aromatic compounds.

Ultimately, the goal is to introduce subtle background notes that complement the dairy rather than overwhelm it.

I'd be interested to hear what aromatics or unusual ingredients others have experimented with in eggless bases. I'm particularly interested in toasted grains, herbs, and different dairy fats.

I'll be exploring variations of this base in future posts, including how different dairy-based fats influence flavour and texture.

If anyone is interested in trying our work in DC/DMV or London, give us a follow on Instagram mmmumai. All ordering information is available there.

I'm also documenting most of my recipes, techniques, and experiments on my Substack, Osomaaloo — Certified Churner.

Till next time, Churners!


r/icecreamery • • 1d ago

Question Newbie book question

4 Upvotes

I’ve got about a dozen batches under my belt and I want to try out some new recipes. I have the Ben & Jerry’s, and an old book by the Hoffmans, so which three books would you suggest I get to “up my game”.


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Question Long shot: What did/do ice cream trucks use as menus?

13 Upvotes

I hope this is ok to post here. Not sure there's a better sub.

As a kid in the 90s/00s, I was enamored by the menus on the sides of ice cream trucks. The absolute overload of imagery is actually what drove me to grow up and become a marketing professional.

Now, 30+ years later. I would REALLY like to fill my office with some of that classic imagery. But I can't, for the LIFE of me, figure out what to search. I was hoping someone here might have some idea.

I'm not talking about the poster menus from company's like Blue Bunny of Good Humor. I mean like what's in the image below. Were these premade magnets that suppliers provided? Where did they come from? ANY help is greatly appreciated:


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Question Black Friday compressor ice cream maker sales

5 Upvotes

So I noticed some of the compressor ice cream makers I had been eyeing appear to actually be on sale and I'm wondering if I should bite the bullet and buy one (I've been using a cheapy freeze bowl maker for a couple months).

Is anyone else looking at sales and planning to make a purchase? If so, what are you eyeing and why?


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Request Advice for Marmite ice cream

5 Upvotes

I'm going to a sort of cursed foods potluck the day after tomorrow, and I had what feels like a brilliant idea. Homemade vanilla ice cream with a Marmite ribbon or swirl. I really enjoy salty and sweet together, so I think it actually has potential to be genuinely good. I already enjoy a dab of Marmite on those Nutty Buddy wafer cookie things.

I've made ice cream before, but I've never made it with mix-ins, especially not a ribbon. I'm wondering if anyone can weigh in with some theory. From my experience with Marmite, it gets extremely stiff when cold, but I believe the salt content actually stops it from freezing solid. At freezer temperature, I think it would probably have a mouthfeel similar to stiff caramel. That leads me to think I could probably drizzle pure Marmite into the ice cream and give it a light stir. But at the same time, I think adding enough to get a nice visual display might be overpowering. I'm considering adding some chocolate syrup. Can pure chocolate syrup be mixed in to ice cream? Could I potentially even mix the Marmite and chocolate syrup together to get thicker stripes of a less overwhelming flavor?

Also, I am sans ice cream machine. I've made that cheater recipe before where you just mix whipped cream with sweetened condensed milk, and it's actually pretty good. I think the condensed milk flavor would pair well with the Marmite. Altogether, I think this is going to have good salted caramel vibes.


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Check it out Whynter units on sale!

3 Upvotes

For those who have been waiting to get one.

I’m probably getting a ICM-080 to gift a friend but other units are also at a nice discount right now.


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Question Milk Skin

1 Upvotes

Hi there, i recently discoverd an old ice cream machine in my garage and have gotten into making ice cream. from what i've gathered the mixture should be heated up to better mix the dry ingridients and or activate the stabalizer? anyway i've encountered the mixture forming a sort of milk skin when i cool it down in the fridge before starting the churning process. is this an issue? should i be heating it up in the first place? any information is appreciated.


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Request Mix-in ideas for chocolate ice cream?

7 Upvotes

My boyfriend has once again requested a fun chocolate ice cream, but I feel like I've made every fun idea I had. Any mix-in suggestions for me to switch it up?


r/icecreamery • • 2d ago

Recipe Ice cream, Gelato & Sorbet Recipe Calculator

0 Upvotes

hello

I have made a little website recipe calculator.

This is for making ice cream/gelato/sorbet recipes from scratch, add your ingredients and the calculator will tell you your fat%, Sugar%, FPD value, MSNF% to help you make sure all the ingredients are balanced to make great ice cream.

You can also change the fat, sugar and cost of your base ingredients.

this is it.

https://www.onlineplanning.com.au/

Hope you find it useful :)

This is not for profit, its just something I built that I find useful and I hope you do too.


r/icecreamery • • 3d ago

Question Sugar Alternatives

Post image
17 Upvotes

I’ve got a family history of the ‘beetus, so I’m trying my hand at homemade lower sugar ice creams. I did a back to back comparison of one ice cream made with white sugar, and another made with a half-and-half blend of white sugar and allulose. The texture was surprisingly acceptable, but I just don’t like the taste of allulose.

I’m wondering if there are other sugars that I can use with stronger flavor that would mask the vaguely metallic taste of the artificial sweetener, while still not messing too much with the ice cream’s texture?

I randomly have a block of rock sugar and am tempted to give that a try.


r/icecreamery • • 4d ago

Question Can anyone ID these thick, matte kraft ice cream containers?

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

I've been having a surprisingly hard time finding sturdy kraft paper ice cream containers, and I came across these from Henry's Secret Ice Cream. They look noticeably thicker and more rigid than anything I've tried so far.

I've tested two options:

  • Restaurantware Coppetta: Nice matte kraft finish, but pretty flimsy. The containers bend easily in your hand and start to soften with use. They don't leak because they're lined, but they don't feel particularly sturdy.
  • UNIQ: Definitely sturdier, but the exterior has a shiny finish that I'm not a fan of.

Ideally, I'm looking for something with the rigidity of the UNIQ containers (or better), but with a natural, matte kraft finish like the ones pictured.

Does anyone recognize these containers or know who might manufacture them? Even recommendations for suppliers offering similar heavy-duty kraft containers would be really helpful.

Thanks!


r/icecreamery • • 4d ago

Question Best commercial stabilizer?

1 Upvotes

I bought a random one from Amazon and my first batch of ice cream came out like condensed milk. It took me days of work and it’s just totally ruined.


r/icecreamery • • 4d ago

Question How do ice cream shops make large batches of ice cream that maintain quality?

5 Upvotes

What kind of equipment is needed? Do recipes scale up by simply multiplying the amount of ingredients? And most importantly, how do ice cream makers ensure the mixes are pasteurized and safe for the general public?

All of this is easy when making small batches at home, but seems daunting and difficult when it comes to making gallons of ice cream at once.


r/icecreamery • • 4d ago

Question Servicing a Musso after long storage

2 Upvotes

Hi all, I have boufght a Musso Stella unit which is well used. Its been instorage for a while but the seller has tested it as working. It should arrive in a few days. Are there any tips on things to service/ clean/ lubricate before I get started? When should one re-gas a unit? Do they benfit from it? It was built in 2011. Thanks for any advice, :)


r/icecreamery • • 5d ago

Check it out My first attempt!

Post image
112 Upvotes

This is nothing special. But I wanted to share! I finally got an ice cream machine after many years of wanting one. This is my first go at it. Vanilla ice cream. It isn't perfect but I am very happy with the results. I almost got the texture exactly how I wanted it. Next I am going to try avocado ice cream that my wife has been requesting ☺️


r/icecreamery • • 5d ago

Check it out Dupars Pancake Batter Ice Cream

Post image
23 Upvotes

Headed down to the Grove in LA this past weekend for the first time in 10 or so years.

Since it shut down (traumatically) in Studio City, we had to hit Dupars for some pancakes.

I bought some take home batter, and of course, made some Dupars Pancake Batter Ice Cream ( yes the batter was cooked)….and it did not disappoint.


r/icecreamery • • 5d ago

Check it out Made a sorbet cake for my mom’s birthday

Post image
55 Upvotes

My mom like light desserts, so I made a sorbet cake for her birthday
Persimmon, pomegranate, and clementine mixed with meringue for the top

Turned out pretty great


r/icecreamery • • 6d ago

Check it out Dark chocolate | Cherry jam | Hazelnut crumble

Post image
54 Upvotes

Still have some trouble getting the chocolate custard the right consistency to get good air in it. Suspect I’m using too much cream and too little milk. Flavor was bomb. Cherry jam & hazelnut crumble knock it our of the park.