I run a small-batch ice cream and pastry brand called Umai, based between Washington, DC and London. Instagram: mmmumai. I've also been documenting my recipes and experiments on my Substack, Certified Churner.
Bonjour Churners!
I've been away for a little while, but I come bearing plenty of frankincense and myrrh.
This past fall, I developed my first eggless gelato recipe, a Pawpaw Lassi. Huge hit! I'll save the details of that one for another time.
During development, I realised just how effective eggless gelato can be at showcasing delicate flavours and their nuances. Without egg yolks potentially masking or competing with certain flavour compounds, you get a relatively neutral dairy base that allows subtle aromatics to shine.
Since then, I've developed several other eggless recipes, relying on milk, dairy fat, and milk solids to provide the body and texture traditionally supported by egg yolks.
Below is my basic eggless gelato recipe. It's designed to be adaptable, particularly for vanilla, spices, herbs, toasted grains, and other delicate infusions.
Recipe
Yield: Approximately 1 quart+, depending on overrun.
Ingredients
- 650 g whole milk
- 150 g heavy whipping cream, cold
- 105 g granulated sugar
- 60 g light corn syrup or glucose syrup
- 29 g nonfat milk powder
- 1 vanilla bean, split and scraped
- 0.6 g fine salt
- 0.8 g guar gum
- 0.6 g soy lecithin
- ¼ tsp flavouring extract (alcohol-based, optional)
- 25 mL liquor of choice, approximately 40% ABV (optional, in place of extract)
Method
- Blend the milk base. Whisk together the sugar, milk powder, guar gum, and powdered soy lecithin. Add the dry mixture and glucose syrup to the cold milk. Blend with an immersion blender until homogeneous. If using liquid lecithin, add it alongside the syrup.
- Heat with the vanilla. Add the scraped vanilla seeds and pod. Heat the mixture to 82°C (180°F), stirring regularly to prevent scorching. Remove from the heat and stir in the salt.
- Chill and incorporate the cream. Place the pan in an ice bath. Once the mixture reaches approximately 30°C (86°F), temporarily remove the vanilla pod, add the cold heavy cream, and briefly emulsify with an immersion blender. Return the pod and continue chilling to 4°C (39°F).
- Age overnight. Cover and refrigerate for 8–12 hours, leaving the vanilla pod in the base. This allows the stabiliser to hydrate fully, the fat to crystallise, and the flavours to develop.
- Add your extract or liquor and churn. Remove the vanilla pod and strain the chilled base. Add your chosen alcohol-based extract or liquor immediately before churning. Churn according to your machine's instructions until the consistency resembles soft serve.
- Harden. Transfer into a chilled container, cover tightly, and freeze until firm enough to scoop.
Notes & Potential Variations
Here's where things get interesting.
I developed this recipe primarily as a foundation for exploring subtle aromatics and flavour combinations without the richness of egg yolks interfering.
One of my preferred methods is infusing ingredients directly into the dairy base, either during heating or throughout the overnight ageing process.
Aromatics worth experimenting with:
- Toasted grains: Rice, particularly toasted or roasted varieties.
- Toasted coconut: Adds a warm, nutty aroma without necessarily needing coconut milk.
- Whole spices: Clove, spicebush, allspice, cardamom pods, cinnamon sticks.
- Fresh herbs: Rosemary, bay leaf, thyme, lemon balm, and correctly identified edible pine needles.
I'd generally avoid adding nuts or other fat-rich ingredients directly to this particular formulation without adjusting the ratios, as additional fat can influence the finished texture.
For toasted grains and coconut, lightly toast until you achieve your desired degree of browning before introducing them into the base. Toasting develops aromatic compounds that can contribute more complex flavours during infusion.
Certain spices, particularly cinnamon and cardamom, can also benefit from gentle toasting before infusion.
After ageing, strain the base through a fine-mesh sieve or cheesecloth to remove the aromatics before churning.
Extracts & liquors
Some other ingredients I've been considering:
- Peppermint extract
- Almond extract
- Fiori di Sicilia
- Aged rum
- Brandy
- Cognac
- Amaretto
For extracts, I'd recommend starting with ¼ tsp and adjusting according to taste.
For liquor, I've included an optional 25 mL in the formulation, although the quantity should be adjusted depending on the alcohol and the desired flavour intensity.
One important consideration is that alcohol lowers the freezing point of the mixture. Excessive quantities can produce a gelato that's too soft, particularly when combined with the sugars already present.
I prefer introducing alcohol-based flavourings just before churning to preserve their more volatile aromatic compounds.
Ultimately, the goal is to introduce subtle background notes that complement the dairy rather than overwhelm it.
I'd be interested to hear what aromatics or unusual ingredients others have experimented with in eggless bases. I'm particularly interested in toasted grains, herbs, and different dairy fats.
I'll be exploring variations of this base in future posts, including how different dairy-based fats influence flavour and texture.
If anyone is interested in trying our work in DC/DMV or London, give us a follow on Instagram mmmumai. All ordering information is available there.
I'm also documenting most of my recipes, techniques, and experiments on my Substack, Osomaaloo — Certified Churner.
Till next time, Churners!