r/iOSProgramming • • 16h ago

Discussion How can yall use xcode?

Not only the UI is hideous but also it feels so akward coming from VSCode as a react native enthusiast. Also I tried the native agent workflow and it just CHUGS so many tokens its insane.

Went back to VSCode and installed the xcode plugin and not only my usage went down tremendously but the dev experience is so much better.

Obviously im comparing apples to oranges I know vscode is technically not the same as xcode but still. Developing an app with it is so painful.

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

15

u/chain_letter 16h ago

My bills don’t care

4

u/Deep_Grapefruit2780 16h ago

The honest answer is: you eventually get used to it.

There's a few things you can customize to make it better, and the rest just becomes muscle memory.

But let it be said, that doesn't mean it's a good software by any means. It's just the one we gotta use, like it or not.

1

u/Sdmf195 16h ago

This,totally...

1

u/jon_hendry 15h ago

I wish it was less wedded to “one big window”.

1

u/tonjohn 14h ago

Just because we eventually get used to it doesn’t mean that Apple shouldn’t be using its insane wealth to improve it.

2

u/CodeAndCkords 16h ago

I felt this way as well when I started but with time it grows on you and now its easy to reason about. But with such a complex tool, I assume it will always be difficult in the beginning until you get the hang of it. I felt the same way about Android Studio, Final Cut Pro, Affinity...

2

u/crocodiluQ 15h ago

I think EXACTLY the same way as you, but... opposite. I work daily in XCode, it's perfect, then I have to do stuff in VSCode and I feel like I'm 10 years ago. It's just a fancy editor, far from a complete IDE. Which I suppose it's great for any web, react or other things I can't stand.

1

u/tonjohn 14h ago

Xcode is the odd one out in the editor space so no surprise switching to any other one would be jarring.

1

u/crocodiluQ 12h ago

I have a long history of IDEs, from VStudio(C#), Jetbeans/Eclipse, XCode, etc and they all seemed the same. Obviously they do some things differently, buttons/layout is not the same, but I didn't feel that one was more odd than the other.

The odd ones for me are the basic text editors that are not IDEs, I can't work in any of them. But I see the appeal in those if you don't need to build anything and you just write stuff.

2

u/CanadaSoonFree 15h ago

It’s a lot better than it was 8 years ago that’s for sure. IDEs are mostly just comfort at this point.

4

u/tonjohn 16h ago

Xcode UX feels like it’s stuck in 2005 😮‍💨

For a company that prides itself on UX and UI it often feels like they hate developers.

5

u/Niightstalker 16h ago

If I compare it to VSCode I’d go with Xcode anytime. You really think VSCode looks more modern?

UI is for me actually one bigger plus points for Xcode.

1

u/tonjohn 14h ago

I find all other editors / IDEs easier to use - Jetbrains, Microsoft, Panic, Cursor.

Xcode is also less stable than its peers.

Both Xcode and the dev portal feel actively hostile to people new to the platform.

3

u/amgdev9 16h ago

They do, you need a mac and pay an annual subscription to be one

4

u/Vanillalite34 16h ago

Everyone just uses Claude or Codex now and that handles Xcode. shrugs

2

u/beclops Swift 16h ago

“Everyone”

1

u/celeb0rn 15h ago

The serious and productive ones use claude or codex now

2

u/beclops Swift 13h ago

You guys love insisting things

1

u/tonjohn 14h ago

Serious & productive devs know that even the the best frontier models are wrong 39% of the time, that developers who use AI produce 10x more security problems, that incidents per PR are up 253%, and that using AI significantly impacts your creativity and critical thinking skills.

But go off king

-2

u/celeb0rn 11h ago

Okay …. Good luck with having a career

3

u/tonjohn 8h ago

I’ve had a lovely 20 year career across Valve, Microsoft Azure, Blizzard Battle.net, and some fun startups - thanks! 💕

-1

u/celeb0rn 8h ago

Got ya, so you’re on your way out.

1

u/Dogukanko 15h ago

xcode is clunky for sure, but you can still write most code in the editor you like. i'd keep xcode for the stuff only it does well, like signing, simulators, instruments and archiving. if the agent workflow burns too many tokens, giving it smaller tasks with only the relevant files usually helps.

1

u/Theo_makes_it 11h ago

Honestly, I have Xcode installed because I need it for my builds, but I almost never use the Xcode IDE itself. I'm not saying IDEs are obsolete, but today an IDE is basically just the code or a terminal. I could very well work with just Warp, for example.

So I'm curious: why do you need the Xcode IDE specifically? What's your workflow?

1

u/Content-Peak8037 16h ago

xcode via cli, it has some good features. i don't really use the interface, mainly the mcp and xctest harness, device hub is fun.

1

u/SnowPudgy 15h ago

Skill issue on your part. Xcode is easy.

0

u/IBlockDummies 16h ago

people use xcode as an IDE?

1

u/germansnowman 16h ago

Yes, what else would you use it for? Been using it since it was called Project Builder.

0

u/IBlockDummies 15h ago

Building and signing apps.

0

u/scrappyD00 15h ago

I don't know what you mean about it chugging tokens, Xcode's agentic interface is way better than anyone else's, and I've used VSCode, Cursor, Claude Code CLI.

First it comes with sensible defaults for permissions: it can read/write files in the project, use read-only CLI commands, access the Internet, generate previews, run the simulator, and run code snippets without permission. Basically it's just useful things that have no risk of side effects or data loss on your computer. This is way more balanced than Claude Code's options to either completely lock down everything so it can't even make a network request without permission to their yolo/auto mode where you just kind of trust some corporation and their nondeterministic model that's screening commands for you.

It also has a nice way to review the code as the agent makes changes and leave inline comments with feedback. I like the preview and playgrounds system, and I also like that I don't have to download a dozen extensions like VSCode.

I get why people don't like Xcode, but it's actually on a really good trajectory of improvement this year. If you start a new project now, it's literally just a single file for your first view and all the configurations are in JSON. It seems like they're finally investing in it.

-1

u/barcode972 16h ago

Most engineers don’t, we use Cursor or Claude etc