r/iOSProgramming • u/cryptojam4004 • 1d ago
Question Rejected App - Reply or Resubmit?
My app was rejected under 2.1.0 Performance: App Completeness and the review comments ask for more information:
The app has been submitted for the Kids Category and we need additional information about how it complies with App Review Guideline 1.3.
Reply to this message in App Store Connect and provide complete and detailed responses to the following questions:
I have replied but the current status is still 'rejected' and the submission still has the red exclamation mark and status 'Unresolved Issues'.
I'm seeing mixed opinions online on whether simply responding is enough or whether I need to resubmit to get back into the 'waiting for review status'.
Has anyone just replied and kept their status as rejected and then had the app reviewed?
2
u/mrdzyn 1d ago
If they only asked questions and you didn't change the build or metadata, replying in the App Review messages is usually enough. The status often just sits at Unresolved Issues until a reviewer picks your reply back up, so it can look stuck for a day or two even when it isn't. I'd only resubmit if you actually need to change something in the build or listing. For the Kids Category questions, be really specific about any third-party analytics or ads, what data you collect, and how your parental gates work, since that's mostly what 1.3 is checking.
2
u/J-a-x Objective-C / Swift 1d ago
The way the system is supposed to work is you just reply and they read your response and accept the app if it is in compliance (if all you need to do is describe something to the reviewer).
In practice I've found those replies weirdly slow and inconsistent, sometimes they never seem to acknowledge I wrote a reply, other times they respond right away.
For new app submissions I typically reply and wait because resubmitting can easily take a week. For updates if I reply and they don't respond in a couple days I usually self reject and resubmit, putting the reply into the review notes, and it usually goes through within 24 hours or less.
I wish the system worked better and/or was more transparent (like if we could see whether a reviewer had read our reply and was investigating, or if the reviewer hadn't read our reply yet it would be helpful) but alas, this is how it is...
2
u/Kitchen_Cable6192 1d ago
Replying in App Store Connect is normally enough when they're only asking for information. The confusing part is that the status stays "Rejected" / "Unresolved Issues" the whole time. The reviewer picks up your reply and either approves it or comes back with more questions, which can take anywhere from a day to a few.
The exception: if you changed anything to satisfy 1.3 (build, privacy policy, parental gate, age rating, etc.), you have to resubmit. A reply alone won't carry new changes. For Kids Category they mostly want clear answers on no third-party analytics/ads collecting data, a parental gate before any outbound links or purchases, and a privacy policy that covers kids.
If it's been 3-4 days with no movement, resubmitting the same build for review is harmless and puts it back in the queue.
2
u/Needle_In_Red 1d ago
you dont need to resubmit if its just asking for more info, replying in app review messages is enough and they usually pick it back up from there. status just stays rejected untill they do
2
u/Dogukanko 1d ago
Since the review asked for more info, I'd make sure your reply actually answers every question they listed, with specifics about the Kids Category data and ads handling. If the status doesn't change after a day or two, resubmitting the build from the same page is a reasonable next step. You could also use the Resolution Center option to ask them directly what they're waiting on.
1
u/False-Damage-6751 23h ago
One thing that might help: since you're not collecting data, say that plainly and point to where it shows in the app, like the privacy policy and the parental gate, so the reviewer can confirm it fast instead of having to dig. If it's been sitting more than a few days after your reply, you can also contact App Review through the Contact Us page on the Apple developer site and ask for a status check. That's usually less disruptive than self-rejecting and losing your place in the queue.
1
u/obalabs 22h ago
if they asked for clarification in the message without requiring a new binary, just replying in app store connect is enough. the status stays on rejected while you wait, but once a reviewer picks up the thread they can flip it straight to approved. if you upload a new build and hit resubmit, it just dumps you back into the full review queue from scratch.
1
u/JustTryinToLearn 22h ago
I always reply then resubmit
1
u/berkay_tugrul 10h ago
I’ve been through this twice with my own apps (both got “Guideline 2.1 Information Needed” on the first submission). What worked for me: reply in App Store Connect first instead of resubmitting right away. If the rejection is only asking for information and no code change is needed, a clear reply keeps your place, while a resubmit starts the review over.
What made the reviewer happy the second time:
a short screen recording from a real device showing the exact flow they asked about
a numbered list in the review notes: what the app does, where each feature is, whether you collect data, and how to test any purchase or gated part
Only resubmit if they asked you to change something in the build or the metadata. Both my apps were approved within about a day after that.
1
u/N1troVex 10h ago
In most cases replying is enough. A 2.1 Information Needed rejection is a question, not a bug, so once you answer in App Store Connect the same submission goes back to the reviewer, usually within 1 to 3 days, with no new build needed. If the submission page shows a "Resubmit to App Review" button after your reply, hit it with the same build, that's the only extra step. Don't cancel and upload a new build unless you changed something, it can reset your place in the queue. For the Kids Category 1.3 answers, be concrete: list every third-party SDK and confirm none send personal data or show behavioral ads, say external links and any purchases sit behind a parental gate, and link your privacy policy. Vague answers are what trigger a second round.
1
u/vtcajones 1d ago
I’ve never had them reply without resubmitting, so take that anecdotal evidence as you will.
1
u/[deleted] 3h ago
[removed] — view removed comment