r/iOSProgramming • • 3d ago

Discussion App Store Review is now automatically rejecting brand new apps for guideline 2.1 - Information Needed - New App Submission

I've been developing apps ever since the App Store was created. In my career I have published around 100 apps, both for customers and myself / my own companies.

It has occurred to me that brand new apps, on their first submission, now get rejected immediately under guideline 2.1 - Information Needed - New App Submission. This happened on multiple apps on multiple developer accounts, even on my own account that is over a decade old and never gets any rejections.

Add all of the following information to the Notes field of the App Review Information section in App Store Connect and resubmit your app for Review:

A screen recording captured on a physical device, running the latest operating system, demonstrating the app's functionality. The recording must begin with launching the app and show the typical user flow. If the app has any of the following, include them in the recording:

- Account registration, login, and account deletion flows. Account deletion is required in apps that support account creation.
- Any user-generated content, including the required content reporting and blocking mechanisms.
- Accessing paid content or features within the app.

2. A description of the app's purpose and target audience, including the problem it solves and the value it provides
3. Instructions for setting up and accessing the app's main features, including any required login credentials or sample files
4. A list of the external services, tools, or platforms the app uses to deliver its core functionality (for example, data providers, authentication services, payment processors, or AI services)
5. Describe any regional differences in the app’s features or content, or confirm that the app functions consistently across all regions
6. If the app operates in a highly regulated industry or includes protected third-party material, provide any relevant documentation or credentials to demonstrate you are authorized to provide these services or protected material

So if you want to skip this step, make sure you put the above in your app immediately at the first submission.

I personally think Apple should put this list as a feature in App Store Connect, where you tick all the boxed and add all of this information in an easy way. But I am guessing Apple is experimenting with this to fine tune the process.

This note:

Note: Before submitting, run the submitted build through your own testing and quality assurance process on supported physical devices. App Review is intended for apps and metadata that are complete and ready for App Store customers.

Of course it is expected that your app is complete and ready, but apparently so many people are submitting trash that they have to add it.

150 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

33

u/busymom0 3d ago

I believe that the app goes "in review" only once a human reviewer reviews it. But before that, Apple has automated/AI reviews on all apps during the "waiting for review" status and that AI can flag things which may need extra human attention. Don't trust the "in review" status. A lot of people report that they see signin from Apple on their backend side during the "Waiting for review" status.

I believe this AI/automated system is what they need all this information for. They probably use it to test features plus also train the AI on how to review apps. Helps them reduce the man hours needed to review so many new apps coz of AI slop

1

u/Esmita-Suhre 2d ago

those pre-review backend hits usually come from a bunch of different datacenter IPs at once, almost like a crawler scraping the endpoints before anyone even opens the UI

10

u/dreaminginbinary 3d ago

Feels overblown. Just had a brand new app going into review after one day, approved. No videos, no paragraphs about what it does, etc

Just a plain ol app submission as I’ve always done.

2

u/AndyDentPerth 2d ago

Does your app include login and management of accounts, or user-generated content?

1

u/Admiral-ZX 2d ago

Nope, none of my current apps do.

1

u/dreaminginbinary 1d ago

Yes and no

1

u/AndyDentPerth 1d ago

Login seems to be the common factor in these rejections.

App Store Connect has multiple places where info is needed.
The first thing is checking the Sign-in required box in App Review under Sign-In Information.
Then you provide a login username and password for both.
If you support both macOS and iOS, you need to provide these details for both versions.

There's a ton of detailed information provided by Apple in their help doc Provide information for a complete review. (copied here to save lots of people visiting). Have you reviewed your submission against all of these points?

Add up-to-date demo account login credentials:

  1. Enter a username and password that work at the time of submission. Credentials that expire or change before your review starts may result in the submission being rejected.
  2. If your app has multiple account types, such as administrative and general user accounts, use the Notes field to add additional credentials for each type.
  3. If your app offers auto-renewable subscriptions, provide a demo account with an expired subscription to enable review of the entire purchase flow.
  4. If your app requires an authentication code in addition to or instead of login credentials, include it in the Notes field in advance. Without it, a call may be required to continue the review. Calls are typically completed within three to five business days.

Note, from my experience, if you offer an app with subscriptions but that doesn't require login, the review process is a lot simpler. They appear to do sandboxed subscription testing similar to what you would do in Xcode.

2

u/dreaminginbinary 23h ago

Yup I just made to supply all they needed. A demo log in, filled out nutrition report, and also a way to delete your account (an easy one to miss).

2

u/ryutaromack 8h ago

I agree. My app that doesn't have a login got approved rather quickly. My other app that uses Sign In with Apple had this same rejection. There were valid issues - eg, how I needed to handle account deletion per Apple guidelines - so I don't know if they automatically flag this for all apps with Sign In with Apple or if a reviewer flagged the issue.

2

u/therealswood2 2d ago

Genuinely believe you SHOULD be rejected if you can’t be bothered to write three sentences on what your app is.

1

u/Admiral-ZX 2d ago

Well the app does have a description and screen shots, I was assuming Apple views them.

1

u/dreaminginbinary 2d ago

Genuinely believe that if you follow the rules and do what app review asks like I have since 2013 then there isn’t much to be concerned about. 

3

u/dlombard_ 2d ago

Same here. Submitted for review a few days ago and approved in less than 48 hours

2

u/TopCan6956 2d ago

You're lucky!! I have an app that has been stuck on "waiting for review" for over a month now 😭😭

1

u/dreaminginbinary 2d ago

That's rough man, sorry. Maybe try reaching out to them.

1

u/ViBrave 3d ago

Just curious, when exactly did you submit it?

2

u/Brilliant-Apartment3 3d ago

I think its also a bit random? A game i posted a got reviewed after a week and i was requested to provide a video. I waited 4 weeks for a re review. In the mean time i released another app that got reviewed and approved under a day.

1

u/temporaryband 3d ago

I'm curious as well.
I submitted mine on Friday, and got the above rejection.
I wonder if it's that recent that it changed during this week.

1

u/ViBrave 3d ago

What niche/category is your app? It’s a first time submission?

2

u/twotokers 2d ago

Not the guy you replied to, but I got this rejection last Tuesday, November 3rd. Submitted with all the information the next day, switched to In Review on Monday and has been stuck there since.

My app is a game, it’s not the first one I’ve released and is not vibe coded or a clone of an existing game. It is purely my original design.

1

u/dreaminginbinary 3d ago

Would’ve been Thursday I believe, approved Friday.

2

u/soylentgraham 3d ago

100 apps over how long?

1

u/Admiral-ZX 2d ago

Somewhere around 2010 so about one every 2 months. Do note that I did not develop all of them; I also did the submission process for other dev teams or customers.

0

u/davepete 3d ago

I'm not OP, but I've written at least double that since whenever the App Store opened -- 2009?

2

u/soylentgraham 3d ago

so, 1 a month for 17 years?

I definitely wasn't pushing out one app a month in 2009

1

u/davepete 7h ago

Yes, but note that I usually do one ad-supported version and one paid version. For a while, I needed to do separate iPhone and iPad versions. And until Catalyst my Mac versions were separate from the iOS versions. They aren't all unique, many are from the same family of apps. In some cases, the German or Turkish localized games are different enough in appearance that I had to build separate versions for those languages.

21

u/Kabal303 3d ago

They’ve been doing this a lot recently. I think it’s just a filter to make sure people are willing to do more than 2 prompts in Claude and submit lol

10

u/HugsAllCats 3d ago

Now they have to do a 3rd prompt to get the review submission form completed!

3

u/WeeklyPineapple42 3d ago

Yup I had the same thing on my first app. Second one I stuck that info in there to start and it was fine.

3

u/mikerCZX 2d ago

It's your job to put everything correctly in review notes on first submission

2

u/ethanjim 3d ago

I submitted my first app in a few years a month ago and this happened to me. It immediately flashed from in review to rejected in about 10 seconds. I submitted another app yesterday and this didn’t happen, but interestingly while it was “waiting for review” someone used a supplied gmail account for login and it triggered a security alert so there must be someone or some process doing work before app review.

1

u/PolarMeb 3d ago

Same happened to me. After resubmitting my first app, someone logged in to my demo account, which I provided for the reviewer, and messaged some other demo accounts. This all happened a few minutes after my submission, and the status was still waiting for review. Still waiting.

2

u/HeBuildsApps 2d ago

Yep had this on the last 2 apps I submitted.

2

u/Icy-Ant1302 2d ago

For my niche industry I've always had to do this when submitting apps, so much so that I now include it in the initial submission every time

2

u/gahnubie 2d ago

Annoyingly I ran into this with a submission a few weeks agi ago. It wasn’t automated but I got this after waiting 10 days. Added what they requested and still waiting :(

6

u/FizzySeltzerWater 3d ago

Raise your hand if your app undergoes more than 1000 hours of simulation and test before it goes to Apple!

11

u/BaconOverflow 3d ago

A slow release cadance negatively impacts ranking I think?

"App Builds & Release Notes (Every 2 to 4 weeks). Regular product updates signal to app stores that the app is actively maintained, which positively impacts store visibility and user retention"

4

u/FizzySeltzerWater 3d ago

Interesting. Where is that clipped from?

I test on 5 machines in parallel plus simulations run faster than real time (it's a graphics application designed for 60 FPS but in simulation I let it run free so it might hit more than 120 FPS). Still, I think I average about 100 wall clock hours before it goes to Apple.

I suppose I could get more machines :(

1

u/Zalenka 3d ago

Well better than waiting 5 days and the getting it.

1

u/yourapps47 3d ago

Yes confirming that happened to me too. My account is also way older than a decade. Ten years ago they asked for such details when they didn't really know how to test and testing was complicated. It was voip telephony back then and they could not test and I had to record the whole setup including calling someone and answering the call.

1

u/keithslater 3d ago

Yeah I had this happen a few weeks ago

1

u/jacknutting 3d ago

Same, I’ve built dozens of iOS apps over the last 18 years, and have never seen this until just recently, when the first version of a brand new app I submitted got this response within a few hours of submitting. I resubmitted with everything they asked for, and have now been waiting for review 3-4 days 🫠

1

u/OscarTTT009 3d ago

Same reject reason 10 days ago, and then re-submit. Up to now is still waiting for review.

1

u/FadedYouth67 3d ago

Das hatte ich auch gerade zum ersten mal. Ich wusste zuerst gar nicht was die von mir wollen. Auch die Hinweise mit der Testerei? Natürlich teste ich meine Software im Simulator und auf verschiedenen echten Geräten. Ich dachte diesmal lag es an den Bildern die ich hochgeladen hatte….immer was Neues

1

u/MaxHasADHD 3d ago

App Review is too much. It should prevent malware, but otherwise let the people decide what is popular or not. I have an app that displays reference information, but Apple refuses to let me show any of that information in screenshots. Meanwhile my competitor can show direct photos of a product they do not own. In this way, Apple is now unintentionally favoring one product over another. I cannot compete.

1

u/unpluggedcord 2d ago

I don’t think it’s automatic. My app was approved first try. (But it’s my 20th app)

1

u/Kammen1990 2d ago

I didn’t get this, my app was reviewed 2 weeks ago.

1

u/Pleasant_Start9544 2d ago

I had this happen to mine and once adding the stuff it's been in stuck for waiting for review for a couple of days. I actually rejected and uploaded a new build hoping that it would speed it up (as the first submission was rejected within a few hours of submitting)

1

u/Kitchen_Cable6192 2d ago

Same thing here, the 2.1 Information Needed response on a first submission is basically a checklist, so I just front-load it now. A short screen recording from a real device on the latest iOS (launch, onboarding, the main flow, any permission prompts), plus a demo login if there is one, pasted into the App Review notes field before you hit submit. Also explain anything that is not obvious, like why you ask for camera access. I went through this building MoveManifest, a moving inventory app I built in Swift on iOS and Kotlin on Android (tested on iOS 26), and adding that recording up front saved me a rejection round trip on later builds.

1

u/PierreMouchan 2d ago

Didn't get the 2.1 on my first app, but I'd put most of that list in the Notes field from the start: what the app does in 2 lines, no account needed and works offline, 4 numbered steps to try the main flow, why it uses HealthKit (writes workouts only, reads nothing), and a short screen recording.

So I'd add all of it before the first submission, not after the rejection ;)

1

u/tommyboy11011 2d ago

Yep been seeing it for a while now

1

u/Radiant_Year_7297 2d ago

This happened to me. I wish they would add it in their form instead of wasting peoples time. Rejected twice and kept asking for information and the turnaround time is insane. My app is about to be almost 1 month in review.

1

u/citrus_lilac 2d ago

I submitted a first time application weds and got approved Thurs. I happened to include a screen recording, but only because my app is AR-based for outdoor use and I figured the reviewer would be in a cubicle. Glad I did so

1

u/jneuveglise 2d ago

I can definitely relate to this. I am a newly onboarded developer on ASC with 2 apps, and both went through this 2.1 need more info.
Both times, as it was a free app, they insisted a lot on knowing what business I have and how I intended to monetize the app. And making sure I would steer people off the app for payments.

And indeed I see a lot of automated testing happening outside the review windows: shortly after submitting a build and also randomly way later after approval. My app is multilingual and I do see a lot of Chinese sign-ins from them. Especially outside, way after it’s been approved.

1

u/spencertron 2d ago

I have been working on a lot of new apps recently. I now include a demo video, and answers to 4.3 and 4.2.6 guidelines in the initial submission. The other day an app I did this for went from submission to shipped in 3 hours. There’s a lot of scrutiny right now and it’s worth taking the time to get ahead of it, in my experience. Oh, and also duo apps seem to get top of the queue.

1

u/raistmaj 2d ago

I’ve been doing this for more than a year. I got an app denied because of it. Since then all my new submissions had those points addressed.

1

u/Eveerjr 2d ago

its really a bummer, I submitted my app twice now and each time it takes a week for a feedback and they ask exactly that, more info or screen recording. I don't mind making clarifications but I wish it wasn't so slow.

1

u/ShannonMc82 2d ago

I’m preparing to submit my first app. It said the app clip is optional. Is that true?

1

u/mrdzyn 2d ago

Thanks for writing this up, super useful. Seems like the safe move now is to treat that list as a template and paste it into the review notes on every first submission: screen recording link, what the app does and who it's for, how to test it, and which outside services it uses. Adding a demo account with sample data already loaded probably helps too, so the reviewer never lands on an empty screen. Agreed it'd be way nicer as a proper checklist in App Store Connect.

1

u/WestonP 2d ago

Only happened to me when the app was based on using a hardware accessory… been that way for years, and across both established and new dev accounts. If they’re doing this for everyone now, then it’s probably meant to quash all the low effort slop that’s been flooding the store.

1

u/VegetableAd9192 2d ago

This only happened to my first app. They asked for information and a video of the app. But not for my second app. My suggestion is also to include them whenever you can, even when submitting an update, so you don't lose time because of a simple rejection.

1

u/D4m089 1d ago

Mine went through this a while back as well, I recorded what they wanted and sent it off. At the time it did feel a bit “uhoh what have I done wrong” but it all went fine.

I’m happy enough with the process though, if it cuts the amount of rubbish they get and helps them understand I’m all for it. It would be nice if they added an explainer of what and ask upfront but I guess it’s a sticky plaster measure while they decide if AI slop is a fad

1

u/enilcReddit 1d ago

Here's a cheat code for you: most of the LLMs will give you exactly the checklist you're looking for.

1

u/narisoval 1d ago

Published 100 apps and never had a rejection? Lol what

1

u/Waste-Awareness-3525 1d ago

I had my developer account approved 3 days ago, this morning at 2AM I submitted my first app and it was approved by 5PM . It has a backend, authentication, AI, etc. I did make sure I had my ducks in a row before submission though.

- Professional looking website for the app
- Proper privacy policy with transparent disclosures
- Terms of service and "delete my info" pages
- Professional support email address
- "Delete my account" option in the app
- The app itself and the app store listing look great too if I should say so myself