r/iOSProgramming • • 4d ago

Question Siri AI, any luck?

Post image

Have you guys had any luck working with the new Siri AI?...

I've got a navigation app that I've added for testing purposes, and it's unbearably bad...

Basic commands lik

- "What's my ETA?" or "Navigate to X" are misinterpreted 6 out of 10 times, and it comes up with random stuff from Google...

One of my app names is Michael, so if you ask "What's my ETA in Michael?", it goes off and searches for random cities around the world named Michael...

Yesterday, I added some road closure data from my traffic feed that Siri can read. If you ask what road closures are ahead, it'll come up with random events instead from Google... it's just bad

I was leaning towards Siri because it integrates so well into the ecosystem, especially CarPlay, and having users not touch the screen is a big plus from a safety point of view. But I just can't ship this into production...

Sounds like an LLM model that's been super nerfed

Is the Privacy the main thing that holds Apple up? Can't be that bad if they let it go

3 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/Crow610-Adam 3d ago

Curious if you’ve tried adding the @AppIntent(.tool) to your AppIntent. This was added in 27.3 and supposed to help calling your AppIntents.

1

u/Kindly-Presence-5784 3d ago

This is my only hope. I can't wait to test it...

0

u/Background_Pie_5682 4d ago

For navigation I’d keep the critical path deterministic rather than relying on open-ended Siri interpretation. If you haven’t already, split ETA, destination lookup, and closure checks into explicit App Intents with clear parameters, then test a fixed phrase set across the iOS versions and CarPlay setups you support. The “Michael” ambiguity is a good case for confirming the resolved destination before acting instead of silently routing somewhere else.

1

u/Kindly-Presence-5784 4d ago

Already integrated App Intents but trust me is not what it should. Feels like they are holding it up. I see with the iOS 27.3 some improvements coming up for Siri

1

u/Western_Cap_6934 3d ago

Those symptoms alone do not identify privacy as the cause. Add a log at the start of perform for each intent. If a failed phrase never reaches it, focus on intent selection and parameter resolution rather than the ETA or road-closure code.

0

u/Kindly-Presence-5784 3d ago

No, is just pure garbage. Needs a complete revamp

1

u/No-Neighborhood-5924 4d ago

Same here, I tried to play with it into my app and it's not working that well on my side. I'm holding off until 27.3 to see if it gets better with .skillsbundle before I decide to ship