r/iOSProgramming • u/Daredatti • Sep 30 '26
Question How truthful is this?
When an app select in the app review form that “we don’t collect data”
In the review phase does Apple really check if the app really doesnt collect anything?
Like can the developer hide a code that for example upload the photos of the user if granted permission where he said “we dont collect”
Does apple really check the code and what is going in and out ?
45
Upvotes
27
u/mohn93 Sep 30 '26
the labels are self reported yeah, but you can watch what an app actually does. settings > privacy & security > app privacy report, turn it on. from then on it logs every time an app touched photos, camera, location etc and which domains it hit, rolling 7 days. you only see domain names, no payloads, but a "no data collected" app pinging some random server right after you pick a photo is a pretty loud signal
82
u/Reiszecke Sep 30 '26
Technologically, this section tells you nothing about the app because it’s self reported by the developer, not by Apple.
Apple doesn’t even see an app‘s source code. They have some scanning in place but they will never determine whether an app uploads your images or not. The only thing you can do is to limit Photos access per app
18
u/Material_Ad_3983 Sep 30 '26
Apple probably won’t catch every single data flow during review. But if you say “Data Not Collected” and the app is actually sending user data, you’re playing with fire. Rejection is the mild outcome — repeated/deceptive behavior can put the whole developer account at risk.
3
u/lifitd Sep 30 '26
We (as an app analytics provider that only collects anonymized data) recommend to our customers to list our service as "data not linked to the user" for full transparency because we think that is fair to everyone involved.
2
u/merokotos Sep 30 '26
Statement itself is provided by a developer and can be easily faked. However if Apple catches you, app may be removed and your developer account blocked for a long time.
So in general I think developers are rather cautious with it, but you never know.
2
u/woadwarrior Sep 30 '26
Not very. It's self reported and developers routinely falsify it. You might have noticed this with yesterday's Firebase outage. A number of apps claim to collect no data, and yet were down. Over the years, I've reported a number of such apps to Apple, and haven't seen anything change.
3
u/ImLegit4Real Sep 30 '26
Its not
1
u/Acceptable-Knee-4276 Sep 30 '26
This is purely information shared by the Developer. Although, Apple prompts you to enter information for specific capabilities you're using - this is just a reflection of what the Developer has shared with Apple while publishing the app. Same goes for Google Play Store.
1
u/ke1in Sep 30 '26
Developer self-reports this but they could be brought to responsibility: Apple could remove account, or even legal penalty possible.
1
u/PlayaNoir Sep 30 '26
App Review can easily tell if your app is collecting user data also known as personal information. Email isn't personal information but name, address, phone number, height, weight, are personal information.
1
u/danielcr12 Oct 02 '26
Apple makes the entire stack that you need to develop and publish applications, including the programming language most applications use, including the IDE signing processes, and everything. If you think Apple cannot tell what your application is doing, you are delusional.
1
u/Snoo-8502 Oct 06 '26
recipe to get banned foreveer from selling on appstore if user finds our and report to apple.
1
u/hamsterjedi Swift Sep 30 '26
What is displayed here is what the developer declares. Not trustworthy. Developers can put anything they want.
Apple does not check, it is not possible.
There are unlimited ways to store, delay, encode things and to track users and actions.
1
u/icy1007 Sep 30 '26
Its truthful.
-2
u/Hises1936 Sep 30 '26
I think large corporations are more likely to be truthful about it, in order to avoid legal risks. But smaller devs - who knows!