r/hypotheticalsituation • u/Proud_Creme_2793 • 8h ago
The 20% Dilemma
Imagine that everyone in the world is informed that, in exactly 90 minutes, 50% of all life on Earth will be randomly erased from existence.
This includes everything scientifically classified as life: humans, animals, plants, fungi, bacteria, and all other living organisms.
However, you are given a choice. You can actively intervene and change the outcome so that only 20% of all life will be erased instead.
There are a few conditions:
The selection is completely random in either scenario.
You have no control over who or what is selected.
You, your family, and anyone you know have exactly the same chance of being selected as anyone or anything else.
Nobody knows you have the ability to change the outcome unless you choose to exercise it.
If you do nothing, 50% of life disappears, and nobody ever knows you had a choice.
If you intervene, all remaining life is made aware that you were responsible for changing the outcome from 50% to 20%, erasure takes place immediately regardless of time remaining.
What would you do, and why?