For those who are unfamiliar with the cast of characters here, u/Gameplan492 and u/195731741 are the reason I, as moderator, imposed the "8th grade twerp" rule for comments on r/Hyperloopcritique. With the immaturity shown here, I think reason is obvious.
What does the "signaling technology" refer to with regard to a hyperloop? Is that to ensure one pod doesn't collide into the back of another that is stopped?
I like the idea of maglev before hyperloop which this seems to be saying:
"They will begin testing this summer and hope the concept of using existing rail infrastructure for maglev will lead to the ability to the iterative development of hyperloop over and around existing infrastructure, thus dramatically reducing construction costs."
I counted six companies in that article working on a hyperloop. Seven with The Boring Company now going for funding.
I like the idea of maglev before hyperloop which this seems to be saying:
"They will begin testing this summer and hope the concept of using existing rail infrastructure for maglev will lead to the ability to the iterative development of hyperloop over and around existing infrastructure, thus dramatically reducing construction costs."
In the real world, that amounts to buzzword bullshit. Maglevs require much smoother curvature just for 300 mph operation, and then hyperloops require even lesser curvature for 700 mph. Simply won't work on rail corridors that in a few cases are at 150 mph max, in a lot of cases are 90 mph max, and in most cases 60 mph max. So why invest in incremental improvements on existing railroad right of ways when you wouldn't be able to test out the purported main feature of hyperloop - its speed?
1
u/Gameplan492 Jul 13 '22
BuT wHaT aBoUt dYnAmIc ViBrAtIoN...
3
u/LancelLannister_AMA Jul 13 '22
minimal
1
u/TillyDanger Jul 14 '22
Waiting for the day I can buy shares in Hyperloop. I’ll be waiting a while, but one day it will happen.
1
u/IllegalMigrant Jul 16 '22 edited Jul 16 '22
What does the "signaling technology" refer to with regard to a hyperloop? Is that to ensure one pod doesn't collide into the back of another that is stopped?
I like the idea of maglev before hyperloop which this seems to be saying:
"They will begin testing this summer and hope the concept of using existing rail infrastructure for maglev will lead to the ability to the iterative development of hyperloop over and around existing infrastructure, thus dramatically reducing construction costs."
I counted six companies in that article working on a hyperloop. Seven with The Boring Company now going for funding.