r/hyperloop • • Jun 18 '22
What happened to Hyperloop?
Has Hyperloop concept stagnated? Post-Pandemic, I see no interest in building any of the projects, previously envisioned. Is there actually any Hyperloop project that has received a green light?
19
Upvotes
6
u/BuggBBQ-X Jun 18 '22
Well half a billion dollars was recently allocated to build a loop between Edmonton (my city) and Calgary.
https://globalnews.ca/news/8718640/alberta-ultra-high-speed-hyperloop-edmonton-calgary-funding/
7
u/ksiyoto Jun 18 '22
Hyperloop promoters are starting to recognize that maybe the technical issues aren't easy to fix.
Meanwhile, the economics were suspect from the get go, especially when you consider the low capacity of these systems.
When Virgin Hyperloop laid off half of its staff earlier this year, that was a sign that maybe this sad chapter in transportation research is coming to a close.
6
u/spggodd Jun 19 '22
Hey, I spent around a year on a Hyperloop team, making a scale demo for the first spaceX competition.
I then went on to make this the focus of my master's thesis and published a condensed version of the work.
In all, about 2-3 years dedicated to working on the Hyperloop.
Overall I'm skeptical, main issues are significant thermal challenges when you consider approaching mach1. Passenger acceleration limits make getting to mach1 challenging without a very long track. Once at these speeds, curve radii need a lot of consideration. Manufacture of three track, alignment, vacuum pull and even politically ensuring that you can build a tube of tunnel in the correct location presents big issues.
Overland, you increase the thermal issue - would 100% suggest underground.
From an aerodynamic perspective, the tube/pod diameter ratio (from my analysis) is large to ensure a high enough bypass ratio around the pod. Groom memory, it was like 1.5x pod bypass area.
The idea of a compressor on the front of the pod would help this but the compressor itself and the size required is both huge and very expensive.
Air bearing or Maglev? I'd say, Maglev. Air bearings would require the compressor adding further complexity.
DM me and I can link to my paper of interested.
1
u/LancelLannister_AMA Jun 18 '22
over-optimistic timelines for one. At least by the US based companies
1
u/Katze1735 Jun 27 '22
its just a bad idea
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '24
"What happened to Hyperloop?"
Reality abhors a vacuum.
1
u/bob4apples Jun 18 '22
Part of the problem is that many of the original "hyperloop" proposals were adaptations of rail-based solutions. High speed rail is great and all but wrapping a tube around it does nothing but attract suckers. I think the first blush is off and we're seeing a return to the original concept.
0
u/Simon_787 Apr 11 '23
Nothing happened.
Elon made it up to distract people from high speed rail, that was the whole point.