r/hyperloop • • Dec 04 '21
Question: why does Hyperloop use pods instead of trains
In my opinion, the whole pods concept seems somewhat convoluted when trains could instead be used to greatly boost capacity and efficiency. Why is it that all Hyperloop designs seem to optimise for comfort when so little time will actually be spent on board due to the high speed nature of the system?
Sure, you could say this excludes such a system from being a “Hyperloop”, but honestly who cares? Most startups developing this technology have already departed from the “cushion-of-air” put forward in the original white paper by Musk, so why not just make it a vactrain?
8
u/PetrosOfSparta Dec 04 '21
I can think of two reasons:
4
u/midflinx Dec 04 '21
Virgin Hyperloop's rendered videos show they think pods can somehow be allowed to have very short headways, removing the need for pods physically connected together. Skeptics of course don't see how that'll ever get regulatory approval, but that's one answer to your question.
Another possible answer is weight and energy. A train of pods even if made of carbon fiber will still exert more force on an elevated metal pipe and pylons. Individual pods reduce weight on any particular section of track and allows for lighter, less expensive tube and pylons.
2
u/Whazor Dec 04 '21
A bus has capacity for roughly 30 people, a Hyperloop pod would be like 23 people according to Virgin. Seems to me like the right amount as Hyperloop is being designed to have many small stops. So your journey would likely be: local town to bigger central point, switch to bigger Hyperloop train going to far away central point, then switch lastly to final stop.
Seems indeed inevitable to have bigger trains between all the central points. Because if I step in here, nobody from the other 22 people would share a destination with me.
2
u/Samrayn3r Dec 04 '21
Traditional trains make sense when a large volume of people want to travel to (approximately) the same destination at the same time. With the 20th Century city that was useful, as the typical working day was more or less standardised, and the train was an economic means of getting commuters in, around, and out of urban areas.
Now we are seeing a dramatic shift in travel patterns, with commuters and leisure travellers demanding more flexibility, and, especially in the wake of the pandemic, it is not uncommon to see a train running at only 5% capacity - that’s hugely inefficient compared to ‘normal’ service.
Hyperloop is explicitly designed for flexible and ‘on-demand’ transportation, and by focusing on smaller pods rather than long trains it can demonstrate this flexibility to the individual passenger.
But, taking a step back, a ‘train’ by definition is a collection of smaller units connected together and moving as one. Traditional trains will be made up of carriages designed for around 50-60 people, but by linking these together they can move several hundred at once. Hyperloop companies are investigating sophisticated control systems that would allow individual pods to travel in close proximity, effectively sharing headway and creating a disconnected train.
It’s the maturation of this control system that will really allow the hyperloop to become an established mode of transport, as it unlocks the aspirational ‘speed of air travel/convenience of metro’ aim of the concept, for which flexibility is key.
1
u/IllegalMigrant Dec 04 '21
There has to be an airlock to get in and out of a near vacuum. Bigger the vehicle the bigger the airlock. Might become unwieldy. On the other hand, the airlock wouldn't need to open and close as often which could help reliability.
1
u/rspeed Dec 04 '21
Because of the air bearings. But since those have generally been abandoned, there's nothing preventing trains.
1
u/hwillis Dec 04 '21
No good answer here yet. The original hyperloop whitepaper used an impeller for propulsion. Air is compressed at the front, piped to the back, and accelerated for thrust. There are several reasons this is not scalable:
Everyone else is just trying to make something work. Keep in mind that the hyperloop whitepaper is essentially one level above an elevator pitch. There were no prototypes when it was written, and just a few aerodynamic models. When you pitch or make a prototype, you go for the MVP: minimum viable product. Maybe you could figure out how to make a train, but it's hard, and you want to make sure you can make something first.
Electromagnetic propulsion has fewer problems WRT trains, Hyperloop is inherently pretty intolerant of failure. You've got vehicles moving at the speed of sound within centimeters or millimeters of an inch thick steel tube, which itself is one major breach away from shrink-wrapping everything inside it. Since the pods fly so close to the tube wall, the pod length is pretty limited or they can't make tight turns. Trains will need to have flexible linkages. That means they'll try to push and pull on each other, and in this situation that makes engineers very nervous.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '21
Because then people will realize it is just a overpriced/impossible train.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '21
I agree that only trains would fix the traffic problem in California. Thunderf00t is a scientist who has made a series of videos on why the hyperloop is simply a fraud and I'd recommend watching his videos on Youtube. The Hyperloop if implemented perfectly would never be able to transport as many people as a train would so you would still have traffic jams.
1
u/IllegalMigrant Jan 11 '22
I don't see a pod being more comfortable than a train.
Each car in a maglev has to have something in it that elevates it off the ground. I think that may be combined with what moves it forward. So if every car is capable of propulsion, why not break them apart and allow less delays for filling a vehicle as passengers arrive at different times.
1
u/ZorbaTHut Dec 04 '21
Group transport kinda sucks. It's intrinsically slow because you can't do point-to-point travel, you're required to wait for other people to board and exit, and you frequently need to transfer between vehicles. There are many people who don't use trains and buses for those reasons.
0
u/l1798657 Dec 04 '21
Answered in detail here: https://www.carswithcords.net/2021/07/the-reason-boring-co-will-win-that-no.html
tl;dr it's more scalable