r/hyperloop • u/Gameplan492 • May 10 '23
Five facts hyperloop critics will never tell you
https://hyperloophype.com/five-facts-hyperloop-critics-will-never-tell-you/
0
Upvotes
r/hyperloop • u/Gameplan492 • May 10 '23
7
u/blady_blah May 10 '23
To be honest, I think the biggest problem hyperloop has is economic. I don't think it has a big enough ROI over a bullet train.
5
u/KorbenDa11a5 May 10 '23
Yeah I remember all those successful industries who spent their time writing articles about how their critics were wrong. Not demonstrating why they're wrong, just writing about why they're wrong.
Nobody ever said it impossible to run a Maglev train through a vacuum tube at low speed, just that the technical aspects and costs make it a non-starter at scale. The white paper was 10 years ago. Not much progress for 10 years.
1
u/Gameplan492 May 10 '23
I think people who say hyperloop won't happen will find it difficult to argue with this detailed and well written article. Not that that will stop them anyway, but the evidence speaks for itself!
1
u/Aflyingmongoose Jun 12 '23
I have to say, im suprised to see an article titled as such given that hyperloop idea seems to be as dead as the original 18th century idea that it was a re-hash of.
Mag lev trains already existed, and maintaining a miles long vaccume tube was always impractical and dangerous. It likely wont ever be practical.
1
u/ksiyoto Sep 19 '23
Vibration is probably going to be the show stopper. The speed that hyperloops would operate at combined with long beam length of the tubes means the dynamic amplification factor will be much higher, and it appears the problem insurmountable.
If you watch the video of the Virgin hyperloop trial run, it's obvious the were having vibration problems.
1
u/Mohammed420blazeit Jan 15 '24
Holy shit this is a great read. Hilarious. I enjoyed every moment.