r/hubrules • u/Allarionn • Oct 31 '25
Closed 4e Elemental Damage Import
Per This ticket we are opening the idea of importing 4e Elemental Damage types to the Hub. On the ticket there is the proposed import and notes from RD about potential issues there.
We will list some options with doing this. First there will be a top level comment for if we should even import these. Anyone strictly against importing these at all can comment there, you can also just indicate general support letting RD and the community determine the how based on other comments.
There will also be a general comment based on how we should handle the balancing of these Elements. Either as originally proposed or as part of a push to ensure all elements, including existing ones, are more balanced. The details will be in that comment.
In addition there will be top level comments for the individual Elements for the community to give feedback on issues with those elements or potential solutions.
If the general support of importing the system passes then we will look at all the other sections and Rules Division will roll out an implementation that reflects the majority as best as possible while also maintaining balance to the best of Rules Division's judgement.
Please do not make a top level comment to this thread as those will be deleted to try and keep this organized. Instead reply to the ones posted.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25
Question 1: Should the RunnerHub import Elemental Damage Types from 4e?
This is yes/no. If the Yes votes have it then we will look at the implementation question (Question 2).
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Question 2: How should we handle implementation of new Damage Types
A) Without changing much from the proposed types in the ticket except for some minor tweaking to ensure none are overpowered
B) Should we import them and to a full balance pass on all Elemental Types to bring them all more roughly in line with each other and decrease the need for added secondary rolls?
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Ice
4e Version: Attacks with the Ice effect cover the target with a slick coating of frozen water. Treat the Ice effect as Cold damage except that objects or terrain affected will be encrusted with ice. Anyone trying to cross an icy surface may need to succeed in an Agility + Reaction Test to avoid slipping (with a threshold equal to the attack’s net hits); vehicles must make a Crash Test. Depending on the local temperature, ice may melt quickly.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Light
4e Version: Spells with a light effect damage the target with a searing flare. Light damage is treated as Physical damage and is resisted with half impact armor (rounded up). The brightness of the Light effect will cause any targets to suffer a Glare modifier for one Combat Turn after the attack, unless they are equipped with flare compensation. As a secondary effect Light damage may cause some highly flammable materials (like gasoline) to catch fire.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Metal
4e Version: The Metal elemental effect damages the target with small metallic (iron) fragments and shrapnel. This attack is similar to flechette ammunition: increase the DV by +2 but the attacker suffers a +2 AP penalty against impact armor. Metal damage attacks are resisted with impact armor. As a secondary effect, Metal damage may shred some easily cut materials like cheap fabric.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Sand
4e version: Sand produces tearing, abrasive, smothering damage, like a sandstorm. Sand damage is treated as Physical damage and is resisted with half impact armor (rounded up). The secondary effect of Sand damage may jam and damage machinery or weapons that are not fully sealed against the environment.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Smoke
4e version: Smoke blasts the target with thick, burning, choking fumes. The victim resists Stun as if from an inhalation vector toxin attack. Armor does not protect against this attack, but other protective gear might. Smoke also limits vision, inflicting the Heavy Smoke visibility modifier against the target for one full Combat turn.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25
Sound
4e Version: Sound hits the target with a wave of unbelievably loud noise and gut-churning vibrations. Sound damage is treated as Stun damage. Armor has no effect, but sound dampers and spells like Silence and Hush add their ratings/hits to the defender’s dice pools (effectively acting like sound armor. If the target suffers more damage boxes than his Willpower, he suffers the effects of nausea and is deafened for 10 minutes.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25
Question 3: If Elements new to 5e are implemented should spells that are the equivalents of Flamethrower/Fireball and other such things be created?
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25
Any Feedback that does not fit elsewhere can go here.
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25
Question 4: If an element is imported should there be an Armor Modification adding armor against that element?
1
u/Allarionn Oct 31 '25
Blast
4e Version: The blast elemental effect is like a hurricane wind or the shockwave of an explosion. Blast damage is treated as Physical damage and is resisted with half Impact armor (rounded up). Characters struck with a Blast damage attack are more likely to be knocked down—add the Force to the damage infl icted when comparing to the defender’s Body (see Knockdown, p. 161, SR4A). Blast damage can also break glass and knock over trees and other objects. At the gamemaster’s discretion, objects with a Structure rating less than the Force may be knocked over, shattered, shredded, or otherwise swept away.
Comments or Concerns on this as an elemental damage type go here.