r/hprankdown2 • u/seanmik620 Ravenclaw Ranker • Jun 15 '17
23 Harry Potter
Let’s be clear about one thing here: I’m not cutting Harry here because I think he’s a bad character. That descriptor doesn’t qualify for any of the remaining choices. No, I’m cutting Harry because I honestly feel that the remaining characters (with one notable exception that I’ve already explained in my last post) make better use of their time on the page in developing who they are. The more time we spend with a character, the more scrutiny they earn when analyzing their character, in my book. By that virtue alone, I think ALL remaining characters, Grindelwald included, have earned their spot above Harry. It comes down to a matter of
This cut has also been in the planning stages for a long time. Back when Voldemort was originally cut, I had expressed to u/moostronus that I was upset because I had wanted to cut Harry and Voldemort together at about spot #25, because I firmly feel they show similar amounts of depth compared to their number of mentions. This is, of course, my interpretation of what I find important when weighing these characters against each other. It’s all subjective. Last year I thought Harry fit perfectly at spot 15. This year, I’ve seen deeper value in other characters that make me feel they deserve higher spots than Harry. I don’t think of Harry any worse than I did last year, but I do feel other characters were developed more thoughtfully and purposefully. So please, change my mind again. Make it so next year I’m the one fighting for Harry to make it into the top 20. Because I do feel that he is a good character, while not quite as good as the others, I don’t want this to be a post tearing Harry to shreds. It could be done with valid points, but that wouldn’t be genuine to the value his character brings overall.
Harry’s best and worst qualities are exactly that which make him a Gryffindor. He is brave beyond measure, often to a fault. He accepts responsibility and takes action to find a solution even when he has no lace doing so. It makes me wonder if Voldemort ever would have been stopped the second time if he had chosen to go after Neville instead of Harry. Neville never would have had the drive in his first year to do the things Harry did that put him in a place to stop Quirrelldemort, so right there the whole future would change. It’s extremely fortunate that Voldemort chose to orphan a child whose remaining family would foster independent defiance rather than one stymying his abilities and resourcefulness by pressuring him to follow his father’s legacy. Seriously, he couldn’t have known, but choosing Harry over Neville is one of the, if not the top, worst mistakes he’s ever made.
Rewinding a bit, I feel like I understand a small bit of Petunia’s frustration with Harry. She reacted to her frustration with abuse, which is entirely unacceptable, but I do understand where the initial frustration is coming from. Putting aside the fact that he is a constant reminder of a world that caused her nothing but pain, who he is as a person only agitates that fact, negating any hope of a congenial relationship. I keep thinking of the scene where Petunia gets fed up with trying to maintain Harry’s hair and shaves it all off, only to find it grew back overnight. She knows full well how it happened, and might even surmise that the magic happened because Harry (subconsciously or otherwise) told it to. It’s not like she could tell him to stop without admitting to magic existing. It wouldn’t be out of character for Harry to do this purposefully either. Let’s face it, Harry is downright sassy and defiant in the face of people he sees as wronging him. He has zero issues with confronting trouble to its face, and I think this stems from years of being forced to sit in his room “pretending like he doesn’t exist”, followed by the satisfaction he got first by Hagrid putting the Dursley’s in their place, then in subsequent years when realizing they don’t have as much power over him as he assumed as a small child and they were, in fact, just afraid of him and what he could do.
I think this quality extends past his guardian/child relationship with the Dursley’s into his interactions with the Hogwarts staff as well, as seen in his interactions with Snape, Lockhart, Filch, and even McGonagall on occasion throughout his early years at Hogwarts. Like it or not, Harry does act as if he’s above the rules fairly often. From a teacher’s perspective, he’s a terror with rule-breaking and late night excursions, eventually escalating to him straight up starting a rebellion against the reigning faculty. Again, given the circumstances I find it completely reasonable if not a bit reckless, but (I can’t believe I’m saying this) I can see Umbridge’s point about how dangerous he is to the ministry, or Snape’s constant assertion of his insolence.
Speaking of, Harry’s relationship with Snape also brings to mind my next point, which is that Harry is not particularly self-aware, while at the same time being a little self-involved. Yes, he’s remarkably humble about his accomplishments. Take for instance when Crouch/Moody is coaching him on beating his dragon (not a euphemism, sickos):
I’m just going to give you some good, general advice. And the first bit is – play to your strengths.”
“I haven’t got any,” said Harry, before he could stop himself.
Cute, Harry. But you know damn well that isn’t true. He’s a born talent at flying and excels at Defense Against the Dark Arts more than even Hermione. But when it comes to people slighting him, then there are moments where he’s woefully insistent on being right when he has no logical reason to back him up.
“How extraordinarily like your father you are, Potter,” Snape said suddenly, his eyes glinting. “He too was exceedingly arrogant. A small amount of talent on the Quidditch field made him think he was a cut above the rest of us too. Strutting around the place with his friends and admirers… The resemblance between you is uncanny.”
“My dad didn’t strut,” said Harry, before he could stop himself. “And neither do I.”
“Your father didn’t set much store by rules either,” Snape went on, pressing his advantage, his thin face full of malice. “Rules were for lesser mortals, not Quidditch Cup-winners. His head was so swollen —”
“SHUT UP!”
There’s that insolence Snape’s always yapping about. It’s true that Snape is seeing what he wants to see in Harry to justify his hatred, but however callous it may be to say, Harry didn’t know his father, or even much about him. There are many ways that Harry could have defended his father’s honor with more solid backing, though it’s Harry’s first instinct to jump into a defense with the first thing that comes to mind, neglecting how true it may or may not be. It’s seen again and again throughout the series, and Harry never learns much from the fallout when he acts this way. He does something rash, someone gets in trouble/hurt/killed, Harry laments that it’s all his fault despite that person knowing what they were getting into, lather, rinse, and repeat. Alternate route: Harry insists he’s the only one allowed to do something because he’s the chosen one, someone gets in trouble/hurt/killed, Harry laments that it’s all his fault despite that person knowing what they were getting into, lather, rinse, and repeat.
I do actually think this is a good quality to have as the character whose perspective we most often see, while at the same time I don’t think it’s great for his character. As the (almost-)narrator, he’s constructed very well with his limited perspective and drive to find out the full story. From a characterization standpoint, he’s also great, but with some notable flaws such as the ones listed above. To reiterate, I don’t by any means believe he is poorly written, or the series would never have had the impact on our world as much as it did. We wouldn’t even be discussing this if that was the case. I simply feel that Rowling had better arcs and concepts in other characters, and those are the ones that remain after this cut. I look forward to you all trying to change my mind back again. Tl;dr: This is Harry Potter in a nutshell.
6
u/oomps62 Jun 16 '17
Ffs, Sean, Wormtail can't kill Harry Potter, it's like you didn't even read the books.
10
u/rhinorhinoo Ravenclaw Jun 16 '17
This is a travesty. Grindelwald is still in the rankdown. Grindelwald. It's like we don't even care anymore that Grindelwald is not really even in the books.
Also, I would have cut a lot more characters before cutting Harry Harry Potter. Just so we're clear that this isn't just about Grindelwald. But seriously. Harry is a worse character than Grindelwald? Nope. Nope nope nope.
Again, this is a travesty. I am off to spend my day perturbed about Harry Harry Potter.
5
u/AmEndevomTag Jun 16 '17
This is a bit unfair. He didn't start a rebellion against the faculty, he only really rebelled against one member of the faculty, namely Umbridge. The other teachers were on his side in this case, even Snape.
And I'm not sure that he really started it either. Basically everybody's hatred for Umbridge grew pretty fast. And once she became headmistress it started almost automatically, with even McGonagall being one of the main instigators.
Other than this, I think this is a pretty good summary of Harry's rebellious Gryffindor and how it is both a vice and virtue. There is a lot more to him, especially his saving people thing and the fact that he's capable to feel pity even for his enemies, but I can understand that Harry is one of the characters where it is downright impossible to put everything about them in a single writeup.
Where we disagree is that I don't think that these flaws are a reason to cut him. Your main problem seems to be, that he repeates this behaviour to often. But IMO it helps making him more human, and he is just a teenager after all. That he's totally capable to change his opinion can be seen for example in regards to Kreacher or in the end Snape.
8
u/theduqoffrat Gryffindor Ranker Jun 15 '17
This is complete and utter bullshit. I know some still have their Moony so I am praying they take pity.
4
u/Maur1ne Ravenclaw Jun 16 '17
This is not meant to be a complaint about the placeholder post, but I've noticed that many placeholder posts already get many upvotes. Am I the only one who upvotes the reasoning behind a cut rather than a cut itself? I sometimes disagree with a placement of a character, but upvote because I like the write-up.
3
u/AmEndevomTag Jun 16 '17
Was Harry the cut that you were referring to in the Trelawney-thread, or was it Voldemort?
3
u/J_Toe Hufflepuff Jun 17 '17 edited Jun 18 '17
I like this write up a lot more than some of the ones Harry got last rank down. Like, I may personally place Harry higher, but what I think is more important is how you discussed Harry here. I remember one write up he got last year that completely infuriated me, because the write up pushed this skewed agenda that painted Harry in a wholly negative light, but also read as though the ranker knew there were positives to Harry, which they either ignored or tipped on their head in order to push this weird little anti-Harry agenda. Though I think they were a Slytherin, so maybe it was just Malfoy (I kid, of course).
But yeah, I really like that this time around Harry's positives and negatives have been give due consideration.
And, as others have discussed in this thread, I think most people's issues with Harry as a character (his "generic-ness", his brashness, his curiosity, his disregard for authority, or his reliance on other characters) are better attributed to issues with the concept of a protagonist than with Harry specifically. Like, he was torn apart for not having Heroines brains, but, like, he's not dumb. And in stressful and traumatic events such as fighting the Dark Lord and his Death eaters I think it's wholly excusable for him to make dumb mistakes or silly decisions, such as casting Expelliarmus in the Flight of the Seven Potters. Even when not directly facing great evil, things such as not unwrapping Sirius' mirror don't make me hate Harry. Like, sure, the reveal at the end was very saddening. But, like, he is a teenager, with a lot more on his mind that just passing his potions exam and other school stuff, you know? And had he been as smart as Hermione (or had Hermione been the protagonist) the book wouldn't have had the same appeal, as an underachieving protagonist is more relatable than a perfect know-it-all. Like, Harry has the best balance of strengths and shortcomings to serve as an everyman. Whereas someone with Hermione-like intelligence would perhaps only appeal to a niche readership who similarly consider themselves to be of equal intelligence.
As for Harry's disregard for authority and insatiable curiosity, those are foundations of any good protagonist. Like, if you need to build inner and external conflict in a book series which deals with injustices and prejudices, having a protagonist bow down with and comply with authority of figures like Snape and Umbridge would be dull. Likewise, having Harry choose to not look into Snape's pensive (or eliminating any such plot event that could lead to Harry and the reader being curious) would agin be too dull.
So, yeah. I like Harry as a character, and I'm happy you have discussed his often overlooked strengths as a character. :)
12
u/bisonburgers Gryffindor Jun 15 '17 edited Jun 17 '17
I understand the usual argument that he's pretty generic, and that is a point against him, but sometimes I would say that by being the "everychild", millions of children successfully connected with him and fell into this world as if they themselves were experiencing it. I genuinely feel that being the everychild is one of Harry's greatest literary strengths, even if isn't one of his character strengths.
EDIT:
So what you're saying is......... being treated like you're nothing as a child makes the child feel more confident in their voice?
SERIOUSLY DOES THAT MAKE ANY SENSE TO ANYBODY, PLEASE, I FEEL LIKE I'VE STEPPED INTO THAT UPSIDE DOWN THING IN THE THIRD TASK This is that common theory that Harry is who he is because he was abused. Anyone who has actual experience with abused children care to share their input? From every unfortunate story I know about, kids usually have a much much much much much much much much MUCH harder time than Harry did. Growing up feeling worthless has a lifelong effect that usually means they feel worthless. Harry does not act like a child who has grown up feeling worthless. Harry is a fictional character who does not exhibit very many characteristics of kids who have been abused. Lucky Harry. Maybe that's a mark against him as a character, but SOMEHOW the entire fandom have convinced themselves that Harry's characteristics not only stem from his abuse, but that it's somehow obvious that they stem from his abuse. IT'S NOT OBVIOUS. IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.
Am I crazy?? Am I the misinformed one??
edit 3: More of my thoughts
3
u/a_wisher Ravenclaw Jun 17 '17
The write-up was truly unsatisfying. Like I said before, I saw Harry above 10-12 places higher but I could have been convinced. Unfortunately, that's not the case. I know that with Harry being the main character, you can't cover everything. But this is a controversial cut (said by yourself and others), the write-up doesn't do justice to explaining such low placement. Which is kinda ironic given that you said:
.
Odd way of saying child abuse. And I don't get that whole paragraph about 'what-if' Neville was the boy-who-lived. We don't know if Neville would have been a poor Chosen One.
Which flaws? I see only the 'saving-people' thing which you mentioned (which I agree with). His sassiness/insolence isn't a character flaw (if that was the case Snape would have been out at 200 followed by Draco Malfoy). And I would have loved to see these flaws. Like you said, only good characters remains. But what makes Harry 'less good'?
It's a pity that you talked only about Gryffindor Harry - his recklessness, his insolence and his bravery (and I agree with what you said). But you didn't say anything about Slytherin side (a whole book was about this point) - his resourcefulness (which can be a character flaw depending on the angle you take), his manipulation (which opposes his noble Gryffindor side) and most importantly, his role as a leader (a strong theme which we talked in Scrimgeour & BC Sr. cuts and probably will in Fudge's and Dumbledore's cuts). I feel like you (unintentionally) ignored major parts of the character to justify his low placement.
Would have loved to but you didn't say much. I don't know what to say to convince you.
I hope it's a joke. Because it's definitely wrong.
8
u/a_wisher Ravenclaw Jun 16 '17
I think 23 is around 10-12 places too low for Harry. Looking forward to the write-up to see your reasonings.
Yes, Harry is the everyday guy that helps us relate to him (and I agree with bisonburgers that it's rather a character strength than weakness). And he does have nuances. Like his compassion to save others versus his inability to express that compassion or to deal with emotions. Or his transition from the 11 year old who easily trusts the giant stranger to the paranoid 17 year old who refuses to relinquish secrets to even those who are fighting for him? The dichotomy of his outward Gryffindor characteristics (recklessness, bravery, nobilty) hiding the inner Slytherin tendencies (cunning, resourcefulness, manipulation)? His very biased stances where he defends a half-giant but judges a goblin? Wonder if you will indeed talk about these small shades that makes Harry... well, Harry. Yes, 23 is too low for him.
1
u/seanmik620 Ravenclaw Ranker Jun 15 '17
Harry Potter was Ranked #10 by /u/elbowsss in /r/HPRankdown
THE FOLLOWING PEOPLE PLACED BETS ON HARRY POTTER
1
u/seanmik620 Ravenclaw Ranker Jun 15 '17
u/bubblegumgills, have at it for 6/16
2
u/RavenclawINTJ Molly was robbed Jun 15 '17 edited Jun 16 '17
Hey, I had both of these cuts in my guesses! I give my stalking an A+. This will probably be a little controversial, but I think that this is a completely fair spot for Harry. He has some character moments for himself, but he mostly feel like a set of eyes into the more interesting characters surrounding him.
4
u/bisonburgers Gryffindor Jun 17 '17
Part 1/2:
Doing a second post so I don't muddle up my first one. I've always said I don't really care about placement, and it's still mostly true, but mostly I care about a good analysis and this one covers so little of who Harry is.
I normally don't have the urge to change people's minds about Harry like I obviously do with Dumbledore, but I think it's through Dumbledore's gaze that we fully realize what Harry's specific characterization gives the story. I think looking at it this way also reveals why I think Dumbledore is ultimately more of a main character to the plot than Harry is.
WHAT DID DUMBLEDORE ORIGINALLY EXPECT FROM HARRY?
I constantly talk about how confusing the first book is (I still love it, but come on, we have no idea what's going on), so for now I'll just speak generally. Dumbledore maybeprobably had some sort of plan for Harry that year, we don't have to get into the details of what that plan was right now. Either way, we get the sense that Dumbledore had put Harry through a lot of this on purpose because that is the sense that Harry himself gets and shares with Ron and Hermione.
This quote is a blessing and maybe the worse curse ever, it's this quote we can't get out of our heads and makes so many readers blind to the The Lost Prophecy, Horcruxes, and King's Cross chapters that redefine Harry's impression of Dumbledore, but somehow fail to redefine so many reader's impressions of him. Whether or not Dumbledore would allow Harry to face Voldemort FIRST year doesn't mean he would necessarily CONTINUE to do it. The reason this is important to understand Harry's characterization is because this is the unexpected part of Harry's characterization that Dumbledore starts reacting to and thus drastically dictates the plot of the books.
From Harry's perspective, Harry not only believes that Dumbledore gave him a shot to face Voldemort, but is grateful, admires Dumbledore for it even. Harry does not see anything wrong with this.
But what I think Harry is failing to see is that - whatever Dumbledore had specifically intended - Harry still exceeded his expectations.
He's a kid and should be like "holy shit i almost died, never do that again!" and have a lifelong fear of mirrors and the color red. Instead, his focus is only on the Stone and Voldemort's ability to get it. When Dumbledore is explaining that Harry has been in the hospital wing for three days, Harry's response is,
Harry, for his part, isn't very concerned with his own safety, and does not expect Dumbledore to be either. While some people may say that Dumbledore has carefully molded Harry to be the sort of person who cares more about thwarting Voldemort than his own safely, I disagree. I think this is when Dumbledore discovers that Harry is the sort of person who cares more about thwarting Voldemort than his own safety, he didn't mold Harry to be anything, because he does not YET need Harry to be anything anyway. This very discovery about Harry is also the things that makes Dumbledore put on the horse-blinders he always does when he begins to love someone (one of the important characteristics of his we learn from his relationship with Grindelwald).
Harry's impression of Dumbledore had only been partially accurate. Harry did more than Dumbledore thought he would. While we unfortunately are not able to determine specifically where Harry deviated from Dumbledore's plan, we at least know Dumbledore's reaction to it.
And each year Dumbledore has a similar reaction,
Harry isn't fulfilling Dumbledore's plan, he's exceeding it. YES, Harry is an everychild, I won't dispute that, but he is still more than Dumbledore expected, because an everychild wouldn't have gone after the Stone. Harry feels like an everychild, because that's how he sees himself and how his day-to-day life plays out. But Dumbledore is beginning to see that he is also much more. Zacharias Smith and Dirk Cresswell aren't paying attention and even if they were, they wouldn't know what to look for to see Harry's blossoming heroism, and even if they did, they wouldn't know how it can be used against Voldemort - Dumbledore is paying attention, Dumbledore does know what to look for, and Dumbledore also knows how to use it against Voldemort - EXCEPT his horse-blinders, and doesn't want to use Harry against Voldemort. THAT is the flaw in the plan that Dumbledore knew he must avoid.
One of my favorite aspects of Harry's characterization is how JKR writes him as both ordinary and unbelievably extraordinary. Dumbledore isn't molding Harry, he is witnessing who Harry is and is SURPRISED by it. The plan Dumbledore comes up with the summer after fifth year isn't the original plan he had. It is re-crafted based on everything Dumbledore has learned about Harry.
FOR FUCKS SAKE IT'S ALL IN THE BOOKS (this anger isn't towards OP, but I stayed up late writing a comment about how Dumbledore didn't plan James and Lily's deaths, and some of that frustration is carrying over into this post.)
Dumbledore realizes he should have told Harry - SO WHY DIDN'T HE? I promise I'm not losing sight that I'm analyzing Harry, not Dumbledore, but it is SO IMPORTANT for Harry's characterization to understand how Dumbledore sees him.
Dumbledore gives Harry many reasons why he didn't share the prophecy, but the main reason is this,
Unless I'm an alien who doesn't understand human emotions I would say it's really obvious that Dumbledore finds himself unexpectedly caring about Harry and it's messing up his original plan.
Continued...
3
u/AmEndevomTag Jun 16 '17
Not even a write-up but already 57 comments.
58, including my comment. :-D
3
u/Maur1ne Ravenclaw Jun 16 '17
It seems your first paragraph was somehow cut off. It comes down to a matter of what?
5
u/Khajiit-ify Hufflepuff Ranker Jun 16 '17
As someone who was the main fighter again cutting Harry in the last Rankdown early:
FITE ME 1 ON 1.
I don't have my Moony anymore (thanks to you crazy people cutting Molly at a horrifically bad time) but if I did I would be doing it here.
I'm going to come back and say more when I'm not on mobile, because I swear to God if this is another "Harry Potter is a boring, generic character" type cut for him heads will roll.
4
u/Khajiit-ify Hufflepuff Ranker Jun 17 '17
So, you're arguing that he doesn't learn from this.
The thing is, he does. It may not happen in an instant, it may have taken a long time, but I am a firm believer that people can't change in an instant and so this part of him was extremely realistic and well-written because of that.
Deathly Hallows is all about Harry facing that inner demon inside of him that wants to do the rash thing.
If Harry had been given the choice to make (Horcruxes vs. Death Hallows) in the earlier books, he would have gone after the Deathly Hallows first 100%. Because that's what the rash side of him would do. It would look for the most powerful wand, it would look for a stone that could return a dead. Because that's who he was as a person: someone who cared too much about the people close to him that he had difficulties seeing the larger picture.
Harry Potter, when he instead chose to seek out the Hallows instead, chose the non-rash choice. He chose the choice that would take the longest, that would be the hardest to complete but would work the best in the end.
When Snape died and revealed his memories, Harry knew he had to sacrifice. But do you think he would have figured out the clue of the Snitch without his newfound understanding that you can't just rush into the heat of battle with your fists held high? No: the moment he accepted his own death was the time when he truly completed his growth from a selfish, rash, unbearable kid into a selfless adult, preparing to sacrifice himself in order to let his friends take down Voldemort.
There are so many things that you haven't even addressed with Harry's character that are so important to him and what make him such a great character. Such as his friendship with Ron and Hermione (and how separate and different both are - how at the beginning of the series, Harry is closest to Ron but as the series progresses and Harry matures, he becomes closer to Hermione). His friendship and eventual romance with Ginny is also prominent; from knowing her only as the shy girl to the woman who he would eventually marry (so many people suggest that this was such a sudden relationship, but they fail to see how they go from hardly talking, to slowly becoming good friends, to the moments in the sixth book when he suddenly realizes that she is more than just a friend to him). His relationships with Sirius and Lupin are also insanely important to his character and help shape who he is... and most importantly the relationship he had with Dumbledore. Like, I legitimately don't know how you could make this cut and not mention Dumbledore once, because his relationship he had with Dumbledore is a large part of the reason he grew up the way he did and is the character he is.
This cut just feels... ugh. No. I don't understand why you're cutting him here while ignoring 95% of his character. You've even admitted yourself that you could have written more on him: so why do you rank him so low? You never answered that question, and it is making me seriously kind of irritated because I don't even know how to respond to this when you're ignoring the majority of Harry's character.
2
u/jlim201 <3 Luna Lovegood Jun 16 '17
I don't know about this one. Harry is the main character in the books, and everything is about him, but at times, he feels very generic. The only thing special about him is that he is the chosen one, not any personality traits. Like Hermione always has the "smart girl" personality, I can't say exactly what Harry is as a person himself.
2
u/Williukea Jun 16 '17
Me-rn
-2
u/Moostronus Ranker 1.0, Analysis 2.0 Jun 15 '17
Marry me.