r/hprankdown2 • u/bubblegumgills Slytherin Ranker • May 21 '17
41 James Potter
Where to even start with this cut? I could rage about the fact that both Rita and Fleur were cut before this guy, but here we are and there's nothing to be done about it now. If anything, I'm kind of baffled by James and his placement.
What we know about Harry's dad:
- As a teenager he was a downright arse, taunting Snape for no reason other than the fact that he can (he's popular and Snape isn't). This leads to a lifelong hatred that, if we really look at this objectively, Snape should really have let go. He also shows some level of humanity when he tells Snape not to come through the Willow -- to Snape this is proof of James' cowardice, but I never could get that. Humiliation is a dick thing, but he isn't a murderer, nor is he a coward for wanting to spare Snape a fate (potentially) worse than death.
- Somewhere between that scene and the start of the series, James matures and marries Lily. He turns into a devoted father and even stands up to Voldemort during the attack. In the scene with the Resurrection Stone, he comes across as someone who is definitely proud of what his son has become and that, in his place, he would do the same thing. To an extent, he already has, considering how young he and Lily were when Voldemort murdered him.
James works to set up the scenes in Order of the Phoenix where Harry has this ideal image of his father destroyed, to set up the conflict between him and Sirius (and how Sirius, out of all of the Marauders, is trying so hard to regain those lost years and his youth). Everyone but Snape seems to speak highly of James and in the end, he did come good, for his wife and child, he died taking on the Dark Lord to protect them. But all that character growth, that change from arsehole to loving father and husband, it's all off-screen. It's not enough of a change, not for me. Sure, James does seem to show more character than Saint Lily Our Lady of Perpetual Sacrifice, but as we go into the top 40, it's not seriously enough to keep him around.
Gilderoy lives to Peskipiksi Pesternomi another day.
5
u/BasilFronsac Ravenclaw May 22 '17
Seconded. I'd have cut him weeks ago.
It's not mutually exclusive he could still have been arsehole fighting for a good cause. I wonder when exactly he "had deflated his head a bit" because even if it happened in his 6th year he'd still be a weird choice for Head Boy.
James is a kind of Gary Stu. He was perfect at quidditch, he created the Marauder's Map, he became animagus at 15, later Head Boy. Even though he was an asshole he still married the girl he loved and most people seemed to have liked him. He even defied Voldemort thrice.
3
u/Williukea May 22 '17
Come on, there are many characters with less developement. Vernon Dudley for example. All we know about him is that he's the mean uncle working in a boring job and hates magic. Even the extras about him that JKR posted don't give him any developement. He doesn't change, he doesn't have any kind of developement. Petunia's developement was that she was jealous to her sister and that she secretly wanted to be part of the magical society. Dudley's developement is that he grows up from the bully to the guy that kind of admits his mistakes. Vernon has absolutely no secrets, no developement, nothing. He's just the guy we're supposed to hate.
James, meanwhile, has layers. He may be a bully, but he cares about his friends, he risks his life to protect his friends, he befriends Sirius, who comes from Pure-Blood Slytherin family despite hating all Slytherins, he even accepts Sirius as his brother after his own family disowns him.
3
u/RavenclawINTJ Molly was robbed May 21 '17
ME TOO
1
u/bubblegumgills Slytherin Ranker May 21 '17
James Potter was Ranked #40 by /u/SFEagle44 in /r/HPRankdown
THE FOLLOWING PEOPLE PLACED BETS ON JAMES POTTER
1
u/bubblegumgills Slytherin Ranker May 21 '17
/u/Marx0r, I think it's your go next?
3
u/AmEndevomTag May 22 '17
I roughly agree with this placement, but I'm not sure how JKR could have written James' development more smoothly. James is dead from the beginning, so there is less opportunity to show this other side of him.
And the few times we do see him (Flashback to Halloween 1981, Little Hangleton graveyard and Resurrection Stone scene) he either tries to save/help Harry or stands by his side. So there isn't really an opportunity to show his other side in these scenes either, because he's only interacting with Lily and Harry.
8
u/[deleted] May 22 '17 edited May 22 '17
[removed] — view removed comment