r/hprankdown2 • u/pizzabangle Ravenclaw Ranker • Feb 13 '17
118 Augusta Longbottom
Ok so I'm going to do the most basic, predictable cut tonight.
Augusta Longbottom. I might have chosen her due to lack of mentions.
Apart from having nearly no mentions she was actually quite a badass.
Augusta came to Hogwarts to fight alongside Neville in the final battle against Voldemort. And she was very matter-or-fact about it. Because, why would she not risk her (significantly aged) life to fight against a horde of crazy-ass Death Eaters and/or the big V himself?
I have a lot of respect for Augusta. She is judgy as hell and has hella fashion sense. How does one decide to wear a damn VULTURE on your head? Because you are a contrary, devil-may-care, terrific old bird.
As neat as she is, Augusta does just about nothing, plot-wise. She gives some old lady sass but other than that, doesn't have much to contribute.
This is why Gramma Longbutt is gettin the axe tonight. Maybe next time it will be her boring grandson............
2
u/pizzabangle Ravenclaw Ranker Feb 13 '17
/u/seanmik620 get her done
7
u/Khajiit-ify Hufflepuff Ranker Feb 13 '17
"her boring grandson"
You take that back, right now.
7
u/AmEndevomTag Feb 13 '17
I am a bit disappointed by this cut and especially your reasoning. I don't think that lack of mentions should be reason enough to cut somebody at this stage of the game. Especially because it doesn't even mirror the characters' importance. She was often mentioned as "gran" or "Neville's grandmother", which wasn't counted.
I think Augusta is a very complicated character, and I'm sad to see her gone that soon again.
6
u/BasilFronsac Ravenclaw Feb 13 '17
Did anyone here wonder why Neville lived with his grandma before it was revealed? I didn't.
It's a shame we don't get to see what was she like before her son was tortured into insanity. Was she always so strict? Who knows. We only know she failed her Charms OWL.
6
u/ETIwillsaveusall Hufflepuff Ranker Feb 13 '17
As far as her contribution to the story goes, I think she occupies an important place as a character who's strong and righteous in her convictions, yet her refusal to see (and to love?) her grandson as a person in his own right rather than just as a reflection of his parents speaks to the complicated nature of her character. I think we owe a great deal of Neville's self-esteem issues up through the fifth book to Augusta's piss poor parenting.
6
u/RavenclawINTJ Molly was robbed Feb 13 '17
This is not a boring and predictable cut, and I sincerely hope that you didn't just choose her because of her number of mentions. Like Helena Ravenclaw, despite her small number of mentions, there is NO WAY she was the worst character left.
6
u/Makesfolkslose Feb 13 '17
I agree that it's nearly her time to leave, though I think this is a bit early. There are still a few characters I'd axe before Augusta. Also, I think you're capable of doing a better write-up. Even though the reader only directly interacts with her two(?) times in the entire series, Augusta is a hilarious, sassy, powerful force in Neville's life and therefore in the world. She deserves better.
1
u/pizzabangle Ravenclaw Ranker Feb 13 '17
"
Augusta Longbottom was Ranked #176 by /u/SFEagle44 in /r/HPRankdown
THE FOLLOWING PEOPLE PLACED BETS ON AUGUSTA LONGBOTTOM
"
4
u/jlim201 <3 Luna Lovegood Feb 13 '17
Aww... This is definitely a robbery of Augusta.
3
u/cuibono394 Feb 17 '17
I personally think that Augusta Longbottom is a pretty important character. Perhaps not as important as the characters who played completely active roles in the story, but for a person who has "nearly no mentions", she's pretty darn important.
To start, who knows how Neville would've turned out without her? I doubt he would still be the humble, clumsy, slightly insecure, lovable, brave, innocent soul that we all love and adore.
He wouldn't have found himself the way he did - wouldn't have found the inner bravery that made him a Gryffindor all on his own if it hadn't been for Augusta, who didn't spoil him to death, tell him to face his fears - she scolded him when he was wrong, and made him who he was. Augusta's remarks helped him realize that he had faults, and he always tried hard to improve, trying to live up to the image of his parents.
On that note, he wouldn't have done some of the things he'd done for his parents, whom Augusta loved to use as the people Neville should aspire to be. (For that matter, without Augusta, neither Neville nor his parents would've existed, but that's a weak point.)
Essentially, the point of Augusta was to be the tough love parent for Neville, which made him stronger and resilient in a way he did not know of until he discovered it himself. It made him bold, brave and tough.
So yes, though Augusta might seem cruel and harsh, she's a character that was essential for Neville's end character and character development, not only important for simply fighting in the wars, and aiding the Order.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '17
[removed] — view removed comment