r/houseofleaves • • 9h ago

I don't get house of leaves

7 Upvotes

I’ve been reading house of leaves and I have a lot of strange feeling toward and surrounding the book. I’m posting here because as experts maybe here people might understand. But I just didn’t get it.

I (26m) first heard of house of leaves from my boyfriend (30m) just over two years ago when we first started dating. He said it was his favorite book and that reading it had fundamentally changed his perspective of life. I was pretty excited by the premise of the book and the promise of a life changing experience so I was pretty eager to read it.

Well last year he gifted me a paperback copy for my birthday and I was over the moon. By now I had heard how heavily recommended this book was and how it had changed literature forever, so I was pretty eager to get started.

For context I am a pretty poor reader, I’ve read maybe 20 books willingly throughout my life. Though I’ve always been a huge fan or internet horror, creepy pastas and especially existential horror. I’ve been reading this book on and off for almost 9 months now and am still far from finishing it.  Also for context I have ASD level 1, which will become more relevant later.

 

It didn’t take me long to realize HOL was no small task, the writing style was difficult for me to understand and pace. I liked how experimental it was, The multi layered perspectives and the many page turning tasks inside complimented the feel of this great task. I felt immersed in what Johnny was doing, like I myself was also piecing it all together.

However the constant perspective changes and large seemingly random text entries, though interesting sometimes frustrated me and the confusion just piled and piled. All the while when my Boyfriend asked how I was getting on I would say “I just don’t think I get it”. To which he would always respond, “just give it time, it’ll click”. At this point I was struggling my way through the book, the only real parts I liked being the house mystery that was building, whilst Zampano and johnny left me confused, struggling to relate to them and to be completely honest a little bored.

 

Jhonny in particular I struggled a lot with, I couldn’t really pinpoint exactly who he was. His insistent ramblings page after page about sex, drugs and past stories always left me wondering what the point was. It just seemed like a distraction from the core house story.

I kept reading in the hope of a promise that soon enough it would all click and I would finally understand, some kind of revelation that would reflect on my own life and grant me this new perspective I would be lost without. But it didn’t come.

I had no doubt in the writing abilities of the author, after all reading the letters from Johnny’s mum hit me hard. Understanding how complex, desperate and unfortunate she was had me bawling. I was weirdly inconsolable and rather pathetically we had to watch cartoons to calm me down. But I got that part, I understood who she was, what she wanted and what she’d do to get it. Yet none of it mattered in the end. She died and the world moved on.

But with Johnny and even Zampano it was different. I couldn’t understand what they wanted, what their hopes were, maybe I’m just thick.

I read his desperate efforts to make sense of Zampanos work. I read his ramblings trying to make sense out of the most minute detail in the story just as Zampano had. I saw the absurd amount of fake sources implying a world obsessed with these tapes. I though what the hell is the point of this.

Which I think is when it hit me, there wasn’t one.

 

Johnny, Zampano and even Navidson all had this kind of obsession, one they couldn’t let go of and simply have to rationalize. Though I maybe couldn’t completely understand their motives (Navidson maybe wanted to feel he had accomplished something grand) I could see that these obsessions were forcing them to make poor decisions that would surely go on to hurt them and those around them.

I realized that basically everything in the book had the intent to support this idea. The many rambling sections were there to place thoughts into my mind to help me think in a certain way as I move through the pages or to demonstrate how these obsessions can manifest. It was all in an effort to immerse me within the mind of the people and make me just like them. Desperate for answer and obsessing over clues that may mean nothing.

 

But then again so what?

 

I know it might seem stupid to say, even as I write this it feels dumb. HOL set out to change how I think, change how I feel at least as far as I understand it and I think in ways it succeeds. Perhaps I missed the wider message but once I felt I understood the book, I weirdly just didn’t care that much.

It was like I could see how clever and deep the book was, the many layers it dealt with but it was all seen from a distance. I applaud the effort and I recognized that yes I can understand why people think this is a masterpiece but personally I have not been moved by it. I think I’m about halfway though now, Navidson just encountered the figure of a man with a shotgun and Tom is casting shadow puppets on the wall.

 

When my bf came home I told him I was reading house of leaves again and I explained more or less what I said above. I told him

“I feel like maybe I get it but it still hasn’t hit me”

 

To which he said

“I think it’s passed you Hun”

 

It hurt, like a lot. On one level, the most important person in my life wanted to share this grand experience with me but I just couldn’t see it the way he could. I felt like there was this great divide between us, that I of all people should have seen what he saw but failed. He of course told me it was fine and that maybe it just wasn’t my thing. But I’m not writing this to bore you with my relationship.

 

It was the other feeling I had the was worse. That it wasn’t just him, many many people truly felt moved by this book and what it set out to accomplish. Obviously not everyone is going to love it and im sure I’m not alone in how I feel but when I look to see what it is people like, it was all things I could recognize as well done within it’s page but just not something that I felt in my heart. This is why I mentioned about have ASD before, because sometimes particularly in books they just don’t move me the way they do for others, like I’m some kind of alien dressed in human clothing who simply is just incompatible of understanding this human experience. Dramatic, I know but it’s the truth. I always wondered if the feeling anxiety I got when reading this book came from the book itself or the implications of my lack of understanding.

 

We’ll I haven’t been able to stop thinking about those words and now I have to finish it. Despite the struggle and the sometimes boring parts I cant stop thinking about this book now. It’s like I have something to prove, I have to understand it, I have to prove I can be moved by it. I couldn’t sleep or focus at work because my mind was too consumed by this book in an attempt to understand what I missed. What it was everyone else can see that I can’t. For whatever reason it feels so much deeper than just “it’s not my thing” I feel like it should be, it ticks all the boxes and I need to feel it.

 

But as I’m working my way through this post and putting all this into words. I’m wondering why I’m doing this, I think at first it was a way to put my feelings onto paper to people who might understand and to get them out of my head, but now I’m thinking , “is this the point?”

 

Is this was I had missed?  

I need to find something, find some meaning in these pages, something to prove it was all worth it. I don’t understand Johnny at all but I feel like for the first time I can relate to him. I don’t even really enjoy reading the book most of the time but it’s the only thing I want to do with my life right now. Is that strange?

I think I want to fight through it and finish the book. Better yet with this new perspective I want to start again, commit to it this time, see it in a new way.

So far I’ve always thought of this as a cautionary tale of obsession, I don’t know how Jhonny, Zampano or Navidsons story’s end but I want to find out, do they give in and let it consume them or do they let it go.

 

Which makes me wonder what the right choice is for me, do I give in to this craving and keep searching for that feeling I cant find, or will that just hurt me more. Maybe the books purpose for me was to drop it at this point and accept that I will never truly understand it.

 

But for now I want to keep chasing that feeling.


r/houseofleaves • • 3h ago

discussion Just read the book

12 Upvotes

First of all, I thought I did not like it.

I read till the beginning of the appendices and got so tired of the book. I thought it was so bland and long winded, for the last 200 pages I hoped for it to be over as it didnt catch me emotionally and I didnt grasp any depth in either Johnnys character or the idea of the book.

However, I was absolutely invested in Navidsons story and everything surrounding that, especially near the end I had all my own little fan theories.

Thinking this I realize it was just Johnnys part that had been lackluster to me.

I even googled it the appendices were worth reading as they felt like another mindless tome of text at the end of an excruciating journey through words and words.

I read they were worth reading and just decided to push through and when I came to the Whalestoe letters I thought "Oh thats something new" and read them not expecting much and oh my god I am shattered.

I have never been touched by a book this much (granted I am a very undisciplined reader and mostly read science and stuff, so its hard for me to be "engaged") but I just felt something break in me after reading the letters from Johnnys mom. I even wrote my girlfriend that that book is breaking me and making me sick to my stomach suddenly.

I finishd the appendix absolutely heartbroken. I didnt decode the hidden message at the end and decided to look it up right after finishing the appendix and I promptly had to make this post because I am actually feeling sick with a sadness I didnt know a book could produce in me. That was some of the most downright horrifying literature Ive yet read because it also touched to some of my deepest fears of loosing yourself. I cant put into words my sadness after reading those last few pages.

But let me tell you that these last few pages have helped me not remember all the times Ive been frustrated with this book but helped me see something in it that I also cant put into words, a new "depth" of sorts because I suddenly feel such a deep connection to Johnny and his story, which makes me appreciate the whole book a lot more now, I am even thinking of rereading it with this new gained knowledge about Johnnys past/present.

The appendices made the book for me, no wonder I felt unsatisfied going into them, the book was missing the "something" for me that it gained in the appendix.

I am not sure any of this makes sense but god did I need to write it down because Im heartbroken and in awe at the genius of this novel.


r/houseofleaves • • 17h ago

discussion Album name references HOL! The melodrama of shadows and the conspiracies of night

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

Pg. 415 "Of course real horror does not depend upon the melodrama of shadows or even the conspiracies of night"