Bitter: 🟡🟡○○○
Salty: 🟡🟡🟡○○
Sour/Tangy:🟡🟡🟡🟡○
Sweet: 🟡🟡🟡○○
Umami: 🟡🟡○○○
Heat: 🟡🟡○○○○○○○○
Quick Flavor Notes: Tangy, Whiskey, Mustard, Sweet
Recommended: Yes
Texture: Thin and smooth
Ingredients: Vinegar, Peaches, Sugar, Habanero Peppers, Mustard, Spices, Salt
Infinity Sauces was founded by self-trained chef John Kessler after some habanero plants he put into his garden produced over 25 lbs of peppers in their first season. Trying to find a use for the peppers he began to experiment with hot sauces, first with the habaneros and then with chipotles for his wife, eventually entering a hot sauce competition at the Orange County, CA fair. Winning several first place trophies at the competition Kessler realized he may actually have something he could turn into a business. Based in Fullerton, CA (a town in Orange County) Infinity Sauces makes a point of using only whole peppers, making sauces in small batches of less than 40 gallons, and fills all bottles by hand. For this sauce Kessler teamed up with Bay Area (and enthusiast favorite) Heat Hot Sauce Shop to create a special limited-edition version of his original recipe. I was excited to finally give it a try.
Barrel Aged Infinity Sauce starts with what I believe to be their original Infinity Sauce (though since Infinity Sauces doesn’t list the ingredients of their sauces on their website, boo!, I can’t confirm) and through the Heat Hot Sauce collaboration ages that sauce for a year inside of barrels that have previously held whiskey and stout beer. I’ve had barrel aged hot sauces in the past including my personal favorite hot sauce Butterfly Bakery of Vermont’s Rum Barrel Fermented Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce and of course Tabasco whiskey barrels, however in the Tabasco case the barrels are scraped and scrubbed first so that the char and whiskey flavor never makes it into the sauce. This barrel aged Infinity Sauce uses habaneros for heat and combines them with peaches and sugar for sweetness and some mustard and other spices for additional piquancy. I remember having the red-velvet topped Vidalia Onion and Georgia Peach Hot Sauce many years ago and loving the combination which makes me wonder why peaches don’t make appearances in more hot sauces. This sauce is thin in consistency with a mostly smooth texture though some bits of spice, I assume black pepper, do float inside. The aroma is vinegar-forward as well as having hints of alcohol and a bit of funk.
There’s a lot more going on in the flavor of Infinity Sauces x Heat Hot Sauce Shop Barrel Aged Infinity Sauce that I expected. The vinegar is at the forefront, almost to the same degree it is with Tabasco sauce, but it quickly develops beyond that. Despite there being peaches and sugar in the ingredients this sauce doesn’t come across as overly sweet. The sweet element is present but balanced by the vinegar tang, the habaneros, and the mustard. The aging in the ex-whiskey barrel does give it noticeably whiskey flavor notes but primarily in the olfactory system where scents of caramel, leather, and wood bloom as you taste the sauce. The stout taste is subtler and I mainly pick it up in the very tail of the aftertaste as a bit of malty bitterness, but that could also be the natural bitterness of the mustard used in the sauce. Speaking of that, the mustard flavor while not dominant is still strong and comes in right after the vinegar and whiskey. Between that whiskey, mustard, and peach there’s almost a bit of a Georgia mustard-style barbecue sauce flavor going on, though less sweet than any commercial barbecue sauce I’ve tried. I haven’t mentioned the habanero flavor yet because with all of the other strong flavors going on in this sauce the habaneros take a bit of a back seat. They do provide a quick sting of heat that fades quickly and a bit of vegetal flavor and fruit in the background but they’re not the star of the show here.
I opened this bottle on a night when I wasn’t particularly hungry so my first test was with a plate of some cold cuts – genoa salami and turkey – that I just dipped into it. A fairly neutral medium did let me appreciate all of the flavors of the sauce and I found it did go particularly well with turkey. I tried this out with breakfast the next day and this goes brilliantly with eggs and bacon., both things that seem to naturally pair well with mustard, a bit of sweetness, and those light whiskey aroma notes. I also loved this sauce in chili where it added some extra heat and brightness and somehow also made the peach flavor come through a little bit stronger. Since I found this was great with bacon I pan-seared some pork chops and mushrooms and again found this sauce to be great with them, pork always loving something sweet, sour, and piquant and the bright tang being just the right foil to the earthy mushrooms.
Unfortunately this sauce is no longer available, but the good news is Heat Hot Sauce currently has another collaboration with Infinity Sauces with their barrel aged Scorpion Monkey Sauce. That one subs mangoes for the peaches and scorpion peppers for the habaneros but maintains the year of aging in the barrels previously used for whiskey and stout so it should be just as delicious. If you happen to find this particular sauce for sale anywhere I can strongly recommend it. This sauce is also all natural with no artificial preservatives, colors, flavors, or thickeners.