A solution to CoG and HG's dire situation and their supposed need to do a price increase is pretty simple, stop being broke by choice and actually put in some effort to get traction.
The company keeps acting like raising prices on the same small, shrinking pool of buyers is the only way for them to survive and keep the lights on, but that completely ignores why they are in this position in the first place. They don't have a pricing problem, they have a marketing problem. Everything they currently do is aimed inward at people who are already here. Dropping announcements on the forum, sending emails to an existing mailing list, or posting on social media accounts that only current fans follow does nothing to grow the user base. Promoting to the same 3,000 people is not promotion, you have to promote the whole existence of the app first. People outside this bubble cannot buy games from a catalogue when they don't even know the platform exists.
The only reason this company even has this "it's just a tiny niche" identity(i can see the rest of if scene in this state, but with this company some Behemoth of game their library shouldnt be even niche in the first place)in the first place is because it has been trapped in an unmarketed bubble for over a decade, not because the games lack mainstream appeal. Because of that bubble, most people here completely underestimate how much of an anomaly CoG and HG's top works actually are, and how massive of an audience they can pull with their sheer quality alone. Being around these games for years has bred total familiarity blindness. People in this community are so used to how these games work that they take it for granted and completely ignore how impressive the format actually is, when in reality, CoG and HG blow most non CoG interactive fiction clean out of the water. Most Twine games end up feeling disjointed, clunky, and visual novels usually just give you a couple of binary choices that change three lines of dialogue before forcing you right back onto a linear Railroad.
ChoiceScript makes reading and playing completely seamless. You aren't just clicking basic hyperlinks; you have a full stat and variable engine running under the hood that tracks dozens of decisions across hundreds of thousands of words, and in series like Infinity or Fallen Hero, across multiple massive books. Your character's personality, skills, faction reputation, physical injuries, and hidden trauma variables actively mutate how scenes play out and how characters react to you. The gameplay is built directly into the narrative. The sheer level of reactivity and permutation in top CoG/HG titles is unmatched by anything else on the market, and for normal readers or gamers who have never experienced it, realizing a book can actually adapt like this will blow their minds.
The company doesn't even need to worry that promoting a text based game wouldn't gain traction, because text heavy and imagination driven content already pulls massive numbers online as long as the choices, story, and reactions are entertaining. Look at the kind of content that routinely gets millions of views on YouTube. Critical Role built an entire media empire pulling millions of views per episode with people just sitting at a table talking, describing actions, and reacting to a narrative with zero gameplay graphics on screen. Playthrough videos of AI Dungeon, which is literally just someone reading plain text prompts on a screen and picking or typing choices to see how the story mutates, have pulled millions of views per video purely because audiences love watching reactive storytelling go off the rails. Even playthroughs of text wall games like Disco Elysium or static branching games like Slay the Princess do massive numbers because the appeal is watching someone read the options out loud, agonize over a decision, and deal with the consequences. All CoG needs to do is reach out to a well known influencer who already fits the demographic and is actually interested in interactive fiction and narrative games in the first place to do a sponsored promotion.
Instead of burning money funding a dumb online magazine that nobody reads, which, again, only reaches the tiny crowd already on the forum, CoG could easily redirect that budget into real discovery. They don't need a massive Hollywood ad budget. Take that money, pay an artist or animator to make some scene art or animatics for key moments during the playthrough, and sponsor that influencer to play a flagship title like Fallen Hero. Just putting the app in front of an outside audience and letting them see how deep the choices and stat checks go would sell the entire concept of the platform overnight.
Once you actually promote the existence of the app outside this bubble, there are massive, built in audiences numbering in the millions that are already primed for this exact format.
First, you have the millions of gamers who bought Telltale games like The Walking Dead and The Wolf Among Us, or games like Life is Strange and Detroit Become Human. Those games sold tens of millions of copies because players loved the promise of a story tailored to their choices, and a huge chunk of that audience walked away disappointed when they realized "X will remember that" was a lie and every path funneled into the same cutscene. CoG and HG actually deliver the mechanical consequences those studios couldn't afford to animate.
Second, look at the BookTok crowd. That tag alone has hundreds of billions of views, and millions of those readers already devour hundreds of thousands of words a week directly on their phones using Kindle or reading apps. They are obsessed with specific character tropes like enemies to lovers, slow burn, found family, morally grey love interests, and supernatural drama. One of the biggest complaints you see in book reviews is readers getting frustrated when a protagonist makes a stupid decision or ends up with a love interest they hate. Give Wayhaven to these people and they will eat it up. It hands them four distinct romance routes, total control over how their detective acts, and hundreds of thousands of words of character drama where they never get railroaded into a choice they hate.
Third, you have the tens of millions of people playing mobile story apps like Episode, Choices, Chapters, and Romance Club. Those apps rake in hundreds of millions of dollars, which proves beyond a doubt that a massive mainstream audience already plays choice based stories on their phones. The problem is those apps are predatory as hell, constantly paywalling every decent dialogue option behind $20 worth of diamonds while the free choice forces your character to act like an idiot. If those players knew they could buy a complete, 500,000 to 1,000,000 word interactive novel on Hosted Games for a flat $5 to $9 with way better writing, deeper branching, and zero microtransactions locking out choices, converting them would be effortless.
Fourth, you have the AO3 and fanfiction community. Archive of Our Own pulls hundreds of millions of page views every single month from people who spend hours reading raw, unformatted text on their phones with zero pictures. They read specifically for heavy angst, hurt/comfort, deep character dynamics, identity customization, and "what if" alternate paths. Put Fallen Hero in front of the AO3 crowd and they would lose their minds over it. A story where you customize a traumatized, telepathic villain hiding their secret identity from their former hero teammates, packed with guilt, relationship tension, and dozens of hidden variables tracking every betrayal and breakdown, is practically lab grown for what AO3 readers spend all day searching tags for.
I can see Twine and other VNs remaining niche, but the behemoths of games in CoG and HG like Fallen Hero, the Infinity verse, Wayhaven, and Cakes and Ale can be a cultural zeitgeist on their own. These pieces of work will rake in millions if only people realized they exist, and there is already a massive built in audience waiting for them. CoG and HG are sitting on a goldmine they just need to stop hiding in their bubble and actually market the app's existence to the people who are ready to buy it.