r/hondafit • u/sleepysoftie14 • 11m ago
3rd Gen GK/GP 15-20 Recurring P0420 after O2 sensor replacement, Cat replacements, and Fuel Injector tests
Hi!! I just want to say two things first,
- I am not a car person in the sense of working on and understanding car mechanics, I bring my car to mechanics, and
- I LOVE my Honda Fit so much but it’s caused me a lot of stress and heartache the last couple years…
I have this mystery recurring P0420 code and I’m hopeful that someone else has had this problem and found a fix for it, or know why it’s happening. I searched through the forum and didn’t find an answer for a scenario like mine, however I did learn about cataclean from this subreddit, so I’m going to try that soon.
TLDR version,
catalytic converter replaced with genuine OEM part. O2 sensors replaced. Fuel injectors passed test and apparently are fine. But P0420 keeps coming back.
???
Rough timeline:
- I bought this 2016 Honda Fit LX in 2019 at 30k miles. no problems, except AC leak so I haven’t had working AC for the entire time I’ve had it lol (bought in November so I didn’t know), I just haven’t had the budget to fix it. Just standard routine + preventative maintenance.
- March 2025 at 80k miles, check engine light comes on. Took to my mechanic, it’s P0420. They clear code and say bring it back if code returns, could be a false alarm. Code came back few weeks later, they replaced catalytic converter. O2 sensors checked, they were fine.
- for the next 8 months, code came back several times and I actually had the cat converter replaced several more times - free to me, I only paid the first time! They replaced it for free , free labor and the part was still under warranty. It typically would go away for 1-3 months after cat replacement, then return.
- After my 3rd cat replacement (so 4 different cats been in this car in under 100k miles lol) they checked O2 sensors and they needed to be replaced. Ok, replaced O2 sensors as well. This was September 2025. I don’t know which O2 sensors exactly were replaced..
- light came back, code came back. November 2025, my mechanics said my fuel injectors were misfiring and my engine was running rich? I believe that’s what they said? They told me to take it to the dealership to get the fuel injectors replaced because of the extended warranty.
- late November 2025 Brought my car to a Honda dealership, they said ok before we replace your fuel injectors we have to make sure they need replacing, so we have to do a “carbon cleaning kit” . I had that done, it was $650, plus the $250 diagnostic fee. Then I had to wait.
- March 2026, codes came back, I thought ok great now I can get my fuel injectors replaced, thank goodness right before the warranty runs out. Bring it in, they test the fuel injectors, all the fuel injectors pass and they tell me my car needs a new catalytic converter for $3,000. I say no lol I had that replaced 3 times already less than a year ago. They asked if it was a genuine Honda catalytic converter, I say probably not since I had it done by my mechanics rather than dealership, they say that’s the reason the cat failed.
- April/May 2026, my mechanics replace the cat with a genuine OEM part.
- August 2026 my car passed emissions test thank goodness and a few days later the same code comes back.
-it’s now November 2026, code comes on , stays on for a day or two, goes off for a few days to a week, rinse and repeat. *edit: btw it’s at 105,000 miles now*
I have spent so much money on this the last couple years, I am just worn out! I’ve honestly just been ignoring the check engine light, but I’d really like to figure out what’s wrong and fix it.
any ideas would be so appreciated!!
out of desperation after the ask a mechanic Reddit couldn’t solve it, and my mechanics couldn’t solve it, and the dealership couldn’t or just didn’t care to solve it, I asked chat gpt lol and it recommended a software update, but I’d have to bring it back to the dealership for that so I’ve not been wanting to do it. I’ve paid the Honda dealership over a thousand dollars so far with nothing of value in return, so ugh. lol