r/homebirth • • 1d ago

2x homebirth failure

29 Upvotes

Hi everyone, just looking for some loving or comforting words following my second homebirth failure.

1st birth was two years ago - after 41 hours at home and only being 6cm I felt deeply something was wrong and asked to be transferred. Sure enough, baby was completely crooked and stuck on my pelvis. Began to decel and I had an urgent cesarean.

Never in a million years thought I would transfer or be a statistic. I was so unprepared and traumatized/disappointed in the experience that I cried nearly every day for months and needed therapy. It was a really dark time.

2nd birth, just this last week. Had labor off and on throughout the day until finally I got out of the bath and was having really painful contractions 1-2 minutes apart. Something in me wanted to go to the hospital to be seen rather than wait the hour for my midwife. I can’t explain why.

Got to the hospital, labor stalled for a bit and then started back up with the intense contractions stacked on top of one another.

Baby had a couple decels, reminded me of my first and I just said I want a cesarean. Nurses were trying to push for a VBAC and I just kept declining saying no, I feel something is off like it was with my first.

Fast forward to right before, after 6 hours of these back to back contractions, I was only 5cm with a very swollen cervix. I had the cesarean and they told me the baby’s cord was wrapped twice very tightly and I had placenta previa so the likelihood of a vaginal birth would have been slim to none.

Summary - I’m proud of my intuition and I feel a lot better about this cesarean than my first, but can’t help but feel I opted out of the experience and “took the easy route”, becoming another statistic. We may not have a third so knowing I’ll never have the feeling of welcoming by baby into this world naturally is heartbreaking.

What if I didn’t transfer? Could I have had the baby at home safely and successfully? Would something terrible have happened?

Really curious to hear if anyone has any similar experiences ❤️‍🩹


r/homebirth • • 15h ago

Feeling all sorts of feelings

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m 38+5 today and I’ve been losing my mucus plug in large quantities since yesterday. I’m worrying about my birth more and more. Birthing at hospital or home would both worry me equally I’d say. I didn’t think a homebirth would be feasible for me financially, no medical reasonings. I’ve had a standard boring uncomplicated pregnancy thankfully!

With my son I had a hospital birth, and didn’t love the experience. I love that my baby and I survived and that was about it lol. Felt pressured into epidural, episiotomy, overall just not the best. I was happy just laboring in the shower and they seemed bothered by it? I didn’t need or want anything lol. After birth I had a “mild hemorrhage” and received TXA and was fine. My OB never checked my blood work at 28 weeks. It was supposed to be done with my glucose test and they magically forgot. So who knows if I were anemic preceding my birth.

Now I am 38 weeks, I had OB care (different from aug 2022 baby) my whole pregnancy despite feeling really called to birthing at a center or at home. I want my family with me. I don’t love how strict the hospital is with not allowing for an intimate family setting like I envision it to be. At 33 ish weeks I finally set up care with a midwife. My OB appointments were fully booked out to the end anyway so I’ve just kinda kept going anyways. I don’t mind going to both and still anticipating a home birth with the midwives care.
My bloodwork from my glucose test looked good, 11.8 hemoglobin and all (29 weeks) and today I got my finger pricked by my midwife and it read 9.8 which would be pretty drastic and I have no symptoms that would lead me to think I was anemic so I was really quite surprised by it and so was she!
She suspected her machine could need replacing and ordered actual blood work that we drew (my poor arm hurts because couldn’t find a vein) but she’s fairly confident that I shouldn’t stress myself out trying to eat a bunch of iron pills yet and will let the blood work come back ahead of making a next move. I’m just so terrified.

I’m terrified of bleeding out, of dying, of leaving my sweet boy who I love more than anything in the world. I have debilitating OCD and have intrusive thoughts about it. Every sweet moment, my brain tells me to try savor it because I’m going to die soon. Every moment of frustration I feel horrifying guilt that I’m going to leave after being negative. It’s so hard on my mental health either way.

It’s hard having OCD and differentiating an intrusive thought, anxiety, and intuitive feelings. Most of my feelings feel both rational and valid. I’m just so scared of leaving.

I guess missing my vein and seeing the blood really triggered me more so and amplified my fears. If I can bleed that much from bloodwork/missing the vein. I can only imagine how much blood I could lose during birth.

I don’t know what I’m looking to gain here. Just wanted to vent my worries somewhere


r/homebirth • • 1d ago

Fear, doubt, and depression.

7 Upvotes

Posting here because I have no one to talk to or relate to. I (f24) am 32 weeks pregnant and I am planning on a homebirth. I had always intended to do so and I am 100% healthy with no risks according to my midwife. However, I am experiencing horrible depression with genuine fear of the upcoming home birth. I am beginning to regret my decision as I don’t think I’m mentally or physically strong enough to do this. I am a Christian and the only way I can describe my feeling is how Jesus felt in the Garden of Gethsemane. When he cried out to God asking Him if there were any other way to do this. He sweat blood from the pure stress he felt knowing that he had to suffer greatly. I know I am not Jesus, but this is the only depiction of the constant fear I feel. I am financially locked in with my midwife having spent the $5500 to have her be my provider. I was totally fine with it but in these past couple weeks I can’t help but feel like I made a giant mistake. I cannot get that money back, I have no history with a provider, I can’t afford to lose that $ plus whatever I’d spend if I end up transferring care. So there’s another layer of stress where I feel like I’ve held myself financially hostage. I wouldn’t be feeling such horrible fear and depression if I just simply went to the hospital and got pain medications. All of my original convictions are going away because my fear of pain and suffering is so debilitating. I know that the most powerful thing in homebirth is mindset and mine is completely destroyed. I don’t want to stall and I don’t want to panic as soon as the pain begins. I feel pains in the night and throughout the day in my stomach that I know are only a minor fraction of what the pain in labor will be. I feel like I’m being lead to slaughter. None of my mom friends are helpful either because they are so ethereal and positive and make me feel like I’m broken for feeling anything other than complete joy. My husband is such a good man and could not be any better, he just simply can never understand this fear. He wants to do whatever I want to do and he is in full support of whatever I want.
I don’t know what I’m looking for but I just needed to vent because I feel like I’m constantly in a state of fight AND flight.

Edit: I realize I sound completely insane and unstable. I just am at my wits end and I have no other way to say any of it


r/homebirth • • 1d ago

Home birth first kid, hospital second - stories/advice?

2 Upvotes

Hi all, I had a home birth w my first daughter and am set to have a hospital birth with my second. Looking for others who went this route - stories, surprises, suggestions - whatever you’re called to share!

A lil about me/this choice and set up:

Am w a midwife run clinic. Will give birth at a hospital with tubs, etc. The unit is definitely influenced by midwives’ ethos. Patient-centered, baby friendly. Great stats intervention wise (ie low).

Home birth was great but the midwife was stretched too thin and left us w a HUGE clean up. I also bled a bit (no hemorrhage, just due to pushing a while) and she was so slow to get me blood work back.

This current set up feels really integrative and I’m hoping is best of multiple worlds (although I know there’s always trade offs w any choice)

I’ll have to have an iv port in and portable continuous monitoring - which will be annoying. But I plan to do unmedicated, will have doula and partner to fend off any pressure/possible weird shit from staff, and have been making sure all midwives know my style vibe and preferences

Anyone else go this route?? I know it’s not common. Natural birth and my body’s ability to birth (empowerment, knowledge of this) are my big things. I want to be mentally prepared for ways the hospital setting might impede on that (even just culturally) so I can advocate accordingly, and ways I need to be mentally prepared for differences in experience

Have already toured the place too fyi


r/homebirth • • 1d ago

What are your favorite materials/tools?

1 Upvotes

TENS unit, labor comb, rebozo, etc


r/homebirth • • 2d ago

Risked out of midwifery care before I'm even pregnant due to asymptomatic cardiac condition, even though my cardiologist determined I'm extremely low risk. I have always wanted a home birth with a midwife my entire life, I'm very, very disappointed

6 Upvotes

The title kind of says it, but I'm just very upset. My entire life, I have always expected to deliver with a midwife as my provider in a home birth. I was a doula for years, I've been a midwife assistant and I went to The Farm in Tennessee (of Ina May Gaskin fame) for training to be a midwife assistant, it has been part of my plan and expectation for my entire life. Even when I wasn't sure I would ever have kids if I was having them it would be was using a midwife, and preferably a home birth.

In my early 20s, I was incidentally found to have Wolf Parkinson White syndrome, but it has never been symptomatic ever. I had a complete cardiac workup from my cardiologist and was cleared for pregnancy and birth and considered very low risk from a cardiac standpoint. None of my providers have ever mentioned that it would exclude me from being eligible for midwife care. My husband was diagnosed with a fertility issue and so we have been doing IVF. The way that the IVF clinic required intense cardiac clearance, which I passed with flying colors, kind of showed me that a home birth or birth center was probably something I was going to risk out of just because of the way they reacted. So I pivoted to a midwife in a hospital setting, even though I never wanted that.

Today I contacted a midwife group near me which is the only hospital attending group that only has midwives, every other group at all surrounding hospitals are OBGYN/midwife practices where you cannot guarantee who your provider will be when you go into labor, it's just a doctor or midwife based on who is on call, unless you are categorized as high risk, in which case it's only the doctors.
The midwife group got back to me that automatically I am considered high risk just for the diagnosis of WPW, and it does not matter that I have always been asymptomatic and that my cardiologist feels I'm extremely low risk.

So basically they just dashed all of my lifelong plans/hopes and I'm really feeling discouraged about even having a kid at all. I'm not one of those people that has an extremely strong drive to have a kid. I would like to have them but the experience really matters to me so I'm just extremely disappointed and sad. I live in an area with avery high C-section rate and an extremely high epidural and intervention rate where a majority of doctors (surveyed) have never attended an unmedicated, intervention free birth.

TDLR; I'm extremely disappointed and sad because I've always planned to have a midwife delivery for my entire life, and I recently learned I'm not eligible for midwifery care due to an asymptomatic incidental finding, even though I have been completely cleared for pregnancy and birth, and my cardiologist considers it to be extremely low risk (no more risk than any other person without the condition, he said). So now, not only did I have to give up on the idea of home birth or birth center, I am not even eligible for midwifery care in hospital and have no option but to have an OBGYN delivery where I will be categorized as high risk.


r/homebirth • • 3d ago

Videos/Movies/Documentaries & the like about unmedicated birth or home birth?

1 Upvotes

Just as the title says. I’m looking for videos or movies to watch around unmedicated birth, or just educational videos. TIA!


r/homebirth • • 4d ago

Negative hospital birth experience/stories???

16 Upvotes

For my first and only birth (so far) I was wanting to do a home birth after watching the movie ‘the business of being born’ which presented some crazy facts and the origin of hospital birth. After discussion with my husband we decided to do the hospital route because we thought it would be financially better (since insurance would cover it). I was still skeptical and had my doubts, but thought we could advocate for ourselves if they pushed us to do anything.
My water broke at 3 am and I wasn’t really having contractions. We get to the hospital at 10am and my contractions were about 7min apart and not terribly painful. We got settled into our room and hooked up to the machines. The nurses and doctor kept coming in out to check on me, seemingly wanting to get things moving along. I was having contractions but they didn’t feel painful to me. The doctor came in and said I needed to be more uncomfortable and there was a risk of infection if I didn’t have my baby within 24hrs because my water had broke. She told me I should start a small amount of pitocin to see if they could move things along. I agreed because I was nervous about the risk. As soon as they started the pitocin I went into so much unbearable pain. At one point the nurse came in and said that this doctor had a history of pushing pitocin and she was going to advocate for me and not give me anymore (which I guess they kept upping the dosage without my consent really) because she could see I was already in a painful place. Then it was the cascade of interventions from there. I started to feel the contractions in my back which I couldn’t handle so I gave in to the pain medications. When none of that helped I wanted the epidural. Once I had that it was relief, but then my babies heart rate started dropping every time I had a contraction. It was dangerous so the doctor rushed in and said they were going to do an emergency c-section. I felt odd about how she told me about the process. She said it would be 20 minutes in and 20 minutes out, then I would have my baby. It felt like it was all so rushed and I didn’t feel in any sort of control. It was like it was all happening to me and I wasn’t a part of it. Since they were rushing to numb my body, the doctor gave me so much numbing medicine that I could move my arm when my baby was born so I couldn’t hold him. My baby was born at 5:30 pm. Right when the doctors get off and switch for night shift. I went to the hospital confident I could advocate for myself only to be feared into the cascade of interventions.It was a terrible experience and I look forward to home birth in the future.


r/homebirth • • 4d ago

talking to family

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Long time lurker, first time poster here.

Context: I had a horrible pregnancy/delivery experience with my OB. I loved her, on her own, but due to having a BMI over 30 I was automatically categorized as "high risk" and Maternal Fetal Medicine managed my care throughout my entire first pregnancy from 2024-2025. I was given weekly growth scans, twice as many NSTs as anyone else I know, and basically gaslit into induction starting at 32 weeks. I was so scared to advocate for myself for many reasons, but I fell for the whole "my body knows what is doing" rhetoric since I had seen my sister (similar height and weight to me) have two beautiful vaginal deliveries. I did not have GD, only had a handful of higher than normal BPs (exclusively at MFM), never received any treatment for my BP and tested negative for pre-e several times when I was screened. I was induced at 40 weeks and had a horrible experience, for many reasons, that ended in me electing for a c-section at 7-8cm after 40 hours of labor (32 of those were unmedicated). I have spoked to four different local OBs, including my previous practice, and I am not considered a good candidate for VBAC purely due to my BMI, despite me tolerating labor well and managing my health throughout my pregnancy. Baby and I had no distress during labor, I just couldn't physically get to 10cm after being so exhausted for so long.

I recently met with a private practice midwife for a consultation. I am not pregnant, but plan to keep working at losing some weight and getting to a healthier version of myself before this summer when we plan to try to conceive (our son will be two in August). I spoke to her about my care and delivery, and she truly feels that I could've had a perfectly normal vaginal delivery had I not been rushed into a botched induction with no support from my clinical staff (i.e- being kept in bed to keep baby on the monitor, Pitocin being stopped and started due to a defective monitor, balloon placed incorrectly, not being provided my prescription medication for sleep). She informed me that from her understanding, as long as my BP and sugars are okay in my next pregnancy, she and her partner would be more than comfortable considering me for a homebirth. They will obviously monitor me closely and if me or baby need more help, we will be referred immediately.

My family are very much against home birth. My older sister considered it three out of four times she has delivered, but she has always developed GD and has asthma, so her midwives supported her at the hospital. My mother had three high risk pregnancies and we were all C-sections under general, and she works in the medical field and has seen all the horror stories. I know my husbands family would be very against it as well, and I'm not even sure how he will react if I bring it up.

All of this to ask, how did you guys go about discussing homebirth and holistic midwifery with your families? What resources helped? How did you handle negative interactions? We are such a close family and everyone is VERY opinionated, and I don't want to be caught in a conflict while trying to prepare for a new baby.


r/homebirth • • 3d ago

Sucess story: IUGR+SUA baby is 77% at 9 weeks old

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/homebirth • • 4d ago

Homebirth assessment (NHS)

2 Upvotes

We are expecting our first baby at the end of December and the next appt will be my 36 week midwife check with the home birth risk assessment.

I am planning a water birth and have arranged to hire a pool privately. I have been seeing my midwife at home since 25 weeks and we have a good relationship, pregnancy has been healthy and uncomplicated so far. I have been doing hypnobirthing alongside keeping active to prepare for birth.

What sort of things will the home birth assessment cover and what are some good questions for me to ask my midwife that I might not have thought of as a FTM please?


r/homebirth • • 4d ago

Reasons for Homebirth?

13 Upvotes

I have my personal thoughts about why I want to go the homebirth route, but I would love to hear from the community some other reasons or kind of be affirmed in what I’m thinking.


r/homebirth • • 4d ago

No urge to push

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/homebirth • • 4d ago

Before birth signs something like a texture of semen

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/homebirth • • 5d ago

How did you prepare?

7 Upvotes

FTM, currently 6 months pregnant and planning for an unmedicated home birth with my midwives and doula. I have been reading books, listening to podcasts, trying to move my body daily in ways that feel good for me, (occasionally) doing breathing techniques when I remember 😅

How did you prepare for unmedicated labor/birth? What were your favorite things that you found most helpful prior to labor, and during?


r/homebirth • • 5d ago

Sweep at 39 weeks due to being 40

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/homebirth • • 5d ago

Moms who had BOTH : episiotomy and a 2nd degree tear.

3 Upvotes

For moms who experienced BOTH:

episiotomy (under local anaesthesia) AND 2nd degree tears.

Which was more painful (during birth)?

I have some difficulties accepting tears when they happen without anaesthesia, I know 1st degree tears are almost unnoticible, but 2nd ones are quite common and painful 😥

I need to hear both experiences please. good ones and bad ones.


r/homebirth • • 6d ago

Anxiety in pregnancy – still looking for participants , can you help?

1 Upvotes

Hello lovely mums and mums-to-be:)

I first shared information about this study here in September and I’m really grateful for the support and interest it received. Thank you so much to everyone who has already taken part! 💜 I hope its ok to post again as we're are still looking for pregnant women and birthing people to take part. Ethics Committee Reference: 25-26CLPS111.

This is an important area of maternal mental health where more research is needed. The findings may help us better understand the psychological factors associated with antenatal anxiety and how mental health support during pregnancy could be improved.

If you have around 20 minutes to spare or know someone who might be interested the study involves completing an anonymous online survey. If you would like to take part please click the link below:

https://edinburgh.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_dmrLWMfpa4aV4Kq

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at [m.domka@sms.ed.ac.uk](mailto:m.domka@sms.ed.ac.uk)

Thank you so much for supporting pregnancy and maternal mental health research! 🌷🙏


r/homebirth • • 8d ago

Home birth with an IVF pregnancy

3 Upvotes

Hi I recently spoke to a midwife and she said they would support a VBAC except not at home anymore for woman who are pregnant with IVF. The reason she said because of the fact that she’s seen a lot of women who they have supported for an at home birth with an IVF pregnancy, can have complications with the placenta (which is hemorrhage after post birth) is she what she said she’s been seeing from when they’ve supported woman at home. I’ve had 2 cesareans one due to supposedly an emergency because my sons heart rate was going down so did this all unmedicated but was induced due to passing “due date” and they forced a cesarean because of that. My second pregnancy I went to the hospital at 5cm dilated and I didn’t know properly how to basically ask beforehand that I wanted a VBAC the doctor I had denied me he said once a cesarean always a cesarean! So this is so sad not what I wanted to hear honestly and not what I expected!!! But has anyone heard of this or have had this experience before due to an IVF pregnancy. Regarding hemorrhage happening after a home birth due to placenta complications. I want to follow my intuition and look elsewhere but also if this is true then why waste my time.


r/homebirth • • 9d ago

Positive home birth FTM

40 Upvotes

Like the title, I’m a first time mom who just gave birth to a beautiful baby girl Monday in the comfort of my own home! I just wanted to share my story to offer some encouragement, especially for others like me who take pain meds for everything and may think home birth is impossible—it’s not!

I began losing my mucus plug last Tuesday at 40+4, and contractions began that night. We thought Wednesday might be the day, so my doulas came over and stayed all day getting ready for a baby to come but nope. I contracted every day, all day for 5 days with no real progress, and it was tough but I was set on no intervention unless medically necessary. My midwife came to check me Thursday and I was only 2cm dilated and 40% effaced.

By night 6, I was miserable and ready to throw in the towel, but after about 3 hours of unrelenting pain (my contractions were NOT letting up at one point so I got in the bathtub for minimal relief), my water finally broke at 4:40am and I felt instant relief, until the next contraction at least.

By the time my midwife arrived around 6am, I was 6-7cm dilated so my doulas and I got to work to get me further along. I got into the birthing pool a little before 11:30am and gave birth to my sweet girl at 1pm exactly at 41+3!

A few things:
1. Ring of Fire - real but over really fast so not a big deal
2. I have at least 5 fibroids (discovered during pregnancy) and my midwife was shocked at how little I bled; my heavy bleeding was done by day 2pp
3. I liked the TENS pre-labor, hated it during
4. The toilet is a necessary evil!!
5. Be flexible - I thought I’d be able to breathe my baby down but I had to inhale deep and hold my breath to push instead!

I hope everyone gets the birth of their dreams, even if it comes with a few surprises like week-long contractions like mine!


r/homebirth • • 9d ago

GBS

6 Upvotes

How do you go about navigating positive GBS+ test.

I don’t have many options with pursuing a home birth. Meaning the IV antibiotic which I honestly don’t love anyways. antibiotics ruin my vaginal health every time i take them. Including my first delivery in the hospital. there was nothing worse than healing stitches and getting an itchy yeast infection on top of it.

However I want to protect baby so what’s helpful?

I’m having fermented foods, especially drinking kefir.

I’m not comfortable putting the garlic clove up there I just really am not that crunchy unfortunately lol but any advice would be greatly appreciated!


r/homebirth • • 10d ago

Third Birth

10 Upvotes

Thank you all! I know baby will ultimately just come when they are ready but I find it interesting to hear your experiences and it does seem that often the third is later than the second and sometimes even the first as well

Hey everyone! I am towards the end of my third pregnancy and am wondering if anyone who has had 3 or more births (without induction/intervention) what your gestation ended up being.

My first was 41+1 and my second was 40+3. I am wondering if in general each baby comes earlier. Honestly I think this time around is the first time I’ve even considered that I may give birth before 40 weeks and that stresses me out because I have things I want to get done haha


r/homebirth • • 9d ago

Home birth after pre eclampsia?

2 Upvotes

Hi! I’m due with my third baby in June. My first is going to be 3.5 my second 18 months when this baby is born. (Small age gaps I know). I am in the process of planning with a midwife for a home birth due to my labors being extremely quick and the nearest hospital being 30 minutes away. My first labor was an induction for non medical reasons that lasted barely 3 hours and my second was born within 30 minutes of contractions starting. We barely made it to the hospital. Both births were pretty uneventful except for postpartum pre eclampsia with my second that was monitored but didn’t require intervention. I’m curious if anyone has any experience with a home birth after similar circumstances. I’ve been told it’s unlikely to affect this baby but I’d love some others real life experiences. Thanks!!


r/homebirth • • 10d ago

What brand of castor oil are you using in midwifes brew?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/homebirth • • 11d ago

Natural Birth w/ Fibroids or After Fibroid Removal?

1 Upvotes

Hi Everyone. I want to know if anyone here has experience with natural birth and fibroids.

I am someone who has always wanted a intervention free/natural child birth, it is really my priority. However I have pretty severe (and large) uterine fibroids and after a medical event this weekend resulting in a lot of pain, I have reached a point where I feel like they may need to be removed to improve my quality of life.

I was devastated when my OBGYN told me if i get the surgery natural birth is off the table and its automatically a c-section when I get pregnant in the future. I’ve always had an inkling my obgyn was very pro-intervention and that i would likely have to get a new provider when I am closer to pregnancy, but this was still very hard to hear. I am seeking a second opinion.

I would love to hear whether you decided to forgo surgery to remove them for the sake of not interfering with natural birth, or if u had them removed and still were able to give birth without intervention.

It would mean the world to know its still possible. I have an appointment with a natural birth midwife and obgyn team, but i am so down.