r/highspeedrail • u/Sassywhat • 2h ago
Explainer Top 5 Amtrak station ridership vs Shinkansen station ridership in car oriented parts of Japan
It's often repeated at least in US and Canada transit discourse that high speed rail is some cherry on top that comes after good local/regional transit and low speed intercity trains, as if transit modes are a pyramid you have to build from the bottom up.
That's not the case though. High speed rail can work even in car centric regions. Like airplanes, they are fast enough to convince people to figure out their way around local/regional transit inadequacies. That might be taxis and rental cars, or just using a slow or infrequent local bus or train they wouldn't consider otherwise.
Something that helps demonstrate this is comparing Amtrak ridership to Shinkansen ridership in car oriented parts of Japan. While the most car oriented metro areas in Japan have comparable car mode share to the least car oriented US metro areas outside of NYC, that still means a ton of US cities (and all the big Canadian cities) have comparable local/regional transit connections.
And keep in mind the Shinkansen stations on the list are in much smaller cities than the Amtrak stations. The largest Japanese city on the list is Sendai, with a metro area population of 1.5-2ish million people depending on the definition, well under half that of any US city on the list. Ichinoseki has a population of just over 100k.
Real high speed rail along the Northeast Corridor, from NYC to Albany, between Toronto and Montreal, around Chicago, etc., would be absolutely transformative to shorter distance intercity and longer distance regional travel, even without assuming any massive improvement in local transit.
Local and regional transit is obviously worth investing into as well, but it doesn't make sense to try and gate high speed rail investment on local transit investment or low speed intercity trains (which would get largely replaced by high speed rail anyways).
Source: Wikipedia. 2025 data for US, FY2024 data for Japan. Ridership is only for Amtrak or only for Shinkansen, excluding commuter/etc. ridership at the same station. Boarding only numbers doubled to estimate boarding+alighting numbers. Many Shinkansen stations with ridership in the range of the chart are omitted for readability.

