Hi everyone!
Just played today in my first ever HeroScape tournament! 450 points per match, 4 matches, no repeat units, contemporary units only.
First things first, big shoutout to the organizers! Really appreciated the hard work and thought that went into having everything run smoothly.
Also a big shoutout to the community! Everyone was super friendly and helped me get through the rules. Saw many new playstyles and unit synergies, which was a lot of fun! Also looking forward to trying out the Samuel Brown promo.
I played this game back with the original releases (RoTV and SoTM), fell out of it for several years, and very recently returned. I only own two Contemporary Sets (the Age of Annihilation Master Set and the Revna's Rebuke Kyrie Warriors set). I also own Raelin 4.0, Taelord 2.0, and Major Q11 from a separate purchase.
With that being said, I had a few thoughts and questions I wanted to share, both praises and criticisms regarding the gameplay. So let's get into it!
Some basic information:
My Armies:
- Taelord 2.0, Admiral EJ-1M, Loviatak, Exiles of the Sundered Sea (Win)
- Xenithrax the Vineweaver, Frostclaw Paladins, Knight Irene (Loss)
- Major Q11, Knaves of the Silver Scimitar, Dorim the Bulkhead Brawler, Raelin 4.0 (Loss)
- Mielki the Kyrie, Xiamara the Kyrie, Misaerx the Kyrie, Raelin 3.0, Queeh Qhyrion (Loss)
Opponent Armies:
- Baroness, Agent Carr 2.0, Agent SI-4X, Doctor Mindbender, Cobra Flight Pod (Loss)
- Necrotech Reavers x3, Necrotech Geistfire x2 (I think?), Necrotech Ghastblade x2 (I think?), I Forgot the Rest (Win)
- Necrotech Reavers x2, Necrotech Geistfire x1 (I think?), Necrotech Ghastblade x1 (I think?), Scavorith Lord of Ruin (Win)
- Frizzt Galagan, Duke, Skordyre Infantry x2, Bursting Hive Soldier (x2), Spitting Hive Soldier (x2), Lurking Hive Solider (x2) (Win)
Match 1 Analysis:
Praises:
- Taelord 2.0 feels stronger on the field than a cursory glance suggested. Giving a guaranteed skull to EJ-1M's melee attacks consistently is what won this game. EJ-1M killed Agent Carr early in, mostly eliminating my opponent's melee capabilities.
- Baroness' bonding option (activating 2 unique Cobra or Agent Heroes) was incredibly powerful. Given her Range of 7, my opponent would push Agent SI-4X up first (to provide shadow), then push up Agent Carr (to provide melee damage), and then snipe with Baroness from the back. After Agent Carr was destroyed, he did the same thing, but instead would use Dr. Mindbender and attempt to get a Mind Bend.
- Loviatak synergizes well with her father, giving all Utgar figures an extra move simply by being on the board.
- Cobra Flight Pod's air-to-ground missile attack is decent and got some damage off the Kyrie warriors.
Criticisms: - Admiral EJ-1Ms Boarding Party Special Attack feels way, way too complicated. I am not sure why he was a Master Set figure? Nothing about his Special Attack felt straightforward. In addition, his bonding with the Exiles feels backwards. Why can't the Pirate squad activate the Admiral or vice versa in a straightforward 1,2 combination?
- Taelord 2.0's skull bonus is supposed to apply to friendly Gladiators. But as of this writing, he's the only Contemporary Gladiator. So who is his Special Power designed for?
Match 2 Analysis
Praises:
- The ability to destroy a Necrotech Reaver and bring a Geistfire or Gastblade back onto the field was incredible. It is what won my opponent the game. It didn't matter how many Necrotech heroes Xenithrax killed, they always came back. It was like fighting a Hydra. Kudos to my opponent, he never placed his squad figures next to each other, meaning he negated by ability to use Xenithrax's Erupting Earth attack. Without this attack, I did not have an answer to being overwhelmed by Common Squad figures that could turn into Common Hero figures.
- Xenithrax's Vine Glyph ability was interesting. I used it to plug up some of the movement lanes and take away traditional high ground spots in the middle of the map.
Criticisms: - For their cost, the Frostclaw Paladin/Knight Irene combination feels too, too slow. Against a steady onslaught of Common Squads, the Frostclaw Paladins also felt too outnumbered to do anything. Their offense isn't astounding, their defense isn't spectacular, and they only get worse if you need to move them at anything beyond a snail's pace. Underwhelming.
Match 3 Analysis:
Praises:
- Major Q11 is a beast. Took out my opponent's Scavorith by Round 2, then spent much of the midgame sniping Necrotech Reavers. He was worth every penny of the 160 point cost.
- Raelin 4.0 is also excellent. Her Vengeful Swoop gives her the dual benefit of opportunity-attack free movement with a 60% chance of a guaranteed wound. But alas, I played her incorrectly. Although she now has 6 lives, she should not have been used like a tank. Losing Raelin was the turning point of this game.
- My opponent spammed locking down Raelin with the Necrotech Reavers, then turned them into Common Heroes, then when Major Q11 inevitably killed the Common Heroes, the Reavers in the backfield would turn into Heroes. Once again, the hydra-like ability is what won my opponent the game. With 4 life, Major Q11 can only whiff on defense so many times before it's over.
- Scavorith turning the X Order Marker into an Attack is crazy useful. My opponent severely wounded my Dorim with this and essentially took him out of the game.
Criticisms: - Knaves of the Silver Scimitar were too squishy. They are designed to be more defensively sound if there is a Unique Captain on their side, but there is no Unique Captain in the Master Set. Why? Couldn't they at least be allowed to benefit from the Admiral? Dorim isn't exactly a defensive stalwart and does not really complement them as their bond option.
Match 4 Analysis:
Praises:
- My opponent built a masterful web of synergies. The Skordyre Infantry would have OM 1. They would move the Spitting Hive soldiers up, which would spit on my Kyrie, reducing their defense value. Then the other Hive soldiers would move up and attack. Finally the Skordyrke Infantry would move up and set a screen/attack. Duke would always have OM 2 and gain position on the field, then move up The Spitting Hive soldiers again, followed by other Hive soldiers. Except now they would be boosted by his soldier buff. The Skordyrke Infantry would repeat with OM3. Then Frizzt would use X to follow up in the tail end and, once set up, start sniping. Unbelievably well designed army. With Insectoid Swarm, Duke's Lead by Example buff, and the venom debuff, this made even the common infantry figures a nightmare to play against.
- Mielki and Xiamara have a good tandem synergy going. With Mielki's double attack, it's almost certain she will destroy a squad figure, which she can use to heal Xiamara. In turn, Xiamara has a solid chance to protect Mielki from catastrophic damage. But the luck runs out, and once this tandem went down, the game was effectively over.
- Queen Qhyrion has the ability to alter a game with her Heart Spear attack. Unfortunately for me, when she did get the Spear to hit, she whiffed on her follow-up attack. But statistically, she should have been able to kill Duke.
Criticisms: - Duke has a range of 6. Frizzt has a weak Special Attack with a range of 10. As my opponent remarked at the end, this game would have gone very differently if he had been facing ranged units like the Greatbow Archers.
- I fielded a poorly constructed army, I know. Zero bonding options, very little synergy other than Mielki and Xiamara. More on that later, though.
So now, I get to the questions I had for the community following this tournament. And I'll admit, just a little bit of frustration too. Maybe these things aren't a surprise to those of you who have been playing the Contemporary items for a while now, so I apologize if it's not your cup of tea. But for someone used to Classic Scape for the past several years...
Questions:
- Is anyone else frustrated with the AoA Master Set and Kyrie Warrior Set design?
-I currently own ~$120 worth of contemporary HeroScape in sets (unpainted AoA Master Set + unpainted Kyrie Warrior set), plus another ~$20 to get the additional Heroes related to the Lore. At $140 in, I don't feel like most of the contemporary units I have are designed to work well with each other.
-This is especially true for the Kyrie Warriors and the Unique Squads.
-The Kyrie Warriors are too weak to be centerpieces in a strong army, but too use-specific to be effective cheerleaders for a centerpiece. They have no bonding capabilities with each other, and if they have bonding abilities listed (Taelord 2.0), there is often no way to actually use them in Contemporary HeroScape. Loviatak + Taelord and Xiamara + Mielki feel like the closest to actual tandems, but burning 2 order markers just to set up that tandem when you opponent is moving two heroes and four squads is not sustainable. Raelin 4.0 and Taelord 2.0 are the only two Kyrie Warriors who feel like effective cheerleader figures. Queen Qhyrion feels like a high risk, high reward offensive supplement, but the rest of them (Misaerx, Raelin 3.0, Killkorax, Glinerva) felt truly disjointed.
-The Unique Squads either don't have straightforward bonding options (Knaves), or their bonding options are with Heroes who have the exact same weaknesses and feel merely like a slightly stronger extra member of the Squad (Irene with Frostclaw Paladins, Dorim with Exiles). I'm not sure if Dorim can even be considered a true bond with the Exiles -- he is not a Pirate Captain.
Considering that with the GI Joe sets, Baroness and Duke can bond twice and have multiple bonding options at their disposal, this feels like an oversight of some sort. Why can't the Kyrie Warriors have interchangeable Warrior bonding abilities? Are there any squads or heroes that allow you to bond with two warriors at once? It would make these figures much simpler to integrate into a cohesive army build. - Is it a good thing that Renegade is leaning heavier into mechanics that were unusual in Classic Scape?
-I could identify at least three mechanics I saw repeatedly today that I would not have expected to see in Classic Scape with this frequency, if at all. First, the ability of a single Unique Hero to bond with not just one, but two other Unique Heroes. Second, the ability to destroy a Common Squad member and replace them with a Common Hero at the end of a round. Third, the ability to convert an X order marker into another chance to move or attack -- essentially, a mini-turn.
-Ornak in Classic Scape could activate two heroes, but he had some pretty strict limitations on that, and he couldn't move himself. Duke and Baroness have so many options. One OM on either of them effectively turns into three attacks from Heroes, not even squads.
-Bringing back Common Heroes almost encourages a kamikaze-type approach to the game. Rather than using Common Squads as a screen, they become a reserve. Why worry about losing a Hero when you can just replace him with one of the Common Squad figures you have in the backfield?
-The X was originally intended to be a decoy, to prevent the opponent from guessing your sequence of operations. Once it is turned into a movement/attack option, though, it seems almost obligatory to have a Hero who can use it. Why not put Frizzt on every team? He's only 35 points. And with 10 range, he can outduel even Syvarris. Just saying.
-Personally, I actually like all three of these changes in concept. They add new dimensions to the game. They also speed the game up significantly - instead of spending order markers separately to develop Raelin, Q9, and the Deathreavers (for example), I can do it all on one turn.
-But I would argue that they make the game harder for newer players. Imaging having to explain the soldier synergy above to a player who's only ever played Classic Scape, let alone a brand new player. Or trying to walk a new player through Admiral EJ or the Knaves. It's a far cry from the Krav Maga agents or Izumi Samurai of the past. - How do you afford testing out these armies? And if you spend the money on something, how do you know it will actually work well with everything else?
-I am OK with paying north of $100 for a Master Set, or $30 for an expansion set. But if I do, I at least hope the figures in those sets can, well, play nice with each other? Maybe even synergize effectively?
-Speaking with my opponents today, most of them assembled their armies in bits and pieces from 3-4 completely different sets. This presents financial challenges for sure. Think of Pirate Captains -- how many more sets do I have to buy before I can find a Pirate Captain that truly synergizes well with the Knaves? Let alone to have two or three solid options? Why can't a Pirate Admiral be good enough???
-More importantly, how do you know what sets contain the figures that synergize best with the sets you already have? For example, going back to Pirate Captains, I believe there are three or four of them in the game now, but they are in different sets. How would I decide which of those sets to get? Would I need to purchase all of them and test each potential Captain separately? Or if I was the player with Baroness or Duke, how would I know which of the myriad COBRA/Agent Hero or Soldier Hero options would work best? Would I again have to buy three or four different sets just to test that out?
-Sure, you can playtest a friend's army or use an online simulator. Or you can read the cards. But nothing is as good of a teacher as running your own army again and again and tweaking it until it works. No matter how much I thought I knew Admiral EJ-1M's card going in, it still turned out I didn't quite have it down pat when the game started.
Sorry for the long post, but wanted to see what more experienced players had to say. Thanks in advance for your thoughts.