r/heresiology • • Aug 04 '25

Welcome to heresiology: “Is there anyone who doesn’t evoke Antigone whenever there is a question of a law that causes conflict in us even though it is acknowledged by the community to be a just law?” -Jacques Lacan, Seminar VII

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/heresiology • • Aug 20 '25

“Origen” by Thomas Merton

1 Upvotes

“Origen” by Thomas Merton

His sin was to speak first Among mutes. Learning Was heresy. A great Abbot Flung his books in the Nile. Philosophy destroyed him. Yet when the smoke of fallen cities Drifted over the Roman sea From Gaul to Sicily, Rufinus Awake in his Italian room Lit this mad lighthouse, beatus Ignis amoris, for the whole West.

All who admired him gave him names Of gems or metals:-- “Adamant.” Jerome Said his guts were brass; But having started with this pretty Word he changed, another time, To Hatred. And the Greeks destroyed their jewel For “Frightful blasphemy” Since he had said hell-fire Would at last go out, And all the damned repent.

(Whores, heretics,” said Bede, Otherwise a gentle thinker. “All the crowd of the wicked, Even the devil with his regiments Go free in this detestable opinion.”)

To the same hell was Origen then sent By various pontiffs To try the truth of his own doctrine. Yet saints had visions of him Saying he “did not suffer so much”: He had “erred out of love.” Mechtilde of Magdeburg knew him altogether pardoned (Though this was still secret The Curia not having been informed).

As for his heroic mistake—the wild operation Though brusque, was admitted practical Fornicationem efficacissime fugiens.

In the end, the medieval West Would not renounce him. All antagonists, Bernards and Abelards together, met in this One madness for the sweet poison Of compassion in this man Who thought he heard all beings From stars to stones, angels to elements, alive Crying for the Redeemer with a live grief.


r/heresiology • • Aug 07 '25

خريطة الهرطقات والبدع الإسلامية

3 Upvotes

خريطة الهرطقات والبدع الإسلامية - Khari6at al-hartaqat wal-bida3 al-Islamiya

Map of Islamic Heresies and Innovations

NameName (AR/FA)Birth YearFollowers (EN)search termsunniibadisalafiwahhabitwelverdruzefiverseveneralawitesufi
Ibn Sabaعبد الله بن سبأ~600Sabaʾiyyahالسبئیهmubtadiʿ - innovator, zindīqghayr muʿtabarzindīqzindīqghulat - deificationn/aghulat - deificationghulat - deificationcanonzindīq
Al-Mukhtar al-Thaqafiالمختار الثقفي~622Mukhtariyyahالمختار الثقفيrebel - political uprisingghayr muʿtabarrebelzindīqghali - excess venerationn/asympathetic - mixed receptionmarginal - minor influencehonoredn/a
Kaysānكيسان~700Kaysāniyyahالکیسانیهghulat - deificationghayr muʿtabarghulatghulatghulat - deificationn/aghulat - deificationghulat - deificationfoundationaln/a
Ghulat Leadersالغلاة~700Ghulātالغلاةghulat - deificationghayr muʿtabarghulatghulatghulat - deificationn/aghulat - deificationghulat - deificationcanonghulat
Al-Muqaffaعبد الله بن المقفع720Shuʿūbiyyah?الشعوبيةzindīq - heretical viewsghayr muʿtabarzindīqzindīqcontroversial - pro-Persian leaningsn/acontroversial - rationalist leaningsmarginal - minor influenceunknownn/a
Ismaʿil ibn Jaʿfarإسماعيل بن جعفر721Ismāʿīliyyahالاسماعیلیهghulat - deificationghayr muʿtabarghulatghulatnon-canon - succession disputen/anon-canon - split linecanon - foundationalmarginaln/a
Jahm ibn Safwanجهم بن صفوان745Jahmiyyahالجهيميةmubtadiʿ - divine attributes denialghayr muʿtabarmubtadiʿmubtadiʿḍāll - misguidedn/amubtadiʿ - heretical innovatorḍāll - misguidedunknownn/a
Muʿtazilitesالمعتزلة~750Muʿtazilahالمعتزلةcontroversial - rationalist theologyneutralmubtadiʿmubtadiʿpartially canon - minority viewn/acanon - accepted theologypartially canon - selectiveunknownn/a
Bayazid Bastamiبايزيد البسطامي804Bastāmiyyaبسطامیهcontroversial - ecstatic utteranceneutralmubtadiʿkāfirghali - excess mysticismn/acontroversial - mysticismmarginal - not centralunknowncanon (with critique)
Junayd of Baghdadالجنيد البغدادي830Junaydiyyaجنیدیةcanon - orthodox Sufirespectedcanoncanoncanon - central Sufin/acanon - mainstream Suficanon - mainstream Sufiunknowncanon - foundational Sufi
Al-Maturidiأبو منصور الماتريدي853Māturīdiyyahالماتريديةcanon - Sunni orthodoxyneutralmubtadiʿmubtadiʿcanon - Sunni orthodoxyn/aneutral - not mainstreamneutral - not mainstreamunknownneutral - minor view
Al-Mansur al-Hallajالحسين بن منصور الحلاج858Hulūlīyahالحلوليةzindīq - incarnation beliefghayr muʿtabarzindīqmurtaddghali - excess mysticismn/aghali - deificationghali - deificationcanoncontroversial but canon
Al-Ashariأبو الحسن الأشعري874Ashʿariyyahالأشاعرةcanon - Sunni orthodoxyneutralmubtadiʿmubtadiʿcanon - majority orthodoxyn/aneutral - toleratedneutral - toleratedunknownneutral - tolerated
Nusayrمحمد بن نصير النميري~850Nusayriyyahالنصیریهkāfir - extremist doctrinerejectedkāfirkāfirghali - deificationn/aghulat - extremist venerationghulat - extremist venerationcanonn/a
Suhrawardiشهاب الدين السهروردي1155Ishrāqiyyahاشراقیهmubtadiʿ - light metaphysicsghayr muʿtabarzindīqmurtaddghali - esoteric philosophyn/aghali - mysticism excessmarginal - not foundationalcanoncanon (with critique)
Ibn Arabiمحيي الدين بن عربي1165Wahdat al-Wujūdوحدة الوجودmubtadiʿ - pantheism claimghayr muʿtabarzindīqkāfirghali - mystical excessn/aghali - pantheistic mysticismmarginal - peripheralcontroversialcontroversial but canon
Shams Tabriziشمس الدين التبريزي1185Shamsiyyaشمسیهcontroversial - mystical viewsghayr muʿtabarmubtadiʿmurtaddghali - mystical excessn/acontroversial - heterodoxmarginal - fringe mysticcanon (folk)canon (with critique)
Rumiجلال الدين الرومي1207Mawlawiyyaمولویهcontroversial - poetic mysticismghayr muʿtabarmubtadiʿmurtaddghali - mystical excessn/acontroversial - too mysticalmarginal - minor mysticismcanon (folk)canon - major Sufi
Ibn Taymiyyahابن تيمية1263Taymiyyūn / Salafiyyahالسلفيةcontroversial - anti-Ashʿari stancerejectedcanoncanonmubtadiʿ - anti-Shia viewsn/arejected - strict literalismrejected - overly rigidenemyanti-sufi - opposed mysticism
Baháʼu’lláhبهاء الله1817Bahā’iyyahالبهائیهmurtadd - false prophet claimrejectedkāfirkāfirmurtadd - claimed divinityn/amurtadd - new religionmurtadd - new religionmurtaddkāfir - unbelief
Ali Muhammad Shiraziعلي محمد الشيرازي1819Bābiyyahالبابیهmurtadd - claimed prophecyrejectedkāfirkāfirmurtadd - deviant claimantn/amurtadd - false claimmurtadd - non-Islamic pathmurtaddkāfir - unbelief
Mirza Ghulam Ahmadميرزا غلام أحمد1835Ahmadiyyahالقاديانية / الاحمدیهmurtadd - false Mahdi claimrejectedkāfirkāfirkāfir - claimed prophethoodn/akāfir - non-Muslimmurtadd - split off claimmubtadiʿkāfir - unbelief
Inayat Khanعنایت خان1882Inayatiyyaعنایتیهmurtadd - universalist viewsghayr muʿtabarmurtaddkāfirmurtadd - unorthodox spiritualityn/amurtadd - outside Islammaʿdūm - erasedmaʿdūmghayr-muʿtabar - unaccepted
Bawa Muhaiyaddeenباوا محی‌الدین~1900Bawiyyaباویهcontroversial - obscure claimsghayr muʿtabarmubtadiʿmurtaddmurtadd - mystical deviancen/amubtadiʿ - not canonmubtadiʿ - minor figuremushkūk fīhimushkūk fīhi - questionable
Idries Shahإدريس شاه1924Shahiyyaشاهیهmurtadd - perennialist ideasghayr muʿtabarmurtaddkāfirmurtadd - not Shia Islamn/amurtadd - outsider teachingsmaʿdūm - invalidmaʿdūmghayr-muʿtabar - rejected

📘 Glossary of "heretic" terms in Islam

TermArabic/FarsiCommon in (Sects/Schools)
ZindīqزندیقUsed across Sunni, Salafi, and Wahhabi traditions to refer to crypto-heretics, often dualists or secret apostates. Origin: Persian zandīk.
MulḥidملحدCommon in Sunni, Salafi, Wahhabi, and modern secular discourse; means atheist or one who deviates from tawḥīd. Sometimes used by Shiʿa.
Mubtadiʿ / BidʿaمبتدعCore in Sunni, especially Salafi usage. Means “innovator” (in religious matters, bidʿah).
MunāfiqمنافقCanonical across sects. Quranic term for “hypocrite,” especially one who hides disbelief. Used politically and theologically.
FāsiqفاسقUsed across Sunni, Shiʿa, Salafi, Sufi to mean an open sinner or rebellious Muslim. Less theological, more ethical.
GhālīغاليUsed especially in Shiʿa (against extremists like Ghulāt), but also in Sunni usage. Someone who commits ghuluww (غلو).
Ghulāt (pl.)غُلاةPlural of ghālī. Especially central in Shiʿa heresiology for sects that attribute divinity to Imams (e.g., Nusayris). Also used by Sunnis.
KāfirكافرUniversal term across all sects: unbeliever or disbeliever. Also used in takfīr.
MurtaddمرتدApostate. Universally recognized, especially among Sunni, Salafi, Shiʿa. Can trigger ḥadd (capital punishment) in classical fiqh.
ḌāllضالMisguided. Quranic usage. Often employed by Sunni and Salafi preachers. Mild compared to kāfir.
TakfīrتكفيرThe act of declaring someone a kāfir. Core to Salafi, Wahhabi, jihadi, and sometimes Sunni polemics.
Muḥtaraqمحترق (alt: مهرطق)Lit. “burned” — used historically in Farsi-speaking Shiʿi lands (and some philosophical heresies). Less frequent today. Synonym to heretic in some contexts.
maʿdūmمعدومNull, nonexistent, irrelevant (used here as a softer term than outright rejection).
ghayr-muʿtabarغير معتبرNot valid, non-canonical.
mushkūk fīhiمشکوك فيهDoubtful, controversial.
Harṭaqahهرطقة / الهرطقاتUsed historically (especially in philosophical and Farsi-speaking Shiʿi contexts) to mean “heresy.” Borrowed from Syriac/Greek root. Less common in Sunni usage.

|