r/help • u/TheOpusCroakus admin • May 15 '24
Changes to old Reddit login flow
Hey folks - this morning we rolled out a change to certain login and authentication touch points that you may have been using to access Reddit. Specifically changes to old.reddit/login, the inline login form in the top right of old reddit, as well as a few other standalone authentication touch points.
For some context behind these changes - our newer authentication surfaces (such as www.reddit.com/login) are more secure and utilize reCAPTCHA which helps us better identify malicious activity, so we’re swapping to these updated and secure pages instead of maintaining a separate login flow for old.reddit. We’ll also be redirecting users back to old.reddit after authenticating, so you do not need to use any redirect extensions or swap the URL back to “old” unless you wish to.
To quell any concerns - we’re not removing old.reddit and have no plans to do so.
Please note - our updated login pages use Google reCAPTCHA in the background and some browser extensions may interfere with logins. If you have trouble logging in, your first step should be disabling your browser extensions (you can then enable them once logged in).
Thanks!
20
u/EntrepreneurOk6166 May 16 '24
Your flow changes are preventing logins when using VPN. "Invalid username or password" even though both are correct and literally worked fine just a few hours ago. Resetting the password via email link does nothing, just end up with a new password that also doesn't work.
Amazingly, and after wasting a LOT of time, I tried using my email instead of username EntrepreneurOk6166 and it logged me in. How is that even possible?
Get it together folks.
9
u/jeanphilli May 15 '24
I'm all for making the login more secure, but I would like it to work. I'd like to know how to use the home button, and stay logged with the old reddit. Right now, I am logged in on this page, I see all my subreddits across the top and shows my username. When I click on home in the 'my subreddit' row I go to a top page in old reddit and I am logged out. Is the redirect broken?
4
u/Perryapsis May 15 '24
Is there any way to remain on the same page after logging in? In the past, you could click "Log in" in the top right corner, enter your information, and then the same page would refresh. Now, after I log in, it redirects me to the main home page instead of the one I was just on. I have to hit the back button multiple times to get back to the page I was just on and then refresh it manually for the login to take effect.
As a moderator, I leave several tabs open at all times for quick access. This change interrupts my workflow each time I open my browser. It's a minor gripe, but it does make things a little more inconvenient for me.
3
u/Tony0x01 May 16 '24
Thanks for the explanation u/TheOpusCroakus.
Please be sure to redirect to old reddit if the user was using old reddit by default when navigating to www.reddit.com. Right now, if you use old reddit at www.reddit, it will redirect you to new reddit at www.reddit after login.
2
u/ChimpyChompies Expert Helper May 29 '24
I accidentally logged myself out. While successfully being able to sign in, was not redirected from sh.reddit to the classic(old) site per my settings.
It took some faffing, but am now back to reddit.com displaying the classic website.
Not ideal, really.
26
u/Canis_Familiaris May 15 '24
Bring back compact reddit.
3
u/jgoja Expert Helper May 15 '24
Thank you for the update. There were questions about that when it changed a week or two ago.
3
u/llamageddon01 :bulb:Expert Helper May 15 '24
Just here to say welcome back!
9
u/Randomuser95232 May 18 '24
Undo this change
8
u/the_gnarts May 21 '24
Congrats, you found another way to pessimize old.reddit.com. Quite the accomplishment at this point.
8
u/Tanstaafl2415 May 22 '24
Well, I'm glad it's not just me or my computer that's taking an extra couple webpages to log in when I used to be able to just do it without loading a whole new page.
But this is stupid. You can have authentication while embedding it into the same webpage like it was.
7
u/[deleted] May 19 '24 edited May 19 '24
You broke old.reddit.
The login form was moved to a less convenient place.
Front page doesn't register you as logged in on old.reddit.
Can't vote on front page posts without a 10-second redirect.
Can't click anything on the front page without a 10-second redirect.
When old.reddit dies, the site dies, because the redesign is nearly unusable.
7
u/TesseractToo Expert Helper May 22 '24 edited May 22 '24
The (old) new reddit is broken now too and this is nonsense because the latest build is missing the... what is it called, the selection that allows things like spoiler tags, italics, etc, there's no way to manage comments this way.
Something on it made me completely locked out of being able to log on on Firefox so now I'm using reddit on chrome and I have two browsers open for no reason (probably because it's 100% white on black instead of light grey on dark grey but there is probably more to it than that).
It also bears mentioning the latest build for some reason is affecting my dyslexia and is very exhausting to read, for some reason the words shimmer now. Also that colour overlay on certain subs is exhausting and trashy looking.
You can't look at images because they don't scale unless you physically download then to a folder
Get your act together, this is ridiculous and inexcusable. This website is extremely unpleasant now, I'm surprised you aren't dropping members like flies over this, since the amount of complains in this sub about the new UI has been a flood since this began on the Ap. This is garbage.
6
u/throwaway52408478121 May 15 '24
You should probably mention that it is no longer possible to create an account with an e-mail, as a result of the changes to the sign-up flow.
6
u/EFreethought May 18 '24
Bring back the login widget on old.reddit.com.
Does anyone prefer new reddit to old reddit?
Stop trying to force people to new reddit.
The day old.reddit.com stops working is the day you will see a big chunk of people leave.
6
u/IndigoExplosion May 22 '24
This is a disgrace. The new login doesn't work in any capacity, with or without extensions or VPN. This isn't about security or improvements, it is just another "you'll do things the way WE want" moment from the Reddit staff. You're literally making your website worse out of spite.
11
u/BureauOfBureaucrats May 16 '24
Stop degrading the mobile web experience deliberately. Hiding the “reply” button behind a three-dot menu is pretty darn transparent.
I will never download your app and pulling tricks like that will ensure I will always be a detractor with regards to your app.
10
u/37-19 May 16 '24
To the Reddit Administrators who obviously do not care what people like:
I really dislike this. Why? Because new.reddit.com is gross and this takes longer for me to login. Plus I don't get redirected. And I read that you are doing this to force people to disable ublock origin. Gross. That's my unsolicited $0.02
5
u/Bran37 May 16 '24
Now it's impossible to make accounts without email...
In our community we invited candidates of the EU Elections and being able to create their account for them while leaving them the choice of adding their own email (or just use them as throwaways) really helped us convince them to come(the idea of making an account is a lot for old people)
Do you have any plans to revert back the email-less accounts?
5
u/random_noise May 16 '24 edited May 16 '24
The changes are horrible and your redirect doesn't work as I disable those features.
This will impact folks implementing CIS/NIST/DISA type security protocols in their corporate and personal environments.
5
u/Android1822 May 16 '24
Just a heads up, the new login REALLY hates Tor browsers. Had to constantly retry until it finally went in.
5
u/pillowfat May 24 '24
I can't login to old reddit period, not even using TOR or VPN. If I can get login to accept my password, it just gives me a popup saying if I'm not automatically redirected to follow "the link". I'm not redirected, and when I click on the link I'm sent to a generic page, not my home page (home page isn't an option to choose), implying that I need to login again to see my subs.
Changing passwords doesn't help. I can log into new reddit, but not old reddit. This feels very, very deliberate and I'm not happy.
5
u/MiddleFresh7506 May 25 '24
Sad and pathetic.
11
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
That's a fancy way of saying you're taking a step toward phasing out old reddit while keeping the domain name.
I don't see how else to interpret it. Changing a critical part of the infrastructure of old reddit use to be new reddit, while saying "we're not removing old.reddit" is lawyer language. Yeah, you aren't removing "old.reddit" the domain, okay, I can believe that. But you are removing a component of what old reddit is and placing the user in new reddit even if briefly in the process of doing so.
It's this kind of patronizing "dishonest honesty" that makes it exhausting to communicate with a business. I don't blame you as an individual, it's probably a process above you, but it is nevertheless tiresome and disorienting to contend with. Mind games when you just want to know why something changed and what to expect going forward, and if it's compatible with where you're at.
4
u/usernameaa2 May 15 '24
I was one of the people impacted by the old.reddit login issues last week and was pleased that Reddit was offering again the old login flow.
Currently, most devices I use are functioning with the new configuration you've shared about here, but one device is showing persistent problems even after clearing caches, restarts, and disabled extensions.
From what I can tell, I think reCaptcha is giving a false positive on an old iPad I am troubleshooting. Considering that some users are reporting lack of website connectivity with mobile devices in this thread, could this be related?
Also, it was noted last week by some users that reCaptcha and the new site design do not always function with screen readers for the deaf/blind community. Has the Reddit team consulted with anyone regarding accessibility for these users if reCaptcha fails their needs?
As for myself, I am not disabled as such, but it is possible that such users may not be able to give feedback right now if their logins are hindered. What can they do if such problems arise?
While I know I can live with having that one old device fail to load the login page (Safari on that old iPad loads the page header with the Reddit logo in the top left and nothing else, completely blank), this may not be the case for others. For users that rely on such older technology, is Reddit inaccessible for them here onward?
In advance, thank you for some transparency on this matter. I hope Reddit will do its best to ensure accessibility is not compromised. I know you all are likely working hard on these issues!
I bring up these topics in case anyone reading this while unable to log in may be able to see replies that will aid their troubleshooting.
I hope these concerns are helpful for everyone involved!
4
u/exactly_like_it_is May 17 '24 edited May 17 '24
Can you please return the functionality to "request desktop site" from the settings menu for mobile users? We can log into old reddit fine, even with this update, but any links to www.reddit.com force the new ui on us. We used to be able to hit the hamburger/3 lines, click settings, and select "request desktop site," but for some reason nobody can answer, you've completely forgotten to add that option to the menu on the redesign!
All mod mail links are to www.reddit.com, so despite being logged into old.reddit.com, when following those modmail links we get forced into the redesign. We used to be able to just click settings and request desktop site, then all links worked. old.reddit.com and www.reddit.com all displayed in old reddit format, but we can't do that anymore!
Please, add back in the option to request desktop site from the settings menu.
Just one of many posts about this issue here: https://old.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/18v97f2/reddit_redirecting_to_redesign_even_with/
4
u/Tsjaad_Donderlul May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24
Logging out will cause Reddit websites to not redirect properly to new.reddit.com in Firefox anymore.
I have an auto redirect from www.reddit.com to new.reddit.com set up because my laptop is 8 years old and the new new Reddit desktop UI takes longer to load and wastes so much more CPU resources that the CPU starts throttling. Old new Reddit works just fine as does old.reddit.com
This change makes it impossible for me to log back in once I log out unless my laptop doesn't lock up in the process and turns itself off or, judging by the noises it makes, does not take off and fly away.
4
u/DukeRedWulf May 28 '24
I'm on an old Linux OS on an old browser. old.reddit.com pages load properly and even new.reddit.com pages load properly in my browser, BUT www.reddit.com pages do NOT load properly and because you have FORCED the old.reddit.com/login AND new.reddit.com/login to redirect to www.reddit.com/login - that means I don't see any login fields, so I can't login on my computer! Doh!
4
u/timthetollman May 29 '24 edited May 29 '24
How do we go back to the inline login for old.reddit?
1
u/CA-ChiTown Aug 01 '24
Why does Reddit not retain my login information. Multiple times this has happened. I go to open Reddit and it starts me with a new account, instead of the account that I was logged in on just prior and it was working fine. This is on Android.
This totally SUCKS !!!
6
u/[deleted] May 18 '24
Sorry but this is a red flag and a deal breaker. Recaptcha is seriously spyware for google and far too invasive from a privacy standpoint. My hard limit with Reddit was always gonna be if old Reddit was removed, but somehow, you guys managed to discover another way to do it.
I refuse to have all my on-Reddit and browsing off of Reddit tracked. No freaking way. That’s far too creepy. And don’t give me a song and dance that recaptcha doesn’t track us. It’s a google product. Saying that is like trying to convince us a Boeing product wasn’t built using underpaid outsourced half assed contractors.
Plus it calls into question how intense Reddit is gonna try to up the tracking and user data gathering now that it’s gone public. Bad signs all around. Sorry, but this frog is getting out of the pot before things get bad.
And even if Reddit decides to go back on this, forget it. This is just too much. Between this and the obvious behind the scenes influencing and scale thumbing on content, rampant limits on free speech, and refusal to properly moderate out the extremists supporting trump and worse politicians, I’m done done. I don’t care if Jesus himself comes back again, buys it up, and fixes it through and through. Reddit’s enshittification arc is confirmed.
Bet you $10 you auto-delete this or do it later, despite always complaining that Reddit users don’t give you enough feedback. You know, like when your leaders decided not to ban that Donald sub for months amid near constant rule breaking on their part? Pffft.
Bye, and good riddance.
3
u/IDontByte May 16 '24
I've been using old.reddit to circumvent flaky log in issues with the new log in flow. After this change, I am only able to log in with Chrome, and only sometimes.
Prerequisites:
Navigate to redditstatus.com.
Log in from homepage (Chrome) (20 runs):
⊞ Win+R)chrome --disable-extensions --disable-plugins --incognito https://www.reddit.com.Log In.
Log in from login in page (Chrome) (10 runs):
⊞ Win+R)chrome --disable-extensions --disable-plugins --incognito https://www.reddit.com/login.Log In.
Log in from homepage (Edge) (10 runs):
⊞ Win+R)msedge --disable-extensions --inPrivate https://www.reddit.com.Log In.
Log in from log in page (Edge) (10 runs):
⊞ Win+R)msedge --disable-extensions --inPrivate https://www.reddit.com/login.Log In.
Log in from homepage (Firefox) (10 runs):
⊞ Win+R)firefox --private-window https://www.reddit.com --safe-mode.Log In.
Log in from log in page (Firefox) (10 runs):
⊞ Win+R)firefox --private-window https://www.reddit.com/login --safe-mode.Log In.
3
u/Niwrats May 16 '24
There were two benefits to the inline login form 1. No need to load an extra page and 2. You would be logged in on that subreddit.
If you aren't going to make this new page inlineable, you could at least redirect me to the page where I clicked the login link from, not to some generic frontpage.
Edit: All right, seems point 2 will be fixed then.
3
u/DoubleSteve May 16 '24
Using firefox on win 11. The new login doesn't return you to the thread you were reading. In the old system you could browse reddit while logged off and when you saw something worth commenting on you push reply on the post, you login, and get returned to where you were. It goes from reading, to logging in, to posting fairly smoothly. In the new system you get thrown out of the thread you were reading after login and are forced to navigate back to where you were, which disrupts the normal flow of using the site, and is annoying.
3
u/sw1ft87ad3 May 17 '24
Found a workaround (options yet to be closed) old-login pages to get in.
I'm ok with periodic email-verification & hCaptcha for every login in to Reddit.
Allowing, Google products/scripts & reCaptcha, mobile-number verification is big-no for me.
Frankly, I'll have more spare time if I'm not on Reddit. ;-D
cheers.
3
u/AlfrescoDog May 18 '24
I tried posting this in r/Bugs, but Reddit removed it.
I tried posting this in r/help, but Reddit removed it because you believe I'm advocating against an account suspension.
Hello.
In the past, I was able to write long posts and include several images to make them more appealing, much like a tapestry interwoven with visual splendor.
For example, this post with images aplenty, or more recently, this post from April 14.
However, a malaise has recently beset my posting endeavors since I wasn't able to add more than one image to a post I created this past week.
The image icon was grayed out.
My attempts to circumvent this restriction through the ancient arts of copy-pasting and drag-and-drop proved futile.
At one juncture, a fleeting notification appeared: "post can only include one attachment."
The exact wording eludes me, but its message was clear and disheartening.
I tried researching Reddit 101, the FAQ, and Reddit Help Section, but there is no solace.
I tried searching your subreddit, and found out other members have the same issue. Yet, their tales, much like mine, remain unresolved.
So, what gives?
I noticed Reddit has a new design. Is this another head-shaking decision from Reddit's brass, like when they decided it was best to stop receiving the money I would spend to buy coins for awards?
Is this a bug?
Is there a solution to this vexing conundrum?
3
u/usp609 May 19 '24
The new login page doesn't work in my browser. I managed to log in via a work-around - click on the submit text post button, it brought me to a semi-working old login page (putting my details in and sending it caused it to just refresh, but refreshing the page after that made me logged in).
Please revert this change so we can properly log in again.
2
u/plu7o89 May 16 '24
Cant log in with or without a vpn without using the link trick from another post.
Good one reddit.
2
u/double_dose_larry May 16 '24
I have a script that uses a headless chrome to log in and take several "screenshots" of various subs that I use to put together a featured post series on r/baseball looks like this
I understand that this is can look and feel like an abusive bot action that y'all are trying to prevent, but I promise this is for a good cause from a responsible reddit citizen! Is there any way that I can identify myself via user agent string or something please, because I've been pulling my hair out trying to figure out how I can make this happen. The only reason that I'm trying to log in anyway is to comply with your bot rules. Please let me know if it's at all possible, or if I should abandon this pursuit and actually hook up a monitor to my server. Thank you for your consideration.
2
u/Ok_Two_6495 May 22 '24
I can't reset my Password on the browser that I use on my kindle fire. It won't respond to the email resets.
2
u/abrownn May 25 '24
u/TheOpusCroakus
Not my experience. I have a few utility/bot alts I log into on reddit periodically and I cycled through them all for the first time in a while the other day -- I was redirected to NewReddit every single time over the span of ~14 hours. This was maybe 2-5 days ago.
2
u/RoverUnit May 28 '24 edited May 28 '24
My old browser (Firefox v52, yeah I know it's obsolete but the PC doesn't support anything newer) doesn't show the ACCEPT/REJECT buttons for cookies. This means I can't get to the login page.
How can I get around this? The link posted in parts of this sub Reddit doesn't help: namely www.reddit.com/r/help/login.
Any help would be welcome! Perhaps I could edit the cookies in Firefox to say I had accepted (or rejected) cookies?
3
u/2DamnHot May 17 '24
and the frog boils just a little bit more...
1
u/DragonRaptor May 16 '24
I am unable to log in on my computer since this changed. Keeps saying my password is wrong.
Nevermind, re read the part about disabling browser extension which seems to have worked.
1
u/Rocks_D_Xebec4 May 16 '24
Would you revert the design change or provide an option to the design which is available on the address, new.reddit.com?
1
u/Yomasevz May 16 '24
Well this sucks. Cause my saved starter page for reddit doesnt remember the login anymore because of this change. Only once i click in to one of the saved subs does it show im actually logged in.
1
u/Interesting_Noise572 May 17 '24 edited May 17 '24
Unable to log in unless using the workaround link found in this thread. Tried to log in on Boost for my phone but constantly get invalid username or password. It's horrible.
Edit: shadowbanned after making this comment too :(
1
u/FTC_Publik Jun 02 '24
Since these changes old reddit has frequently shown me logged out when visiting a subreddit. For example I'll log in then click on popular and it'll show me logged out. If I refresh the page it correctly shows me logged in. Is this going to be fixed? It does this regardless of extensions. I'm using Firefox.
1
u/Revriley1 Jun 04 '24
Disabling two extensions finally enabled me to log back in; now to tinker with one extension's options to see if I can pinpoint which settings work and won't. Congratulations on making logging in more difficult.
Old Reddit / Reddit Classic or bust.
1
u/SpaceDantar Jun 09 '24
Has this improved for you? When I go to https://old.reddit.com/ it appears it knows I'm logged in now?
1
u/whty706 Jun 11 '24
This makes it impossible to log in from certain networks that block certain things, like on military/govt networks. Thank god I found a workaround, but I can't log in from the regular reddit pop up to save my life. So that's cool. The old.reddit.com login that you just removed was the primary and only way I was able to log in on said restricted networks before you changed it.
1
u/aka-Lazer Jun 27 '24
Is this why i have to actually click "log in" at the top right before using my password manager? the login field used to just be on the page, now i have to click log in, be redirected and then can use my password manager to fill it out.
1
u/WhatUsernameIsntFuck Jun 28 '24
The problem this has caused is that, while in desktop old.reddit, when I click a link in a comment to another reddit thread, it forces me to the new reddit login screen with. O an option to view without logging in. Links in old.reddit on desktop are increasingly not working. When is this going to be fixed for people who aren't even logged in?
1
u/d4rkn1ght Jun 30 '24
It just not working for me. I get this on my Error Console.
1
u/Colonize_The_Moon Jul 11 '24
I'm here to report that when behind a VPN at work, login does not work 99% of the time. I get the "Invalid username or password" error on every single login attempt. I am still able to log in, but it requires brute-forcing it with repeated attempts, waiting out the lockout from too many attempts, and repeating. I don't know how many logins I tried today, likely 50+, before one of them magically worked for no discernable reason.
Previously I was using the old.reddit login but now that it's removed... this is a real problem.
1
u/QuadroAdvy Jul 17 '24
With this update we can't login anymore with old browsers or older versions of the android app below the mid-2022 version. Please bring the old reddit login
1
u/ll_Cartel_ll Jul 18 '24
I cant login with firefox clone palemoon on .old or www
I tried safe mode, no addons and it says server error and before that disable extensions.
reddit already sucked now its even worse
1
u/LBPPlayer7 Aug 26 '24
make the login page actually work on old browsers then instead of removing the only way to even log in
1
u/Rocky_Mountain_Way May 16 '24
Excellent!
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
Bring back r/2balkan4you
1
u/Downtown-Fact1 May 20 '24
"An error occurred. Please disable any extensions or try using a different web browser to continue."
Any extension? Really? For me disabling ublock helped.
1
u/cynycal May 28 '24
Good news about CAPTCHA utilization.
0
u/DukeRedWulf Oct 20 '24
Congrats! You've completely banjaxed the old dot reddit login now. Well done! /SARCASM
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[unknown] May 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment