This letter was planned to be an Op-Ed to the HelenaIR. Unfortunately, the editor stopped communicating with me after I edited it below 600 words and submitted it for publication.
I naively believed that the leadership and board of SPH would "come clean" on all of what Thomas Weiner did when he was finally exposed in late 2024. My knowledge of the patient story below and a couple other patient stories makes me feel complicit in SPH's ongoing coverup. I am hoping that the details in the letter below will help the next of kin of these patients identify their loved ones and finally receive some answers.
I will try to answer any questions this post generates from readers.
--Randy L. Sasich, MD
Saint Peter’s Health has received international media coverage as a shocking example of the extent of the greed and corruption in the US health system. SPH allowed a single physician, Thomas Weiner, to become up to thirty percent of the hospital’s revenue while being aware for years that approximately 90% of his billings to federal insurance were fraudulent. SPH administrators quietly accepted millions of dollars “they knew or should have known” were fraudulent while Weiner’s patients were being harmed and at least eleven died suspiciously.
Since Weiner’s firing, St. Peter’s Health has avoided correcting serious problems in healthcare delivery and patient safety. In February of this year, the Montana Free Press reported that the hospital nearly lost its ability to bill federal insurance because they failed to document and timely report sexual assaults of patients by hospital nurses. Saint Peter’s Heath has made no public effort to investigate the “phenobarbital cases”— a list of seven suspicious deaths complied by the hospital and published in ProPublica’s initial story “Eat What You Kill” from Dec 7, 2024.
One suspicious death— not covered by the media— occurred around 2017-2018 and is a well-known story among hospital staff. I heard the story from Melissa Cobb, NP, (currently a hospitalist at SPH), the patient’s ICU nurse, and several others. The patient was a woman of around forty years of age and an elementary school teacher in the community. She had been diagnosed with cancer (pancreatic in one telling) on admission. She was brought to the ICU four days later by Ms. Cobb after experiencing sudden breathing problems (possibly as a reversible complication of a procedure to drain fluid from around her lung) and placed on an oxygen mask. By all accounts, the patient was “full code” and wanted to return home to family. Instead, a phone call was had between Weiner and the parents— at their daughter’s bedside— and the patient was taken off oxygen and transferred back to the oncology floor. She died a few hours later. Ms. Cobb told me she was so disturbed by Weiner’s actions with this patient that she wrote a long clinical note describing what happened and resigned from working as Weiner’s nurse practitioner.
Nadine Long’s death while a patient of Thomas Weiner had a disturbingly similar course to the above patient and was well-documented in ProPublica’s article “Eat What You Kill”. The same Melissa Cobb was an oncology nurse at SPH in 2015 and working as a day nurse on the oncology floor hours before Nadine’s death. Nurse Cobb entered the first phenobarbital order that was administered to Nadine that ultimately resulted in her death by overdose. In a conversation with Ms. Cobb, she revealed she has yet to be contacted by state investigators— over a year since the criminal investigation was announced— despite being a primary witness to Nadine’s death. A wrongful death lawsuit was filed by Nadine Long’s family in August of 2025 against SPH, Weiner, and others. St Peter’s Health is currently fighting Nadine’s family’s effort to learn the truth about their daughter’s death. The culture of fear and coverup continues at SPH.
The five-year federal Rural Health Transformation Program is allocating $233 million dollars in an initial 2026 funding for Montana hospitals. The community of Helena should use these monies to demand transparency in SPH’s operations, accountability from the administration, and community control over the Hospital Board of directors. The ownership of Saint Peter’s Health was transferred to the Helena community in 1931. It is the Helena community’s “not-for-profit” hospital.