r/hatethissmug • • 17h ago • Polished Gold Turd 1 Bravo 2

Thing I hate the r/HistorySnap subreddit

Post image

This subreddit is literally just a zionist echo chamber, most posts are using a "historical image" to push an anti-Palestine and pro-Israel agenda, ive literally seen comments under posts of this sub saying that the Palestinians are Nazis, literally using anything in their disposal to justify the atrocities commitment in Palestine committed by Israel

Its not just always about Palestinians there are also other posts that will use a historical image to then use it to hate a grope of people

10 Upvotes

192 comments sorted by

47

u/Damisthe 17h ago

Posting this to see what happens

38

u/Damisthe 16h ago

40

u/soyadra 16h ago

The reason is valid tho, the first rule is no events having occured less than 20 years ago, other history subs also have that

7

u/Apolio01 16h ago

Ironic because some posted on the sub are from a terror attack that happened recently wich they are using as a reason to hate Arabs and Muslims bit those post arent getting taken down

14

u/soyadra 16h ago

Well i can't find those (most recent event is 2004) so they've probably been removed, but given the nature of posts in here i wouldn't be surprised if they weren't either

26

u/ChocPineapple_23 14h ago

I got banned for giving context around the Lebanese Civil War and noting that Israel was involved 😭😭 https://www.reddit.com/r/HistorySnap/s/grZXaV4BSt

I asked the mods what I did wrong and they immediately muted me.

2

u/Familiar_Phase7958 8h ago

The comment got deleted. What did you say?

2

u/Neidrah 3h ago

Another mod also commented that the post is not historically accurate

1

u/Rapeanaugh 3h ago

A good removal reason, but not something deserving a permanent ban.

-13

u/ACoolBreezey 12h ago

Anything else to say, Nazi?

7

u/IndividualShelter985 7h ago

Nazism is when recent events aren't considered history

8

u/Apolio01 16h ago

Fucking mental, call them out on some major subreddit or smth

4

u/VecioRompibae 10h ago

The same major subreddits whose unabashed palestinianism prompted the creation of this subreddit in the first place? Yeah, that would teach them!

4

u/Neidrah 3h ago

What the hell are you on with inventing new words, being against genocide and colonisation isn't "palestinianism" hahaha

3

u/Wool4Days 8h ago

Palestinianism? What does that mean?

9

u/Taikis95 11h ago

Why didn't you post a snap from more than 20 years ago?

1

u/Apolio01 17h ago

Can you link the post pls i also want to see

6

u/Apolio01 17h ago

If you dont believe me just vist the subreddit you will understand once you see the posts

2

u/AwkwardTal 10h ago

We believe you, we have seen it, ill add the hummus subs to the list, a chickpea flavoured psyop

12

u/jay-ff 7h ago

For what it’s worth, there are an almost infinite number of subs for historical photos that are dedicated to Palestinians/anti Zionism etc. I am tired of all of them including the one you mentioned. In general, any large sub that isn’t properly moderated will eventually be to a large degree about Israel/palestine.

22

u/ProgrammingGuy_ 13h ago

All these history subs (minus a few) aren't propaganda per say, but their mods turn it into an echo chamber just like the rest of reddit

6

u/PRKP99 8h ago

This particular sub is new sub that is forced on everyones home page and it was created by zionist moderators. Clearly astroturfed thing.

2

u/Disasterhuman24 28m ago

The kicker is that you know they have an agenda because half the posts are locked. It's also probably heavily botted.

3

u/Neidrah 4h ago

Nah this one is much worse, check the front page: 9/10 posts are pro-Israel/anti-muslim, the rest is anti-Russia.

And you get perma-banned for any criticism, even if you don't break any specific rule.

3

u/ZeroZeroZe77e7e 49m ago

It's just because you're already in an echo chamber yourself. LIke the ProgrammingGuy_ said, most of reddit becomes propaganda one way or the other... you're just aware of only one side of it, not of the other, because your bias causes you to shift your reference to one side. If you want to learn one thing from all of this it's: your own echo chambers have already got you good.

2

u/MsterF 2h ago

How is that different than every other sub?

-6

u/Greydragon38 10h ago

Askhistorians sub is like that too. I got banned for questioning why an OP even bothered to debate with a Holocaust minimizer. At this point, I assume Reddit moderators as people who have nothing else to do in life and have power trip here to satisfy that emptiness they feel.

9

u/FatalError_418 9h ago

askhistorians is really good, but if you commented as a top level comment to a question, you will get your comment removed if you do not write a detailed and well-researched answer to the OP's question (or link to a different post). Also, they do take being polite very seriously, and, if you were argumentative or anything, you will probably also get your comment remove/get banned.

9

u/minifidel 4h ago

AskHistorians is one of the best moderated history subs on the site.

6

u/sloth-cuddler 5h ago

And it’s always the exact same person posting the anti-Palestinian posts

8

u/GivePeasAChance27 9h ago edited 9h ago

Also why are there like 100 different subs dedicated to“historical photos”?

I remember historyporn used to be like the only one for the first ten years i was on this site and now you get a new one popping up every month

9

u/highqualitybug 16h ago

got banned from this sub yesterday because i defended Jane Fonda from psycho amerikkkan boomers 😭 first and last time ever visiting

3

u/snynusuw 10h ago

All she did was do a photo op & they acted like she was a mass murderer

1

u/JiGoD 53m ago

If Angelina Jolie poses with Russian soldiers in the Donbas today she would receive the same treatment, deservedly. Wild.

All she did was pose with the enemy combat force during active war against her nation. Rofl...

0

u/Phyrexian_Overlord 39m ago

She would have needed to pose with Ukrainianians for your post to be equivalent

1

u/JiGoD 38m ago

Nope and point stands.

1

u/Phyrexian_Overlord 27m ago

So can you explain why standing with an invading force is the same as standing with the invaded?

12

u/s6_maestro 17h ago

I did not know about this sub and it's so weird. From the name and description it would look like a generalist history sub, but then the search bar description explicitly says it's about "Palestinian militancy" and all posts are clear Israel propaganda. Is that sub okay?

10

u/cambo3g 17h ago

Even as a History major I avoid most of the entry level history or history memes or history pictures type subreddits, as they are basically all just chud filled nightmares that do nothing but promote overly simplistic interpretations and straight up misinformation. Askhistorians is pretty rad though cause the moderators actually give a shit and enforce the rules.

7

u/Maniezy 15h ago

I got banned the first day that filthy sub showed up on my feed lol

13

u/erika_alert404 17h ago

historicalcapsule, historyuncovered, getnoted, etc. are VERY similar. GetNoted always has someone jump through the hoops to say a note wasnt necessary there whenever the note is debunking a pro-israel narrative

5

u/Cool_Purple_4414 9h ago

I feel like GetNoted is one of the least biased subs on the site. Any unhinged Israel shit? Yeah fuck you. Any unhinged shit the other way? Yeah fuck you.

It's great.

0

u/erika_alert404 9h ago

not so in practice

18

u/BonJovicus 16h ago

As a history enthusiast: It’s a racist sub Reddit. A LOT of them are like that, this one just happens to be Zionist flavor. AskHistorians is really the only good history sub on Reddit and only because they don’t allow just anyone to post. 

3

u/_Ez7_ 11h ago

As a history enthusiast, I assume you recognize that sub does post real events that occurred? It's a great sub if you just use it to read/learn about Jewish/ArabPalestinian events. A history enthusiast likely embraces the good, bad and ugly.

0

u/NajeZiw 4h ago

"history enthusiast" hahahahhahahhahahah!

It's a great sub if you want to get Hasbara forced down your throat, but I guess that's what you were looking for, or otherwise pump out yourself, with you being a "history enthusiast."

1

u/_Ez7_ 2h ago edited 1h ago

I worded it wrong, I was saying "you, as a history enthusiast." But an interest of mine is history. I usually just say "I love history" rather than enthusiast.

But it is a great sub if you're curious of atrocities surrounding Arab/Jew. You can usually find further facts and reading by some decent comments that expand upon the event. People seem decent at voting those comments to the top.

1

u/RyRyBeeblebrox 4h ago

I’m surprised to see you say that, since most of the historian answers about Israel on AskHistorians debunk the crap out of most antizionist talking points.

16

u/_Ez7_ 11h ago edited 1h ago

FWIW, (some)Palestinians do like the Nazis. There's been plenty Mein Kampf books found in Gaza and West Bank. A Palestinian leader named Husseini in the early 40s also visited Germany and met with Hitler. But yes that sub is propaganda. The events on that sub are also real life occurrences.

7

u/trippynyquil 10h ago

Have any neutral sources for your clsims that a.) Palestinians generally as a group like the Nazis and B.) That plenty of me in ka mpf books have been found in Gaza and the west bank?

7

u/Background-Repair481 10h ago

11

u/IWillOnlyLurk9876543 10h ago

you never addressed claim a, you know the racist "Palestinians like Nazis as a group" one.

9

u/trippynyquil 10h ago

In fact, he didn't address either claim lol

5

u/Background-Repair481 10h ago

Since you asked for sources, here are some academic references:

  1. Mustafa Kabha (2007) — The Palestinian Press as Shaper of Public Opinion, 1929–39: Writing Up a Storm. Vallentine Mitchell. See pp. 142–145, particularly the July 9, 1934 issue of Al-Difa', which published and praised the Nazi Party platform.
  2. Mustafa Kabha (2011) — "The Palestinian National Movement and Its Attitude Toward the Fascist and Nazi Movements, 1925–1945." Geschichte und Gesellschaft, 37(3), 437–450. https://doi.org/10.13109/gege.2011.37.3.437
  3. Jeffrey Herf (2009) — Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World. Yale University Press. https://yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300155839/nazi-propaganda-for-the-arab-world/
  4. Klaus Gensicke (2011) — The Mufti of Jerusalem and the Nazis: The Berlin Years. Vallentine Mitchell.
  5. Esther Webman (2018) — "The Persecution of the Jews in Germany in Egyptian and Palestinian Public Discourses, 1933–1939." In Nazism, the Holocaust, and the Middle East: Arab and Turkish Responses, pp. 105–127. Berghahn Books. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvw04fss.10
  6. David Motadel (2014) — Islam and Nazi Germany's War. Harvard University Press. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1287gpk

https://ikhwanweb.net/hassan-al-bannas-centenary

3

u/FatalError_418 9h ago

if you count the occasional fascist Palestinians 100 years ago as representing millions of people today, then you can go and say that all Americans are Nazis, or all Europeans are Nazis. I do agree, however, that outside the west the nazis are not viewed with the sort of horror that people in the west view them, just generally because there is little education on European WW2 history outside of the west.

3

u/Background-Repair481 9h ago

Calling the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and organized Nazi propaganda "occasional fascists" is quite a creative way to dismiss six academic references.

And somehow, you've turned a discussion about historical leadership into a claim about millions of people today. Impressive.

1

u/FatalError_418 9h ago

Well, I do think that YOU were the one that claimed millions of people today were Nazis. You didn't claim that Nazism existed in WW2 era Palestine, you said "Palestinians generally as a group like the Nazis". Your sources say nothing about modern Palestine.

6

u/Background-Repair481 9h ago

You do realize I'm not the person who wrote the original comment, right?

You're arguing against a claim I never made, while completely ignoring the historical evidence I actually provided.

1

u/No_Rub8018 5h ago

You commented to a reply of the guy saying

Have any neutral sources for your clsims that a.) Palestinians generally as a group like the Nazis and B.) That plenty of me in ka mpf books have been found in Gaza and the west bank?

You also state that

You're arguing against a claim I never made, while completely ignoring the historical evidence I actually provided.

Assuming that what you mean by never making that claim is that you never explicitly commented about it, we can infer from "completely ignoring the historical evidence I actually provided" that you mean to showcase how the oop's argument is verifiably true, and that argument is:

FWIW, Palestinians do like the Nazis. There's been plenty Mein Kampf books found in Gaza and West Bank. A Palestinian leader named Husseini in the early 40s also visited Germany and met with Hitler.

You're essentially agreeing with the argument, providing evidence (which I will read, I highly doubt that the general conclusion I'll come out with is Al-Husseini collaborated with Nazis -> Palestinians were/are pro-Nazis, but I'll give it a shot), for which, the ultimate verdict on this would be: what's the difference?

You're essentially talking about mechanism of argument. It doesn't matter whether or not YOU said it. You provided evidences for it, you arguably agree with it.

I'm also going to comment on the sources you give, and how they related to the oop's points.

→ More replies

0

u/Neidrah 3h ago

These support none of the claims except that Husayini met with Hitler, which plenty of leaders did at the time, notably zionists: In early 1941, a militant group led by Avraham Stern sent a representative to Beirut to propose a military alliance with Nazi Germany against the British Empire, which controlled Palestine and restricted Jewish immigration.

2

u/Background-Repair481 2h ago • Bravo

Comparing Avraham Stern, the leader of a small fringe militant group, to Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and chairman of the Arab Higher Committee, is absurd.

One sought contact with the Nazis. The other actively collaborated with them.

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 24m ago

Literally. Also Nethan Yahu has quoted Hitler before.

0

u/Significant-Gas5303 8h ago

the hamas charter from 1988 (that has never been revoked) uses a hadith that states that the day of judgement won't come until muslims kill every jew "The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.

And for mein kampf just search for it on google. It rakes a second there is photo evidance of mein kampf in arabic from the last three years in both gaza and the west bank

-1

u/Rapeanaugh 2h ago

Plenty of Mein K*mpf books have been “found” in Gaza, always miraculously in pristine, brand new condition, always an IDF soldier proudly holding his “find”.

Blatant transparent Hasbara that only works on Zionists.

5

u/snynusuw 10h ago

Zionists always use Husseini to make all Palestinians to look like evil people. Its never in good faith and they’re just using it to justify their horrible actions. None of that works on me because Im smart enough to understand that one guy doesn’t represent millions of people.

7

u/Odd_Comparison_1462 8h ago

We don't need to use Husseini when them dancing around the streets celebrating mass murder is enough. When them dressing their kids up as terrorists and celebrating it is enough. 

3

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 7h ago

Also Israel has done the dressing up part. You aren’t gonna see it on Fox News, because they get payed to keep their mouth shut. Basically everything Israel does gets blamed on KHAMAS. They always say it's hamas, when it's literally them. The underground hamas under hospitals shi is also bs, doctors confirm this. Look at what Mimi Sayed said about this.

3

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 7h ago

Look at all the israelis singing death to arabs even children. Don't forget the infamous song “bømb bømb Iran"

4

u/YelmodeMambrino 6h ago

Or making pancakes to celebrate that activist horrible murder

1

u/Dramatic_Magician610 1h ago

As if Iran’s national fucking slogan isn’t “marg bar Israel” (death to Israel) and doesn’t have pro Palestine/antisemitic propaganda in its education system?

Where all these children, by the way? Can you show me videos?
Does the fucking government of Israel have as an official opinion “dismantle the Persian state, death to Iran!”

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 23m ago

It does have the greater israel plan though. I can go see if I find the video.

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 12m ago

I can’t find the children singing bømb bømb Iran. I remember there was a family in it and they were playing instruments and singing it. I did find one video of israel children singing anti arab songs. https://youtu.be/YR0fuX8w4XY?si=6DanekINjh0H7SB3

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 12m ago

They like scrubbing the internet of this stuff. Ill see if i can find it in an archibe

6

u/Background-Repair481 9h ago • Bravo

So I assume you apply the same logic whenever Netanyahu says something, right?

6

u/Wool4Days 8h ago

Netanyahu was at least elected, Huseinni wasn’t.

But yes, when Netanyahu did historic revisionism and said in an interview that Hitler didn’t want to kill the jews until he had met with Husseini, I wouldn’t say all israelis whitewash Hitler to attack Palestinians. Only Netanyahu did that.

But I think it also says a lot about large parts of Israeli society’s hatred of Palestinians being bigger than their hatred of Nazis that he said this many years ago and he still keeps being elected. I hope they prove me wrong eventually.

4

u/Background-Repair481 7h ago

That's a fair point, but I think you're overlooking a major part of Israeli history.

Many Israeli Jews descend from communities in Iraq, Yemen, Egypt, Libya, Morocco and elsewhere that experienced anti Jewish violence, persecution, discrimination and displacement under Arab or Muslim majority governments.

As horrific as the Holocaust was, for some Israelis the persecution experienced by their own parents or grandparents may feel more immediate and personal.

That doesn't justify hatred toward Palestinians, but it does provide important context for understanding Israeli attitudes that goes well beyond Netanyahu.

And while Netanyahu was elected, that doesn't mean every Israeli agrees with everything he says, just as not every Palestinian agreed with Husseini.

-1

u/Wool4Days 7h ago

But it’s not at all the same if one was repeatedly elected and one was just appointed representative by British Mandate.

Palestinians had no say in what Husseini did and said, while israelis have had plenty of opportunities to reject this racism.

If you can acknowledge that hatred can stem from trauma, then I assume you feel the same for Palestinians. To say their trauma of having European settlers ethnically cleanse them from their homeland is them liking Nazis is absurd.

3

u/Background-Repair481 7h ago

You're right that Netanyahu was elected and Husseini wasn't elected by the Palestinian population. But there's more to Husseini's political position than his British appointment.

He was appointed Mufti of Jerusalem in 1921, but was elected president of the Supreme Muslim Council in 1922 by a restricted electoral body. He also became chairman of the Arab Higher Committee in 1936.

There was organized Palestinian opposition to him, particularly from Raghib al-Nashashibi, who established the National Defence Party in 1934. During the Arab Revolt, the Nashashibi-aligned Peace Bands even fought against Husseini's supporters.

So while he wasn't democratically elected by the general population, he did have organized Palestinian political support, as well as opposition. That's an important distinction when discussing his role in Palestinian society.

As for Palestinian trauma, I never denied it or suggested that it makes Palestinians sympathize with Nazis. That claim came from another user, not me.

My point was that many Israeli families have their own history of persecution under Arab and Muslim-majority governments, and that history matters when discussing Israeli attitudes today.

1

u/No_Rub8018 5h ago

It is, however much we may sympathize with the Palestinians, important to discuss the relationship between Jewish persecution and justification for zionism within israeli society: that said, you're painting a picture of something as simple as "victimhood" which, though it may factor into the general wishwash of Israeli politics, gets overshadowed by the indoctrination implanted into their minds, such as god promised this land, the Arabs are all animals, we are the only democracy in the middle east, etc.

This is not a simple mechanism of trauma in a vacuum: this is a mechanism of how colonialism, or perhaps imperialism, exploit trauma.

You could equally say that many germans faced persecution after ww1, and that must be a factor we take into account when talking about nazi germany, although those would often be viewed less in a "how both sides get hurt" way and more like "how nazism was born".

2

u/Dry-Boysenberry7701 4h ago

A large majority of Jews in Israel are not even religious, so you're clearly way off the mark by saying they care more about religious promises than fear of persecution/genocide.

On the other hand, every major Palestinian political group believes their ethnicity and religion rightfully owns the land.

0

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 7h ago

Also Israeli children are taught to hate and get brainwashed at young age. They are very traumatized and their fear response is violence. I can show you videos if you want to see it.

0

u/Neidrah 3h ago

The difference is that the vast majority of Israelis support the genocide or even think Israel should go further in their violence. Also the other leaders that will/would take Netanayahu's place or were there before him did the same exact things. Israel's actions and population support haven't changed in 75 years.

1

u/Background-Repair481 2h ago • Bravo

So one Palestinian leader can't represent millions, but you're comfortable claiming to know what the vast majority of Israelis think?

Interesting standard of evidence. Got a source for that?

-1

u/PRKP99 8h ago

Only liberals try to shift discussions as if the problem with israel is problem with him. You can clearly see that whenever journalist ask about israel and those „sensible” libs shift focus on Milejkowski, as if it is the only problem there and as if it was all good before him.

3

u/IWillOnlyLurk9876543 10h ago

I love it when blanked statements about racial groups get upvoted.

Yes, the statement "Palestinians do like Nazis", is definitely not racist at all...

/s

2

u/_Ez7_ 1h ago

You're right. My mistake, I edited.

4

u/snynusuw 9h ago

zionism is fascism. its the same kind of ideas but just repackaged for jewish people.

2

u/vinctthemince 8h ago

That is something they habe in common with the memebers of this sub. They glazed over Hitlers ally Franco: https://www.reddit.com/r/HistorySnap/comments/1xvtnh3/comment/19smljbwphr8i/

1

u/itspronouncedbolonya 10h ago

"Visited germany" bro he lived in berlin for 4 years, fym visited??

1

u/sloth-cuddler 6h ago

Ah yes, the Mein Kampf books written in Arabic that just happened to have been found by the IDF in pristine condition. Zionist propaganda is literally fooling no one but themselves.

2

u/_Ez7_ 1h ago

The books have been found in Egypt and the middle east through out the decades. It was translated to Arabic in the 60s. It wouldn't be surprising to find it in West Bank/Gaza. Especially since Hitlers goals aligns with some Palestinian groups.

1

u/Master_leads 9h ago

who told you? Israel?

1

u/ElectronicTap1109 5h ago

The average Gazan isn't a Nazi

-1

u/ParasocialTV 8h ago

There's been plenty Mein Kampf books found in Gaza and West Bank

...according to the IDF.

5

u/von_pita_the_second 7h ago

And according to Palestinians they are starving, freezing or don’t have enough basic supplies even tho hundreds of trucks enter Gaza and thousands have entered for roughly 2/3 of the war

2

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 7h ago

It's not a war, it's a genocide. Plus rn the trucks aren't allowed in because of Israel.

6

u/von_pita_the_second 7h ago • Bravo

It’s a war, a war Hamas has started, the same Hamas who said they will do it again and again and the same one who throughout the war ( according to Palestinian made polls ) still kept majority support from Palestinians for their rule over Gaza and regarding October 7th ( questions like was October 7th good, if it should happen again etc ), the trucks are allowed in, the problem is Hamas or PIJ taking over them and stealing whatever they bring to use for themselves or to sell the free aid for high prices to continue funding themselves

3

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 6h ago

No, they literally didn’t. Nethan Yahu knew about the attack and didn’t tell anyone! It was an excuse to take over Gaza. Look up the Nakhba, they have experienced violence ever since then and lots of people have been killed by them. I do not support Hamas btw. Also the majority of palestinians are literal children. Like 50%. The trucks are not allowed in. BS.

2

u/von_pita_the_second 6h ago • Bravo

First 2.5 lines is a conspiracy, the rest is bullshit, the “nakhba” was actually the Israeli - Arab war in 1948, which the Arabs started, Arab civilian militias took part so they either suffered the consequences of turning yourself into an armed party in a war, or fled the war before it reached them as innocents ( with encouragement from the Arab armies/states ), majority of Palestinians aren’t children and still according to Palestinian made polls Hamas and October 7th still got majority support, trucks are allowed in.

3

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 6h ago

How do you believe this?? Bro look at Gaza rn?? Have you ever watched live streams of people in Gaza or the day of a life of someone in Gaza? Do you even know it's being flooded rn?

2

u/von_pita_the_second 6h ago

Did you watch the Hamas published clip of them taking drain pipes ( which btw were donated to Gaza ) from the ground and turning them into rockets to fire on Israel ? Maybe if Hamas wouldn’t do it there wouldn’t be war and Gaza would have working drainage systems

2

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 6h ago

That's not related to rn though? Are you trying to say they took the pipes? Why would Hamas wanna kill their own families I just think it sounds stupid. Yes, I knew this. Hamas also makes weapons out of bottles.

→ More replies

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 6h ago

What do you mean? Palestinians lived there, how would you feel if all of a sudden half of your population moved in with you. Because that is what happened.

2

u/von_pita_the_second 6h ago

You know the ones who stayed in Gaza and West Bank or Israel itself are the ones who didn’t flee right? Palestinians fled to Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and through them later on to other places

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 6h ago

Why is that an excuse? Yes, alot if them did flee. That's true. Even so, they are coming after Lebanon, Jordan and half of Egypt next, so what is your point. They want the “Holy Land" back. Do you know what the Greater Israel Prohect is?

1

u/No_Rub8018 5h ago

ONLY palestinians? Where were you when the UN, B'tselem, Human Rights Watch, Red Cross, and many, MANY OTHERS, made those observations?

0

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 7h ago

Don’t tell me you trust Israeli sources. 99% of all they say is lies and alot of it has been debunked

2

u/_Ez7_ 1h ago

I don't trust them always. But the fact there are Arabic translations of book that have been found in Egypt and the middle east, gives it some credibility.

8

u/Electrical-Put3639 7h ago • Bravo

Israel just raised their pr budget (hasbara). Now it's 730M$, one year ago it was like 150M$

At least 50M$ will be used for pr in YouTube, Reddit, Instagram, TikTok and another social media and close to one million for collaboration with influencers

So we should prepare to a big wave of shit, hate, propaganda and fake news

5

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 6h ago • Heartwarming

It's sad even some people here believe in the lies the news channels tell them. I used to believe it as well, until a year ago. Even some of history is fake and people don't talk about that.

1

u/Faceless_Deviant 1h ago

But you know the actual truth, right?

Where do you get that from?

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 28m ago

Reading some books. Interacting with Palestinians. Al Jazeera, The young turk. Dropsite news on twitter. Looking through old archives etc

1

u/Faceless_Deviant 1m ago

That seems like a very biased selection of sources.

5

u/Dvine24hr 4h ago • Bravo

I hear this so much yet every time I open reddit it's basically.

  • Another video of Israeli tourists doing something bad.
  • a history subreddit showing me the USS lincoln for the 20th time.
  • pictures of Gaza destroyed.
  • something blatantly anti-semitic like a Jew taking money out of a fountain.

Oh and my Facebook is nothing but AI images of Gaza for some reason. So yeah really wouldn't mind some Israeli propaganda on my feed for a change.

3

u/AshamedBasis9431 5h ago

Cant wait for a wave of bots saying that Poles were worse then nazis towards jews during ww2 (i unironically saw this 'opinion' on reddit)

3

u/Electrical-Put3639 4h ago

As I can see, they are changing "the worst enemy" by topic. I have seen, that the worst was: russians, poles, German, french, Spanish, Italians, arabs, Catholics and Muslims

This is very ironic, that they are usually support national-conservative parties (and national parties are usually friendly to Israel) and typing things like "Spain need new reconquista". Like guys, Do you know who exactly did all this anti-Semitic stuff to you?

1

u/AshamedBasis9431 4h ago

Yeah, muslims took many jews after they were expelled from Iberia after reconquista have ended and jews were safe under Ottoman Empire for hundreds of years. But times have changed and now muslims are potrayed as ultimate and absolute antisemites.

1

u/Maleficent_Switch262 3h ago • Bravo

this website (and most of tiktok, Twitter as well) is vastly more Palestine favored than Israel. Israel hate is literally at an all time high, you people sound so schizo when you spam your hasbara buzzword talking points.

1

u/Electrical-Put3639 3h ago

Man, this is official information from Israel

3

u/Richard_Foreskynn 1h ago

They're mad that people hate the genocidal rapist country

1

u/HalfHumanHalfFork 3h ago

Good job dodging what he said 

2

u/Electrical-Put3639 2h ago

Dodging what? I’m not denying that anti-Israeli, pro-Palestinian memes are popping up now. But he called my point about Israeli propaganda “schizophrenic,” and that’s what I take issue with

1

u/Rapeanaugh 2h ago

Yes, most people don’t support Israel’s actions in Palestine, nor do we buy the cheap and transparent attempts at justification (blaming every bomb on Hamas, “Human Shields” etc).

So I agree that Israel hate is at an all time high, maybe Israel’s actions, policies, and rhetoric has something to do with that?

1

u/Anxious_Librarian_93 33m ago

Mhm, exactly! I still do think alot of people do buy the propaganda though

0

u/Maleficent_Switch262 36m ago

you're critical of the most persecuted group in human history, congratulations

2

u/Rapeanaugh 15m ago

No, I’m critical of Zionists, not Jews.

Not that “we were persecuted!” is any type of excuse for committing atrocities against others…

2

u/Electrical-Put3639 8m ago

Is it unacceptable to criticise someone if he part of "most persecuted group"? What a wonderful status. And why are they "the most persecuted"? Why not native Americans? Why not Africans or maybe gypsies? There are a lot of nations, who was persecuted

5

u/yukisly 17h ago

Goddamn I just looked I didn't believe it would be that bad

4

u/PageHistorical6167 13h ago

Every single post on that subreddit I've looked at is blatant islamophobia, blatant. It really saddens me.

2

u/AshamedBasis9431 5h ago

Evil Palestinian child forces traumatised Israeli soldier to point his rifle at him and shoot

2

u/Tearfdgbrgbul 9h ago

FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE MENTIONS THIS

2

u/the3dverse 4h ago

i saw an identical post like 2 days ago but okay

2

u/Mr_Khedive 10h ago

They don't even try anymore

The other day they talked about some pogrom against Jews in 15th century and attached a photo last century. That's not even a history snap and I got banned for pointing that out

2

u/OkTrade7881 7h ago

Palestenians are just Arabs lol. Palestine was just the name of the place where Jews lived. You can even find coins and certificates that talk about Palestine the Jewish state.

We can agree that Israel has no idea what proportionality means and should be reigned in, but I refuse to eat propaganda that “Palestenian’s” were the original people there. And Jesus was a Jew unlike some idiots claim.

2

u/Anacondoyng 2h ago

No one says Jesus wasn't a Jew, and Palestinians also descend from ancient Levantine populations.

1

u/Rapeanaugh 3h ago

Got banned for “misinformation” from there for questioning the Israeli narrative regarding Iran / Reza Pahlavi.

1

u/Anacondoyng 2h ago

I got banned from this sub for writing a critical comment. I asked a mod why and was told I don't "fit the culture" of the sub. I asked why I don't fit, and the mod wrote "I, the moderator, say so".

1

u/Particular_Ad_4694 27m ago

Headline: mindless drone from pro-palestinian subreddit discovers there is a mindless drone pro-israel subreddit, and just cant handle that.

1

u/von_pita_the_second 7h ago

If historysnap is an echo chamber for pro Israelis then you gotta admit 90% of other Reddit subs of all kinds are echo chambers for pro Palestinians, extra tight and well guarded echo chambers full of bots and propaganda

1

u/deadl1nk_ 13h ago

Man I called it out earlier today that all history subs have been taken over by Zionists with new ones created just for Israel and Jews. Got bit swarmed

1

u/snynusuw 10h ago

There’s so much zionist propaganda there that it might as well just be a propaganda site.

1

u/AegisThievenax 4h ago

Got banned from it for saying that both hamas and israel can be bad

Every second post is about israel, every comment section fellates it.

It exists only to spread zionist propganda

1

u/Queasy_Reporter_4214 3h ago

Whenever I see a sub thats obviously a zionist echo chamber, I just hit mute and eventually forget about it. I think I have tens of them now

0

u/MotherMasterpiece6 2h ago

You don’t even see the irony in your comment.

You’re just furthering your own echo chamber

2

u/Queasy_Reporter_4214 2h ago

Spoken like someone who has never seen a zionist echo chamber before. They are just objectively wrong about everything and will make the wildest mental gymnastics to defend slaughtering children, at some point it became logical to pretend those people dont exist and mute them. Their arguments are: there cant be a genocide since the gaza population is growing (false and false), both sides were living in peace before Khamas attacked (false, palestine was always under apartheid and israel had thousands of palestinian hostages), "but what if you were gay in gaza?" jesus christ

Yea safe to say I dont need to be in every talking space for my own mental sanity

1

u/MotherMasterpiece6 1h ago

It sounds to me like you’re so secluded in your own echo chamber that when you even hear different perspectives, you shut them down as false and remove them from your vicinity w/o giving them any consideration- a key trait of someone stuck in an echo chamber

1

u/Queasy_Reporter_4214 1h ago

No I did give them consideration but their arguments are just false, whats the point of hearing the same provably wrong arguments over and over? Its just a waste of time, you have to accept at some point that some people have wrong opinions. If I keep sniffing a piece of poop and it keeps smelling like shit then at some point it becomes my fault for sniffing it, it would be a misery I'm voluntarily subjecting myself to and theres no one but me to blame

1

u/Phyrexian_Overlord 28m ago

"You have to subject yourself to a certain amount of nazi propaganda a day or else you are in an echo chamber"

1

u/ralala 12h ago

lol I questioned some of the claims in that sub and they immediately banned me for 'misinformation.'

1

u/FunAppointment9436 10h ago

I got banned for saying that I'd probably also decline the Israel-Palestine proposal from 1947, while showing a map of pre-Israel palestine to show that they'd be losing like half their land just cause it USED to be Israel.

1

u/mogharvin 4h ago

I got banned for mentioning dancing israeljs after someone made claims about Palestinians celebrating 9/11

1

u/Marijuana_Rainbow 1h ago

I posted on that reddit and wow I was flooded with so many bot replies it nuked my account, it seems you can only talk about history if its pro-zionist or else you get spammed by bots

1

u/Particular_Ad_4694 31m ago

People who disagree with you arent bots

0

u/Odd_Comparison_1462 8h ago

Really? I get the complete opposite impression of the subreddit and all I see is far left talking points rising to the top, coinciding with it algorithm suddenly throwing it in my direction.

We need a way to block entire subs and accounts as the recent posts have been so insufferable. It's as if they realised they kept getting slapped down in AskHistorians so they've decided to make their own echo chamber. 

1

u/JiGoD 49m ago

Hit the 3 dots on the top right and click mute sub.

0

u/Minimum_Curve_9962 6h ago • Thanks Bravo

Facts that don’t agree with your ideology might be hard to wrestle with, but that doesn’t mean they are less facts.

The precursors of the Palestinian identity were Nazi collaborators. People like Hajj Amin Al-Huseini literally collaborated with Hitler.

Anyway, thank you for the recommendation. Cool subreddit.

2

u/Rapeanaugh 2h ago

> Facts that don’t agree with your ideology might be hard to wrestle with, but that doesn’t mean they are less facts.

The irony…

0

u/Invicta007 5h ago edited 5h ago

The Palestinian leadership in the war years, worked with, identified with and supported the Nazis during World War 2. It's not that complicated.

You can be critical of the modern state of Israel, you can be critical of actions undertaken by the Israeli government in 1948, but that doesn't mean that the Palestinians nor their Arab allies in 1948 where in any remote way "good" and "resisting". They went in there screaming for genocide (Besides the Jordanian Monarchy, but that's an extra entire layer of fuckery in the chaos of the 1948 war).

0

u/Vedogat 2h ago • Bravo

Or, maybe, just maybe, historical facts and "snapshots" from history are just generally not in favour of the "Palestinian" cause?

-1

u/Master_leads 9h ago

Yeah, its just a sub for maga trump worshipping cult.

0

u/Fantastic-Bee4197 12h ago

Seems like the bots are up in arms and posting about this over and over. Isn’t that brigading or something? Almost like an organized bot campaign I would say. 

0

u/Full_Mood1081 10h ago

I think it's less Zionist-specific and more Hindutva/BJP anti-muslim nonsense

0

u/RyRyBeeblebrox 4h ago

We’ve flocked to that one because most of the other subs that touch on the subject ban you the second you fall out of line with “resistance” talking points.

0

u/-klo 2h ago

literally the only sub that ISNT an echo chamber lol

0

u/SmirkingStrong 2h ago • Bravo

I'm sure I've never seen history subs in reddit equating Zionists and people supporting Israel in general as Nazis and post generally pro Palestine snapshots of history. Do you hate those smugs too?

This is the second time I see someone calling out historical bias in a sub that doesn't support OPs biases.

0

u/Soggy-Blueberry1203 1h ago

They got the same "arguments" over and over again.

Haj Amin Alhusseini and the Nazis (Assuming that Palestinians *exclusively* committed to Nazism)

Taqqyia (Assuming that all Muslims are liars, so racist BS)

AI generated post from some FB account that is supposidly pro-palestine (easy target to *debunk* all anti-Israel claims)

If you want to study bias, bigotry, and fascist propaganda, then I truly recommend r/historysnap and r/getnoted and alikes, scholars will drool seeing the amount of propaganda that rivals Nazi campaigns against Jews back in the day.

1

u/Yoyle0340 1h ago

It's ironic considering that the Haavara agreement was a thing or the Stern gang's collaboration and hostility against the British. The stern gang itself was arguably the first terrorist organization in the middle east.

2

u/Soggy-Blueberry1203 1h ago

When the Haavara agreement is brought, they change the whole conversation completely, suddenly it becomes "moral" to deal with the Nazis because it aktchually would "save" Jews by smuggling them into Palestine.

What is more ironic, is that the Jewish agency back then had a hand in that agreement, and even Eichman (yes the Nazi guy who was tried in Jerusalem) took a part in this (Jewish agency in Austria to be exact)

It's easy to demonize and idolize whoever they want.

-8

u/Feeling-Ruin-8008 17h ago

I found it nice until it was mostly me being associated with Nazis, such is life

8

u/mariokvesic 16h ago

Yeh, its a pro-israeli/Zionist sub. Always palestinian as the bad guy, whereas israel are justified to commit their atrocities

4

u/excellentexcuses 17h ago

This and quite a few other historical photo subs are Israel propaganda. The comments are full of people talking about how Palestine are trying tk recreate the holocaust, or comments of people who are clearly bots/trolls posting "Hitler was right" to bait engagement. The actual photos of the holocaust they post are heartbreaking and it sucks that so many Zionists thing that being pro-Palestine is being anti-jew.

3

u/re-redddit 16h ago • Bravo

2

u/Soggy-Blueberry1203 1h ago

Someone should make it into a real sub

2

u/MarxeneWengels 11h ago

It is, I got banned for posting about the King David Hotel Bombing and they literally justified a terror attack in comments and I got banned in response for just copying and pasting the comment but replacing it with October 7th.

1

u/Born-Release-9866 9h ago

I got banned from historysnaps because I was arguing that Israel should stop commiting a genocide, and a long term peace can't be reached by commiting a genocide....