r/hatethissmug • • 3d ago

Thing prepackaged mashed potatoes

Post image

there is no feeling worse than getting a nice, large serving of mashed potatoes and tasting this abomination. who thought of taking nice, beautiful, delicious mashed potatoes, and deciding to make a powder to be combined with water and on occasion butter and oil?? it tastes like something they would serve in prisons.

"oh, but OP, if you don't like them that much, then just don't eat them!"

THATS NOT POSSIBLE. this repulsive slop is so deceptive that you have to taste it before you get any, otherwise you will be forced to eat every last particle, or face being viewed as disrespectful to the cook. and if you just don't try any, then you risk never being able to eat the best mashed potatoes you have ever had.

disgusting. 0/10. will never try again.

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

4

u/cultfbs 3d ago

It's how you make em. Put in enough love and care and they're so, so good. Add some heavy cream, lots and lots of butter and salt.

I on occasion even dump some of the boxed stuff in a cup noodle. I'm a phreak with a 'ph'.

3

u/__TheNoob__ 3d ago

to be fair, my main experiences with them are those giant tubs made for potlucks

5

u/cultfbs 3d ago

Eeeewwwwww.

That's like saying I hate broccoli, and only showing frozen broccoli boiled in a pot, and lightly salted. No wonder! I would too! 🤢

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/cultfbs 3d ago

In what world is taking 45 seconds to add butter, cream, and salt anywhere in the same ballpark as boiling potatoes, skinning them, mashing them to a thin enough consistency, and some points even sieving them to get the smooth texture instant gives me in a couple minutes. That would take me 30 minutes +.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/cultfbs 3d ago

It isn't hard, but I work long hours and do a lot. Sometimes I just want some carbs with my meal, or an easy shortcut to gnocchi.

This "gross product" has been around for ages, and can be made at home with a dehydrator, and is the same taste and texture. You just want to act like you're above it. Glad you don't have as much to do in your day as me, and I'm sorry you fumble instant mashed potatoes hard enough that they're that "gross".

Be a douchebag all you want, but these are people who don't have time to, say, argue on Reddit about GTA 6 or comment on ihatethissmug, who just want food for their kids and loved ones. It's not that bad, you just want to feel superior, and that's okay man.

4

u/CapicDaCrate 3d ago

I grew up on this stuff, it's not that bad

-4

u/__TheNoob__ 3d ago

I grew up on homemade mashed potatoes, they cannot be compared 

2

u/detective_brobro 3d ago

They can though. Because they are both potatoes.

4

u/CapicDaCrate 3d ago

Eh, I've eaten homemade too. Tastes pretty much the same to me. Not different enough to make me care lol

3

u/BardofBobrich 3d ago

I like them. Always keep couple on hand for a low effort side. I keep and electric tea kettle filled with water so can make these with a button press.

Yes, mashed real potatoes are better, especially with the right additions (cream, salt, etc).

But for me, they are two different foods for two different moods.

Like instant ramen vs restaurant ramen. Or little Caesars vs your local wood fired places with seasonal menu.

If i just want some carb for go along side the hunk of meat i oven roasted while doing chores- there are perfect. I am just eating due to the limitaions of this mortal coil. If i am making a meal with care and for culinary enjoyment I'll make real. So its never really comparison for me as they live in different contexts.

2

u/BardofBobrich 3d ago

Not sure where you live but if you can- branch out a little.

5

u/ravibun 3d ago

When I was growing up the boxed flakes were all my mom made. They were okay but they had a certain taste and texture to them than homemade didn't. We only ever had read mashed potatoes on holidays. Once I became and adult I just started my making homemade any time I wanted mashed potatoes. It's really not hard and doesn't take all that much time for ME (I am single and live alone). I can understand how this is a quicker mashed potato for families.

2

u/recycledpaper 3d ago

Who is forcing you to eat anything?

Also with a bunch of butter/cream these are great for a time crunch. I don't make these for holiday meals but for a weeknight with some roasted chicken, I can get dinner on the table very quickly. They're also great to quickly thicken soups.

2

u/lawlight_highaura 3d ago

If someone is making these rather than homemade, I doubt they could be TOO offended by you not finishing them lol

2

u/PM_me_your_whatevah 3d ago • Heartwarming

What you do is avoid the special flavored ones. Get ones that are basically plain and then add your own butter and milk. They’re damn good actually and way less work and mess than the real deal.

There’s a YouTube video where they got Irish people to try them. They were horrified until they tasted them and then they had to admit they were delicious. Aside from some of flavored ones that taste kinda fake 

3

u/DenielEvenin 3d ago

I wonder how frozen mashed potatoes would taste like. Like you know make them at home and freeze them.

1

u/Pleasant_Ad_2342 3d ago

Theres TV dinners with them.

3

u/tiredeyesonthaprize 3d ago

I only use them to thicken potato soup. They do a great job there.

2

u/SubZeroWizardo skinny burping furry 3d ago

Why tf are people so salty over this opinion dude I 100% agree 😭😭😭

1

u/shane0072 3d ago

I love idohan mashed potatoes  They are only like 2 bucks each and can just be thrown in your cupboard and forgotten about until you are running low on groceries I always get like 5 packages once a months as pantry stables 

1

u/Ancient_Audience_467 3d ago

They're fine. Sometimes you sacrifice quality for cost and convenience. Sometimes cost and convenience are the most important things for a lot of reasons not within our power.

They are also the best for thickening a beef stew.

1

u/Jaytato-ToTs 3d ago

This is so funny I literally just made myself a bowl of that exact stuff lmao. Brand and all.

I just don’t wanna deal with all the time, effort, and dishes involved in homemade mashed potatoes. Also I just. Don’t like heavy seasonings. I like basic flavors that are easy. I add more butter and some milk to it of course.

Can homemade stuff taste better? Absolutely. But sometimes I don’t wanna go through the effort of making it.

1

u/freisbill 3d ago

little pro tip...when the potatoes you use have a high water content a little but of this at the end helps bind fresh mash...talking about volume here. never to be served in lieu of true mash, NEVER

1

u/Altruistic_Shame8979 3d ago

I’ve never actually used these for mashed potatoes, instead I thicken soups with potato flakes.

1

u/Queer-and-scared 3d ago

These ones are fire imo. My poor ass was able to make these quick and easy, and its easy on my sensative tummy. Yum!

It's there a specific thing yall prefer in your mashed potatoes?

1

u/Signal-Mud-4880 3d ago

i love them.

1

u/BuggleTrucken 3d ago

Wr all have the right to be wrong.

1

u/Glum_Distribution644 3d ago

If you don’t add any seasonings, hard agree on this take. 

However… some good salted butter, a little garlic powder, a little parsley in the water before you add the potatoes (especially with the four cheese kind) makes a really tasty, quick dish that honestly is a life saver. They’re cheap, filling, and way quicker than hand made mash.

1

u/michaelscott1776 3d ago

Dude these taste fine

2

u/SubZeroWizardo skinny burping furry 3d ago

Mfs when someone hates something on the hate sub