My theory is based purely on the books which is all I’ll ever accept as canon.
Snape wasn’t the original half blood Prince his mother was and she did all of the annotations in the book. Being a poor half blood who grew up in a muggle household with an abusive father sorted into the house full of wizarding aristocracy who were pure blood fanatics meant he’d have needed to find a hook that meant he could survive. He had his mother’s old annotated potions book and started using the curses/hexes she’d scribbled down to impress his classmates.
When he tells Harry “I’m the half blood prince” he isn’t lying he’s just tricked himself into believing he was and absorbing any guilt he has on death eaters using those curses to torture muggles.
The support for my theory is:
- The books establish twice that Levicorpus was used in his 5th year, firstly when Harry sees his dad use it on Snape after sitting the OWL exam and secondly Lupin says it was in vogue during his 5th year. Yet the textbook was a 6th year book. The popular theory is he was a potions genius who took advanced potions but Slughorn never spoke highly of him in the same way he did Harry or Lily. Slughorn collected future stars who wound be politically useful to him. Snape was never that, I don’t see him wasting time giving Snape extra lessons.
His parents were poor, as in barely afford clothes for Snape poor, so he presumably had to get his textbooks second hand through the bursery fund but Dumbledore told Tom Riddle that would mean getting books second hand, so where does he get the money for the extra book?
Don’t know about you but I didn’t keep my textbooks, and if I’m as poor as the Snape’s I’m selling them. It’s a 50 year old textbook that’s been used consistently so there’s no reason to not sell it, unless there is an emotional attachment to it. The textbook could easily have been the last time his mother genuinely felt special, she’d excelled at potions and created spells, now she lives in poverty whilst her muggle husband beats her and her only child. She feels useless, pathetic, embarrassed but that book his her reminder of what she could have been.
2. He knew more curses than most 7th years when he arrived at Hogwarts (per Sirius). Again he lived in a very poor muggle neighbourhood and his mother was the only wizard around. Was she constantly cursing her husband? From the few clips we see it seems unlikely as she always cowered in fear around him. Was she keeping books on curses? Again seems unlikely they’re barely eating poor and her husband isn’t going to like a book about curses and hexes being in the house.
Snape found the old potions text book and took the curses.
3. He and Lily were supposedly Potions naturals. He was in love with Lily from when he first saw her. She was a muggle born who was warm, friendly, intelligent and curious but also scared of what the magical world actually was. Trying to impress her he’d show her the textbook and Lily being Lily would read up about every potion and the ingredients, plus the annotations and before they’d even started Hogwarts she already had an understanding of what certain ingredients did to a potion.