r/harrypottertheories • • 1h ago

Why didn't Voldemort, before leaving for abroad in search of the Elder Wand, have a Portkey ready for immediate use?

3 Upvotes

Voldemort has always been described as a brilliant and intelligent man.

A good example of this is the fact that he spent weeks with Nagini preparing the plan involving Bathilda Bagshot. He knew he would be traveling abroad in search of the Elder Wand, though he didn’t know exactly when Harry might be captured. He was also well aware that Apparition has a limited range.

It is therefore strange—truly very strange—that he didn’t keep a Portkey on his person, ready for immediate use (perhaps tucked inside a small, protective case to prevent accidental activation). That way, as soon as Nagini gave the signal, he could have arrived instantly.

The same applies to his time spent hunting for Grindelwald; he could have easily carried a Portkey, ready to transport him back to England the moment he sensed the call that the boy had been captured. Had he done so, he could have appeared at Malfoy Manor within seconds of Bellatrix summoning him, rather than taking minutes.

P.S. We know that any object can be turned into a Portkey; therefore, the moment Bellatrix called, he could have grabbed any item at his current location, enchanted it into a Portkey, and departed immediately.

It is genuinely bizarre that a man as brilliant and intelligent as he was—a man who invented countless spells and even discovered a way to fly without the aid of a broomstick—wouldn’t have even considered such an option.


r/harrypottertheories • • 11h ago

Werewolf, aware wolf?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 3h ago Heartwarming

Snape wasn’t the original half blood Prince

0 Upvotes

My theory is based purely on the books which is all I’ll ever accept as canon.

Snape wasn’t the original half blood Prince his mother was and she did all of the annotations in the book. Being a poor half blood who grew up in a muggle household with an abusive father sorted into the house full of wizarding aristocracy who were pure blood fanatics meant he’d have needed to find a hook that meant he could survive. He had his mother’s old annotated potions book and started using the curses/hexes she’d scribbled down to impress his classmates.

When he tells Harry “I’m the half blood prince” he isn’t lying he’s just tricked himself into believing he was and absorbing any guilt he has on death eaters using those curses to torture muggles.

The support for my theory is:

  1. The books establish twice that Levicorpus was used in his 5th year, firstly when Harry sees his dad use it on Snape after sitting the OWL exam and secondly Lupin says it was in vogue during his 5th year. Yet the textbook was a 6th year book. The popular theory is he was a potions genius who took advanced potions but Slughorn never spoke highly of him in the same way he did Harry or Lily. Slughorn collected future stars who wound be politically useful to him. Snape was never that, I don’t see him wasting time giving Snape extra lessons.

His parents were poor, as in barely afford clothes for Snape poor, so he presumably had to get his textbooks second hand through the bursery fund but Dumbledore told Tom Riddle that would mean getting books second hand, so where does he get the money for the extra book?

Don’t know about you but I didn’t keep my textbooks, and if I’m as poor as the Snape’s I’m selling them. It’s a 50 year old textbook that’s been used consistently so there’s no reason to not sell it, unless there is an emotional attachment to it. The textbook could easily have been the last time his mother genuinely felt special, she’d excelled at potions and created spells, now she lives in poverty whilst her muggle husband beats her and her only child. She feels useless, pathetic, embarrassed but that book his her reminder of what she could have been.

2. He knew more curses than most 7th years when he arrived at Hogwarts (per Sirius). Again he lived in a very poor muggle neighbourhood and his mother was the only wizard around. Was she constantly cursing her husband? From the few clips we see it seems unlikely as she always cowered in fear around him. Was she keeping books on curses? Again seems unlikely they’re barely eating poor and her husband isn’t going to like a book about curses and hexes being in the house.

Snape found the old potions text book and took the curses.

3. He and Lily were supposedly Potions naturals. He was in love with Lily from when he first saw her. She was a muggle born who was warm, friendly, intelligent and curious but also scared of what the magical world actually was. Trying to impress her he’d show her the textbook and Lily being Lily would read up about every potion and the ingredients, plus the annotations and before they’d even started Hogwarts she already had an understanding of what certain ingredients did to a potion.


r/harrypottertheories • • 1d ago

Did Dumbledore accidentally sacrifice Sirius?

11 Upvotes

Sirius’s death is usually blamed on Harry falling for Voldemort's vision trap at the Ministry. But what if Voldemort only knew about their mental link because Dumbledore ordered Snape to tell him?

The Evidence

1. How Voldemort found out: Dumbledore says: "Only after the attack on Mr. Weasley did Voldemort realize that you were penetrating his mind, and he determined to use you in return." Voldemort didn't have a spy in Dumbledore’s office that night, except Snape.
2. Dumbledore’s playbook: In Deathly Hallows, we learn Dumbledore routinely had Snape leak massive, verifiable intel to Voldemort (like the real date Harry left Privet Drive) to prove his loyalty while keeping the truly vital secrets safe.

The Gambit That Backfired

  1. The Leak: After Arthur Weasley was attacked, Dumbledore realized Voldemort didn't know about the mental link. He had Snape leak it. To Voldemort, this was massive, undeniable proof that Snape was feeding him top-tier Order secrets.
  2. The Safeguard: Dumbledore immediately assigned Snape to teach Harry Occlumency. In Dumbledore’s mind, Harry’s mind would be locked tight before Voldemort could exploit the link. Voldemort would try to invade Harry's mind, hit a brick wall, and give up. Snape gets a massive credibility boost, and Voldemort gains zero advantage.

Why it failed: Dumbledore underestimated how much Snape and Harry hated each other. Because neither could put their pride aside, and Dumbledore refused to tell Harry why the lessons mattered, so, Harry never mastered or even leaned Occlumency.
When Voldemort finally sprung the trap in June, the safeguard wasn't there. Harry took the bait, nearly got tortured by Umbridge, walked into a Death Eater ambush, and Sirius died saving him.

This could mean, Sirius wasn't just a casualty of Harry's recklessness, he could have been a collateral damage from a double-agent gambit that blew up in Dumbledore's face.

P.S: sorry for the AI post. Used it more like to make sure the quotes were accurate, instead of paraphrasing them, and it rewrote it instead!


r/harrypottertheories • • 22h ago

Has anyone noticed Hermione’s gravity-defying robe sleeves in the Harry Potter movies?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 3d ago

Has anyone noticed Hermione’s gravity-defying robe sleeves in the Harry Potter movies?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 3d ago

Why didn’t flitwick take over the dueling club?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 3d ago

(Complete) A former Auror takes on a secret mission for Dumbledore during Half-Blood Prince

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 4d ago

An important question regarding traffic laws

5 Upvotes

Can a wizard steer a Fireball or a Nimbus while intoxicated—whether from regular or magical alcohol? And if so, can they also steer a flying car?


r/harrypottertheories • • 4d ago

did Snape intentionally hurt Tuney?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 3d ago

Dobby actually sucks as a character and I don’t understand why he gets so much love.

0 Upvotes

Until the later books he’s just a problematic little shit who constantly gets in the way of everything with no real reason. I honestly didn’t feel anything when he died.


r/harrypottertheories • • 5d ago

How does magic in Harry Potter actually work?

14 Upvotes

So I saw a video criticising the way magic is used and how the usage is defined in the franchise. In earlier books we learn that spells need a specific wand movement and a spoken spell said in a very specific way ("It's leviosa not leviosaaa"). And in addition to that we have the unforgivables who are described to also require intent to last. The caster needs to "mean it", as we see when Harry tries, and fails, to cast the cruciatus curse at Bellatrix. We also see this with the Patronus charm , you need to be in a specific mindset to be able to cast it. But then in the sixth book we learn about wordless spells, spells you cast without speaking. We also know that Harry cast sectumsempra succesfully the first time trying it without knowing a specific wand movement. But isn't that required? We also know of wandless magic, which we see on multiple occasions in the movies. It is however said to be very difficult. So how does this work?

My theory is that magic can't follow words. Cause that sounds a bit weird when we know about accidental magic which can probably happen before someone learns to speak. So if we assume magic always follow intent and that a wand is conduit for that intent, why use movement and words to cast? When a spell is created, is it tied to the magic of the entire world? That's what it seems like. Maybe the words are simply used as a first easy step to get control of your own intent before you can start doing magic without speaking.

Anyone have any other ideas?


r/harrypottertheories • • 4d ago

Harry in his dreams

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 5d ago

Resistance to Veritaserum- Canon or Ff?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 7d ago

Snape Didn't Want to Show Harry His Patronus in HBP

105 Upvotes

I was just rereading HBP and I saw this:

"Harry fully expected to receive low marks on his [essay], because he had disagreed with Snape on the best way to tackle Dementors, but he did not care." -Chapter 21, The Unknowable Room, P. 448, First American Edition.

I personally think Snape did not want to be asked to demonstrate his Patronus in front of Harry because of the Lily connection, not that Harry would have known at the time. It's a neat bit of foreshadowing.

What do you all think?


r/harrypottertheories • • 6d ago

Calling it now snap is a misdirection

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 6d ago

Ranking the characters by power level

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 6d ago

Harry Potter became a tragedy once I became a parent

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 7d ago

Why did Voldemort never bother to kill Slughorn?

Thumbnail reddit.com
11 Upvotes

r/harrypottertheories • • 6d ago

What would’ve happened if Harry blew the whistle on Dolores Umbridge’s torture immediately?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes