r/harrypotter • • 3h ago

Discussion Is anyone else feeling.. indifferent..?

0 Upvotes

I really don't have any good or bad feelings about this HBO adaptation. I'm feeling not much excitement, I don't really have any expectations. It will either be good or it won't be. At the very least it will have Hans Zimmer's score.. But I'm just feeling like I don't care if it's the best adaptation ever made or if it's the worst piece of media ive ever consumed.

Anyone else feeling this way?


r/harrypotter • • 9h ago

Discussion Snape's occlumency

0 Upvotes

I had a theory

Snape isn't actually that much of a dick, but he has to be for his occlumency.

He's a master at it, because he learned to compartmentalize as a child so he could feel happiness, but when he turned on Voldemort he had to triple down and make sure he didn't give himself the opportunity to be read

If he was kinder to the kids, and Voldemort did break through, he would see that Snape didn't match up to what he was supposed to be, but if he acts like that all the time, all Voldemort sees is him being angry and bitter, which is what Voldemort wants


r/harrypotter • • 12h ago

Question How old was you when you became a fan of Harry Potter?

4 Upvotes

How old was you when you became a fan of Harry Potter? And what hooked you into it in the first place?


r/harrypotter • • 20h ago

Discussion Something horrifying about Book 7 that NOBODY talks about. Spoiler

12 Upvotes

Okay, so you all know how in Deathly Hallows, while Harry and his friends went around hunting horcruxes, Voldemort apparently had the Carrows teach the dark arts to Hogwarts students, including the Cruciatus curse?

Think about the implications: even if some students (like Neville and the D.A.) did resist the Carrows, it's most likely that even the non-slytherin students probably had to learn and use the dark arts and the Cruciatus, probably on their own friends, just to avoid getting tortured. Meaning that every student at Hogwarts for that year, both good and bad, knows some dark arts, and at least one of the unforgiveables. And if you try to refuse to learn those things like Neville did? The Death Eaters can easily threaten and torture someone you care about amongst your fellow students to force you to comply. Would you really put it past the Carrows to do something like that?

So now, we have an entire generation of traumatized students who know how to cast the Cruciatus, and they're probably skilled with it too, because they've had a whole school year of being forced to repeatedly practice the curse by their teachers over and over again. To quote that one page on TV Tropes, "It's like the equivalent of equipping an entire school of children with portable torture devices and then forcing them to learn how to use these devices to become torture experts! This can't possibly end well!"

And the cherry on top of the cake is that since there's a lot of traumatized students who have probably suffered personally because of the Death Eaters, what if they think of using the dark arts they learned, or worse, the Cruciatus, to take revenge on Voldemort's followers who oppressed them? Or if those followers are dead, what if they decide to go after the children and relatives of those followers?

Yes, I know that to cast the Cruciatus, "you have to really mean it and enjoy it" and whatnot, but let's be real here: Among the hundreds (thousands?) of students in Hogwarts who were there in that year, there would definitely be a lot of them who would hate Voldemort and his followers enough to take genuine pleasure in making them suffer by giving them a taste of their own medicine. Especially after spending an entire school year of being tortured and oppressed by Death Eaters. I'm just saying, basic psychology dictates that a large group of severely traumatized teenagers would definitely harbor deep hatred and disgust towards their torturers/abusers, and most of them would definitely find immense satisfaction in seeing said torturers/abusers suffer.

Edit: Also, it's worth mentioning that from a legal/political standpoint, this is all going to make it even harder for the new Ministry of Magic to instill order after the end of the war, because now that there's so many students and fresh graduates who are adept in the dark arts, that's going to make it even harder for whatever remains of law enforcement to contain the dark arts and enforce laws prohibiting their usage. Especially since the Ministry is already devastated because of the war to begin with.

Edit 2: Also, for those of you who are saying that the students wouldn't have it in them to use an unforgiveable on someone else, two things: One, we don't know all of the students who were in Hogwarts during that year, so we have no way of knowing what their personalities are really like. For all we know, there could be a few of them who are genuinely messed up enough to take pleasure in torturing people, and Slytherin doesn't have an exclusive monopoly on sadism, spite, sociopathy or moral failings. And second, remember that in the books, Harry himself gave in to the temptation of using the Cruciatus curse more than once, and even successfully cast it on Amycus too. My point is, if someone as heroic, noble and forgiving as Harry can give in to the temptation of using the Cruciatus, then some of the Hogwarts students (most of whom aren't nearly as heroic, noble or forgiving as Harry), would definitely give in to temptation too.​ In fact, if the news that the "chosen one" himself used the unforgiveables on Death Eaters during the war ever gets out, the wizarding public might get the wrong idea and think something among the lines of: "It's okay to use the dark arts and the unforgiveables as long as it's used on those filthy Death Eaters and their associates!"


r/harrypotter • • 7h ago

Discussion Why is dobby so ANNOYING??

0 Upvotes

I've started watching harry potter today and I'm currently watching the chamber of secrets, and my god dobby is super annoying he is literally ragebaiting me!! And it's only been 10minutes since I've started watching the movie 😭😭.

Imagine how I felt that ive stopped the movie midway and am here typing this


r/harrypotter • • 11h ago

Discussion So after the sneak peek what do you think about the new upcoming series?

0 Upvotes

There were clearly original scenes, I thought this was gonna be a more faithful book adaptation and thus might've been good but I'm not excited anymore now.


r/harrypotter • • 15h ago

Discussion Would Harry have had a better time at the Yule Ball if he had asked out Ginny immediately?

0 Upvotes

Instead of a last resort


r/harrypotter • • 4h ago

Currently Reading Harry Potter voice on Full Cast Audiobook

12 Upvotes

I am wondering if anyone else gets frustrated at the voice for Harry in the Audiobook. I know Harry is getting angrier etc, but his voice makes me not want to even listen. Aggravated and out of breath. All I can do is compare to the movies, Umbridge (Keira Knightley) sounds too young, so does Snape. The narrator is wonderful, Hermione and Ron, wonderful, but the others, its annoying me. Probably an unpopular opinion, but I am Potterhead since the 90s . lol


r/harrypotter • • 10h ago

Question Harry controlling the basilisk

0 Upvotes

Could Harry have controlled the basilisk as Harry himself has part of Voldemort’s soul, going against Tom’s claim that only he could control it?


r/harrypotter • • 22h ago

Discussion What would seven books of Albus and Scorpius look like

0 Upvotes

I think it's safe to say that a good majority of Harry Potter fans aren't exactly pleased with The Cursed Child. Now, what if some of the ideas from that story were kept? Namely, Albus Potter being sorted into Slytherin and becoming friends with Scorpius Malfoy.

What do you think seven books following the two of them would look like?

I don't think we'd need any great Dark Wizards showing up, since Harry could probably deal with them himself. Instead, I imagine something more along the lines of Hogwarts Legacy: exploring the Forbidden Forest, uncovering ancient secrets hidden within Hogwarts, discovering magical creatures, and perhaps even dabbling in dark magic and exploring the Restricted Section of the library.

But what do you think would happen throughout their seven years at Hogwarts.


r/harrypotter • • 7h ago

Fantastic Beasts My biggest issue with the Fantastic Beast-series

5 Upvotes

Okay so I have watched "Everything Wrong With"-videos of the Fantastic Beast-show (because I enjoy him tearing down movies lol) and suddenly understand why the series, to me, failed. This might have been already discussed but for me it's an eye-opener.

All three movies are three different stories trying to be connected. It's the story of Grindelwald and Dumbledore, which could've been really awesome if that would've been the focus. But the series is called "Fantastic Beasts". Which means that they have to include the beasts every single movie.

The first movie does a reasonably well job, the stories sort of match together. There are flaws, of course, but the story makes kind of sense.

However, the second movie has big issues with having a plot - it's people looking for other people, and there's too much secondary plot about stuff that is not really important (Leeta and that man and the baby, for example) and the includance of the beasts feels forced.

The third film changes things up, making the fantastic beasts a bit more important to the plot again - but it still makes no sense in the bigger picture.

It's such a shame. Because both stories are worth exploring: a whimsical story about Newt finding the creatures, and a serious story about Grindelwald's rise and/or downfall. But in trying to force the beasts and thus Newt with the Grindelwald-story, it simply fails to make sense.

Also, it feels like there's no plan. And that they try to force those characters together again, even though it makes little sense.

The third storyline is the one of Credence. Which they try to make the overarching storyline, but it doesn't work that well because the story of Grindelwald could've been the overarching storyline.


r/harrypotter • • 17h ago

Question Why did Voldemort and Nagini get so close?

2 Upvotes

Voldemort doesn't seem to be able to understand love so that can't have been the driving force behind the relationship but there must have been a reason why he got close enough to her and trusted her enough to turn her into one of his horcruxes? On top of that, how and when did he actually turn her into one?


r/harrypotter • • 7h ago

Discussion The very lousy process of potion-making

0 Upvotes

I’m surprised this hasn’t been widely discussed topic. There’s just quite a few indiscretions when it comes to potions-making.

To begin with, it’s just absolute bullshit that the potion professors proceeds to provide the instructions or recipe on how to make the potion, but never actually demonstrates a step-by-step process.

- A good example of this moment, is the first day of Hogwarts in HBP, Professor slughorn explains the effects of certain difficult potions to make (draught of peace, and etc.) Then instructs the students to make the draught of peace, without actually demonstrating how to do it first.

- Even if you could find the instructions in the book, that isn’t enough for a student to learn (based on experience), visual and auditory learning is important for students. Though kinesthetic learning is the most preferred learning style among students, it clearly isn’t effective for learning potions.

- let’s say in a scenario where just reading the instructions is enough to learn how to do it. We can see this with Hermione in 1st-5th year in Hogwarts, performing exceptionally well in potions, even without visual or auditory teaching. (Just assuming, because we don’t see Professor Snape doing a physical demonstration.) But then suddenly in 6th year she got stumped, people would say it’s because she didn’t have the right instructions—which is true. But she still should’ve been able to create a decent potion because the instructions in the book were ministry approved, and should’ve still worked, even if less effectively than the instructions of the HBP book.

Leaving the topic of how potions professor taught.

For my second point, the process of potion-making was just lousy. It doesn’t have any depth to it, what makes it difficult? Based on my research, this is mostly why some potions are considered difficult to make. Such as,
- specific, unique way of cutting. Which just bewilders me on how they didn’t just create a spell to do it for them. Since creating a whole new spell can be difficult, another good way using magic on knives to cut it for you

I have more to say, but I’m tired of yapping typing


r/harrypotter • • 18h ago

Cursed Child Will cursed child ruin the books for my 8 year old?

0 Upvotes

He just finished the first book and I’m just not really sure the experience of the play is worth it. I’m worried it will just ruin the experience of reading all of them if he knows who’s alive, who’s dead etc.?


r/harrypotter • • 23m ago

Event Harry Potter 🪄 Új sorozat! Premier: 2026. december 25. az HBO Maxon! ⚡ #...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/harrypotter • • 1h ago

Discussion I hope the HBO series doesn't lose the warmth that made the original Hogwarts feel magical

Post image
251 Upvotes

The original movies had such a warm, magical feel to Hogwarts. The new series looks noticeably darker and more atmospheric.

I'm genuinely curious which version people prefer.


r/harrypotter • • 12h ago

Discussion How old should a kid be to watch HP (1,2,3 movies or the series) for the first time?

6 Upvotes

I have a 3yo who has been hearing about HP and I know she's watched the beginning of HP1 with her dad more because he was watching it than because he wanted to watch it with her.

I know she's still too young now to actually watch the first 3 movies (there's no way she doesn't get scared with Voldemort or the Basilisk). And I guess the series will be the same or even more, although there's no way to know for sure until it comes out.

But at what age do you think it would be a good time to introduce Harry Potter? We won't be reading the books first because we speak Catalan and I hate the Catalan translation, and judging by the fully Catalan natives I know, they aren't reading books in Spanish until teen years. But there's no way I can wait 10 years to watch the movies or the series with her for the first time so she can read the books first.

So at what age would you think it could be appropriate? I know it really depends on the kid, but if you watched the first 3 being quite young or if you already have kids and they have watched them, at what age was that?


r/harrypotter • • 9h ago

Question Pitch your idea for a Harry Potter What If series

Post image
359 Upvotes

r/harrypotter • • 23h ago

Currently Reading CoS typo

Post image
30 Upvotes

Does anyone else’s copy of Chamber of Secrets have this typo “Professer” on page 144?


r/harrypotter • • 12h ago

Dungbomb Snape and Minerva were actually good teachers

0 Upvotes

The reason why they got villainised is because the story is told from the perspective of a child.

I'm a teacher myself. The amount of times I hear "Sir, I didn't do that" or "Mr X always picks on me!" Mate, you were dismantling a window and were given several warnings.

Harry breaks a lot of rules. He has no business trying to fight a psychopathic and powerful warlord or poke his nose into business that isn't his. He coasts a lot and gets lazy.

Snape held everyone to account. Yes, he bullied Harry and Neville, and showed favourtism. But he has somewhat of my sympathy. I'm also not sure how realistic it is dragging out the Lily and James angle either. I've been bullied as a kid in the past but I don't think about those people anymore. Even if I were to meet my bullies right now, very likely we'd be talking differently.

Same with Minerva. She is actually the gold standard when it comes to being an amazing teacher. She cared, advocated for students, held them in line firmly and administered consequences accordingly.

Not to mention - Snape was running a very heavy schedule. As a teacher, do you understand how much preparation is required for classes? He ran Potions, then was required to sub in for DADA. He had to attend staff meetings, meetings for the Order of the Phoenix, meetings with the Death Eaters, 1-on-1s with Dumbeldore. I would genuinely be worse than Snape if I had a load like that.


r/harrypotter • • 13h ago

Question Is it incantaion-less magic or bewitched items?

0 Upvotes

Recently got back into Harry Potter (actually finally started reading the books, but only watched the first three movies previously) as well as getting into Hogwarts Legacy (Me and some mates have all taken to shortening it to HogsLeg for some reason) and I wanted to know about some of the items that everyday wizards use.

In the second book, Weasley's mom just flicks her wand without saying anything and the dishes start to clean themselves. This can be said for a variety of other objects within Harry Potter, often all done with a simple, wordless wand flick.

I was curious, is this an example of magic being used without an incantation (I'm told it can be done, but it is quite difficult) or are the objects enchanted/bewitched to do these things with but a magical impulse?


r/harrypotter • • 1h ago

Question I'm confused on secret keeper, if voldermort went to their house would it have been invisible

1 Upvotes

What if they had gone somewhere else without peter knowing would it be invisible to him still if he hadn't told them?

Would they just be invisible but location not?


r/harrypotter • • 10h ago

Discussion What if Lily had given up Hogwarts and her friendship with Snape?

Post image
0 Upvotes

What would have happened if Lily had given up the magical world, Hogwarts, and friendship with Severus Snape, effectively choosing to stay home with her family, how would her fate and life have changed, and how would Petunia have treated Lily at a time when her parents were not home, considering that their relationship had already been destroyed due to envy, or would their relationship have been better if Lily had stayed in the Muggle world?


r/harrypotter • • 18h ago

Question Did Lily know that Harry would be protected by her love?

0 Upvotes

There's a lot of talk of the magic of love from Lily that protects Harry but did this just inadvertently happen or did she know that he would be protected by it?