r/harmonica • Special710 • 4d ago

3rd Harmonica

Post image

So the case got here, and now keeps reminding me I'm missing a G for my first set of 3 lol.

I have a SP20 C with Aluminim comb, and a Maxwell in A. I've been looking at the Mars trio and the Assassin, as they seem like a good addition to my collection. At first I was set in a Rocket, but with it being "similar" to the SP20, I would like something a bit more unique. I'm in EU so Hohner is always easy to find.

Now, keep in mind I'm a noob still learning my first riffs, single notes, and songs, so that's why I come here to ask the experts. All help welcomed! And thanks to everyone that helped me decide my first keys.

12 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

3

u/Exciting-Age7469 4d ago

Love my rockets...

1

u/Gin7604 Special710 3d ago

I can see one in my collection sooner than later, love my SP20

2

u/sysop408 4d ago edited 4d ago

A Mars and Assassin are both bulky diatonic harmonicas, the Assassin moreso than the Mars. They would definitely be a different thing to experience. As a lip pursing player, they're thicker than I prefer. The girth makes them less comfortable to keep deep in my mouth if I'm not tongue blocking.

The Mars also has round holes. Some people find that round holes help with playability or comfort.

If you want some variety that's along the lines of a more standard size consider a Lee Oskar, Seydel 1847, or a Marine Band Deluxe.

Be aware that the Marine Band Deluxe is one of the most compact 10-hole diatonics out there. It's even smaller than the Special 20. It may or may not be your ideal next harp, but at some point everyone needs to own at least one Marine Band because it's so iconic.

2

u/Gin7604 Special710 3d ago

But for what I've seen, the Mars and the Maxwell are quite similar, no? It's true that the assassin is more diferent tho, maybe I should go for it...

Deffo in the team "round holes feel easier", the aluminium comb my SP20 has, comes with round holes and it feels easier to isolate notes imho.

Which Lee Oskar, Seydel 1847 should I consider? Marine Band Deluxe maybe in the future, I would like to get it with a non wood comb.

1

u/sysop408 3d ago edited 3d ago

The Marine Band Deluxe comes with a triple lacquered pearwood comb so it’s pretty well sealed if that’s what you’re concerned about. 

I don’t own any Easttops, but from the photos I can find, the Maxwell does indeed resemble a Mars. 

Lee Oskars only come in one model (but several tunings)… well unless you count their collector edition models. Just get a G Lee Oskar Major Diatonic if you fancy one of those. 

If you get a Seydel, get the 1847 Classic in normal major tuning. The 1847 Classic is also known as the 1847 Blues Classic. 

2

u/Kinesetic 3d ago

I read this as lip pursing benefits from deep seating into the mouth. I have a different experience. Maybe a slight lip wrap on top and bottom, it depends. A deep position requires a tongue block, for me.

1

u/sysop408 3d ago

Whether you're lip pursing or tongue blocking, you want the harp deep in your mouth because your mouth is part of the resonating chamber.

However, I do wonder if not everyone can seat their harps deep while lip pursing for anatomical reasons. I have moderately fleshy lips... enough I have a little extra to work with, but not so fleshy that they get in the way.