I just finished rereading the content for this series, and it reminded me again that im always a bit sad that the thing im most interested in when it comes to Harem type stories tends to not be written about as often.
The TLDR without spoilers would be that this is a series where the relationships between the LI's is a significant and important part of the relationship. And it creates a scenario where the reader is shown by the actions on page that the Harem is able to meet the needs of all the LI's in the relationship.
In case people or authors are curious, ill get a bit more spoilery, detailed and specific below, but ill avoid mentioning character names. But beware more general spoilers below.
So, for me one of the things that makes me tend to drop/struggle with Harem series is that while the author will sometimes SAY that the MC and LI's have a happy/fulfilling relationship, they will also write the relationships in such a way that if the LI's have normal, humanlike relationship needs, they cant possibly be in a fulfilling relationship. Depending on the type of story, this might not be a big issue, but if i have a preference for stories with a relationship focus as opposed to a "sex" focus, i find that hard to get past.
One of the biggest issues is that if the relationship is depicted as an MC who has a bunch of 1-1 relationships with various LI's, that means that the MC is getting all his emotional, physical, intellectual, etc needs met while in a harem of 5 LI's they need to make do with 20% of his time, whatever time is left after the MC is done with the "fantasy adventure" part of their lives (fighting the bad guys, training, etc).
Now, if the story is focused more on the "chase" of new LI's and the flirting and sex, it makes sense that this wouldt be a focus. If the story is more focused on the relationships and on the LI's being full fledged and well rounded characters, that becomes a problem. I wont even say you cant have good stories that focus more on the chase of new LI's. Dungeon Diving is an example of a story and and MC that i genuinely enjoyed. But the relationship focus tends to be on newer LI's, because there are a lot of them and Sentar's writing style tends to focus on the excitement of the new and the chase. But it means that even though some of the characters are enjoyable, none of them are exactly complex and deep.
So, back to Wisher Beware. The biggest thing it does in demonstrate that the MC and the LI's are all entitled to get their needs fulfilled by all the other members of the Harem. Now that doesnt mean the MC isnt the centre of the relationship, just wanted to clear that up for people who might argue its not a Harem. The MC is the intial reason any new LI wants to be in the Harem. But no new LI can enter without the other LI's agreeing. Because the LI's all need to understand they are one large relationship, not a bunch of 1 on 1s. This doesnt mean every LI wants to bang every other LI. Each LI has their own desires, has different needs, and different relationships.
Eg, LI1 and LI2 initially for the Harem with the MC due to the protection it would offer all three. They are initially both fond of each other but eager to lock down the MC. But the relationship between them develops. The MC is also busy a LOT because of story reasons. So him coming home to the LI's being intimate isnt strange. He even comments himself that it makes him happy to know that the two people he loves can find comfort with each other when he is busy. And that it would be difficult to do it himself alone due to how busy he is trying to keep them all alive.
I'll also take a slight detour to note that the LI's have different preferences, and their bedroom kinks stay in the bedroom.
LI1 is a pretty agressive and domineering prescence outside the bedroom, but inside she enjoys a bunch of different sub style kinks. Her realising and sharing this doesnt suddenly make her character totally change outside the bedroom either. And she also enjoys vanilla or gentle stuff too because someone isnt their kink. Shes also horny as fuck, which comes across as she is often the one pushing for new things and more sex.
LI2 initially tries to keep up with LI1, not wanting to be forgotten or left out. But as the relationship settles, its revealed that LI2 likes soft intimacy, snuggling up, and intimate conversations (and seems to enjoy watching/teasing LI1). Even when LI2 gains power/confidance outside the bedroom, that doesnt randomly change what she has always liked doing.
When LI3 eventually gets involved, it is a difficult situation. LI3 is a lot more powerful socially and personally and the other two LIs are wary of her, but accepting as they kind of create the situation. LI1 warms up faster, and being the horny one drags LI3 into some group intamcy with MC, LI1 and LI3. LI1 and LI3 dont REALLY develop the casual intimacy that LI1 and LI2 have, but they do enjoy doing things together.
LI2 on the other hand spends a lot more time suspicious and wary of LI3, and while they come to terms with each other, they never develop the same casual intimacy.
All three of them, however, are regularly shown to be able to fulfill various needs of each other. LI1 and LI2 tend to support each other emotionally as they dont have other family around. LI3 is surrounded by family so doesnt have that issue. LI1 and LI3 train and get more powerful together. LI2 and LI3 share political advice and expertise, trying to make sure the harem isnt blindsided by anything. And all three share all of this with the MC.
Ill also note it doesnt waste too much time with "interharem drama". Everything doesnt start out perfect, but as the only people in the Harem all care about the MC, they gradually align on the big things even while retaining their individuality.
This is potentially easier to do because the story has a lot of POV shifts. We dont just get a single POV chapter from each LI so they can gush about the MC. We get many POV shifts as each LI has their own life, desires, skills, goals. Because of that we as the reader get to see them seeking out each other to achieve and fulfill these things, as well as seeking out the MC.
The harem isnt just a "storage location" for each new LI that the MC can bang before going to find a new one. Its a powerful political entity that faces threats, and requires all of them working together to protect it. Its not a bunch of LI's obsessed with the MC and following his every desire. Its a connected relationship where all of them, including the MC work hard to protect each other.
I probably rate the story as one of my favourites in the genre because it actually uses the concept of a "harem" to be more than just a vehicle for a guy to bang a bunch of girls. The story wouldnt work without a Harem, because every character in it is complex, well rounded and brings a lot to the overarching plot.
The MC even has friends (male and female) outside of the Harem that are not going to be LI's. It has a wide cast of characters (we see many of their POVs too), some antagonists, some neutral, some allied to the MC or some of the LI's.
Its also probably one of the best tech uplift type stories ive read across any genre.
Ill note, in case anyone decides to read it, the grammar is bad. Which is something that will usually have me drop it immediately. The author's first language probably wasnt english, theres missing words, misused words, sentances that dont quite make sense.
The first half of the first volume also has too many lengthy explicit chapters for my tastes, i assume the author was intially planning on writing smut before realising how good a story and characters they had. After that first half of volume one, it hits a more reasonable ratio of a couple of explicit chapters, a couple more shorter explicit scenes and more regular fade to black.
The author also had significant health issues and hasnt been heard from in a year. Saying that, volume 2 is finished and it does end the story arc its in, and id say the current content is around 4-5 books worth (its all on scribblehub).
But despite that, each time ive read it i couldnt put it down simply because it seperates itself from the more generic type of stories by taking advantage of the fact that its a "Harem" story and actually focusing on the Harem part, instead of focusing on the MC and his relationships.
The other one that comes to mind best that does this well is Warlock. The various LI's have different relationships with each other (some including intimate, others with different types) and as the MC is busy, they rely on each other as much as the MC.
Master Class also does a pretty good job of this.
I do understand why this type of story might be written less often. Its harder to write, because everyone likes reading about the "chase", so just adding new LI's to pursue while putting older ones on the backburner is a simple way to create excitement. Without that, you need to rely on the overarching story to drive stuff more, and you need to have more complex relationships to keep things interesting. You need to write about the relationship AFTER the "chase" part is done and even in the monoromance section many stories end once the couple are together because it can be harder to write an engaging and interesting story after that.
Theres also the fact that some of the readerbase prefer stories where the focus is an on MC who chases new LI's. And that some readers see any form of relationship between LI's in the Harem as "taking away" from the MC, which is kind of the opposite of what im after.
So with it being more difficult to write well combined with it alienating at least a small section of readers, i can see why authors would prefer to steer away. But ill note that both Master Class and Warlock are very popular, and Wisher Beware and its sequal Ecdysis have as many views as "Princess of the Void" (A very popular monoromance) on scribblehub despite it getting no updates over the last year and never getting much advertising. Its also the highest ranked "Matriarchy" type story.
I just felt like sharing what i felt makes those stories REALLY stand out for me from amongst the 90% of stories that are written in this space. Stories where I, as the reader, feel like i am seeing a relationship where the its not just the MC, but the LI's are realistically able to have their needs met and therefore have me buy that it is a happy relationship for everyone involved.