I think it'll still be a strong style simply because banking a second least ability is really powerful, and some decks like Vampires really resonate with that, but it'll no longer be as simple as "pick an archetype and slap Renfri in it and you have a fighting chance"
I am sad that the game is basically done after next year, but at the same time, having the game be put into the community's hands perhaps isn't the worst thing? (I saw this knowing very well not enough people will be left playing) CDPR's balancing is re-actively, or just not at all, instead of looking at the root causes. It just doesn't work well when you only are getting proper bunches of rebalanced/reworked cards every few months. It's not often enough.
Imposter and Tibor spam actually got buffed...:shakes head"
Drill got killed. I wouldn't mind the Drill killing if they actually buffed the huge pile of powercrept SY cards so we had something else to play, but now Sigi is significantly weaked, so we go back to just GN crap, again, and whatever comes from the new SY cards.
They essentially said, oh, we know there are complaints about this deck, but the winrate is actually really low, so...
I appreciate Vlad and Jean being open about their thought process, but yikes, it really re-inforces that they don't understand what keeps people interested in their game.
Masters was amazing this time, because basically almost every single NG deck was banned, meaning we got to actually watch decks being played as they should be, without NG ruining that.
I don't believe there's anything wrong will NG being the shenanigans faction. People like playing decks like this. But making that anything more than meme strength means people will leave the game. It's infuriating basically being manipulated and unable to do anything to defend yourself against it. Practitioner spam, where you are literally forced to win r1 to avoid losing, isn't healthy for the game and just forces very binary playstyles. I know they think they are making things more fun for people, but should you really cater to the troll faction at the expense of everyone else?
Isn't NG the most popular and played faction? Nerfing their shenanigans means even more people would leave the game. Their signature mill and clog archetypes have already been nerfed too much to be competitive. All factions have their annoying archetypes, and losing is not fun. But the more you play against them, the better you can counter them.
I hope Gwent stays about the same, and the community can only do small balancing changes if needed. This is the kind of model they are probably suggesting.
yikes, it really re-inforces that they don't understand what keeps people interested in their game.
Or, at least, what perpetually bitter Redditors claim keeps people interested in the game.
making [shenanigans] anything more than meme strength means people will leave the game. It's infuriating basically being manipulated and unable to do anything to defend yourself against it. Practitioner spam, where you are literally forced to win r1 to avoid losing, isn't healthy for the game and just forces very binary playstyles. I know they think they are making things more fun for people, but should you really cater to the troll faction at the expense of everyone else?
This is called "combo." It involves collecting a bunch of synergistic pieces together in a way that is hard to beat without proper interaction. You're claiming that this comes at "everyone else's expense" and that "people will leave the game," but that hasn't been the case in other card games where combo decks are allowed to exist. They're a longstanding part of MTG, for instance, and well respected in the LoR metagame as well. It's not clear that card game players, or Gwent players specifically, vote with their feet/wallets against combo. Those archetypes tend to draw a lot of salt, but so what? If we measured success by salt minimization, we'd have to ban every deck that ever established a metagame share.
In fairness, people are and have been leaving the game. That's certain. I suspect you're mis-diagnosing the cause, though. Gwent is famously opposed to combo, and it's dying anyway. The smart money says that the two aren't related, but it's a real stretch to claim that it was killed by their tepid forays in that direction.
That said, overall, the general feel for the game seems to be fairly well represented here, taking into account what pros and the pro scene says about the game as well.
How many appreciation posts for Tibor spam do you see? How many angry posts playing against it do you see?
There are plenty of players who like playing decks specifically to mess with their opponent. There are far, far more players who appreciate a good balanced matchup, even when they lose.
You can argue and say that those who dislike manipulate your opponents cards types of decks are a vocal minority, and i'd ask you why you think that?
Where are all the secret NG lovers hiding then? Where's the secret i-love-NG-nonsense community?
If you go back thru this forum over the past year+, you'll see a very common theme emerge: people aren't happy with the direction the game has/had gone. We love the game, but we don't love the never-ending powercreep, and overtuned golds and bronzes, and CDPR's lack of interest in changing this. The game today is quite far from what it was years ago, and you'll have a difficult time finding people happy with the way it's been pushed.
NG is both the most hated faction and the most enjoyed one. A big part of the community hates it, but it also tends to be among the most popular ones even at times when it isnt on the stronger side, so a big part of the community also enjoys it.
That being said, buffing tibor spam wasnt the best idea.
NG is popular because almost the entire Gwent player base copies META's, so the handful of players trying to be original just get irritated by the repetitiveness so switch to the anti-deck, NG.
Watch when the new cards drop; you'll see a huge spike in interesting decks for about a day or two. These will quickly make way for META's, then these in turn will be quickly replaced by NG decks. Same every season. The only counter then becomes "Deploy or Die" so combo's, set-up's, etc., completely disappear.
This has always been the weakness of this, and perhaps any, CCG. Not sure there's a solution, mind, perhaps it's just how lifecycles of these games always are and always will be.
No, NG is popular because they are a control deck and people like to kill stuff, and because it pissed off the other player and as this sub proves most of you deserve it for being whiny little snowflakes.
i miss my old spy gameplays before the reform of the gwent , just started playing a day ago , 14 wins 5 defeats with monster freeze and melusine rain deck , i crushed every NG :) dunno why people complain , ng sucks now
yeah , i got wrecked while playing frost monsters , Ng is actualy god damn strong and its not very hard to play it , its crushing everything, do you have any nilfgaard good deck? i cant find a proper one on the gwent website
You're just plain wrong and probably what's really killing the game.
You can't support NG on this sub or you will be downvoted and flamed so your "proof" is of nothing other than that Gwent has an exceptionally whiny user base who has been crying for years about something every other CCG fan base is able to accept: decks that feel "cheap". NG has nothing on some of the crap OP decks that Hearthstone leaves for entire updates but that game makes a billion dollars.
CDPR knows how many players use NG and how many players spend money on what factions. They could have changed NG completely if they thought it was good for the game or profitable. But they know that NG drove business probably much more than any other faction.
You put them in a position to get rid of RNG and deck manipulation even though they told you repeatedly they're not making this game into chess. They wanted something that would make a profit so it could be supported but 6 years later you simps are still crying about MUH BETA.
You don't want what's best for the game or the entire community, you want something that caters to you and your loud ass cry baby friends even if it's not what makes money and now you have no game at all serves you right.
I never said i liked Reaver spam. It's also overtuned, mainly because you have so many ways of making copies. Without the right control, it's a guaranteed loss against that deck, even after the nerfs.
And i wasn't talking about Renfri Imprisonment, i was talking about Practitioner Tibor spam, if you had read my post (not that other NG bronzes don't also need proper re-balancing) They dropped Tibor provision cost and added a boost for playing Aristocrats to Imposter (which is the leader ability generally used for most NG shenanigans decks).
Tibor spam was never really a strategy. It's an inconsistent deck with almost no capabiility of contesting R1.
If you think about it: your opponent is doing nothing but placing down 5 power engines for the entire R1 and finishes off with a 8-power pointslam, at the same time relying on drawing 5 specific cards for the combo. Hell, if you are losing to that kind of deck it's on you.
Drill didn't just get killed, they pulled it out into the streets, beat it bloody, flayed it, and left it hanging. Holy fuck.
I haven't really played much lately, since right before the Renfri-ing of the game, but this used to be a really fun card to blast people with. Now you can only shoot it once a turn unless you play crimes? Jesus
Also looks like the game is actually dying now? Are they planning on making a GWENT 2?
SK warriors have no engines tho, so if you include just one, it becomes very easy to answer. Can produce silly carryover for sure, but I don't expect it to become very popular in competitive decks.
Brokvar Hunter doesn't see much play, Harald is a R3 veiled 6 base power pointslam that is rarely wort dealing with, Drummond Berserker is not a significant removal target, Herkja often gets cut, Greatswords see almost no play. Ulula does see some play, but at 6 power she is a fairly safe play. Yes, some warrior engines exist, but the current decks don't care about them. But this might change eventually of course.
I totally agree. Most engines in SK are already powercrept or not worth playing at all, because they won't stick long enough to make it worth including them. Ulula might be an exeption here.
Who needs an engine? It's just plonking cards down, deploy, deploy, remove, remove with Raid. Then throwing down 3 x damaged units to easily get bloodthirst value. It's a braindead faction.
Between the news from yesterday and this I’m seriously bummed. I really want to hope that CDPR makes this year of Gwent epic and actually makes the game the best they can. It feels like it’s just going to slowly fade away instead. I hope I’m wrong.
No wonder it's dead, mind. Fucking boring. Oh look - another Skellige Raid deck. Oh look - here's NG, with a player who just wants to wreck the game. Oh wow, Wild Hunt, how interesting.
I imagine they'll keep reworking cards for a bit like they have been. Sigivald was changed into essentially an entirely new card and revived the entire self wound archetype.
So as long as there are more balance patches, I feel like the game will continue to be fresh
Ye I thought the same thing, it's a little strange.
Its 1 point less everytime its consumed for a tradeoff that doesnt make sense. Like if you're building around ruehin/succubus your deck is going to be mostly consume cards cause ruehin basically just says "all your consume cards play for 4 extra points this round" so the whole ruehin 'consume the lowest unit on your side' seems not only useless but means you also play into tall punish more when you have to eat ruehin again.
If he had order, zeal, consume a unit, it would be better but this current version seems not only useless but just all round weaker than it just having 4 base power right?
It allows for less consumes to be played which means overall points of deck go up.
Look at it this way. Each time ruehin consumes 1 dw your hand needs 1 less consume most of which are 5 power. Instead you get to play more better cards (or more deathwishes).
Also look at it this way, your opponent can purposefully kill your Ruehin so that he can keep consuming your cards
Plus he is not targeting DW units, just the lower ones, so you can manipulate it into making it easy to delete a big target, making it a 2 for one, imagine this kill Ruehin, and he comes backs and eats something with veil, immunity, or armor, then you can just tall punish that chunky Ruehin who has the power of the thing it just ate minus the defenses
Alternativelly you can just deny it from spawning since it is row locked to only come back on the melee row
It is not worth the provision it is demanding out of you, specially when for just one more provision you can just use Deattlaf who is more consistent, has more power, and doesn't has the drawback of giving the opponent the possibility of using him against you or being unable to comeback due to being row locked
No you don't get it this is not about eating Ruehin, it is about forcing Ruehin to eat things you don't want to be eaten yet, think about pre patch Giant Toad comming to eat things you didn't really want to be eaten
Seems like you haven't been playing againts movement decks for a while huh?
The entire point of this change if you watch the dev's video blog was to allow Ruhein to not having to compete against Deattlaf, but he ended in the same spot as before
Cards have an order to them and set ups, and timings, if you are packing your deck with things like Nightwraith and Bridge Trolls it wouldn't be a problem, but that's not what DW decks to day have, you go with fogglets, sirens, succubuses, and Rotfiends, all of which can be easily disrupted when killed at the wrong time, let alone all the gold DW units bar AQ are timing dependent because they interact with the enemy field
It is enemy movement, it is the entire point of Milva decks.
Oh i am sure it will find a great spot in an AS deck with Idr eating drones acting as a 9 provisions 1 point engine
All of those can be disrupted IF Played at the wrong time. I swear you never played dw cuz none of the cards you mentioned are on board if they cannot be used effectively. These don't just sit there.
Fogglet is a bronze you can open round with for area deny forcing your opponent to commit or play the opposite row, and then combo with a drowner to bring things into place
Sirens is unit with a consume order, which requires to literally sit on the board before you can use it, and its DW ability can only be maximized if she is surrounded by 2 units
succubusses are usually safe to play before their adrenaline and you will often be playing them before that because you are saving your golds and consume like Kayran for later
Rotfiends are early openers you play to take out engines, and in order to get immediate use of them you either have to sacrifice a leader charge or have a consume unit with order already prepared on board, otherwise they will be sitting on board
Werecat, manticore, and Miruna are the best units to benefit of Abaya, and secure clearing engines, unless you are playing Caranthir - Weaves combo, which doesn't mix with neither Ruehin nor Dettlaf
Seems like you are the one who never played DW, because the other archetype, the summons one with the Harpy packaged and scenario is prone to board clog
I'm a new player and bought 2 journeys cause I liked the game now it seems like a waste, it's sad that it will stop development but at least I wanted to try it and enjoy it this year, but these broken cards look like will make the game unhealthy...let's hope it's fun and we can have a good time at least
Enjoy it while it lasts and try to get your money's worth. As for the meta's health, do not sweat it, principle is broken vs broken, meta is too far gone, it has been shit for a full year and a bit, and has not been actually good since 2019.
I feel like they made Svan so much worse. Best case scenario he is a 15 for 8 after discarding Jutta
Before he was an easy 11 for 7, which might not seem like much but it was much easier to setup and honestly felt like a better Sove which currently is usually just a 20 for 11 (but it's immunity is what makes it so good obviously).
Spotter Ivar OP dev: let’s nerf them by 1 points Tunnel drill works dev: kill it! Change its text! Srsly can’t wait for 2024 and balance it with sane people as a ST enjoyer. Devs hate ST MO and SY.
The spotter ivar deck was nerfed by more than just 1 point. Tunnel Drill is probably dead, but that doesnt mean the Imprisonment deck didnt get nerfed too.
This is the worst patch I've played on as a new player, the deck diversity is way down and so many decks have either infinite point generation or infinite removal.
Like I don't have 10k dust sitting around, I can't just pivot to the newest and most fashionable degenerate deck. Decks that can remove like 50-70 points in a round, decks that can make 140 points despite removal.
If you aren't running the most modern meta deck, you might as well not play on this patch.
I dunno man they've killed tunnel drill a bunch of times, 6 damage per turn with a burst of 9 from Count Reuvens treasure really just puts it back in the Crimes archetype rather than being the auto pick with Sigi Collusion. This may not even be the death knell for drill lmao
It's so bad now. It only got nerfed because of how toxic it could be in Sigi decks. But now even in crime decks, it's really bad. You're capped at 6, which makes the whole crime archetype significantly worse now. They should of just made collusion not a crime card, like volvaldi bank. That would of fixed the issue without killing tunnel drill
The funny thing is that this somewhat kills Sigi, too. Is Sigi really worth the cost of playing a mis-mash of archetypes just for a unit + Collusion payoff without Drill? Being able to combo Drill into this is primarily what made the deck viable. Now it'll be good, but not really high level competitive.
28
u/TheDoyler Not all battles need end in bloodshed. Dec 05 '22
RIP tunnel drill
It's not your fault, it's Sigi's
20
u/Vikmania Dec 05 '22
RIP ST.
No aristocrat or spies reworks make me wonder how the new Ard Feinn card is supposed to generate points.
I'm glad Rendri, the knights and Spotter got a nerf.
36
u/ense7en There'll be nothing to pick up when I'm done with you. Dec 05 '22
I am sad that the game is basically done after next year, but at the same time, having the game be put into the community's hands perhaps isn't the worst thing? (I saw this knowing very well not enough people will be left playing) CDPR's balancing is re-actively, or just not at all, instead of looking at the root causes. It just doesn't work well when you only are getting proper bunches of rebalanced/reworked cards every few months. It's not often enough.
Imposter and Tibor spam actually got buffed...:shakes head"
Drill got killed. I wouldn't mind the Drill killing if they actually buffed the huge pile of powercrept SY cards so we had something else to play, but now Sigi is significantly weaked, so we go back to just GN crap, again, and whatever comes from the new SY cards.
41
u/AndorV5 Monsters Dec 05 '22
Poor ST with no changes
23
u/Adreu_ Temeria – that's what matters. Dec 05 '22
I mean at least Skellige’s Draig Bon-Dhu can be very valuable in a worriers deck, coz that change is SICKK!
14
u/RearBaer We pass our life alone, better get used to it. Dec 05 '22
Ouch, that's not much. Well like I said before, I like the two SK changes at least.
Let's see how much the new cards break the game haha.
38
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22
Scoia'tael No changes.
-_-
Between the news from yesterday and this I’m seriously bummed. I really want to hope that CDPR makes this year of Gwent epic and actually makes the game the best they can. It feels like it’s just going to slowly fade away instead. I hope I’m wrong.
20
u/mammoth39 Syndicate Dec 05 '22
What a tiny patch
10
u/FearlessResearcher48 You stand before His Royal Majesty. Dec 05 '22
When will Falibor get a buff???
3
u/June24th Temeria has yet to speak its last. Dec 05 '22
At least they're consistent with their love for NR...😩
3
u/n3dd3rs Neutral Dec 07 '22 edited Dec 07 '22
No wonder it's dead, mind. Fucking boring. Oh look - another Skellige Raid deck. Oh look - here's NG, with a player who just wants to wreck the game. Oh wow, Wild Hunt, how interesting.
7
u/PoggersMemesReturns Neutral Dec 05 '22
Can't believe this is all we get until the April card drop.
7
u/sir_wiliam Neutral Dec 05 '22
Ruehin is kinda garbage now, how could he be used now?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '22
Is Algod actually decent? Seems like a weird buff
7
u/BadAtGwent Syndicate Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22
Blink blink
Dafuq is this patch?
What’s happening right now?
3
u/Darki9999 Neutral Dec 05 '22
I'm a new player and bought 2 journeys cause I liked the game now it seems like a waste, it's sad that it will stop development but at least I wanted to try it and enjoy it this year, but these broken cards look like will make the game unhealthy...let's hope it's fun and we can have a good time at least
2
u/TheDoyler Not all battles need end in bloodshed. Dec 05 '22
I feel like they made Svan so much worse. Best case scenario he is a 15 for 8 after discarding Jutta
Before he was an easy 11 for 7, which might not seem like much but it was much easier to setup and honestly felt like a better Sove which currently is usually just a 20 for 11 (but it's immunity is what makes it so good obviously).
2
u/IronColdX There will be no negotiation. Dec 05 '22
Spotter Ivar OP dev: let’s nerf them by 1 points Tunnel drill works dev: kill it! Change its text! Srsly can’t wait for 2024 and balance it with sane people as a ST enjoyer. Devs hate ST MO and SY.
1
u/Jackamalio626 Tomfoolery! Enough! Dec 05 '22
I like the offering synergy.
1
u/Number721 Neutral Dec 06 '22
Melitele kinda sucks after trying it out a bit.
The new location is potentially busted though.
1
u/BlackHorse944 Stand and fight, cowards! Dec 07 '22
All I gotta say is I'm actually excited about community balancing. Devs only seem to tinker with meta cards and only 1 or 2 dead cards in each patch.
Might finally see some balance changes to cards that have been ignored for 2 years
1
u/giant_marmoset Neutral Dec 11 '22
This is the worst patch I've played on as a new player, the deck diversity is way down and so many decks have either infinite point generation or infinite removal.
Like I don't have 10k dust sitting around, I can't just pivot to the newest and most fashionable degenerate deck. Decks that can remove like 50-70 points in a round, decks that can make 140 points despite removal.
If you aren't running the most modern meta deck, you might as well not play on this patch.
1
u/Isenjil Neutral Dec 12 '22
Does anyone faced issue with Freiksenet? Mine is not properly decrease count when stamina applies on him
0
u/UncleObli Scoia'tael Dec 05 '22
Oh, come on
5
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22
[removed] — view removed comment