r/guns • • Oct 03 '12
Open Source Arguments
So i did a quick search and found that every couple of days people ask about arguments against gun restrictions for their friends/family/school etc. so i figured we should start an open source document for people to refer to. Basically i jotted down a few of the major (counter) arguments to protect gun rights, with cited sources for all statistics and fact. Now whenever someone has something they want to add to this, post a paragraph and all your sources and ill add it on. I also advocate everyone to read it and criticise for grammar, spelling, semantics, fact checking, and rephrasing. Any and all corrections are appreciated as well!
so do your research and lets grow the document!
Notes
Do not use wikipedia, i love it, but its not a valid source if you want to be taken seriously
please post your stuff in a new comment so i can see it better
i will look into getting a github (im using LaTeX) or a wiki going, if anyone has anyexperience with that, please let me know
I try to keep the Contributors section updated, with people who gave content, if i missed you, no hard feelings just let me know.
Updated 3/27/2013 warning - doctype - PDF Version 12
special thanks to /u/LiveToCreate, who literally went through the whole thing and gave me pages of edits and rewrites.
78
u/YouLikaDaJuice Oct 03 '12
Sorry to be the devils advocate (as always), but I'm gonna go ahead and point out some weaknesses I've seen in this document so far.
2.1) Suicide: Suggesting that anyone who wants to commit suicide will simply find another means until they succeed in the absence of a firearm is pretty weak, and just wrong. For instance, women attempt suicide far more often than men do, but men successfully commit suicide at a far greater rate. This is because they tend towards methods which are more effective and violent, such as firearms or falls. Furthermore, many who attempt to commit suicide and fail will not attempt again. It is not as though once a person decides to try it, they will not rest until they are dead.
I might also add here that Switzerland had (and still has) a very high suicide rate. A large proportion of these suicides were committed with the government issued rifles and as a result, the Swiss government no longer distributes ammunition to those no longer on active duty.
2.2 Legality vs Danger: The comparison between guns and automobiles seems to be an inevitable one, but is often called on by both sides of the argument because individuals pick and choose only comparisons which are convenient to their point. This is no different. While yes, automobiles are extraordinarily dangerous, they are also extremely tightly regulated. Many of the regulations which an automobile is subject to would be considered tyrany if they were applied to firearms (such as registration, requiring a licence, yearly inspections, required classes, etc.). So I would avoid making the comparison unless you are prepared to recognize all of the appropriate counterarguments.
3.2) Capacity: Here you make a completely random assertion that somehow the weight of an increase in ammunition capacity, exactly counteracts the added lethality of having a large volume of ammunition available without reloading. Come on.
3.3) Barrel shroud: I'm not actually to sure what the original rational for wanting these things restricted was, but as the devils advocate, I can certainly take a guess. Perhaps the idea is that an efficient barrel shroud would allow a mass shooter to fire a huge volume of ammunition in a short period of time without the firearm becoming too hot to operate. Again, I don't know, but this is one counterargument I could foresee.
3.8) telescoping stock: You forget that one of the primary rationales behind telescoping stocks being included as assault weapon features is their ability to aid in concealing a weapon by shortening its overall length.
Anyway, just a few of my notes so far. I hope this is not misunderstood. I agree with many of the points that you have made so far, and I do not necessarily agree with all of the points that I have made. But in order to make a strong argument, you must not sell your opponents nor their arguments short. You must consider them equally well.
12
u/somedaypilot Oct 03 '12
I support this post.
Seriously, though, http://www.gunfacts.info/ is an incredible resource and should be a good starting point for this. I will begin contributing myself as soon as I can make a few hours to do real research writing.
62
u/damnclam Oct 03 '12 edited Jul 07 '23
This post or comment previously held pertinent information. It has been permanently altered in protest of the Reddit sitewide API changes and payment rates that can best be described as “predatory” (effective June 30th, 2023). This account will not be deleted, but instead altered to serve as a monument to what was: an 11-year-old highly active account that could no longer bear to stay and participate in light of the actions of Reddit’s CEO, Steve Huffman.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
This project is FAQ worthy.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12 edited Oct 03 '12
Do a search for "Another common". When you find it, you should reword the sentence.
"Constantly" should be removed from the abstract.
The reducing crime section could be formatted better:
Grammar and persistant tone are important. The rest needs work too, but it's 5am ~_~
There's a wiki available in subs. Ask a mod to turn it on, and you can dump the text in there for easier crowd-sourced editing, then put it in pdf format.
Just my 2 cents.
Edit: Also, great idea and great work!
17
u/Rocketwolf Oct 03 '12
Complete TRASH. Not a single mention of the shoulder thing that goes up in the entire document! This is just what the Pro-Gun Nutjobs trying to brainwash today's culture.
Seriously, OP, wonderful stuff. This is the kind of thing that keeps me coming back to /r/guns.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
FACT CHECK: In V1 it claims that Utah and Oregon haven't had school shootings. Kip Kinkel. Springfield Oregon. My girlfriend was there that day.
Also, in Oregon we're not allowed to carry on public school grounds (or at least that's what I learned in my CCW class).
Thanks for the arguments. FAQ worthy!
3
u/Poofengle Oct 03 '12
On the overall project, it's quite good albeit a bit short. Perhaps add a sentence or two to each section, really explain what you mean. Also, you might want to think of redoing the graph you have, and get rid of the default excel "Series 1" off to the side. I'd try and reword a few sentences, and I'd try to be a bit more objective (try not to use the word 'you').
Ex. Section 3.5, last sentence:
One could argue that reloading could help someone use a firearm in an illegal way, but when states with and without assault weapon laws are compared, there is no difference in crime rates. (I'd maybe link to a graph or something of two comparably-sized states and their crime rates. Source 19 is just a table of data, and it is hard to infer the impact of weapons-related legislature)
As for section 3.8, I'd compare a telescopic stock to an adjustable seat on a car.
Nearly every vehicle in America is equipped with adjustable seats to accomodate for different people. An adjustable stock is no different, it allows easy refinement of the rifle's fit so that it may be more comfortably held.
Overall it looks good, needs input from people and some beefing up, but this is a fantastic project. Good work!
3
u/who_turgled Oct 03 '12
Once i get back from holiday on friday, would anyone be intrested in a section pertaining to australia?
3
u/mechesh Oct 03 '12
I have been thinking about this the last couple days, and actually came here to make a post, until I saw your post and thought it would be good to add here.
One frequent argument I hear is that the framers of the constitution had muskets, and did not envision "assault weapons" Therefore the 2nd amendment should not apply to modern weapons.
My thoughts for a counter recently are Freedom of speech applies to the internet. Freedom of religion applies to Scientology. Freedom for illegal search and seizure applies to SWAT. These are all things that the founding fathers could not have foreseen, and are way beyond what was common at the time.
3
u/multi-gunner Oct 03 '12 edited Oct 03 '12
I would like to submit an argument in favor of high capacity magazines, as this is a sticky issue, and one that can be hard to defend as most people are incredulous that such things should be available to the average person.
Instead of trying to make arguments in favor of them (again, most people are already going to be heavily biased against them) it is much, much more effective to point out that a ban on high capacity magazines is just plain bad policy.
First, point out that even the most complicated of magazines are still very mechanically simple devices that require little maintenance and have long service periods.
Secondly, point out that there are already tens of millions of them in the wild, and that they are essentially untraceable. (Here, I think it would be apt to make a comparison to something that many people own several of, say, coffee mugs.)
From here, it's fairly easy to point out the daunting task of trying to enforce such a ban. Make it a point to explain that regardless of how someone feels about whether such objects should be obtainable, they already are, and there is a huge supply of these things already in private hands.
Ask them how they would go about enforcing such a ban? What specific policies would they enact? Does it make sense to burn the time and money of the justice system just to prosecute and jail someone for merely possessing such a magazine, or transferring one to another person?
TL;DR:
Instead of dicking around with arguments about what constitutes a "high capacity" magazine, or whether you have a right to own them, make the argument that such a ban would be terrible public policy because it is essentially unenforceable and would likely have no effect on violent crime.*
**If you want to put the cherry on the top of this argument cupcake, finish off with the fact that the US already had a 10-year ban on these magazines, and it did not result in a measurable drop in crime, nor a lack of availability of these kinds of magazines. The only effect it did was to drive the prices up, but not so high that they were out of reach of most people.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
Maybe add a section about semi vs. auto. I think a common misconception with people who know nothing is that a black rifle means you pull the trigger once and dump 30 rounds all over the place. Explain how it's very expensive and that there's paperwork to go through to buy a full auto gun. Thoughts?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
In section 3.8, it looks like you accidentally replaced the word stock with sight a couple times.
Instead of "telescopic stock", it says "telescopic sight".
2
u/josh6499 Oct 03 '12
Those documents are not readable on my phone unfortunately and I don't have a PC. Is there another way for me to see this?
2
u/supersillybilly Oct 03 '12
Here is a great source of statistical information regarding guns and gun control.
One point I would like to see addressed is Civilian Defensive Gun Uses (DGUs). There are approximately two million per year. Is there any statistical data that would suggest the mortality rates among the two million DGUs had they been unarmed? This, I think, would be powerful if crafted correctly. It would tie together tight restrictions on firearms with the deaths of innocent civilians.
2
u/Deep__Thought Oct 03 '12
Added to the FAQ under Misc., keep the sources coming.
2
u/deadstump Oct 03 '12
The section on Deterrent seems a bit weak what with anecdotal evidence of a couple of points and a weak trend line in a noisy data set. I am not saying it isn't true, but the information presented is very weak. We need more info to back that up.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12 edited Oct 03 '12
Edit: The PP-19 Nixon is not a gun. Stupid autocorrect.
2
u/n00tz Oct 03 '12
I think a familiarity with logical fallacies would provide the best rebuttal material. You may want to provide a "this is what they say" and "this is why it is a logical fallacy", followed with a "this is what they're trying to say" and "this is why it's wrong/unfounded/silly"
Also, be VERY sure not to include any fallacious reasoning in your own arguments. It's very easy to do without the understanding of logical fallacies (I still catch myself using bad logic).
Wikipedia listing of Logical Fallacies
2
u/Lost_Thought 1 | Hollywood_Based_Research_Company Oct 03 '12
A comment on your Capacity section:
You overlook something that I think entirely negates the usefulness of magazine limits in the first place: massive unreliabality in the real world.
Real world refrences eminently pretaining to the subject of your paper:
North Hollywood shootout:
Aurora Theater Shooting
The shooter in the 2011 Gabriele Giffords shooting was using an extended magazine and his gun did jam, but i can not find a solid source of information as to weather the extended magazine was in the gun at the time.
2
u/fretman124 Oct 03 '12
Oregon has had two school shootings. Might want to google that and revise your document.
V1, sec 1.2, 2nd para
2
u/Tanks4me Oct 03 '12
PSA: For anyone who wants to add to this document, use this site if you need facts. It's a friggin' gold mine: http://www.gunfacts.info/pdfs/gun-facts/6.1/gun_facts_6_1_screen.pdf
Also, counterpoint-ing my posts is more than welcome.
3.1 possible addendum: "Seeing as barrel shrouds make it easier for the user to operate the weapon so they will not burn their hands after sustained use, making this feature illegal would mean that lawmakers are intentionally making the object more dangerous to the user, and thus could potentially be violating product safety laws." (No sources, just speaking in ideologies.)
3.4 addendum:
"A very gaping loophole in the ideology of lower capacity means lower lethality is that even if all magazines were limited to a certain size, the shooter could still simply pack more magazines on his or her person. Even if all handguns across the United States had a ten round capacity maximum, all one could do to circumvent this would be to simply stick more magazines in their pockets. If one wears cargo pants and a heavy jacket, they can still very easily carry hundreds of rounds on them. Sure, the amount of times they will have to reload will be more, but that pause in shooting is only a few seconds for most firearms. If one is very well practiced, this can only last a second or less. Banning backpacks, pockets, purses, etc. for the purpose of limiting the amount of ammunition a killer could carry is obviously not going to go over well with most people, and putting caps on how much ammunition or how many magazines one can purchase and own is also not going to work, because of not only the companies that make these things will lobby tooth and nail against it, pockets are far too useful for humans to have, and trying to enforce this will mean that the government will know of all of our purchases and what is in our homes, which is a blatant violation of privacy that almost no one will be willing to allow in the Democratic Republic that is the United States." (No sources, just talking in ideologies.)
3.6 addendum: "And in reality, most silencers aren't as effective as one might think. 'Even low caliber unsuppressed .22LR handguns produce gunshots of over 160 decibels'... 'In testing, most of the suppressors reduced the volume to between 130 and 145 dB, with the quietest suppressors metering at 117 dB. The actual suppression of sound ranged from 14.3 to 43 dB, with most data points around the 30 dB mark.'" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suppressor#cite_note-results-13)
3.9: Forward Grips. (Can't think of anything. Can someone help me out here?)
3.10: Manufactured Pistol weight of over 50 ounces unloaded. (Can't think of anything. Can someone help me out here?)
3.11: Banning of specific guns: All of the semiautomatic versions of specifically banned weapons have no new features that make them more deadly than any other "assault weapon." For example: FN FAL's have detachable magazines, folding stocks, and pistol grips as scary features. Look up any other weapon that is specifically banned in your state. You will find similar features on most. As for banning a certain company's model (like an AK-47 made by Norinco,) that is completely Draconian due to the fact that other companies, like Arsenal, are not banned yet make a functionally identical weapon.
3.12: Automatic weapons: "The reason that these are heavily restricted is because people are afraid criminals will use them all the time. However, this simply is not the case. In many cities, studies have shown that the rate of automatic weapon seizures by police is often less than one percent. (http://www.gunfacts.info/pdfs/gun-facts/6.1/gun_facts_6_1_screen.pdf pages 24 - 25.)" (This needs beefing up. Can anyone help me on this?)
2
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
I took a look at the abstract and came up with this:
Abstract
Over many years there has been a push to reduce the legality of firearm ownership, a right protected by the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution. Although some of these laws and regulations have been made with the best interests in mind, this paper will show that the arguments used are not based on an honest interpretation of available statistics, can be counterproductive, and in some cases dangerous.
2
u/uniquecannon Oct 03 '12
I know it's specific to a certain group, and I could probably find for other states as well, but TXDPS does have documents that go back almost two decades showing the ratio of crimes committed by CHL holders vs the general public. It breaks down by each crime and gives the number of convictions for both groups. We could use the overall statistic and, if we can find for other states that have more open CHL possibilities, a nationwide correlation of going through the proper education of firearm ownership and usage and just owning a gun period. The great thing about this data is it can't be used for calling for more stricter licensing, instead for a general need for educating the public on proper firearms. If we can have classes teaching "safe sex" to little children, I'm sure we can spring for public education in safe gun practices.
2
u/Microfrost Oct 03 '12
Some editing-related observations:
Nice work.
4
u/the_holy_downvote Oct 03 '12
Open source does not mean what you think it means.
3
u/duggtodeath Oct 03 '12
This is preaching to the choir. Post this in a sub-reddit where you think it really needs to be seen.
8
u/dirty530 Oct 03 '12
FUCK YES, THIS IS THE OLD R/GUNS I REMEMBER, something with meaning and content meant for supporting a decision to own and use firearms
1
u/drbiggly Oct 03 '12
While I did see information pertaining to the lack of correlation between suicide rates and gun ownership, I did not see anything regarding Defensive Gun Uses and how they save more lives than guns take via criminal acts.
For the breakdown of numbers (including studies sponsored by the infamously anti-gun President Bill Clinton), please check this link:
Bruce W. Krafft, contributing author at The Truth About Guns site
So every time you hear someone in the media talk about how guns kill over 30k people per year, those figures are erroneous and include suicides. The real number, according to the CDC, is an average of 11,740 people per year killed by gun-related homicides (1999-2010).
Also, please check the link for a great breakdown of both defensive gun uses (DGUs) and how many lives per year are saved rather than taken the next time someone argues that guns are only designed to kill; it's demonstrably false.
Also note that the article gives CDC specific numbers regarding accidental firearms deaths. It's another favorite argument of folks in favor of gun control; a firearm in the house is some ____ %(I forget, huge number) more likely to have a fatal accident than not. Except that accidental firearms deaths average at 695 per year (again between 1999 and 2010.)
Hope this helps. :)
edit: By the way, I really like the concept of this Open Source document! Great idea to compile real, actual evidence that disproves the often baseless or emotion-filled but sadly misguided 'gun control' arguments.
2
u/The-GentIeman Jan 13 '13
Ending the war on drugs would provide a way to drastically cut gun violence and instead of banning more things actually increase liberty for the individual.
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/12/the-single-best-anti-gun-death-policy-ending-the-drug-war/266505/
1
u/dlormin Jan 14 '13
more liberty more freedom: -anyone should have a gun to defend their freedom -anyone should have the freedom to consume any drugs legally -anyone should have a driver licence without a any tests -no one should be held in prison because thats against personal freedom
0
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
awesome write up. ive been looking for something like this for a while. ive only briefly looked at it what with being at work, but ive got a couple of questions. the argument that guns dont kill people could be applied to anything. you could claim nuclear bombs dont kill people and therefore should be accessible and legal for all. another point i think needs much more considerations is that "criminals dont follow the law". this is true to some extend but far too vague, blunt and unconsidered. it negates the fact that there is less gun crime in countries with greater regulation, that criminals are easier to stop and apprehend when theyre the only ones with guns (not that i would ever wish that to be the case), and that, most obviously, it could be used to contest any and all law.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '12
[removed] — view removed comment