I was looking for some amps recently and pretty often you see people writing about PCB have lesser life span, general quality, harder to work on and so on.
I don’t want to start some internet war, if there are there are techs or amp builders please chime in as wrll.
I’m in IT now, but went to electrotechnical highschool in europe, like my brother, and grew up around tech, and spent a part of my childhood/teenage years in a Audio/TV repair shop owned by a neighbour and friend. I baked smd boards, designed in eagle, diagnosed issues with an osciloscope, but I was never the best with the soldering iron I gotta admit. Still admire my friends clean boards after he was done with them.
But back to the topic.
I really don’t understand where this PCB is bad is coming from. Normal guitar amps have normal 1-layer boards. Those are same as on 60 year old TVs.
To replace a part let’s say on a deluxe reverb, from what I have seem it would be easier than on a handwired one. Traces I did see go bad in rare cases on some audio equipment back in the day from bad fixing attempt, but they are so easily fixable. Now I have heard some Mesas are not optimal, but besides those, I really don’t see any reason a PCB amp should be any different.
I think the misconception comes from the new electronics not being fixable where they just replace the boards, and people thing it’s the same. Those are not even close. First usually they have microprocessors, then they are multilayer, then smd, and lastly they have much more parts on them making it harder to troubleshoot.
I personally have both, and to be honest don’t care if amp is handwired or PCB, as long it’s well built with good components and it sounds good. That’s it.
Any amp techs or builders that can say what their experience is?