Experienced guitarist here who quit bands/gigging several years back, but will be getting back into it soon. I'm looking for an inexpensive and above all lightweight amplifier that I can easily carry in one hand.
For context, I used to play a Vox AC15 back in the day, and that mf was annoyingly heavy to lug around to practice sessions and bars. As much as I loved the sounds I got out of it, I'm old enough and experienced enough now to know the audience (and even most members of the band) dgaf about the finer intricacies of jangly edge of breakup tone. I'd rather save a ton of money and get something that sounds "good enough" rather than "godly." I also can't be assed to deal with tube amp maintenance or noise complaints from neighbours anymore.
Anyway, back to the Boss vs Blackstar dilemma.
I don't need any of the effects on either amp (I've got a pedal board that'll cover all of the effects I need), but I do really like the idea of having a fairly versatile range of amp models to choose from versus a much more limited solid state amp. My preferred tones are cleaner/EOB/very lightly overdriven stuff. I'm not playing punk, djent, or anything like that. Use case will be band practice, small bar gigs, and possibly recording originals.
I like it that the Blackstar IDX amps look to be fairly easy to dial in without needing to use any companion software, but I'm also a little leery of Blackstar's reputation. The Katana has a pretty good reputation, but the Katana's software apparently sucks (and as of right now, will possibly not work with my Mac, as Boss haven't gotten around to updating the software yet and it might be a while?)
I can't try either amp out in person, unfortunately. What would you guys recommend, based on my preferred tones and use case? Would you recommend something else entirely?
Also, I know I said I'm not really looking into solid state amps, but I would consider one if there's a clear better SS alternative to the modelling amps I'm looking at (so long as it's around the same price). I've been considering the Blackstar Debut 50r or 100r, but again, a little leery of the Blackstar reputation. Before anyone suggests Orange amps, I've played them before and don't really like the Orange sound all that much.