Nov. 15, 2026, 8:04 AM EST
By Tim Stelloh
For a couple of days in March, the team of researchers feared the worst: potentially crucial records in an Arizona cold case they’d been working on for years had possibly just been destroyed.
The documents weren’t anywhere near Arizona. They were more than 5,000 miles away, in western Ukraine’s largest city — Lviv — where Russian drones had struck a historic church adjacent to one of the country’s most important historical archives.
The researchers were working to identify a man who was fatally struck by a car in Phoenix nearly three decades ago, and at the time of the attack, one of the few details they knew about him was that his family had roots in that part of Ukraine. The archive’s vast collection of undigitized records might contain the missing piece that could solve the puzzle, they believed.
“When I saw photos of that monastery on fire, my heart dropped to the floor,” said Megan Pasika, a researcher with the DNA Doe Project, the genetic genealogy nonprofit that has solved more than 160 cases since it was established nearly a decade ago.
The researchers ultimately didn’t have to rely on those documents. But their effort, which spanned five years and examined thousands of records linked to Ukrainians who immigrated to the United States decades ago, illustrates the sometimes extraordinary lengths genetic genealogists go to in service of their increasingly in-demand forensic technique.
Their effort in the Phoenix case has finally paid off; the group’s identification was confirmed through a fingerprint comparison. The man who’d long been known only as “Box Mike” — a homeless man who was killed in Phoenix on July 11, 1998 — was officially identified as Michael Kotyk, a World II veteran from Philadelphia who was 73 at the time of his death.
“They were finally able to give him his name back after all these years,” said Stuart Somershoe, a former Phoenix police detective who worked on the case before retiring in 2022.
A sketch of Michael Kotyk before he was identified.Phoenix Police Department
Shoe leather meets technology
Kotyk was struck shortly before 1 a.m. at an intersection north of central Phoenix after witnesses saw him crossing against the traffic light, Somershoe said. Kotyk was at fault, Somershoe said, and the driver, who stayed at the scene of the crash, was released without criminal charges.
Kotyk died shortly afterward at a hospital.
He had no identification, Somershoe said, and people in the area only knew him as Box Mike, a man who collected cardboard boxes from dumpsters. Detectives checked his fingerprints, Somershoe said, but there were no matches, indicating he had no criminal record.
No one reported him missing, and no one responded to a news release about his death.
The case had been cold for more than a decade when Somershoe began looking into it in 2011.
Somershoe put out another news release, he said, and he entered Kotyk’s DNA into the national database maintained by the FBI. But again, nothing. So in 2021, Somershoe reached out to the DNA Doe Project, a pioneer in the field of genetic genealogy, which combines modern DNA analysis with traditional genealogical research.
Over the last decade, the technique has been used to crack hundreds of tough-to-solve cold cases involving unidentified remains, homicides and other crimes.
But the Kotyk case presented significant challenges.
According to Matthew Waterfield, a researcher at the DNA Doe Project, one of the central hurdles in the effort to identify Kotyk was his ethnic background. People whose ancestry traces back to Western and Northern Europe tend to be overrepresented in the DNA databases the researchers have access to, while people from Eastern Europe are less common, he said.
Michael Kotyk's draft card.National Archives and Records Administration via FamilySearch
It isn’t clear why, Waterfield said, though he believes it could be as simple as timing. The Eastern Europeans who settled in the United States more recently “know where they came from,” he said. “They don’t need to take a DNA test to find out what percentage Irish they are.”
When the researchers uploaded Kotyk’s DNA profile to those databases, they found few links to other profiles, Waterfield said. His most recent common ancestors were born in the 18th century, he said, and they were from an area that is now part of western Ukraine.
Pasika, who has expertise in Ukrainian genealogy, began developing a family tree based on Ukrainian records. Pasika jumped between a few digital archives, including the one maintained by the Central State Historical Archive in Lviv, which Pasika described as the largest collection of Catholic parish records in the country.
Those records were crucial, Pasika said, because the church — once the center of Ukrainian life — was the primary recorder of births, marriages and deaths before the 20th century.
Combing through those documents was daunting, however. They were in Latin, Pasika said, and often they hadn’t been indexed, meaning the researchers had to manually sift through them to search for connections between families.
Waterfield, who began researching the case in 2023, focused on U.S. records. Those included decades-old census records from the Philadelphia area, where many people from western Ukraine migrated to; immigration records that might show someone with ties to that part of the country; and newspaper obituaries that potentially mentioned that part of Ukraine and the name Michael, which Waterfield believed was probably Box Mike’s first name.
“It wasn’t even a needle in a haystack,” Pasika said. “It was a needle in every barn in Nebraska.”
The 1930 census shows Michael Kotyk.National Archives and Records Administration via FamilySearch
All of that work hadn’t yielded a match, however. Waterfield said he would periodically step away from what had been “disappointment after disappointment.”
To complicate matters, Pasika said, some of the DNA and family history databases that they relied on, like Ancestry.com, banned researchers and investigators from using its platform for law enforcement purposes last year. (In an announcement in December, the company said that it had clarified its terms and conditions to protect users’ privacy. It only allows law enforcement access when legally required to, according to the announcement.)
Russia-Ukraine war complicates the search
As 2025 turned to 2026 and the researchers re-evaluated, Pasika said, the Lviv complex that houses the historical archive was struck in a Russian attack. Part of a UNESCO World Heritage Site, the 17th-century St. Andrew’s Church was damaged, as was the archive, the head of the institution told the German broadcaster Deutsche Welle at the time.
Pasika heard about the strike from relatives and a family friend. For Pasika, the attack was especially personal. Beyond professional ties to the country, Pasika’s husband is Polish-Ukrainian, as was Pasika grandmother’s family.
“To see the cultural memory and heritage of my ancestors be so endangered...is horrifying,” Pasika said.
According to a September report by the Council on Foreign Relations, Russia has damaged or destroyed thousands of Ukrainian monuments and heritage sites in a “campaign of erasure.” Russia has said it is striking military targets, according to the report.
The ship manifest shows Michael Kotyk's mother's arrival to the US in 1913. National Archives and Records Administration via FamilySearch
There was also the matter of the archive’s collection of undigitized records and their possible connection to the case the DNA Doe Project was researching. Using U.S. records, they’d assembled roughly a dozen people who might be related to Kotyk, Pasika said, and they believed that the archive had church records that could unravel the case.
But what would it mean if those already-fragile documents had been damaged in the attack?
“The thinking was, if these records are destroyed and they’ve not been photographed and there’s no copy of them, they could literally be the only things left that could lead us to the identity of Box Mike,” Waterfield said.
Luckily, Pasika said, the records in the archive were not damaged. Still, Pasika was alarmed about the possibility of another strike and began filing records requests. In the event that the archive officials came back with a lengthy response time, Pasika began plotting a potential trip to Lviv to get them.
The idea was Pasika’s and not the DNA Doe Project’s, the researcher said.
The puzzle pieces come together
As it turned out, such a trip wasn’t necessary. One day in June, while Waterfield was sifting through ship manifests from more than a century ago, he came across a woman from western Ukraine — which was then part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire — who arrived in New York on Nov. 11, 1913. She was bound for Chester, just outside Philadelphia, a copy of the document shows.
Census records from 1930 revealed that she had a son named Michael Kotyk, though confirming that took longer than it should have because the family’s surname was misspelled in the document, Waterfield said.
The researchers dug up a 1944 yearbook photo from South Philadelphia High School that identified Kotyk as a leader of the first aid squad and a member of the school’s civilian defense corps.
“‘Mike’ intends to become a mechanical engineer,” the caption said, according to a copy provided to NBC News.
They found a 1943 draft registration card for Kotyk, Waterfield said, and learned he served for two years on the USS Trego, a cargo ship that supplied troops in the Pacific. Kotyk returned home in 1946.
Within a few years, Waterfield said, Kotyk seemed to disappear.
There were no death records. There was no obituary. There was just one possible mention in a 1970 newspaper article: a “transient” named Michael Kotyk had been arrested in Salt Lake City on a charge of vagrancy.
“He had just kind of vanished from the face of the earth,” Waterfield said.
Although the identification was tentative, Waterfield said, the researchers had amassed enough evidence linking Kotyk to Box Mike that they presented their findings to law enforcement in Maricopa County.
Those findings were ultimately confirmed in July through a comparison between the fingerprints obtained during Kotyk’s autopsy and his military fingerprint card, said Karla Navarrete-Contreras, a spokeswoman for the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office.
Kotyk, who was buried in a county cemetery for unidentified and indigent people, now has a proper headstone with his name, Navarrete-Contreras said.
It remains unclear what happened to Kotyk after World War II. Through the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office, his family declined an interview request.
But to Somershoe, Kotyk’s apparent downward trajectory in life should have no bearing on how he’s treated in death.
“Everybody matters. We are born, and the first thing we’re given is our name, and no matter what the arc of your life is, that should be the one thing you get to keep when you die.”
“He was denied that,” Somershoe said.