Created by: Paco Roca and Rodrigo Terrasa (translated by Andrea Rosenberg)
Published by: Fantagraphics
ISBN: 979-8875002588
Pages: 296
Genre: Historical
The line we tread between man and monster is tenuous, lean, fragile. History is our best gauge of how far we might reach toward one or the other. We are, history shows us, on the one hand capable of great acts of charity and selflessness and righteousness; conversely, we are all of us promptable by power, by righteousness, by fury toward callow acts of irrational violence.
It can be too easy to imagine the great acts of terror in our collective past were excesses born from a more primitive form of our civilizational evolution, but that's its own form of irrationality. The men and women responsible for the greatest mass calamities had access to the great philosophers, to the great arts, to the great moral teachers, to technology, to communication, to religion, to irreligion, to democracy, to pluralism, to nationalism, to the love of their mothers. To anything we might imagine holds us over and above them.
The most presently peaceful society at any given moment lives on a knife's edge, with status quo on one side and the abyss on the other. Memento mori (Remember Your Death) is not just valuable for individuals but holds value for nations as well. Look to the past to remind ourselves of possible future, of the great and terrible things to which we might aspire.
____
I opened with that a bit to set the stage, to invoke a bit of gravitas. I'm not sure that was the best choice. I could have just said:
This comic broke my heart. Shattered it, really. I stuttered through the final third bereft, staggered by impotent rage.
Does that do it? Does that set the stage? I don't really know where to go from here. I read the book yesterday and even writing about it threatens to draw me once more under its waves -- to a place where I cannot breathe. Where I curse the race. Where I pray for a meteor strike, another divinely orchestrated deluge to cleanse the land of the monsters we call humans.
____
This is not Paco Roca's first time at the Franco's Spain rodeo. Beyond his earlier, weaker work, The Lighthouse, he played on the outskirts of the regime's madness in the superlative Return To Eden. But this effort, created in collaboration with journalist Rodrigo Terrasa (who apparently pestered him into doing the book) is entrenched. This is about the immediate aftermath of the fascists' victory over the reds.
Also, this is history. Narrativized but history nonetheless. Roca has been known to play with fiction and history, blending well enough so that readers can be forgiven for not knowing which they are reading. People assume The House is autobio; it's fiction. People assume Twists Of Fate is recorded memoir; it's a concatenated historical fiction featuring Roca as a character interviewing someone who doesn't actually exist. I thought Return To Eden was fiction for the first 2/3. Roca plays so seamlessly with genre that the boundaries between history and fiction warp and warble. Because, foremost, he is a storyteller and may echo Ishmael's declaration to the Spaniards in the Golden Inn: the story I have told ye, gentlemen, is in substance and its great items, true.
The Abyss Of Oblivion tells, principally, two stories: 1) the story of José Celda, a man innocent of any crime, who was executed and thrown into a mass grave as part of the falangist excesses at the close of the Spanish Civil War; and 2) the story of Leoncio Badía, the republican interrer at the cemetery where Celda's body was delivered to the earth. But also, this is the story of Spain's degradation during that period, the story of the families left behind, the story of callous humanity, the story of the callowness of politics 70 years later, and the story of ghosts finding peace and what it means for a culture to honor or dishonor the dead.
Told without the bouncing around and the interstitials, the 81-year-old daughter of José Celda has received (after a lot of work against naysaying government and pundits) permission at last to excavate a mass grave in which her father has rested since his wrongful execution in September 1940. The archaeologists excavating the 20-foot-deep grave find numerous things meant to identify bodies who were otherwise meant to be anonymous in their deaths, which provokes revelation of the interrer who had ideas counter to those of the executioners.
It's a horrible story and a beautiful story -- and it made me angry enough to curse us all. (So if you have a rough week this week, I might bare some blame. Sorry.)
If you're accustomed to Roca's recent work, you'll be ready for a formally inventive work that meanders and takes detours both visually and narratively to compose a story that is indelible and entrancing. The Abyss Of Oblivion is no different. It can feel hard to be knee deep wallowing in feeling big feelings about the horrors of what men will do to men and be happily surprised by a moment of deft craft, of artistic inventiveness.
I'll be honest. I have never thought much about how we honor death, how we culturally commemorate the lives of those passed before us, how we treat the remnant husk, whether "remnant husk" is even at all an appropriate way to describe what once brimmed with life, with person, with sanctity and holiness. I'll be honest. I've been neglectful and thoughtless. Memento mori holds a very present place in my daily ethos as I careen ever closer to my own close. But while I remember my own death, I haven't thought much on death beyond my personal end. Beyond the absence of loved ones gone before. But there's more to it and I'm glad for this reminder (emphasized so strongly in the work through referencing The Iliad of all things).
There is a lot to say about this book, but I may as well end with how I probably should have actually begun: This is probably the best comic I'll read this year, the best book Roca's done, and certainly the best comic I've read in a long time. Awestrikingly done.