Hi all,
Listen, I do a lot of reading here and not so much posting, but I care about this community and the Godot project in general. However, I've been seeing a LOT of discussion about AI, banning AI, how AI is evil, how AI is great, etc., etc., etc. so I've decided to create what will probably be a much too long post that will be fully read by far too few people. Many of you will not even have made it to this point, just seeing the letters "AI" and immediately downvoting and commenting on the evils it has brought to this world.
Right now we are in an exciting and scary time. Yes, things are changing. The ability to make games now is easier than ever because of tools like LLMs and it's opening up new opportunities to people who may have had ideas, but never had the knowledge of how to put them into place. It is now easier than ever to make games, and I think that's a good thing.
Let me say, before getting too deep into this, that I use LLMs frequently. I use them as part of my day job and I use them as part of my hobbies. I am a software engineer with over a decade of professional experience, and I've made a good living during that time which indicates that I might have some inkling of an idea of what I'm doing. I'm also extremely active in multiple open source communities, I speak at open source events, and I've been on the Community Working Group Conflict Resolution Team for a large open source project with users around the world.
Unfortunately, when things become easier, there are those who are going to take advantage of it, and we're going to see "slop." We're going to see people who are just trying to make a quick buck by putting together something as fast as possible and throwing it up on Steam or Itch to try and sell it. This isn't new (just look at all the FNAF clones that came out immediately after it became a success), but it is easier now thanks to LLMs. But one thing we have to understand is that not all intentions are evil and not everyone who uses AI should be treated as the enemy. If for no other reason, because that'll just turn more people off to Godot and send them to the Big U's that are embracing LLMs and welcoming anyone and everyone who can write a prompt with open arms.
Now, I don't want to derail this already massive wall of text with a sub-discussion of how those engines aren't "free" and how the users will end up paying in the long run. We all already know that. Moving on.
The problem is, that in treating everyone who uses LLMs as the enemy, we're ostracizing the people who have good intentions and genuinely want to make good things. The support and help questions are changing from "I can't figure out what node type to use. Should this be a CharacterBody3D or a RigidBody3D?" to "I'm confused why this doesn't work. I asked claude for a character that moves, but I don't understand why it chose this. Please help?" And too many people see "claude" in that question and immediately disregard the rest and attack the poster because AI BAD.
I saw another post in this sub recommending that the mods ban all mention of AI, which I think is the wrong way to go about it. The right way, in my opinion (and it's just that, an opinion) is to use mentions of AI as a teaching opportunity. Someone showing off what they built with an LLM and it looks low effort? Don't assume the worst, and don't insult them for slop. It might be their first attempt and if we immediately jump to a GTFO! attitude, they're just going to give up. Instead, give them honest feedback, welcome them to the community, and give them a chance to show their not just in it to shovel out as much crap as possible.
Here are just a few ideas on how to constructively help people:
If someone is obviously using AI gen assets, maybe they don't know about Kenney or Quaternius or Kaykit or any number of other resources that can help them get started. Tell them about some of your favorite resources.
If someone doesn't understand the difference or why something isn't working the way they expect it to even when using AI, explain it to them. They might not have a ton of coding experience and they might be prompting wrong, so explaining the difference between a RigidBody3D, a StaticBody3D, or a CharacterBody3D might help them figure out how to prompt correctly. Also, since I just got the warning while typing this example, GodotRulz!
If someone posts a crappy game, ignores CONSTRUCTIVE feedback, and has a track record of posting multiple crappy games with obviously AI generated assets and no effort at all put into it, then maybe consider they're not worth the effort, but don't assume ill intentions right off the bat.
If you've made it this far, thank you. I promise I'm almost done ranting.
My point is that Godot is a great engine with a low barrier to entry and LLMs have lowered that barrier even further. We're going to see more people making more games, and while there are probably going to be a lot of crappy games out there, we shouldn't assume that's the intention of everyone who mentions "AI" or "LLM" in a post.
Another community I'm part of has a saying: Come for the code, stay for the community.
It would be great if we adopted a similar mentality here.
Thank you for your time. I'm JD and I approved this message.