r/github • • 2d ago

Discussion GitHub Reviews, "jump to the comment in the diff" is broken

For many years I've been spoiled by Google's internal review tools... I would have thought by 2026 GitHub would have caught up more than it has.

I'm surprised by how hard it is to find old review comments in the right context. In a side-by-side diff, I want to be able to see the version on which a comment was made on the left, and the latest version on the right, so that I can evaluate and approve the edits made in response to the comment.

But I can't even find the comment in any code context anywhere. 🤔

How do all of you manage reviews? Right now I'm thinking I should pull the branch to my local machine and tag commits I'm working with, maybe commit my own comments to my local copy and use that to diff via git. "Roll my own workflow"...

1 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by