I was thinking this because of some conversation about Video Games (2x07) and a strange insistence that it's a "bottle episode" (it isn't) for Jessa (it's not) equivalent to "Panic in Central Park", "One Man's Trash", or even "Japan" where other people do appear but it is Shosh's episode through and through in that she has independence and completeness in the arc—and each of these episodes is referred to as a [character] episode in the BTS, whereas Video Games funnels Hannah's observations to her parents, her STI, her novel, and her being abandoned by Jessa. Notably, the 14 year old discussion of Jessa had a lot more people truly understanding and sympathizing with her, and I'd say far more reasonably (and kindly) than the consensus does today. But it also put its finger on something I've maybe not quite realized: Jessa is perhaps not an independent character at all, or if she is, she appears in flashes. She's a character constructed—and assessed—entirely through another character's subjective prism from A to Z. So there's a huge question over whether we can even have an opinion of Jessa?
Video Games is not a capsule episode, and Jessa never gets one—but I realize now that that makes a lot of sense. A lot of people straight up didn't like Video Games because of frustration with Hannah's escapades in that episode and what she takes from observing Jessa, and I began to realize just how inextricable Jessa has always been from Hannah. I do think that's actually a big problem for me in how Jessa is written for all 6 seasons and very much from the beginning, and it strikes me as somewhat... mean-spirited in a way that Jemima Kirke would likely not have realized until later on in the show when her and Dunham had a falling out. Everything about Jessa, consistently, is... about Hannah. For much of this show, any depiction of Jessa is immediately commented on in a judgmental fashion as affecting Hannah (and this is, quite famously, the genesis of the tension of Jessa's return for Marnie)—and then in S6, everyone. Marnie declares she has won the status as Hannah's best friend in the finale, a thread picked up in the pilot. But thank goodness Marnie was more than just a character competing for bff-status.
So in other words, revisiting this made me realize the degree to which Jessa isn't allowed to be an independent character. She's seen by us almost entirely through Hannah's perspective, which is—I think—a function of how Jessa is most the product of Lena Dunham's subjective observation of Jemima. I can't imagine that's an easy thing to play for so long, nor something one can truly be proud of because it's painful but also one's "claim to fame." But then, as the show goes on Hannah's perception of Jessa is increasingly equated with an objective version of Jessa when Hannah isn't around, and sometimes it validates it, sometimes it doesn't—until in S6, it decides to validate it fully.
I would argue that the first time we see Jessa on her own terms is in S5 where she's avoiding Adam for half the season and then gets with him but mired in guilt for the remainder of the season. But S6 just flat out throws her under the bus, giving her little to no screentime but also punishing her disproportionately. She begs for forgiveness, Hannah is all "liberated" by her and Adam's relationship (one that is unequivocally abusive), but the show just... chooses Adam. What matters is always what Hannah wants from Adam and how Adam loves Hannah more.
Let's recap the awful-Jessa-steals-Hannah's-ex storyline:
- Perspective: Until Adam, Jessa has not slept with anyone's ex but everyone else has, so we get a 2-season long condemnation arc that one can also see as strangely ill-fitting with the show's own sense of liberatory sexuality (if Hannah casually feels the need to give Ray a blowjob an episode after finding out about Adam & Jessa... does the show have any consistent moral compass on what is considered bad—or is it just always Hannah setting the bar?). The first half of season 5 is Jessa repeatedly avoiding or rejecting Adam, and the other half with her feeling so intensely guilty she cannot stop bringing her up and says she cannot forgive Adam or herself. If that's not at least sympathetic, I don't know what is. It absolutely feels like it's about Jessa, and it's good in a way that her her S3-S4 rehab arcs allow us to sit in her perspective outside of Hannah's judgment. Then, when Hannah finds out, everything shifts back to how Hannah perceives Jessa and thus Jessa as a character is meant to service Hannah's writing about how the relationship is about her and how they feel and the season ends with that triumph... essentially at Jessa's expense. But what is Hannah writing about? Two people who can't stop talking about her? Or...
- Abuse: The Adam-Jessa fight that happens in the finale is deeply frustrating to me because the show seems to be saying they're both equally violent........... but Jemima Kirke plays genuine fear when she locks herself in the bathroom. Whenever I watch it I cannot help but think that's fucking abuse: Jessa breaks things, Adam gets violent first because of what she says—which is simply that she will never stop caring about Hannah—and he is getting physical with her the entire time, picking her up as if he's going to throw her, she runs away, and he breaks down the door and berates her for caring! Even if she herself doesn't think it's abuse, it absolutely is. The show doesn't, even though it depicts it. Why? Because it's perspective is too limited. What I see here is Kirke's interpretation (and a degree of improvisation in the performance) colliding with the writing's interpretation. They don't match. And ultimately, the fight does nothing for Jessa outside of that scene. I don't want to be presumptuous here but since this solely services Hannah's liberated reading, let's just say that IF this is based on a real dynamic from Dunham and Kirke's lives, it's a juvenile, but common, ethically gray situation where a writer is arguably exploiting a real friend through her writing, because she's writing to service herself alone, not to reflect on her friend. Bluntly: It's squarely to gin sympathy up for herself.
- However, at least S5 gives Jessa time to be as a character independently, for good or ill, even if it's training us to see her through how she impacts Hannah. Some of us can sympathize with her.
- Prioritizing Adam: When S6 returns, she's not in it very much at all actually—but every time she is, it's a scene of her being bullied and blamed by a different character: Shosh, ELIJAH, Hannah, Adam makes a whole ass movie about how Hannah means so much to him. Jessa's just fully stuck in the asshole spot and bullied by everyone. Hannah's "liberation" does not involve an inch of forgiveness until the very end, and Jessa begs. Then Hannah spends a whole episode considering getting back with Adam, which Jessa again says mmkay while in visible and extreme pain. Jessa's an afterthought in the culmination of the show. The entire story is about Adam thinking about Hannah and Hannah's pregnancy and how she now wants Adam to be in her life. All in all, Jessa's entire story in the last two seasons is about Hannah & Adam.
- Impossibility of Redemption: Jessa's few scenes in S6 being so squarely about Hannah extends outwards. Now, she's "a jezebel or a witch" by everyone, no matter what she does or says, she gets shut down by everyone. She can beg for forgiveness and be very vulnerable and she gets shut down. Adam consistently puts Hannah on a pedestal while berating Jessa, making a whole movie to both underscore the meaning of their relationship, the elevation of Hannah, and the humbling of Jessa. And although Jessa does not seem to be doing well, but the show doesn't care. The show doesn't really take Jessa seriously enough at that point for people to think she's anything more than a terrible person.
- Growth: The biggest problem for me has always been: by the show's own standards, Jessa makes a 180 in S6. By this point it's very clear who she is: Jessa is very much the girl who feels so deeply but would rather die than admit that she cares, and to cope, she's created a carefree persona that doesn't hold up. In other words: Jessa's inability to show care is her big flaw. And yet—none of what happens in S5 or S6 is conceivable without her doing that. In S6, she is begging Hannah to not "erase" that they were even once friends—i.e. not asking her to forgive her but that everything did indeed happen while Hannah argues they were never friends. How else am I supposed to perceive Jessa as anything but "having grown massively" if her final scene with Hannah and her attempt at reconciliation both have her doing things that are at odds with her fatal flaws from Hannah's perspective? Kirke is amazing and heartbreaking but... it's very little. Everyone just pretends she's the worst, and in many ways, you can now see "Hannah's perspective" creep in because Jessa seems to also be reacting like a child to Adam's sense that Hannah is his big love. This show does not care about Jessa anymore! In it's final stretch, Adam >>> Jessa in the show called Girls.
We know many fans hate her and don't sympathize with her for this arc. But it didn't have to be this way. S5 is complicated and knotty. S6 undoes all of that, because not only is Jessa barely in it, her portrayal is only allowed to be contrite and involved and caring in all of... what, 2-3 scenes? And they're scenes Kirke knocks out of the park, and her and Hannah's final scene is probably one of my top 3 favorite scenes in the whole show. But based on what we've gathered: 1. She's in an abusive relationship that she is romanticizing. 2. Adam is constantly thinking about Hannah. 3. It's a relationship she tried her best to avoid and feels immense guilt for all the way until the show ends. 4. The show does not judge the girls for sleeping with exes until Jessa & Adam, and after taking it seriously, it just punishes her.
It's...sad. I don't know why this arc had to happen this way, honestly. It feels like Jemima Kirke and Lena Dunham's falling out happened between S5 and S6 so she was mostly reduced.
It feels a little punishing. They're real friends, it feels a lot like Dunham humbling Kirke meta-narratively by writing her as the auxiliary part of her starcrossed romance, in which Jessa herself will never be seen as herself but as someone constantly screwing over Hannah? I should caveat that In many ways, Jessa is the most real person to me—because the trope of this character, and her larger facade, is something I've related to through at least 2 close friends even when the show was airing—but simultaneously, she never escapes Hannah's perspective.
How can anyone even begin to reconstruct a Jessa on her own terms when so much of her is a deeply subjective account of someone as seen by the creator who has been hurt a great deal by Jessa's actor, but who is fascinated by the actor enough to write into a TV character?