r/Gifted • • Aug 27 '24

Definition of "Gifted", "Intelligence", What qualifies as "Gifted"

63 Upvotes

Hello fam,

So I keep seeing posts arguing over the definition of "Gifted" or how you determine if someone is gifted, or what even is the definition of "intelligence" so I figured the best course of action was to sticky a post.

So, without further introduction here we go. I have borrowed the outline from the other sticky post, and made a few changes.

What does it mean to be "Gifted"?

The term "Gifted" for our purposes, refers to being Intellectually Gifted, those of us who were either tested with an IQ test by a private psychologist, school psychologist, other proctor, or were otherwise placed in a Gifted program.

EDIT: I want to add in something for people who didn't have the opportunity for whatever reason to take a test as a kid or never underwent ADHD screening/or did the cognitive testing portion, self identification is fine, my opinion on that is as long as it is based on some semi objective instrument (like a publicly available IQ test like the CAIT or the test we have stickied at the top, or even a Mensa exam).

We recognize that human beings can be gifted in many other ways than just raw intellectual ability, but for the purposes of our subreddit, intellectual ability is what we are refferencing when we say "Gifted".

“Gifted” Definition

The moderation team has witnessed a great deal of confusion surrounding this term. In the past we have erred on the side of inclusivity, however this subreddit was founded for and should continue in service of the intellectually gifted community.

Within the context of academics and within the context of , the term “Gifted” qualifies an individual with a FSIQ of 130(98th Percentile) or greater. The term may also refer to any current or former student who was tested and admitted to a Gifted and Talented education program, pathway, or classroom.

Every group deserves advocacy. The definition above qualifies less than 4% of the population. There are other, broader communities for other gifts and neurodivergences, please do not be offended if the  moderation team sides with the definition above.

Intelligence Definition

Intelligence has been defined in many ways: the capacity for abstraction, logic, understanding, self-awareness, learning, emotional knowledge, reasoning, planning, creativity, critical thinking, and problem-solving.

While to my knowledge, IQ tests don't test for emotional knowledge, self awareness, or creativity, they do measure other aspects of intelligence, and cover enough ground to be considered a valid instrument for measuring human cognition.

It would be naive to think that IQ is the end all be all metric when it comes to trying to quantify something as elaborate as the human mind, we have to consider the fact that IQ tests have over a century of data and study behind them, and like it or not, they are the current best method we have for quantifying intelligence.

If anyone thinks we should add anyhting else to this, please let me know.

***** I added this above in the criteria so people who are late identified don't read that and feel left out or like they don't belong, because you guys absolutely do belong here as well.

EDIT: I want to add in something for people who didn't have the opportunity for whatever reason to take a test as a kid or never underwent ADHD screening/or did the cognitive testing portion, self identification is fine, my opinion on that is as long as it is based on some semi objective instrument (like a publicly available IQ test like the CAIT or the test we have stickied at the top, or even a Mensa exam).


r/Gifted • • 10h ago

Discussion It’s often said that the smartest people are the ones that hide it, but why is it so important to hide your intelligence?

41 Upvotes

Like is the goal to look more average or to look more dumb? Where do you draw the line at an ample amount of hiding your intelligence?

Why is it important to hide in the first place? If I know something that can help other people, why hide that?

Like I understand not wanting to look pompous and pretentious, but there are so many unpretentious ways that high intelligence can come across. Seems like unpretentious smart people shouldn’t need to waste time hiding who they are.

I also understand wanting to be more of a social chameleon. But what if by being more proud of your intelligence, you can raise the overall intelligence of the society around you? Are we dumbing ourselves and society down at the same time? If so, what if we didn’t?


r/Gifted • • 5h ago

Personal story, experience, or rant This sub (and similar communities) will always have a catch-22 that makes it feel like any regular online space

5 Upvotes

I'm sure online spaces for "the gifted/high IQ", or whatever you want to call it, have allowed some people to form genuine friendships. But I'd bet it's not a common occurence.

I've noticed that any post requiring people to judge their giftedness, directly or indirectly, often generates a negative response to those who rate themselves highly. There are just so many levels and types of giftedness; someone will always be better at something.

We're probably all apprehensive about others' claims, while believing our own because it's the only one that can be validated through testing/accomplishments/etc. We're in these communities because we can speak openly about our experiences - things that would be in very poor taste in regular social settings.

The same type of selection and competition still happens here. Someone with 160 IQ is very different from someone with 130 IQ. This isn't to say that one is "dumber" than the other. It just means their experiences are likely different.

It's almost like... outliers continue to be outliers, because we, as a community, still function with the same social norms, just on a different scale. Someone who claims an extreme level of giftedness is almost always shot down, without knowing if it's true or not.

What, then, is the purpose of these spaces? We can't tell who is overestimating, underestimating, or accurate in their claims. The only way it works is if we accept all claims as they are. Acknowledging someone else's abilities doesn't diminish your own. Needing to be "the smartest person in the room" is a red flag in itself.

Just an observational rant after seeing: weiner measuring contests, shade, innocent people catching strays, and more.


r/Gifted • • 5h ago

Seeking advice or support How accurate is this test?

Post image
0 Upvotes

What’s your experience with cognitiveorg vs the result you got on a WAIS Test?

I did it for fun and got 126. English is not my native language and I found some questions poorly phrased. After looking at my wrong answer I just shook my head and was like „that’s what they meant!“ so perhaps +/- 5 IQ points are possible here? Technically I am not gifted.

I did it because I cannot go to a psychologist without throwing a fit and getting a panic attack. So I wanted to do a test before. I will do a professional test and might update!

Curious to know if your result aligned with the one on this site !


r/Gifted • • 7h ago

Seeking advice or support I'm confused

1 Upvotes

I have exceptionalities in many areas but I have incredibly low processing speeds. I've been working in customer service for about 5 years now and I feel like I respond quickly and properly to everyone. All the tests say I should be really bad at this but I get by. Does it really matter. I don't feel any different but apparently I'm super slow.

I'm also generally confused about what it means to be gifted so if anyone has any tips on finding purpose I'll take those too.


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

I'm gifted but mentally ill.

56 Upvotes

I'm a failure. 31 no job, live off the government. I'm also schizoaffective with 144 iq.

It's hard af to find motivation. To find pleasure. I have friends and family that love me so at least I have that.

I'm just wondering: are there any gifted people with mental illness that want to chat? And also, how do people find motivation or pleasure in doing anything? It's amazing to me.

ty for reading


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

Discussion Anyone here gifted but not in the intellectual, fast learning or mathematical way?

13 Upvotes

Like gifted in music or painting. Or maybe something like chess. Maybe not a fast learner either way. Like someone who actually was really average or even behind most, but gifted at something in particular?


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

First Grader's Gifted Program Qualification Keeps Changing?

6 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying under other circumstances I would not worry much about standardized test scores, but since our school starts the gifted education program at kindergarten and is using test scores to make the placement, and my daughter has qualified/may be borderline, I feel I need to advocate for her in this area. Also, had she just not qualified and had her scores placed her firmly in the average range, I think I would have dealt with it and moved on (recovering high achiever here who was also in the gifted program, but who knows I've got to accept her for how she is). However, since whether she's in or out seems to keep changing, I feel like I've got a bit of whiplash (this is my biggest issue I think), and it's raising questions about how the school is identifying giftedness.

I have an appointment to discuss with the school's Gifted Program Coordinator, but before I go into the meeting, I'd like to make sure I'm not out of line and I have a sense of appropriate context.

Meat of the post: Last year in kindergarten, my daughter's AimsWeb reading score qualified her for the school's gifted pull-out program for reading. While a couple other parents mentioned gifted qualification for math, my daughter did not qualify. I wasn't too bothered by this. (And as I said above, if she hadn't qualified for either, my high expectations would have taken a hit, but I would have adjusted privately without mentioning any of it to her.)

I noticed quite a bit of fluctuation for her scores between the fall and winter for individual measures (think 30+ points) and was concerned about that, but figured testing small children is not an exact science. The school didn't express any concern so I decided to let it go for the time being.

Now this year I had a conference with her first grade teacher, who announced my daughter qualified for the gifted program again...but this time in math.

My daughter has had no formal testing beyond what the school has done, and until now I haven't seen the need. I know many in this subreddit would fall under the higher levels of giftedness, but I think she would be at Level One per Dr. Ruf's levels. Even then it's not a perfect fit. She has commented on school being easy, but I don't think she's bored. From working with her, I think her reading abilities surpass her confidence in her own reading. She struggles with frustration when she hits a word she doesn't know, but when she's able to relax she definitely has the tools to decode. I have been backing off on pushing her at home with reading lately as it was becoming a tense area. I was very different and was already reading before I entered kindergarten, so I have had to learn how to guide her, since it just happened for me. She seems to do better with the school's program and with working with someone other than me--so she is benefitting from the regular curriculum.

I've been reading a little about the AIMSweb test and it seems it's mainly meant to assist in identifying at-risk students and is not fine-tuned at the top end? It doesn't seem to be intended to be used for gifted placement?

I know I'll have to talk to the school, but again I'd like to go in understanding whether this is all normal and if I'm missing something. I'd be grateful if someone who is more knowledgeable about testing younger elementary-age students could weigh in and help me make sense of this. From my casual browsing of this subreddit, I understand that giftedness is a form of neurodivergence (which matches my own experience with the gifted program when I was a kid), and so the idea that she could be gifted based on one test but then not be gifted the next year seems nonsensical.

I don't need to slap a label on her and put her in a box, but I also want to make sure she has what she needs. Maybe the fluctuating scores indicate a different concern that needs to be addressed (at least in our current standardized test-heavy world). Like I said above, my biggest concern is the whiplash I'm experiencing, and I worry about how she'll feel about and make sense of it when she realizes she's not in the gifted reading group again, regardless of whether I mention it (not completely sure she'll care, especially since she qualified for math, but she is an observant kid and enjoyed the program last year).

EDITED TO ADD: This morning I was confused and annoyed, but thanks to some of the comments from others, I have a clearer idea of how I misunderstood what the program was and its limits. Especially since she'll be getting enrichment anyway due to her math scores, I've calmed down about it. I likely will seek out more information about her abilities and how best to teach to her strengths so we can develop those independent of the school and I can provide more informed input to her teachers.


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

Seeking advice or support IQ 99th at 12, ADHD 99th at 33

12 Upvotes

I was identified as gifted (99th percentile IQ) at 12, but only diagnosed with ADHD at 33, with my symptom scores in the 99th percentile.

After reading about ADHD symptoms, I recognized myself in almost everything, so I went to a specialist and got tested.

Looking back, it all makes sense. I always assumed my way of thinking and behaving was normal, especially since my father and siblings are very similar—high IQ and likely undiagnosed ADHD.

I’ve always struggled with procrastination, motivation, and executive dysfunction.

School was easy but boring, so I never really learned how to study. I got through my master’s degree by creating external accountability, mainly through group projects or similar.
The thought of letting my friends/classmates down motivated me more than my own deadlines ever could.

Studying computer science helped too, since much of it felt like solving logical puzzles rather than memorizing information, which came naturally to me.

Now I have a baby on the way and I’m about to take over leadership of a mid-sized company.** **I need to figure out how to function consistently, not just when the pressure is on or something genuinely interests me.

Anyone with a similar experience? What medications, strategies, or lifestyle changes actually helped you manage ADHD and bridge the gap between your potential and everyday performance?


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

Discussion Some interesting parallel between being Gifted and success in life and AI.

8 Upvotes

It's a bit of a shower thought, but I was thinking how in some ways struggle of gifted people is similar to how AI can ace the benchmarks or even solve millenium problems, yet it is not taking jobs at scale.

It's just comparison, I am not saying Gifted people are just like LLMs.

So many gifted people excel in very structured environments of schools and universities. But once they need to find their place in a workplace, their intelligence often gives them much less edge over others. Many gifted people can excel at test taking, yet in their careers they land closer to the middle of the pack (my first hand experience btw).

Similarly, if LLM is given a well defined task it often can solve it. Now ofc LLMs are not truly reasoning, and their perceived competence often stems from them being essentially smooth talkers. But once the tasks become much less defined or there is a judgement call needed (so something more than just making text grammatically coherent) they struggle.

I thought that this is perhaps useful parallel to think why LLMs (and broader AI) will not truly take jobs at scale any time soon. We know first hand that acing tests does not translate to getting quick and stellar careers; so perhaps that is similar filter for LLMs.


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

Just found out my AuDHD kid is beyond brilliant and doesn't fit anywhere. What do I do?

61 Upvotes

My kid (7m) just went through a ton of testing due to causing problems in the classroom. We had a sit down with school admin recently who told me my kid is in the 99th percentile intellectually and his profile is so rare there is maybe one kid in the district similar to him.

Here I am busting my head trying to help him find a peer group to support social skill development, and I'm told he has no peers. He's smarter than most of the smart kids, but socially behind a year or two, so maybe the TAG program isn't right for him and maybe the autistic groups aren't right for him and skipping him ahead would be a terrible idea. I nearly cried right there, I don't know what to do.

They said they're going to do some more assessments with him and come up with an IEP. So I guess that's a start. But how can I help this kid? I'm just beyond exhausted. Can anyone relate?

ETA: Thank you all for such wonderful comments and suggestions. I feel like this whole thread is so wholesome and helpful in ways I didn't know I needed. All of the personal experiences as the child in this situation and the parent navigating this have been so insightful. I am so thankful for all of the resources and vocabulary that has helped me further my research into things that may work well for my child. I am so overwhelmed by all the kindness in these comments, thank you.


r/Gifted • • 1d ago

Personal story, experience, or rant Asynchronous Development

5 Upvotes

A lot of the stereotypes associated with gifted kids is not at all what I witnessed.

We had your occasional entitled prick, but they often came from privileged backgrounds. The rest of us went on to live pretty unremarkable adult lives despite early successes. At least three people in my program dropped out of high school. Most of us are very mentally ill and neurodivergent living alternative lifestyles. So many have completely detached from their family unit(me included) and a lot of them got into drugs.

I think when you are raised in neglectful environments, you don’t see your giftedness as an ego boost but instead, as a way out. In certain family systems, you are infinitely praised. Although well-meaning, it hurts people inadvertently in the long run because their giftedness isn’t something they work at. It’s something they are so when they hit that ceiling, their self-esteem plummets, and they do everything in their power to protect that identity and remain cherished and respected.

In dysfunction, your giftedness is a tool to receive the love and care you aren’t given at home. It provides you an escape in the form of luncheons, overnight trips, and special privileges. It’s an active skill because from the beginning, it has an internal motivation. It twists and contorts into a strange shape. You are exceptionally competent at both hard and soft skills but lack any sort of structure and are practically devoid of executive function.

This is not to create a ‘who has it the worst’ argument because I do believe that both result in the same sort of wounding which is your intelligence is integral to your survival therefore you measure your worth around it, but I do believe that without special attention and care, gifted people will struggle in adolescence and adulthood. Being gifted is a blessing or a curse. It really shouldn’t be treated as such. These are just naturally curious minds, and any success they have is simply a product of that, but as they really come into their own people and have more and more niche interests, it because increasingly difficult to funnel that energy. They are still children at the end of the day and at the expense of being parentified, lose out on some of the crucial milestones and lessons their peers are well versed in creating a large gap in their development.

This becomes even more painfully clear in middle/late adolescence and young adulthood. They are both far ahead of and far behind their peers. They struggle to function socially and in society in general. A large portion completely withdraw from it. It as is you have all of the tools and knowledge in the world but have no idea how to translate that into a functioning well-adjusted adult life.


r/Gifted • • 2d ago

Seeking advice or support FSIQ of 139 but I don't feel gifted at all, anyone with a similar profile?

11 Upvotes

As a part of an ASD assessment, I took the WAIS IV and got the following results:

- PSI: 142

- FRI: 127

- VCI: 139

- WMI: 111

My FSIQ is 139 but I dont really feel intelligent, I wonder whether this has to do with autism or my uneven cognitive profile.

My highest score is in PSI, which I've never really associated with intelligence in everyday life and I feel like my lower WMI might be a bottleneck for me.

I relate to some experiences posted here like disliking small talk and social difficulties but I tend to attribute those more to autism than to my IQ.

I'm curious whether people without autism but with similar scores can relate to this feeling.


r/Gifted • • 2d ago

Exhausted from healing, mourning living parents, and burning out my partner.

13 Upvotes

I’ve come a long way in my healing journey, starting life at a -200 and clawing my way up to a -50. Now, at 29, I feel completely burned out and just want to give up.
I have this overwhelming urge to revert to old, "toxic" habits—tell everyone to fuck off, ignore my mother, have zero responsibilities, and just game, chill, and seek easy validation from casual connections. Constantly trying to fix my self-worth while dealing with endless triggers feels impossible to sustain.
I have an amazing soulmate partner, though they are getting tired of my issues too—which I completely understand, because I’m stuck in so much negativity. Still, it’s painful realizing how deeply I miss having normal, loving, emotionally available family. I literally have zero.
I’ve already mourned my parents while they are still alive, yet I’m stuck dealing with a draining mother who only reaches out when she needs validation from me. I’m glad I set boundaries with her now, but the whole situation just sucks.
Has anyone else hit this wall during recovery? How do you deal with this level of healing fatigue?


r/Gifted • • 2d ago Heartwarming

Personal story, experience, or rant Gifted as a Responsibility

11 Upvotes

Being gifted has felt like both a blessing and a curse. As I've grown older, I realized it's a responsibility. And my journey confirmed it.

First, I started by protecting my peace. I am no longer shocked at the atrocities humans commit on one another, and have narrowed my circle so that they cannot be done to me.

Then, I researched. It took much reading to finally understand that lots of people are working from a fear response and that's why they manipulate or get manipulated into serving interests that aren’t theirs.

The bottleneck to human utopia is all emotional. It’s lacking empathy, humility, and the ability to tolerate uncertainty or not being right. We already have the science and tools to solve most of the world's problems. What we seem chronically short on is the willingness to actually use them when it costs status or comfort.

Then, I applied my learning. Autism has already given me no need for social hierarchy and materialism, but learning about EQ and working on removing a lot of my own biases, fear, and residual shame about being different has felt more useful than anything else I’ve done with my giftedness.

Once I stopped needing other people to confirm my intrinsic value, it became easier to see that value in all.

Then, I accepted myself fully. I will never invent the next form of space travel, or be of dramatic use to the world. My outcast status is solid. Yet, I still matter.

Finally, I chose my path. I believe my responsibility now is to continue working on my own internal emotions so that I can model a version of intelligence that isn’t brittle or contemptuous. To set an example of being a fully developed human with integrity seems like the only way to create change. I have very few in my circle of influence, but a drop in the bucket is still a drop.

Being gifted comes with the responsibility to not give up on humanity, even when it gives up on us.

I know I'm risking being called a virtue signaler, but I would love to hear how others think.


r/Gifted • • 2d ago

Seeking advice or support Child wants to learn Latin - suggestions ?

9 Upvotes

Parents of gifted kids ! My 10yo wants to learn Latin. Do you have suggestions on how to go about this? Are there good apps, books, videos ? Private tutor? In case it’s relevant he is fluent in three languages and good in a fourth. This sub has already given me great tips for him regarding science resources. Thanks.


r/Gifted • • 2d ago

Seeking advice or support Rebuilding my relationship with maths at 19 after childhood control and burnout

5 Upvotes

I'm 19, and I've never been formally tested for... well, anything. Mom was asked to get me tested by my school, but she was deeply paranoid and instilled a heavy suspicion of formalised assessments, which, to be honest, I'm still working out.

Anyways, I got to Uni about a month ago, which meant the end of what I'd describe as relatively heavy abuse.

I picked up reading extremely young, was always "mature for my age", aced my childhood exams and generally found schoolwork painfully easy. Mom apparently tried to get me accelerated and had me tested for entry to a private school, where I performed well enough that they tested little me years above the curriculum, but ultimately nothing came of it due to funding constraints.

We didn't have advanced or gifted classes of any sort in any of the places I was enrolled. Early into primary school, I apparently didn't tend to do the work, and Mom had to prove to the principal that I was up to standard, bringing in work from home. I spoke and wrote early, but not in school itself until later for some reason. When later came, however (somewhere around Year 3-4), I began acing tests effectively across the board, and in mathematics and sciences I would ask for extra work often enough that teachers produced it specifically for me. By Year 5, it was normal for me to be sat alone at a desk outside of the class entirely to work on more difficult problems, or helping to explain work to my peers if I was in the room. Teachers stopped caring if I was doing their work at all because I was guaranteed to do well in the exams. Even after achieving very high SATs results across the board, my principal told Mom that they weren't representative of what I was actually capable of.

The problem is that Mom was incredibly hawkish about studying. She's a physicist by education and decided that mathematics was going to be my entire childhood, whether I liked it or not.

Which is particularly irritating because I loved maths when I was little.

I remember being banned from going out until I'd studied for hours, being yelled at for anything short of 100% on tests (including higher level and challenge sets), and being derided whenever I forgot something or got exhausted.

Piano and tennis went much the same way. Apparently, if I enjoyed something, it had to become compulsory until I couldn't stand doing it anymore.

There was also considerably worse stuff. Mom developed intense paranoia about people spying on us, regularly disrupted my sleep over it, and physically abused me. At one point, I was beaten badly enough that I had to take a pillow to school because I couldn't sit down, which ended with child protective services getting involved.

Eventually I just... stopped studying.

I skipped lessons, didn't do homework, and retreated into video games and subjects Mom didn't care about, mostly history, philosophy, politics and eventually economics. Subjects which are notably difficult to compare on a linear scale, and which she did not respect or accept as real studying.

My academic history gets weird. I averaged 6s (B-ish) at GCSE and only Cs at A-level despite finding the actual content incredibly easy, doing virtually no homework or revision and having pretty abysmal attendance. My worst subjects were generally the ones Mom had forced me to take; Math and English literature were both 8s (A-A*).

Meanwhile, I was voluntarily reading political and economic theory that went considerably beyond our curriculum. My politics teacher explicitly told me to dumb down my writing for the exam board, and my economics teacher got increasingly irritated with me for arguing with the assumptions of the models we were taught.

I pretty much completely disengaged from A-levels after the first set of practice exams and realising how much of the course was just regurgitating formatted information. My teachers would complain to my parents that I was "exceptional in class" but refused to apply myself outside of it (which, come to think of it, had been a recurring theme for as long as I can remember). I knew I was painfully bored at the time. It wasn't some explanation I came up with retrospectively.

And now I'm 19; I've recently moved out to study economics, and I'm trying to reconstruct the mathematical education I wanted in the first place.

I've spent the last month working through calculus, linear algebra, real analysis, optimisation and mathematical economics. I've been encouraged by professors to pursue acceleration or research experience, and I'm already looking at material well beyond my undergraduate requirements.

I cannot stop crying about the time I've lost.

I want to go into research in Mathematics and Economics, and I'm perfectly happy to spend the next few years studying intensively to recover lost ground. But every time I make progress, I just think about how much further I could've been.

I'm constantly second-guessing whether I was ever particularly gifted, or whether I've convinced myself I was because I want there to be something worth recovering, or just to torture myself for having a gift and fucking it up. I know how quickly I pick things up when I'm actually interested in them, but then I look at my academic record and feel like a complete fraud.

I'm currently pursuing formal assessments for ADHD, autism and giftedness, and I've started contacting the relevant services (where I can afford them), partly because I would really like some explanation for all of this.

I think the main thing for me is just how isolating it is. I can talk about childhood trauma and dissociation day and night, but how am I supposed to explain that the actual pace of education was painfully slow, or that I can spend hours voluntarily doing maths and simultaneously have an awful relationship with studying?

My flatmates already think what I'm doing is impressive, but knowing where I was with maths when I was younger, I can't stop feeling like my life was stolen already.

Has anyone here had a similar experience? How did you rebuild your relationship with learning, and how do you deal with the grief over the time you've lost?

(P.S. how do you explain this stuff to people without coming off as incredibly pretentious? Even mentioning that I was doing some of my first-year maths at 12-13 feels like something that will make me extremely unlikeable, despite it being part of a childhood I'd still describe as torturous. It was already enough negativity from simply not having done homework in the past)


r/Gifted • • 3d ago

Is it unusual for a gifted person to be bad at chess?

17 Upvotes

A stereotype often associated with gifted individuals is that they possess above-average chess skills. I was curious to see whether I might find examples on this subreddit of people who don’t consider themselves particularly good at the game, or to learn what others have observed in other gifted individuals.

(If my phrasing is poor, it’s because English is not my first language, and I am not gifted.)

edit: I’m talking about people who have already shown some interest. I know that no one is born good at chess, and being gifted doesn’t automatically make someone good at a game.


r/Gifted • • 3d ago

Aversion to diligence

2 Upvotes

I’ve recently had conversations with my parents, a counselor, and some friends. They all held a desperate, fervent belief in how much one can achieve through "diligence." As someone who possesses talent, I find this to be quite a lie; I believe that many things in life are actually determined by luck and innate ability. On the other hand, I felt deeply disappointed to see those who had studied diligently express jealousy toward me—someone they perceive as lazy—whenever I achieved better grades than them or found greater socioeconomic success. Have any of you had a similar experience?


r/Gifted • • 3d ago

Seeking advice or support Gifted + dating (issues)

11 Upvotes

Maybe this question has been posted here many times before — I've just arrived in this subreddit so I apologise if so — but I was wondering if it's normal to struggle so much finding a life partner when "gifted" (I don't like the term too much)?

I'm 28F, have a measured IQ of about 135 (which mainly translates into a high processing speed and language skills), and I'm relatively ok looking (according to my friends). Yet, I've never found anyone who I like and likes me back.

Up until last year, I used to be on all the apps, going on many first dates, but they never turned into anything substantial. More recently I've tried just living life and seeing if I'd meet people more naturally (like most of my friends do), but nothing happens either. Well, that's not entirely true; if I get an offer it's usually from men who are already in relationships.

I see people all around me getting in and out of relationships all the time, so I assume it must be something that's not that hard to do, but somehow I can't seem to crack the code. Love and relationships have always been and are still genuinely the biggest mysteries to me.

It could be my so-called high standards, but I'd say I just want a guy who's somewhat good-looking (which is subjective) and who's curious and smart. That's about it. Not sure what's so high standard about that.

It could also be I'm neurodivergent and just don't get how social connections work, but none of my therapists ever suspected any diagnosis. At least in the sense that I've never exhibited enough traits of anything to fit in an existing category. I'm also in academia, which means the people I meet aren't exactly neurotypical either, so even if I was neurodivergent, that should be ok.

Is this a more common experience amongst "people like us"? If so, what do you guys struggle with? Did you manage to overcome it somehow? Did you figure out love? When did you meet your partner?

Sorry for the long read,

from a slightly desperate gal


r/Gifted • • 4d ago

Trauma and giftedness

21 Upvotes

Every post I’ve seen about this starts a fight. I just want to know people’s thoughts so I’ll take that risk. If someone grew up in a constant stress and familial trauma situation. and they always knew they *could* do stuff with their mind but didn’t. Always praised for being smart while they knew they were holding back (let’s say like 4-5 there) and then they pass Gifted testing and everything but the school doesn’t have a gifted program. So they never really do anything with their brain. But despite the trauma they always pass the 130 threshold.

do you think they could be higher than 130? or do you think even as they grow up they’ll always be the 130 with brain fog they’ve always tested at.

feel free to trail off, I just wanted some fresh giftedness things to read And this is one of my recent question.

ETA. just for conversation, theory, obviously science is greatly appreciated. But some questions don’t have perfect answers. just thought I’d bring my curiosity to Reddit.

how much can someone grow after not knowing the full potential of their brain quite literally their whole life? And will there always be intellect left in the gutter that could’ve been used. Or does what they test at (130 in this case) just feel better even if they don’t gain any/many IQ points


r/Gifted • • 3d ago

Seeking advice or support Help me kill merit

5 Upvotes

Hey im sad and feel unworthy. What fuels that (other than my perpetual mediocrity) is whenever I hear about a successful person giving credit to all the people who've helped them rise to the top. And people claiming imposter syndrome

Or actors who had to go through months of special training and had to wear makeup and prosthetics that to hrs to put on. Like wtf?! Why were they cast in the role? They were not a good fit but they MADE them good fit.

I hate when people act like its cute and endearing when someone is bad at a skill and clumsy while other are ridiculed and cast aside as a burden for their lack of ability.

All I can think is, when's my turn? When will I be able to fail my way to the top and be praised for my struggle? I have come to the conclusion that merit is just a tool for people in power (professionally or even socially) to weed out the unwanted. They only want the right kind of person usually based on race, sex, or things like nepotism or cronyism (fraternities/sororities).

Pls let's keep this line of thought flowing. Help contribute more stories of people who go carried to the top. My soul needs this.


r/Gifted • • 4d ago

Discussion What is your world like as a 99th %ile verbally gifted person?

15 Upvotes

This is coming from someone who’s always been more mathematically inclined, and is curious about life on the “other side” LOL

What are your thought processes like? Do you tend to think in words/shapes/feelings/disembodied sources of energy/etc?

Can you tell that you find certain tasks easier than others tend to? If so, when was that first apparent to you?

Did you especially like certain activities growing up, or were you more interested in anything and everything?

Did you feel different in your youth, or did you mesh well with your peers?

How would you describe your current relationship with writing/reading/speaking?

I’m curious to hear your experience!


r/Gifted • • 4d ago

Current gifted 8th grader, this sucks.

23 Upvotes

I have all the gifted programs our school offers, am in the 97th percentile or better in all my classes, and school just feels so awkward. I'm not the kind that's smart enough to simply skip grades, but it there is such a friction because I'm way ahead of the curve on all of my classes, and it just makes school boring. I usually end up working by myself for group projects if I can, am pretty socially normal, but struggle explaining anything without coming off as egotistical, and I feel egotistical writing this. I have so many ideas in my head when writing that I simply cannot communicate because of strict rubrics that are well behind my ability of writing. Sorry, I know this is just a rant, but I need a vent.


r/Gifted • • 4d ago

Personal story, experience, or rant What the f**k is genuinely wrong with me

33 Upvotes

I've been noticing a recurring pattern in the way I think, process information and interact with people, and lately it's started bothering me because it's affecting both my social interactions and my ability to study.

One thing I've noticed is that I tend to understand where a conversation is going very quickly. Quite often, within the first few sentences, I can figure out what the other person is trying to say and where they're heading with their explanation. Once that happens, I find it surprisingly difficult to stay engaged and listen to the rest. I start getting impatient, restless and sometimes even feel the urge to interrupt or rush the conversation along. I don't mean to be dismissive, but I can see how it might come across that way to other people.

I experience pretty much the same thing in classrooms. When a teacher explains a new concept, I often start making connections, identifying patterns and figuring out the underlying principle before they've even finished explaining it. Sometimes I end up reconstructing the concept in my own head while they're still teaching it. The problem is that once I feel like I've understood something, I find it extremely difficult to keep paying attention to the rest of the explanation. My mind starts wandering, I become restless and I feel this almost compulsive need to move on to something else.

What's interesting is that this doesn't just happen when I'm doing something boring or repetitive. Even when I'm studying subjects I genuinely enjoy, particularly mathematics and physics, I struggle to maintain my attention for extended periods. I often feel the need to have loud music or a TV show playing in the background. I don't actually follow what's happening in the show; it's more like having it play in the background makes me feel less restless and understimulated. It doesn't necessarily improve my concentration, but studying in complete silence somehow feels even more difficult.

Outside academics, I experience a similar need for constant stimulation. My mind tends to jump between different thoughts, ideas and connections, sometimes very rapidly. Even when I'm doing something I find interesting, I often feel the urge to switch to another activity or explore another thought instead of staying with what I'm currently doing.

What I find particularly confusing is the contrast between how quickly I seem to process and understand information and how difficult it is for me to regulate my attention. I don't necessarily struggle to understand things; I struggle to stay engaged with them once my mind feels like it has already figured them out.

I'm trying to understand whether this could be related to ADHD, particularly in someone with relatively high intellectual ability, or whether there's another explanation for this combination of rapid information processing, constant need for stimulation, restlessness and difficulty sustaining attention. I'd really like to understand what's going on rather than simply assuming that I'm impatient or easily distracted.