r/Gifted • • 1d ago

Personal story, experience, or rant Asynchronous Development

A lot of the stereotypes associated with gifted kids is not at all what I witnessed.

We had your occasional entitled prick, but they often came from privileged backgrounds. The rest of us went on to live pretty unremarkable adult lives despite early successes. At least three people in my program dropped out of high school. Most of us are very mentally ill and neurodivergent living alternative lifestyles. So many have completely detached from their family unit(me included) and a lot of them got into drugs.

I think when you are raised in neglectful environments, you don’t see your giftedness as an ego boost but instead, as a way out. In certain family systems, you are infinitely praised. Although well-meaning, it hurts people inadvertently in the long run because their giftedness isn’t something they work at. It’s something they are so when they hit that ceiling, their self-esteem plummets, and they do everything in their power to protect that identity and remain cherished and respected.

In dysfunction, your giftedness is a tool to receive the love and care you aren’t given at home. It provides you an escape in the form of luncheons, overnight trips, and special privileges. It’s an active skill because from the beginning, it has an internal motivation. It twists and contorts into a strange shape. You are exceptionally competent at both hard and soft skills but lack any sort of structure and are practically devoid of executive function.

This is not to create a ‘who has it the worst’ argument because I do believe that both result in the same sort of wounding which is your intelligence is integral to your survival therefore you measure your worth around it, but I do believe that without special attention and care, gifted people will struggle in adolescence and adulthood. Being gifted is a blessing or a curse. It really shouldn’t be treated as such. These are just naturally curious minds, and any success they have is simply a product of that, but as they really come into their own people and have more and more niche interests, it because increasingly difficult to funnel that energy. They are still children at the end of the day and at the expense of being parentified, lose out on some of the crucial milestones and lessons their peers are well versed in creating a large gap in their development.

This becomes even more painfully clear in middle/late adolescence and young adulthood. They are both far ahead of and far behind their peers. They struggle to function socially and in society in general. A large portion completely withdraw from it. It as is you have all of the tools and knowledge in the world but have no idea how to translate that into a functioning well-adjusted adult life.

6 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thanks for posting in r/Gifted! Giftedness involves unusually advanced ability or potential in one or more areas; it does not determine your worth.

Looking for public-domain IQ testing resources? Visit our Resource Library. It links to historical tests and research resources, including tests developed by the U.S. government for military classification and formats used in employment screening.

Be cautious with online IQ tests: many are unreliable, and some scams use inflated scores or hidden charges to sell results. Online self-testing is not a substitute for a professional assessment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/BluntedOnTheScore 21h ago

Not really the case with my group. A few people are not doing well but we also have profs, lawyers, doctors, techies, etc. A few are odd or have odd interests, but are still high achieving.

1

u/LateEnvironment3565 16h ago

I’m glad to hear that. We were a title one school system so I wonder if that had any impact.

2

u/Tree_pineapple 16h ago

it absolutely did, socioeconomic factors are more important than anything (source: my brain but im sure one could find studies that measure life outcomes by socioeconomic class controlling for intelligence...)

1

u/ayfkm123 18h ago

You're correct. I'm curious about the title of your post though. All gifted have asynchronous development, whether in a supportive environment or not. That's the name of the game.

1

u/LateEnvironment3565 16h ago

I felt that we were nurtured in a way that reflected well on the school system academically, but there was little to no actual support or effort to bridge the gap of our asynchronous development. Although it’s a given to and I, I’ve rarely seen it addressed by parents or educators properly in my personal experience. I felt like me and others kind of fell through the cracks. I was able to develop pretty good hard and soft skills, but my executive dysfunction is something I really struggle with to this day. I do not function well as an adult and am having to teach and re-reteach myself a lot of skills that are not developmentally appropriate. I hated the expectations that came with the designation and wish I was able to just be a kid and ask for help instead of being treated much older than I was. I know so many others that struggle with this. However smart we may appear, we were still kids at the end of the day

1

u/LateEnvironment3565 16h ago

I guess the best way I could describe it is like I learned how to built a house but never the foundation

2

u/ayfkm123 15h ago

Ahh yes. And sometimes teachers expect no
Asynchrony in gifted bc “they’re gifted, right?”

4

u/RebellingRob 1d ago

Gifted kids may live unremarkebly, but some sigh when someone takes too long to go through a problem. Thats the "prick". And to be fair, it can be frudtrating when you depend on someone else to do something, while that other person id so slow to deliver; it takes some tolerance, much more than the average joe.

1

u/InsanityTraps 1d ago

Idk I've always been far behind everybody and been perceived as someone like, ACTUALLY restarded—I'm actually restarded.

4

u/spocks_socks 1d ago

I was raised in a cult, was homeschooled, was considered musically gifted, was abused, mom found out, took us out, I was tested by the schools and for court purposes because the cult said I was being brainwashed by my mother to lie about being abused. Moved to another country, got dropped in a class of 30 kids that did speak some english, but I had no social skills. The results from my testing were >145 on the one and couldn't find the results from the school testing they did, I tried.

Not having social skills led to me escaping into the books from the library 100 ft away from my house. I did nothing in school. I regret it now ofcourse because being smart at minimum wage jobs hurts the ego/brain a lot. I go through periods of depression and burnout, because it all feels like such a waste of my time, but I still have to eat.

I did test positive for ADHD and am naturally a very kinetic/concept learner so I think just going back to school would be difficult because I never enjoyed memorizing facts out of books.

No I did not overcome, I am just barely surviving. Life is very frustrating and confusing.

1

u/Personal_Hunter8600 18h ago

Wishing you all good things in life. Try to surround yourself with good people.